Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54509 (KAR)

KAMALABAI AND ORS v. SOMANNA AND ANR

MFA/202707/2024 · 2026-01-28

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"!# $" %% &'( ) ! " #$% & ' ( !) ( ! " #$% ! **** #$% & ' ( !*+ ! $% ) Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - * * ,') * ! * ( %%%! , %$ * * ! ( * # * - + * * ** * ( ! . ( " /01234/5/016/27896:/50;;/01<6=>8134/;013</: 4<: 0;;/05 <: ;1/>/11/2 ?@ 34/ 5/=05 1/;1/:/6303<A/: 8> 2/7/0:/2 B 0@0;;0 0<0;;0 0::0<5<6= 34/ C92=D/63 062 0E012 203/2 %%% <6 ! 8 , %$ 86 34/ ><5/ 8> 34/ 5/016/2 1<67<;05 /6<81 <A<5 (92=/ 062 03 050?910=< '4/1/<60>3/1 1/>/11/2380:.1<?9605.)://F<6=78D;/6:03<86 - 3 - *81 34/ :0F/ 8> ?1/A<3@ 34/ ;013</: <6 34/ 0;;/05 :4055 ?/ 1/>/11/2 38 <6 3/1D: 8> 34/<1 :3039: 062 106F<6=?/>81/34/1<?9605 3 <: 34/ 70:/ 8> 34/ 750<D063: 3403 86 $%, 49:?062 8> 750<D063 8 #0@0;;0 0<0;;0E0:;<55<861<2/1<6D83817@75/?/01<6=1/=<:3103<86 8# #G%, 062 34/ :0<2 D83817@75/ E0: ?/<6= 1<22/6 <6 10:4 062 6/=5<=/63 D066/1 062 0: :974 34/ 2/7/0:/2 >/55 28E6 >18D 34/ D83817@75/ :9:30<6/2 =1</A89: <6C91</: 062 34/1/0>3/1 :9779D?/2 38 34/ <6C91</:/67/34/750<D063:40A/><5/2750<D;/3<3<86<6 !8 , %$://F<6=78D;/6:03<86 4/ 750<D ;/3<3<86 E0: 7863/:3/2 ?@ 34/ 1/:;862/63:34/1/<66812/138/:30?5<:434/<170:/34/ 750<D063 8 4/1:/5> E0: /H0D<6/2 0: 062 ;18297/2 G 2879D/63: 062 34/ :0D/ E/1/ D01F/2 0: H:38G88105812879D/6301@/A<2/67/;18297/2 ?@ 34/ 1/:;862/63: 4/ 1<?9605 0>3/1 786:<2/1<6= 34/ D03/1<05 86 1/7812 ?@ <3: C92=D/63 062 0E012 203/2 - 4 - %%%0E012/278D;/6:03<868>:G%%% #E<34 <63/1/:30334/103/8>GI;/10669D>18D34/203/8>34/ ;/3<3<86 3<55 34/ 203/ 8> 1/05<J03<86 /<6= 0==1</A/2 ?@ <602/K907@8>78D;/6:03<860E012/2?@34/1<?960534/ 750<D063:40A/;1/>/11/234<:0;;/05 G 0A<6= 30F/6 683/ 8> 34/ :9?D<::<86 D02/ ?@ 34/5/016/2 7896:/5 0;;/01<6=>81 34/ ;013</:0: ;/1 34/ ;8:3D813/D 1/;813 ;18297/2 03 H, 34/ 0=/ 8> 34/ 2/7/0:/2 E0: :48E6 0: @/01: /67/ 0;;5@<6= 34/ 0;;18;1<03/ D953<;5</1 8> 0: ;/1 34/ C92=D/63 8> 34/ 86.?5/ 9;1/D/ 8913 <6 34/ 70:/ 8> 1/;813/2<6 062 0: ;/1 34/ =9<2/5<6/: <::9/2 ?@ 34/ 016030F0 303/ /=05 /1A<7/: 93481<3@ D86345@ <678D/ 8> 34/ 2/7/0:/2<:30F/603:%% #6A</E8>2/750103<86 8>50ED02/?@34/86-?5/9;1/D/8913<634/70:/8> ! " # 1/;813/2<6$%34/750<D063:01/ /63<35/2>81%I8>34/D86345@38E012:>9391/;18:;/73: - 5 - </:, #<67/34/1/01/341//2/;/62/63: 12 40: 38 ?/ 2/2973/2 38E012: ;/1:8605 /H;/6:/: 8> 34/ 2/7/0:/2 /67/ 34/ 750<D063: 01/ /63<35/2 >81 78D;/6:03<86 8> :%% # ':,HHH 12) 38E012: 58:: 8> 2/;/62/67@ 4/1/ 01/ 341// 2/;/62/63: 062 0::974 34/750<D063: 01/ /63<35/2 >81 :%%%% # 38E012: 58:: 8> 786:813<9D 4/1/ <: 68 <63/1>/1/67/ <6:8>01 0: 0E012 8> 78D;/6:03<86 38E012: >96/105 /H;/6:/:D/2<705/H;/6:/:06258::8>/:303/ , 77812<6=5@ 34/ K90639D 8> 78D;/6:03<86 1/K9<1/238?/1/0::/::/20:>8558E: *+,- ./01 8::8>2/;/62/67@ :%% # 8::8>58A/0620>>/73<86 :%%%% # 8E012:>96/105/H;/6:/: :%%% # 8::8>/:303/ :%%% # 8E012:D/2<705/H;/6:/: :, # 8305 /::0E012/2?@1<?9605 64067/D/63 : # :G%%% # -#2 #22 3 49: 34/ 750<D063: 01/ /63<35/2 >81 /64067/2 78D;/6:03<86 8> -#2 #22 3 18962/2 8> 38 -#2 #3E<34<63/1/:30334/103/8>GI;/10669D - 6 - $ 634/1/:953;0::34/>8558E<6= 4/0;;/05<:0558E/2<6;013 4/ 0;;/55063: 750<D063: 01/ /63<35/2 >81 /64067/2 78D;/6:03<86 8> -#2 #3 E<34 <63/1/:3 03 34/ 103/ 8> GI ;/1 0669D >18D 34/ 203/8>;/3<3<863<5534/203/8>1/05<J03<86 /:;862/63 8 # 6:91067/ 8D;06@ <: 2<1/73/2 38 2/;8:<3 34/ 0>81/:0<2 78D;/6:03<86 0D8963E<34<6:<HE//F:>18D34/203/8>1/7/<;3 8>7/13<></278;@8>34<:C92=D/63 ! 3 <: 38 ?/ 683/2 3403 0: 34/1/ <: 2/50@ 8> 20@: <6 ><5<6= 34/ 0;;/05 062 0: ;/1 34/ 812/1 203/2$% 34/750<D063:01/683/63<35/2 >81<63/1/:3>8134/2/50@/2;/1<82 ,3 &( " <:3858