- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %& %'() %( * !""" # $" !"%& !"%& ' & !"%& Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !"%& $ " !"%& ( ) * ** !%" # #% !%'" ( *+ *# * '%# * * ' #",",##", #"#"#" # #"# *** * * - - . - 3 - /012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ </:=:=52/17 9=8/7 0 >/>5 7//?=2@ 8/0A/ 59 :;=7 561: :5 B=:;310B :;/ </:=:=52 =2 1/7</4:59</:=:=52/1 57:5=/04467/3 57:5 # ;/>/>5=7:0?/2521/4513 2A=/B59:;/>/>5:;/</:=:=52=73=7>=77/3 07 B=:;310B2 =2 1/7</4: 59 </:=:=52/1 57 :5 =/ 04467/3 57:5 +',-.'/+0,12123,'+&1).445+,/+& 1 " 16, 7.11,' 2+ 1.8,3 50 ' 43+2/,'.123 .+ 53/,' ' ;=7 </:=:=52 =7 9=8/3 623/1 /4:=52 #% 59 ;010:=C0 0@01=? 610?7;0 02;=:0 #"# :5 D607; <154//3=2@70@0=27::;/</:=:=52/17 04467/3 57':5$=2 5# #"#01=7=2@56:591=>/ 5' #",30:/3 ",##",1/@=7:/1/3EC;08?=610858=4/</23=2@52 :;/9=8/59338=A=8 63@/) *;08?==301951:;/ 599/24/7<62=7;0E8/623/1/4:=527',%!"$"'023 - 4 - '"$1 B/4:=52',5923=02/20853/%$"9517;51: FG023/4:=527023'595B1C15;=E=:=524:,$ 9517;51:F:;/4:G ;/904:759:;/407/=7:;0:=2:;/C/01#" 04467/3 57:50<<1504;/37'023 B=:;951@/3 3=A514/<0</17023>03/:5E/8=/A/:;0:04467/3 5;03 5E:0=2/3 3=A514/ EC 3=7758A=2@ ;=7 9=17: >011=0@/ 44513=2@8C 04467/3 57 :5 </1951>/3 :;/ 7/4523 >011=0@/ ;/1/09:/1 1/7<523/2: 5# 7:01:/3 :5 1/7=3/ 0852@ B=:; 04467/3 5 =2 >0:1=>52=08 ;5>/ ;/ 1/80:=527;=<E/:B//21/7<523/2: 5#B=:;04467/3 57 :5B074513=089510</1=535952/C/01;/1/09:/17;/ 4524/=A/37764;04467/3 57:5;01077/3;/1951 033=:=520835B1C0239510E51:=525B/A/17;/3/8=A/1/3 0 @=18 E0EC ;/1/09:/1 :;/ 04467/3 >03/ :;/ 8=9/ 59 1/7<523/2: 5# >=7/10E8/ EC @=A=2@ E5:; <;C7=408 023 >/2:08:51:61/0:/11/7<523/2: 5#023;/14;=83B/1/ :;15B256:59;567/023:;1/0:/2/325::545>/E04?023 4527:10=2/3;/1:51/7=3/=2;/1<01/2:08;567/7764; - 5 - 7;/853@/345><80=2:E/951/:;/1/7<523/2:!58=4/0@0=27: :;/</:=:=52/170235:;/17B;=4;40>/:5E/1/@=7:/1/3=2 1=>/ 5' #", 9:/1 452364:=2@ =2A/7:=@0:=52 :;/ 1/7<523/2:!58=4/80=34;01@/!7;//:0@0=27::;/</:=:=52/17 023 5:;/17 951 :;/ 0951/>/2:=52/3 599/24/7 EC 0110C=2@ :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 07 04467/3 57' :5 $ /24/ :;=7 </:=:=52 :5 D607; :;/ <154//3=2@7 0@0=27: </:=:=52/17! 04467/3 57':5$ $ /013 8/012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ </:=:=52/17 8/012/3 =@; 561: 5A/12>/2: 8/03/1 951 1/7<523/2: 5!:0:/0238/012/345627/89511/7<523/2: 5# & <01: 915> 61@=2@ 7/A/108 452:/2:=527 8/012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ </:=:=52/17 <1=>01=8C 452:/2:/3 :;0: 52 </16708 59 4;01@/!7;//: >0:/1=087 0E7586:/8C 25 >0:/1=087 =7 <804/3 0@0=27: :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 44513=2@ :5 <157/46:=52 :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 01/ E15:;/17! =2!80B 023 45!7=7:/1 59 1/7<523/2: 5# 023 :;/C 01/ 25 B0C4524/12/30E56::;/088/@/3;01077>/2:>/:/356::5 - 6 - 1/7<523/2: 5#51=2:;/</1951>024/597/4523>011=0@/ B=:;04467/3 5 % 44513=2@:58/012/345627/8951:;/</:=:=52/17 :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 04467/3 57' :5 $ 01/ 1/7=3=2@ 7/<010:/8C0:=>>020@01023002308=:80>07B030 0>01/33C 086? /802@020 023 /A/2 044513=2@ :5 :;/ 45><80=2:0234;01@/!7;//:0A/1>/2:704467/3 57:5 0<<1504;/3 :;/ <01/2:7 59 1/7<523/2: 5# 023 EC <804=2@951@/33546>/2:7:;/C>03/:;/>:5E/8=/A/:;0: 04467/3 5;03@5:3=A514/3915>;=79=17:B=9/2764; 4=146>7:024/7:;/<154//3=2@70@0=27::;/7/</:=:=52/17=7 0E67/ 59 <154/77 59 561: /24/ <10C7 :5 0885B :;/ </:=:=52 , 8/012/345627/89511/7<523/2: 5# 5<<57/3:;/</:=:=52023452:/23/3:;0::;/7/</:=:=52/17 E/=2@ :;/ E15:;/17!=2!80B 023 45!7=7:/1 59 1/7<523/2: 5# :;/C 01/ /D6088C <01:=4=<0:/3 =2 :;/ 41=>/ EC </1951>=2@:;/>011=0@/591/7<523/2: 5#B=:;04467/3 5 ?25B=2@ 9688C 0E56: :;/ /H=7:/24/ 59 ;=7 9=17: - 7 - >011=0@/EC<804=2@0951@/33=A514/<0</1744513=2@8C <10C7:53=7>=77:;/</:=:=52 " /012/3 =@; 561: 5A/12>/2: 8/03/1 0875 5<<57/3:;/</:=:=52023<10C7:53=7>=77:;/70>/ ;0A/@=A/2>C02H=5674527=3/10:=52E5:;52 :;/ 76E>=77=527 >03/ EC :;/ 8/012/3 45627/8 951 :;/ 1/7</4:=A/<01:=/70233546>/2:70A0=80E8/521/4513 # 2 401/968 </16708 59 :;/ 4;01@/!7;//: >0:/1=087=:45683E/@0:;/1/3:;0:04467/3 5>011=/3 1/7<523/2: 5#361=2@:;//H=7:/24/59;=79=17:>011=0@/ 61=2@ :;/ >011=0@/ :08? 04467/3 57 :5 A=7=:/3 :;/ ;567/ 59 1/7<523/2: 5# 023 /H;=E=:/3 951@/3 3=A514/ <0</10237:0:/3:;0:04467/3 5;03@5:3=A514/3915> ;=7 9=17: B=9/ 023 :;/1/EC >03/ :;/> :5 E/8=/A/ :;0: 04467/3 5 B07 3=A514/3 44513=2@8C :;/C </1951>/3 :;/>011=0@/591/7<523/2: 5#B=:;04467/3 5 9:/1 :;/ >011=0@/ 04467/3 57 :5 ;01077/3 ;/1 951 0E51:=52 023 033=:=5208 35B1C ;/ - 8 - 4;01@/!7;//: >0:/1=087 48/018C 1/A/08 :;0: 04467/3 57 :501/=2A58A/3=2:;/>02=<680:=5259951@/3467:5>01C 3=A514/ 59 3/41// 023 0875 =2 </1951>=2@ :;/ 7/4523 >011=0@/5B/A/152</1670859:;//2:=1/4;01@/!7;//: >0:/1=087 :;/1/ =7 25 764; 7</4=9=4 5A/1: 04: 0::1=E6:/3 0@0=27: :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 B;5 01/ :;/ =2!80B7 59 1/7<523/2: 5# 51/5A/1 03>=::/38C :;/C 01/ 1/7=3=2@ 7/<010:/8C915>:;/>0:1=>52=08;5>/591/7<523/2: 5# ' 2764;4=146>7:024/7:;/52.E8/</H561: =2 :;/ 407/ 59 1/<51:/3 =2 ! "#$ %& 0: <010@10<; 5$;/83:;0::;/561:7;5683E/401/968=2<154//3=2@ 0@0=27: :;/ 3=7:02: 1/80:=A/7 =2 41=>/7 </1:0=2=2@ :5 >0:1=>52=08 3=7<6:/7 023 35B1C 3/0:;7 ;/ 1/80:=A/7 59 :;/ ;67E023 7;5683 25: E/ 15</3!=2 52 :;/ E07=7 59 5>2=E67 088/@0:=527 628/77 7</4=9=4 =27:024/ 59 :;/=1 =2A58A/>/2: =2 :;/ 41=>/ 01/ >03/ 56:: =7 08757/::8/3 <57=:=525980B:;0:=90</1752=7>03/:5904/041=>=208 - 9 - :1=08 52 75>/ @/2/108 023 7B//<=2@ 088/@0:=527 B=:;56: E1=2@=2@ 52 1/4513 02C 7</4=9=4 =27:024/7 59 41=>=208 452364: =: =7 25:;=2@ E6: 0E67/ 59 <154/77 59 :;/ 561: ;/561:7<57/036:C:576EI/4::;/088/@0:=528/A/88/3=2 :;/45><80=2::50:;5156@;7416:=2C:59=2356:B;/:;/1 :;/1/ =7 02C @0=2 59 :16:; =2 :;/ 088/@0:=527 51 B;/:;/1 :;/C 01/ >03/ 528C B=:; :;/ 758/ 5EI/4: 59 =2A58A=2@ 4/1:0=2 =23=A=36087 =2 0 41=>=208 4;01@/ >51/ <01:=468018C B;/20<157/46:=5201=7/915>0>0:1=>52=083=7<6:/ *61:;/1:;/52GE8/ </H561: =2 :;/ 407/59 '( # 1/<51:/3=2 )*$$+*);/83=2<010 57#023#% 07623/1- ) ! " - 10 - # $% & $' $' $% ( ,) ! *+, # ! ( - . ! *+, # /. " 0 ! . . ! *+, # . # - # - 11 - 1 $ 2 :;/ =27:02: 407/ 0 E01/ </16708 59 4;01@/ 7;//:>0:/1=08748/018C7;5B7:;0::;/088/@0:=527>03/EC 1/7<523/2: 5# 01/ A0@6/ 023 5>2=E67 <01: 915> 480=>=2@ :;0: :;/ ;67E023 =/ 04467/3 5 023 ;=7 90>=8C>/>E/17>/2:088C;01077/3;/1B=:;03/>023951 35B1C 1/7<523/2: 5# ;07 25: <15A=3/3 02C 7</4=9=4 3/:0=87513/741=E/302C<01:=46801=27:024/59;01077>/2: ;/;0725:>/2:=52/3:;/:=>/30:/<804/510>022/1 =2B;=4;:;/088/@/3;01077>/2:544611/351:;/3/:0=8759 :;/ 20:61/ 59 3/>023 51 =:7 <01:=468017 ;/1/951/ :;/ 4;01@/ 7;//: 804?7 45241/:/ 023 <1/4=7/ 088/@0:=527 ;/ :/1> J416/8:CK 40225: E/ /7:0E8=7;/3 B=:;56: 7</4=9=4 =27:024/ ;/ 70>/ B/0?/27 :;/ 407/ 59 :;/ <157/46:=52 023407:77/1=567356E:52:;/<15E0E=8=:C59:;/A/17=5259 1/7<523/2: 5# ;/ >/1/ @/2/108 088/@0:=527 59 ;01077>/2:B=:;56:<5=2:=2@56::;/7</4=9=43/:0=87B5683 - 12 - 25:E/7699=4=/2::5 452:=26/41=>=208<154//3=2@70@0=27: 02C</1752 & :=77/::8/3<57=:=525980B:;0:561:7;0A/:5 E/401/968023406:=567=23/08=2@B=:;45><80=2:023>67: :0?/ <10@>0:=4 1/08=:=/7 =2:5 4527=3/10:=52 B;=8/ 3/08=2@ B=:; >0:1=>52=08 3=7<6:/7 B;/1/ :;/ 088/@0:=527 ;0A/ :5 E/7416:=2=L/3B=:;@1/0:401/0234=146>7</4:=52=2513/1 :5<1/A/2:>=74011=0@/59I67:=4/0230E67/59<154/7759 561: % 2>C4527=3/1/3A=/B452:=260:=525941=>=208 <154//3=2@7 0@0=27: :;/7/ </:=:=52/17 =/ 04467/3 57' :5$=725:;=2@E6:0E67/59<154/7759561:44513=2@8C <154//3:5<077:;/95885B=2@- = ;/ 1=>=208 /:=:=52 =2 1/7</4: 59 </:=:=52/1 57 :5 04467/3 57 :5 =7 -- - 13 - == ;/ 1=>=208 /:=:=52 =2 1/7</4: 59 </:=:=52/1 57':5$ 04467/3 57':5$=7 - === ;/ <154//3=2@7 0@0=27: :;/ </:=:=52/17 04467/3 57' :5 $ =2 5# #"# 1=>/ 5' #", 1/@=7:/1/3 EC ;08?= 6108 58=4/ =301 951 :;/ 599/24/7 <62=7;0E8/ 623/1 /4:=527 ',%! '"$"$"'1 B/4:=52',59023 /4:=527 023 ' 59 5B1C 15;=E=:=52 4: ,$ <1/7/2:8C </23=2@ 52 :;/ 9=8/ 59 338 =A=8 63@/ ) * ;08?= =301 =7 ;/1/EC. =A : =7 >03/ 48/01 :;0: :;/ <154//3=2@7 7;088 452:=26/ =2 1/7</4: 59 </:=:=52/1 57 :5 04467/3 57:5 /) %!( ! - -#' -