- 1 - !" ##$ %&'! !# (&) * (&) * ! " # # $ % &'%() ) & # &'%(% &'%() ! " #$ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - )) ))* $ )*%))(% ) )(%)*%))(% ) + & $ * " # # $ % &'%() ) & # &'%(% &'%() " #$ - 3 - )) ))* $ )*&%)&)(% ), )(% )*%))(% ) + $ -. / 0121314545672891:5;1<=>40131454567192211?57@46 AB820 401 69<192 <841< )*%))(% =18957@ 62) 6C<>20114 )(% 87< ), 6C<>20114 )(% 38221< => 912367<174 6) D5<1771EB91& - 4 - ) 452401F8216:401314545671924084401>891401 =B257122G17 9125<57@ 84 8;8=B98@5 12367<174 6 C954417 8 ;14419 46 912367<174 6) 17BG198457@ 401 <1485;2 6: 401 F821 91@524191< 8@85724 401 31454567192 B92B874464084912367<1746)9154198457@401F6741742 6: 401 ;14419 248457@ 4084 401 31454567192 C540 40159 2B33694192 891 5745G5<8457@ 4091841757@ 87< 217<57@ C967@ G1228@12 46 401 3B=;5F 87< 8F457@ 57 @96B32 87< <524B9=57@;8C87<69<1957401D5;;8@1217F18F82152 91@524191< 8@85724 401 31454567192 57 484567 8H89 6;5F1 4845675795G16)I )(%:694016::17F123B75208=;1 B7<19 1F45672 %, %,* ) ), ,% (, ( 87< ()918<C540 1F4567%,I6: 821<6740191@5249845676:401F95G187<:5;57@ 6: 401 F089@1 20114 912367<174 6 7231F469 6: 6;5F1 91F6GG17<1< 46 6317 8 96C<> 20114 8@85724 401 31454567192 019157 821< 67 C05F0 912367<174 6) 082 38221<40169<19257F;B<57@40178G126:40131454567192 => 631757@ 96C<> 201142 8@85724 401G 57 401 91@52419 - 5 - <841< )*%))(% 82 401 31454567192 C191 57D6;D1< 57 95G16)I )(% , 4 52 F67417<1< => 401 F6B721; :69 401 31454567192 4084 401 31454567192 08D1 =117 8FAB5441< 57 1225672 821 6'' )(%* 895257@ 6B4 6: 95G1 6)I )(%C8>=8F?67)*(%)(%'123541C05F0401 31454567192. 78G12 891 57F;B<1< 57 401 96C<> 201142 87< 401> 891 2BGG671< 46 401 36;5F1 2484567 45G1 87< 8@857 C5406B4 87> 918267 C084261D19 5;;1@8;;> 87< F674989> 46 401 396D525672 6: 9<19 62%(' 87< %(I 6: 401 897848?86;5F187B8;4528;26F67417<1<408476206C F8B217645F152522B1<87<G191;>67401=82526:87189;519 F95G17BG=1940178G126:4013145456719289157F;B<1<57 401 96C<> 201142 0191:691 401 31454567192 G8<1 91231F45D1 913912174845672 46 912367<174 6% 67 (()() :69 91D51C57@ 401 5G3B@71< 69<192 87< 46 <1;141 40159 78G12 :96G 401 96C<> 201142 82 401> 08D1 =117 8FAB5441< 57 401 F821 =821< 67 C05F0 40159 78G12 - 6 - C19157F;B<1<5740196C<>2011420128G1082764=117 F6725<191<=>912367<1746% 452F67417<1<4084C01740131454567192G8<1 833;5F84567269913912174845672401912367<1748B406954512 6B@044608D18FF1341<40191391217484567287<396D5<1< 87633694B754>4640131454567192463B4:694040159F8216: 40191=157@768;;1@845676:F95G578;F8212317<57@8@85724 401G 87< 4084 57F;B2567 6: 40159 78G12 87< F67457B57@ 40159 78G12 57 401 6C<> 0114 1@524192 52 D56;845D1 6: 401 3957F53;12 6: 784B98; JB245F1 57F;B<57@ 40159 3192678; ;5=194> 4 52 8;26 F67417<1< 4084 57 23541 6: 401 31454567192 =157@ 8FAB5441< 57 401 F821 4084 C82 :5;1< 8@85724401G87<<123541401913912174845672=157@G8<1 40131454567192.78G12891764249BF?6:::96G40191@524192 6:96C<51240191=>F8B257@B746;<089<205387<D56;84567 6: 40159 :B7<8G1748; 95@04 6: :911 G6D1G174 87< 40159 ;5=194> - 7 - * 4528;26F67417<1<=>401;18971<F6B721;4084 912367<1742 08D1 764 :6;;6C1< 401 71F12289> @B5<1;5712 ;85<<6C7=>40526B9457401F8216: 9136941< 57 !" 0191:691 01 F67417<2 4084 5G3;5F8457@ 401 31454567192 87< 91@5241957@ 40159 78G12 57 401 96C<> 201142 52 5;;1@8; 87< D56;845D1 6: 3957F53;12 6: 784B98; JB245F117F140178G126:4013145456719291AB59146=1 91G6D1< 87< F6721AB174;> 401 285< 69<192 =1 AB8201< 17F1 401 31454567192 891 319:69F1< 46 833968F0 4052 6B9457D6?57@401C954JB952<5F4567 ' ;18971< <<545678; 6D197G174 <D6F841 91391217457@ 912367<174& 4841 8<G542 401 8FAB5448; 6: 401 31454567192 57 401 8:691285< F95G578; F821 87< 67 D195:5F84567 87< 8:419 48?57@ 57249BF45672 2B=G542 4084 401 31454567192. 78G12 891 245;; F67457B57@ 57 401 96C<> 201142 =B4 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 C191 57F;B<1< 57 401 6C<> 0114 1@524192 39569 46 8FAB5448; 87<8;26AB1245676::6;;6C57@401@B5<1;5712;85<<6C7=> - 8 - 4016&69<5784117F06:40526B9457401F8216: "2B398$ C6B;< 764 89521 :69 401 918267 4084 57F;B2567 6: 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 57 401 6C<> 01141@524192523956946401285<JB<@G17417F1401 28G1C5;;76417B914640159=171:54FF69<57@;>01211?2 46<52G522401314545672 I 08D10189<;18971<F6B721;:6940131454567192 87<;18971<<<545678;6D197G174<D6F841:69401 4841 %( 4 52 8 :B7<8G1748; 9B;1 6: ;8C 4084 C017 8 319267 52 5G3;5F841< 82 8 96C<> 2011419 => 57F;B<57@ 052 78G157401;5246:96C<>2011440167B252B367401 4841 46 :6;;6C 401 <B1 396F1<B91 F6741G3;841< B7<19 401 91;1D874 9B;12 87< 91@B;845672 7 401 3912174 F821 401 897848?86;5F187B8;G691231F5:5F8;;>4011@524196: 6C<512 G85748571< 57 69<19 6%(I C05F0 <18;2 C540 052469> 201142 87< 96C<> 201142 87< 1796;;G174 69 91@524984567 6: 3192672 57 401 285< 20114 :69 91@52419 :69 F67457B6B2 G67546957@ => 401 36;5F1 8B406954512 52 764 :6;;6C1< 487<57@ 9<19 6%(I <18;2 C540 91@524984567 - 9 - 6:96C<51201<1:5754567396D5<1<524084896C<>G8>=1 <1:571< 82 8 @B7<8 87< 57F;B<12 8 066;5@87 46B@0 D8@8=67<6987>319267C0652<87@196B2463B=;5F318F1 87<4987AB5;54>0191891G87>:69G26:96C<52G C05F0 891 <12F95=1< 4019157 87< 401 396F122 87< 396F1<B91 F6741G3;841< 46=1 G85748571< 57<5::1917438942 78G1;> 89489487<894C05F0@6D197401G85741787F1 6: 8 91@52419 87< 401 78G12 6: 401 96C<512 57 40159 91231F45D1 38942 4 52 401 <B4> 87< 6=;5@84567 F824 B367 401 912367<1742 C05F0 52 764 6345678; 46 :6;;6C 401 <B1 396F1<B91F6741G3;841<B7<194012487<57@69<1926:401 897848?8 6;5F1 87B8; C05;1 1741957@ 401 78G1 6: 8 319267 57 401 96C<> 20114 87< 40191 891 F194857 396F1<B91246=1G87<84695;>:6;;6C1<=1:6911741957@401 78G12 2 F67417<1< => ;18971< F6B721; :69 401 31454567192 401 396F122 87< 396F1<B91 82 F6741G3;841< B7<194012487<57@9<196%(I6:401 897848?86;5F1 87B8; 082 764 =117 :6;;6C1< 87< 76 633694B754> C82 @5D17464013145456719246:5;140159913;>691E3;8784567:69 - 10 - 91G6D57@ 40159 78G12 57 401 6C<> 0114 1@524192 87< G191;> =1F8B21 401> C191 57D6;D1< 57 F95G578; F821 57 C05F08;264013145456719208D1=1178FAB5441<57401>189 )(%'4528;26F67417<1<4084406B@04013145456719208D1 G8<1 913912174845672 46 401 912367<174 8B406954512 8:419 4018FAB5448;67(()()40191391217484567208D1764 =117 F6725<191< 87< 1D17 8:419 401 8FAB5448; 401> 08D1 =117 2BGG671< 46 401 JB952<5F45678; 36;5F1 2484567 :69 B771F12289>5741996@84567C017401915276F821317<57@ 8@85724401G %% 4C6B;<=191;1D874461E498F43898@98306%* 6:401JB<@G1746:5D5256717F06:40526B9457401F821 6: # #$%&' ' 9136941< 57 () ** + C019157 401 5D52567 17F0 <18;4 C540 25G5;89 2B=J1F4 G84419 C05F0 918<2 82 B7<19 - 11 - ! "# # $ % &'( ) # $ $ % &'( # ) *) # + ) ) ) ) # )) ) ) ) ) , )# ) - K %) 487<57@ 9<19 6%(I 6: 897848?8 6;5F1 87B8;%II'521E498F41<=1;6C &'( ./0 # ) ) 1 .2/ 3+ / ! 45, / 6 )) # # 3 /), - 12 - / !)1 + + ))))) , /*, /, / .7/ 6 # 8 8 % &&) #9 0 : 4 ) ; 0# .</. /% ) 848 0 ) ) ./% ) 848 ) = 8"48 : ) # ) ./ % ) >%#> 4 + .'/ $ ) +*# $ # .?/% ) ) 0 : !6) - 13 - ./ @ ) # ) 848 # ) 1 $ .A/ 4 # ) ) ) ) ) ) 0 " * ) ) ) .(/$ " * ) # # # 8 8 : ) ) " * 4 6) *$ # # .&/)#) # #)) ./ @ # + $ ! 8:8 )) $ ! - 14 - 808 .2/@ 8481 + 8488:8 @ 848 ) ! $ 46) .7/ % ! 808 8:8 ) 6 6) ) +*# $ .</6) + ) ) 6) 1 ! ) .'/ B C 3 ./ ) ! # ./ ))) 2(< 4 . 9 /, ./ # ! (2./.)/.1/ ./D ! - 15 - 0(?7 )# #C3 .#/0&A./ 4 , .#/0&4 4 .#/0&4 4 .#/ 0 )## , #/EC)'' '?D ! 0(?7, .C/ 0 '&( 6 4 #+ 3 .?/E# ) E " : ) + # )) # ++ )) !) + ./ @ # $ ) ) " # # .A/)&? ) 3+ / % 2/% ) - 16 - 7/5) ) </ % ) '/ ?/$F /% A/ ! .(/ 6 ) ) # ) 1 ) # ! ) - % 016&69<5784117F06:40526B9457401F821 6: "2B398$ 082 ;85< <6C7 @B5<1;5712 C05F0 891 46 =1 :6;;6C1<C05;1 91@5241957@ 401 78G16: 8 319267 57 401 6C<> 0114 1@52419 C05F0 1D17 39569 46 401285<JB<@G174C828G87<841:69401912367<174246 08D1:6;;6C1<2495F4;>578FF69<87F1464012487<57@69<19 6%(I 6: 401 897848?8 6;5F1 87B8; C05F0 57 G> 6357567 F6725<1957@ 401 :8F42 87< F59FBG2487F1 6: 401 3912174 F8212 082 764 =117 :6;;6C1< 87< 1D17 8:419 401 8FAB5448; 6: 401 31454567192 87< 1D17 8:419 401 - 17 - 913912174845672@5D17=>40131454567192:6991G6D57@40159 78G12 :96G 401 6C<> 0114 1@524192 40191 52 76 91236721 69 913;> 69 8F4567 => 401 912367<1742 57 91G6D57@4015978G12 %, 7 D51C 6: 767&F6G3;587F1 6: 401 396F1<B91 F6741G3;841< B7<19 2487<57@ 69<19 6%(I 6: 401 897848?8 6;5F1 87B8; 87< 767&F6725<1984567 6: 401 913912174845672@5D17=>401314545671923B92B8744640159 8FAB5448; 4052 6B94 52 6: 401 6357567 4084 401 31454567192 08D1G8<16B48D8;5<F82146F6725<19:8D6B98=;> % FF69<57@;>3822401:6;;6C57@ 5 0195414545672891,,% 55 01 5G3B@71< 69<192 <841< )*%))(% 91@89<57@ 631757@ 6C<> 0114 1@524192 57 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 =18957@ 6) 6C<>20114 )(% 87< ), 6C<>20114 )(% 38221< => 912367<1746)8910191=>AB8201< - 18 - 555 01 912367<1742 891 0191=> <591F41< 46 91G6D1 401 78G12 6: 401 31454567192 :96G 401 6C<> 0114 1@524192 G85748571< => 401G C54057 8 31956< 6: :6B9 C11?2 :96G 401 <841 6: 91F1534 6: F1945:51< F63> 6: 401 69<19 5D 5=194> 06C1D19 52 91219D1< 46 401 912367<174 484146396F11< 57 8FF69<87F1 C540;8C8@85724401314545671925:848;;87> F82152G8<16B487<C05;1<657@26401> 208;;2495F4;>:6;;6C401@B5<1;5712;85<<6C7 => 4052 6B94 57 401 F821 6: 9136941<57 !" !+* ( !#) ' 5246, ;6%