- 1 - !!" #$%! &$' ! ""# $ % " %&'&( %&'&($ ! "# $$ $$) * Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $)$$( $ $($)$$( $ +% ,- . /01 23404056 01 70839 :; 4/3 234040563< 133=06> 45 ?@A1/ 4/3 5<93< 9A439 $)$$( :3A<06> 51$ 5B9;1/334 $( 2A1139 :; <312569364 5$C093663D@<3% $ 4 01 4/3 EA13 57 4/3 234040563< 4/A4 /3 01 4/3 :@106311FA6 <310906> A4 A8A:@<A>0 312569364 5 B<04436 A 83443< 45 <312569364 5$ 36@F3<A406> 4/3 934A081 57 4/3 EA13 <3>0143<39 A>A0614 4/3 234040563< @<1@A64454/A4<3125693645$<3043<A406>4/3E5643641 574/383443<14A406>4/A44/3234040563<B04//011@225<43<1 01 0640F09A406> 4/<3A43606> A69 136906> B<56> F311A>31 - 3 - 454/32@:80EA69AE406>06><5@21A699014@<:06>8ABA69 5<93< 06 4/3 C088A>31 36E3 A EA13 01 <3>0143<39 A>A0614 4/3 234040563< 06 4A4056 AGA< 580E3 4A4056 06 <0F3 5$H $( 75< 4/3 57736E31 2@601/A:83 @693< 3E40561 I I) $ $I I &(I &( A69 ($ <3A9 B04/ 3E4056IH57 A139564/3<3>014<A4056574/3E<0F3A6970806> 57 4/3 E/A<>3 1/334 <312569364 5 6123E45< 57 580E3 <3E5FF36939 45 5236 A <5B9; 1/334 A>A0614 4/3 234040563< /3<306 A139 56 B/0E/ <312569364 5$ /A1 2A11394/35<93<06E8@906>4/36AF3574/3234040563<:; 523606> <5B9; 1/334 A>A0614 /0F 06 4/3 <3>0143< 9A439 $)$$( A1 4/3 234040563< BA1 06C58C39 06 <0F3 5$H $( I 401E56436939:;4/3E5@613875<4/3234040563< 4/A4 4/3 234040563< /A1 :336 AE?@04439 06 3110561 A13 5'' $() A<0106> 5@4 57 <0F3 5$H $( BA; :AE= 56 $)($(' 312043 B/0E/ 4/3 234040563<-1 6AF3 01 06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 A69 /3 01 1@FF5639 45 4/3 - 4 - 2580E3 14A4056 40F3 A69 A>A06 B04/5@4 A6; <3A156 B/A4153C3< 0883>A88; A69 E564<A<; 45 4/3 2<5C010561 57 <93<51(&'A69(&H574/3A<6A4A=A580E3A6@A8 4 01 A815 E56436939 4/A4 65 1/5B EA@13 6540E3 01 011@39 A69 F3<38; 56 4/3 :A101 57 A6 3A<803< E<0F3 6@F:3< 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< 01 06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 /3<375<3 4/3 234040563< FA93 <32<31364A4056 45 <312569364 5 56 (&($($& 75< <3C03B06> 4/3 0F2@>639 5<93< A69 45 938343 /01 6AF3 7<5F 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 A1 /3 /A1 :336 AE?@04439 06 4/3 EA13 :A139 56 B/0E/ /01 6AF3 BA1 06E8@939 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 /3 1AF3/A1654:336E561093<39:;<3125693645 & 4 01 E56436939 4/A4 B/36 4/3 234040563< FA93 A2280EA4056 5< <32<31364A4056 4/3 <312569364 A@4/5<04031 5@>/4 45 /AC3 AEE32439 4/3 <32<31364A4056 A69 2<5C0939 A6 5225<4@604; 45 4/3 234040563< 45 2@4 75<4/ /01 EA13 57 4/3<3:306>65A883>A405657E<0F06A8EA131236906>A>A0614 /0F A69 4/A4 06E8@1056 57 /01 6AF3 A69 E56406@06> /01 - 5 - 6AF3 06 4/3 5B9; /334 3>0143< 01 C058A40C3 57 4/3 2<06E02831576A4@<A8J@140E306E8@906>/0123<156A880:3<4; 4 01 A815 E56436939 4/A4 06 12043 57 4/3 234040563< :306> AE?@04439 06 4/3 EA13 4/A4 BA1 70839 A>A0614 /0F A69 9312043 4/3 <32<31364A4056 :306> FA93 4/3234040563<-16AF30165414<@E=5777<5F4/3<3>0143<57 <5B90314/3<3:;EA@106>@64589/A<91/02A69C058A405657 /017@69AF364A8<0>/4577<33F5C3F364A69/0180:3<4; ) 401A815E56436939:;4/383A<639E5@61384/A4 <3125693641 /AC3 654 75885B39 4/3 63E311A<; >@09380631 8A0995B6:;4/015@<4064/3EA1357 <325<439 06 /3<375<3 /3 E5643691 4/A4 0F280EA406> 4/3 234040563< A69<3>0143<06>/01 6AF306 4/3<5B9;1/33401 0883>A8A69C058A40C3572<06E02831576A4@<A8J@140E3 36E3 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< <3?@0<31 45 :3 <3F5C39 A69 E5613?@3648; 4/3 1A09 5<93< :3 ?@A1/39 36E3 4/3 234040563<0123<75<E3945A22<5AE/4/015@<406C5=06>4/3 B<04J@<0190E4056 - 6 - ' 83A<639 9904056A8 5C3<6F364 9C5EA43 <32<3136406> <312569364% 4A43 A9F041 4/3 AE?@044A8 57 4/3 234040563< 06 4/3 A75<31A09 E<0F06A8 EA13 A69 56 C3<070EA4056 A69 A743< 4A=06> 0614<@E40561 1@:F041 4/A44/3 234040563<-16AF3 01 14088 E56406@06> 06 4/3<5B9; 1/334:@44/36AF3574/3234040563<BA106E8@939064/3 5B9; /3343>0143<2<05<45AE?@044A8A69A815?@314056 57 75885B06> 4/3 >@09380631 8A09 95B6 :; 4/3 5%5<906A43 36E/ 57 4/01 5@<4 06 4/3 EA13 57 !1@2<A#B5@89654A<01375<4/3<3A1564/A406E8@1056574/3 6AF3574/3234040563<064/35B9; /3343>0143<012<05< 45 4/3 1A09 J@9>F364 36E3 4/3 1AF3 B088 654 36@<3 45 4/30<:363704EE5<906>8;/3133=145901F0114/323404056 H /AC3/3A<983A<639E5@613875<4/3234040563< A6983A<6399904056A85C3<6F3649C5EA4375<4/3 4A43 ( 4 01 A 7@69AF364A8 <@83 57 8AB 4/A4 B/36 A 23<156 01 0F280EA439 A1 A <5B9; 1/3343< :; 06E8@906> /01 6AF3064/3801457<5B9;1/3344/356@101@2564/3 4A43 45 75885B 4/3 9@3 2<5E39@<3 E5643F28A439 @693< 4/3 - 7 - <383CA64 <@831 A69 <3>@8A40561 6 4/3 2<31364 EA13 4/3 A<6A4A=A580E3A6@A8F5<3123E070EA88;4/33>0143<57 5B9031 FA064A0639 06 5<93< 5(&H B/0E/ 93A81 B04/ /0145<; 1/3341 A69 <5B9; 1/3341 A69 36<588F364 5< <3>014<A4056 57 23<1561 06 4/3 1A09 1/334 75< <3>0143< 75< E56406@5@1 F56045<06> :; 4/3 2580E3 A@4/5<04031 01 654 75885B39 4A6906> <93< 5(&H 93A81 B04/ <3>014<A4056 57<5B9031/393706040562<5C0939014/A4A<5B9;FA;:3 9370639 A1 A >@69A A69 06E8@931 A /5580>A6 45@>/ CA>A:5695<A6;23<156B/5019A6>3<5@1452@:80E23AE3 A694<A6?@0804;/3<3A<3FA6;75<F157<5B901F B/0E/ A<3 931E<0:39 4/3<306 A69 4/3 2<5E311 A69 2<5E39@<3 E5643F28A439 45:3 FA064A0639 0690773<3642A<41 6AF38; A<4A<4A69A<4B/0E/>5C3<64/3FA06436A6E3 57 A <3>0143< A69 4/3 6AF31 57 4/3 <5B9031 06 4/30< <3123E40C3 2A<41 4 01 4/3 9@4; A69 5:80>A4056 EA14 @256 4/3 <3125693641 B/0E/ 01 654 524056A8 45 75885B 4/3 9@3 2<5E39@<3E5643F28A439@693<4/314A6906>5<93<1574/3 A<6A4A=A 580E3 A6@A8 B/083 3643<06> 4/3 6AF3 57 A - 8 - 23<156 06 4/3 <5B9; 1/334 A69 4/3<3 A<3 E3<4A06 2<5E39@<3145:3FA69A45<08;75885B39:375<33643<06>4/3 6AF311E56436939:;83A<639E5@613875<4/3234040563< 4/3 2<5E311 A69 2<5E39@<3 A1 E5643F28A439 @693< 4/3 14A6906> <93< 5(&H 57 4/3 A<6A4A=A 580E3 A6@A8 /A1654:33675885B39A69655225<4@604;BA1>0C36454/3 234040563<457083/01<328;5<3D28A6A405675<<3F5C06>/01 6AF3064/35B9; /3343>0143<A69F3<38;:3EA@13/3 BA106C58C3906E<0F06A8EA1306B/0E/A8154/3234040563< /A1:336AE?@04439064/3;3A<$('401A815E56436939 4/A44/5@>/4/3234040563</A1FA93<32<31364A4056454/3 <312569364 A@4/5<04031 A743< 4/3 AE?@044A8 56 (&($($& 4/3<32<31364A4056/A1654:336E561093<39A693C36A743< 4/3AE?@044A8/3/A1:3361@FF5639454/3J@<0190E4056A8 2580E314A405675<@663E311A<;0643<<5>A4056B/364/3<301 65EA13236906>A>A0614/0F 4B5@89:3<383CA64453D4<AE42A<A><A2/5) 574/3J@9>F364570C0105636E/574/015@<4064/3EA13 57 !" " - 9 - <325<439 06 #$ %&& ' ( B/3<306 4/3 0C01056 36E/ 93A84 B04/ 10F08A< 1@:J3E4 FA443< B/0E/ <3A91 A1 @693< ! "# # $ % &'( ) # $ $ % &'( # ) *) # + ) ) ) ) # )) ) ) ) ) , )# ) - K $ 4A6906> <93< 5(&H 57 A<6A4A=A 580E3 A6@A8HH'013D4<AE439:385B &'( ./0 # ) ) 1 - 10 - .2/ 3+ / ! 45, / 6 )) # # 3 /), / !)1 + + ))))) , /*, /, / .7/ 6 # 8 8 % &&) #9 0 : 4 ) ; 0# .</. /% ) 848 0 ) ) ./% ) 848 ) = 8"48 : ) # ) ./ % ) >%#> 4 + - 11 - .'/ $ ) +*# $ # .?/% ) ) 0 : !6) ./ @ ) # ) 848 # ) 1 $ .A/ 4 # ) ) ) ) ) ) 0 " * ) ) ) .(/$ " * ) # # # 8 8 : ) ) " * 4 6) *$ # # .&/)#) # #)) - 12 - ./ @ # + $ ! 8:8 )) $ ! 808 .2/@ 8481 + 8488:8 @ 848 ) ! $ 46) .7/ % ! 808 8:8 ) 6 6) ) +*# $ .</6) + ) ) 6) 1 ! ) .'/ B C 3 ./ ) ! # - 13 - ./ ))) 2(< 4 . 9 /, ./ # ! (2./.)/.1/ ./D ! 0(?7 )# #C3 .#/0&A./ 4 , .#/0&4 4 .#/0&4 4 .#/ 0 )## , #/EC)'' '?D ! 0(?7, .C/ 0 '&( 6 4 #+ 3 .?/E# ) E " : ) + # )) # ++ )) !) + ./ @ # $ ) ) " # # .A/)&? ) - 14 - 3+ / % 2/% ) 7/5) ) </ % ) '/ ?/$F /% A/ ! .(/ 6 ) ) # ) 1 ) # ! ) - /35%5<906A4336E/574/015@<4064/3EA13 57 !1@2<A# /A1 8A09 95B6 >@09380631 B/0E/ A<3 45 :3 75885B39B/083 <3>0143<06> 4/3 6AF357 A 23<156 06 4/3 5B9; /334 3>0143< B/0E/ 3C36 2<05< 45 4/31A09J@9>F364BA1AFA69A4375<4/3<312569364145 /AC375885B3914<0E48;06AEE5<9A6E3454/314A6906>5<93< 5(&H 57 4/3 A<6A4A=A 580E3 A6@A8 B/0E/ 06 F; - 15 - 5206056 E561093<06> 4/3 7AE41 A69 E0<E@F14A6E3 57 4/3 2<31364 EA13 /A1 654 :336 75885B39 A69 3C36 A743< 4/3 AE?@044A8 57 4/3 234040563< A69 3C36 A743< 4/3 <32<31364A4056 >0C36 :; 4/3 234040563< 75< <3F5C06> /01 6AF3 7<5F 4/3 5B9; /334 3>0143< 4/3<3 01 65 <3125613 5< <328; 5< AE4056 :; 4/3 <3125693641 06 <3F5C06>/016AF3 I 6 C03B 57 656%E5F280A6E3 57 4/3 2<5E39@<3 E5643F28A439 @693< 14A6906> 5<93< 5(&H 57 4/3 A<6A4A=A 580E3 A6@A8 A69 656%E561093<A4056 57 4/3 <32<31364A4056 >0C36 :; 4/3 234040563< 2@<1@A64 45 /01 AE?@044A8 4/01 5@<4 01 57 4/3 5206056 4/A4 4/3 234040563< /A1FA935@4ACA809EA1345E561093<7AC5@<A:8; & EE5<906>8;2A114/375885B06> 0 /3<04340405601)) 00 /3 0F2@>639 5<93< 9A439 $)$$( <3>A<906>523606>5B9; /3343>0143<06 - 16 - 4/3 6AF3 57 4/3 234040563< :3A<06> 5$ 5B9;1/334 $( 2A1139 :; <3125693645$01/3<3:;?@A1/39 000 /3 <3125693641 A<3 /3<3:; 90<3E439 45 <3F5C34/36AF3574/3234040563<7<5F4/3 5B9; /3343>0143<FA064A0639:;4/3F B04/06A23<0595775@<B33=17<5F4/39A43 57<3E302457E3<407039E52;574/35<93< 0C 0:3<4; /5B3C3< 01 <313<C39 45 4/3 <312569364 4A43452<5E339 06 AEE5<9A6E3 B04/8ABA>A06144/3234040563<07A4A88A6; EA1301FA935@4A69B/0839506>154/3; 1/A8814<0E48;75885B4/3>@093806318A0995B6 :; 4/01 5@<4 06 4/3 EA13 57 <325<43906 () &!' % H