- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %& %'() %( * !! " #$ % & ' ( #$ ! ( #$) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! #$ % & ( * ' ( $ ( + , ( ( ( ( $ -. ( (( )$ )"! , ( &/'&0' &/'&-' &1' ( ( ( ( 230. ( ! 4 4 5 6/- 78././29 /- :/;8< 39<80 8=./29 $ 2: 6>0>./?> >@>0/A 30>A-6> >96/.> .2 B3>-6 .68 702=88</9@- >@>/9-. 78././2980->==3-8< 2- >9< ) /9 7; >-8 2, &>0/-/9@ 23. 2: 0/C8 2 $' 08@/-.808< D? 6/..>730> 2;/=8 :20 .68 2::89=8- 739/-6>D;8 39<80 8=./29- )$ )>9<"0E 8=./29,2: - 3 - >9< 8=./29- &'&0' &'&-'>9<&1'2:.68 &08189./29 2: .02=/./8-' =. 708-89.;? 789</9@ 29 .68 :/;8 2: <<; /-.0/=.>9< 8--/29-3<@8>.>;>D30>@/ 68 >D0/<@8< :>=.- 2: .68 =>-8 >08 .6>. 29 ">.>D23.,4 7CE68908-729<89.2!"# 39/;A3C>0 >9< !)#9/; 3C>0 E808 -.>9</9@ 98>0 /08 >->1>99>8C7;8>..>>==3-8<2-.2$/9=;3</9@.68-8 78././2980-=>C8.6808>9<7/=A8<37>B3>008;E/.608-729<89. 2 >9< >D3-8< 6/C /9 :/;.6? ;>9@3>@8 D? C89./29/9@ 6/- =>-.82E8180!">9<!)E62E808708-89..6808C><8 >9>..8C7..27>=/:?.68B3>008;..6>../C8 >==3-8<2- >9< D?62;</9@>=627780>-->3;.8<!">9<!)29.68/0 68><>9<6/9<720./29D?>D3-/9@.68C/9:/;.6?;>9@3>@868? >;-2 >-->3;.8< 08-729<89. 2 29 6/- 780-29 !689 .68 >==3-8<2.2>;-2-70/9A;8<.68=6/;;/72E<8029.688?8- 2:08-729<89.2>9<!">9<!):;8<>E>?:02C.68-72. --3=6>=2C7;>/9.E>-;2<@8<D?08-729<89.2D8:208.68 08-729<89. 2#2;/=8 29 ) >@>/9-. .68 78././2980- >9<2.680- - 4 - 9.68-.089@.62:.68->/<=2C7;>/9.(=>C8.2 D8 08@/-.808< /9 0/C8 2 $ :20 .68 >:208C89./298< 2::89=8- 3D-8B389.;? .68 08-729<89. 2#2;/=8 /918-./@>.8<.68=>-8>9<;>/<=6>0@8-688.>@>/9-.$780-29- /9=;3</9@.68-878././2980-D?>00>?/9@.68C>->==3-8<2 >9< ) ==20</9@;? .68 ;8>098< 78=/>; 3<@8 .22A =2@9/F>9=8 2: .68 2::89=8- @@0/818< D? .68 ->C8 .68 78././2980-:/;8<.6/-78././29.2B3>-6.68702=88</9@->@>/9-. .68C 8>0< ;8>098< =239-8; :20 .68 78././2980- >9< ;8>098< /@6 230. 21809C89. ;8><80 :20 08-729<89. 2 623@6 92./=8 /- -8018< .2 08-729<89. 2 68 08C>/98< >D-89. 7>0. :02C 30@/9@ -8180>; =29.89./29- .68 ;8>098< =239-8; :20 .68 78././2980- =29.89<8< .6>. 29 7803->; 2: .68 =2C7;>/9. >9< =6>0@8 -688. >;;8@>./29- 8G=87. .68 2C9/D3- >;;8@>./29- C><8 >@>/9-. .68-8 78././2980- .6>. .68? E808 708-89. /9 .68 -=898 2: 2==30089=8 >D-2;3.8;? 92 -78=/:/= 2180.>=. >..0/D3.8- >@>/9-. .68C 8 :30.680 =29.89<8< .6>. .6808/->=239.80=>-8:/;8<D?.68>==3-8<2/9.6/-=>-8 - 5 - >@>/9-. 08-729<89. 2 >9< 2.680- E6/=6 E>- 08@/-.808< /9 0/C8 2 , - -3=6 23. 2: 189@8>9=8 > :>;-8 =2C7;>/9.6>-D889:2/-.8<>@>/9-..68-878././2980->9<>..68 /9-.>9=8 2: 08-729<89. 2 .68 08-729<89. 2#2;/=8 :/;8< =6>0@8 -688. >@>/9-. .68-8 78././2980- >9< 2.680- 89=8 68 =29.89<8< .6>. .68 =29./93>./29 2: .68 702=88</9@- >@>/9-. .68-8 78././2980- /- >D3-8 2: 702=8-- 2: 230. ==20</9@;? 70>?-.2>;;2E.6878././29 " ;8>098</@6230. 21809C89.;8><80 2772-8< .2 .68 78././29 D? =29.89</9@ .6>. 92E =6>0@8 -688. 6>- D889 :/;8< >@>/9-. 78././2980- >- -3=6 .68 702=88</9@- >@>/9-. .68C =>992. D8 B3>-68< ==20</9@;? 68 70>?- .2 </-C/--.6878././29 ) 6>18@/189C?>9G/23-=29-/<80>./29D2.629.68 -3DC/--/29 C><8 D? .68 ;8>098< =239-8; :20 .68 08-78=./18 7>0./8->9<7803-8<.68=6>0@8-688.C>.80/>;- $ - =23;< D8 @>.6808< :02C 08=20<- .68 =2C7;>/9. >9< =6>0@8 -688. >;;8@>./29- 29 .68 <>.8 2: /9=/<89. /8 " 08-729<89. 2 >;29@ E/.6 !" >9< !) E808 -/../9@ >. /08 >->1>99> 8C7;8 >..> >. .6>. ./C8 .68 - 6 - >==3-8< 780-29- =>C8 .6808 >9< B38-./298< .68 08-729<89. 2#! !" >9< !) E6? .68? E808 -8>.8< .6808 >.80 >==3-8< 2- >9< >-->3;.8< !" >9< !) E/.6 .68 =627780- >9< =>3-8< /9H30/8- .2 .68C 68? >;-2 >-->3;.8< 08-729<89. 2 >9< .608>.898< E/.6 </08 =29-8B389=8 68 2.680 >==3-8< 2- >9< -70/9A;8< =6/;;/ 72E<80 29 .68 8?8- 2: 08-729<89. 2 >9< 2.680- 2E8180 .6808 /- 92 -78=/:/= >;;8@>./29- >@>/9-. .68-8 78././2980- >08 :20.6=2C/9@ 8189/9.68=2C7;>/9.20/9.68=6>0@8-688.C>.80/>;-8G=87. -.>./9@ .6>. .68? >08 708-89. /9 .68 -=898 2: 2==30089=8 <C/..8<;?.6808E>->=239.80=>-8:/;8<D?>==3-8<2/9 .6/- =>-8 >@>/9-. 08-729<89. 2 >9< 2.680- E6/=6 /- 08@/-.808</90/C82 , , 92180>;;7803->;2:.68C>.80/>;-2908=20<>C 2: .68 =29-/<808< 1/8E .6>. .68 =29./93>./29 2: =0/C/9>; 702=88</9@- >@>/9-. .68-8 78././2980- >08 C>9/:8-.;? :0/12;23- 2018G>./23-20/9-./.3.8<E/.6.683;.80/20C2./18:20E08>A/9@ 189@8>9=86889./08>;;8@>./29-/9.68(>9<=6>0@8-688. >==87.8< 29 /.- :>=8 1>;38 8189 .689 .68 ->C8 <2 92. =29-./.3.8 2::89=8- =6>0@8 -688.8< >@>/9-. .68 - 7 - 78././2980->==3-8<2 >9<)==20</9@;?702=88<.2 7>--.68:2;;2E/9@4 / 6878././29/- // 68 702=88</9@- >@>/9-. 78././2980->==3-8< 2- >9< ) /9 7; >-8 2, &>0/-/9@23.2:0/C82 $'08@/-.808<D? 6/..>730> 2;/=8 :20 .68 2::89=8- 739/-6>D;8 39<80 8=./29- ) $ ) >9< " 0E 8=./29 , 2: >9< 8=./29- &'&0' &'&-' >9< &1' 2: .68 &08189./292:.02=/./8-'=.708-89.;?789</9@ 29.68:/;82:<<;/-.0/=.>9< 8--/29-3<@8 >.>;>D30>@//-6808D?B3>-68< +) %!( ! /-.24 ;24