Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54455 (KAR)
BABUMIYAN AND ORS v. MR.ANJANNA AND ANR
MFA/201669/2019 · 2026-01-21
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54455 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54455 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! ! "#"$
%#!! ! !!&&
'( )
!!&&
'( )
! "#
$
%
!%
$
&''
( $
)
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'' *
'*
! $
'' $
&'
( '$
+
!, $)
+ +
-%()
+ $ ' # ''
# !- ! ' $ %! $
#
'
+ #!. "# #
+
%%
! +
!%
$
% +
! $
"+ +
/
$
- 3 -
+ +
-
$
+" +
$ ''
'
+''
''
( $
)
'' *
'*
! $
'' $
'
( '$
+
!, $
! ! ! ++ )
++
-%()
+ $'
#!- ! ' $ %! $
#
'
+ # !. ++0
0
+
+
''
+
#$
- 4 -
1
#
23456728234925:;<9=283>>238?;4672>346@2=
! 72=2 3>>238= 342 >42?24425 AB 672 :83@C396= 3==3@8@9D 672 <5DC296 395 3E345 53625 !- ! @9 $
;%! 395$ ;%! ;9672?@82;?29@;4@F@8 <5D2 395 <C93A35 (?;4 =7;46 G672 4@A<9380) 5@=C@==@9D672:83@C>26@6@;9=
% +;4 672 =3H2 ;? :;9F29@29:2 672 >346@2= E@88 A2 42?244256;3=>24672@4439H@9DA2?;426724@A<938
724282F396?3:6=?;435I<5@:36@;9;?67@=3>>238342 6736 ;9 ! 672 52:23=25 <=<? 739 395 8@B3= 739 38;9DE@67;6724=E242>4;:225@9D@939<6;4@:H=73EA234@9D 42D@=6436@;9 ;%!/6;E345=@534395E729672<6; @:H=73E423:72592342F39@+34C;9@534<C93A354;35 3667366@C2;9295@:3:34A234@9D42D@=6436@;9 ;% /- A2@9D54@F29@9343=739592D8@D296C3992453=7256;672<6;
4@:H=73E 395 672423?624 672 =3@5 95@:3 :34 E3= 9;6 =6;>>25 395 82?6 672 3::@5296 >83:2 72423?624 672 52:23=25 <=<? - 5 -
739 395 8@B3= 739 E242 63H29 6; 672 7;=>@638 72 <=<? 7395@25@9672;F249C296;=>@6388@B3=739E3=63H296;
672
# 7;=>@638 B5243A35 395 63H29 64236C296 ?4;C ! -! 6;
% -! D3@9 72 E3= =7@?625 6; ;F249C296;=>@638395;9672=3C253B725@2529:2672 82D38 42>42=29636@F2= ;? 52:23=25 <=<? 739 395 8@B3= 739 73F2 ?@825 :83@C >26@6@;9= @9 $ ;%! ! 395 $
;%! 42=>2:6@F28B ;67 672 >26@6@;9= E242 :8<AA25 6;D26724AB6724@A<938
?624 =24F@:2 ;? 9;6@:2 672 42=>;95296= 2962425 3>>23439:2395:;962=625672C36624;9C24@6=
6 @= 672 =>2:@?@: :3=2 ;? 672 42=>;952969=<439:2 :;C>39B 6736 672 F27@:82 @9 J<2=6@;9 E3= 9;6 @9F;8F25 @9 672 3::@52967242?;42=;<D76?;45@=C@==38;?672:83@C>26@6@;9= 9;45246;2=63A8@=7672@4:3=267422E@692==2=E2422K3C@925 AB672:83@C396=3='#6;'#%395C34H25!%5;:<C296= 3=K'6;K'!%2=>;95296=73F22K3C@925;92E@692== 3= # 395 C34H25 6E; 5;:<C296= 3= K 395 K! 72 4@A<938 3?624 :;9=@524@9D 672 C3624@38 ;9 42:;45 AB @6= <5DC296 395 3E345 53625 !- ! 5@=C@==25 A;67 672
- 6 -
:83@C >26@6@;9= +228@9D 3DD4@2F25 AB 672 =3C2 672 :83@C396= 73=>42?24425672=23>>238= - 2345 4@3A< 263D<553 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D ?;4 672 :83@C396= 395 4@ =>388@ 8234925 :;<9=28?;467242=>;95296 ;!@9A;676723>>238=
234925:;<9=284@3A<263D<5533>>234@9D ?;4 672 3>>288396= AB @9F@6@9D 672 366296@;9 ;?
67@= ;<46 6; >343D43>7 ;-395!%;?672@C><D925<5DC296;?672 64@A<938 395 =<AC@6625 6736 672 4@A<938 73= :;CC@6625 39 244;4@95@=C@==@9D672:83@C>26@6@;9==;828B;9672D4;<956736 672:734D2=7226E3=?@825A2B;95!53B=39567242?;42672 =3@5?@95@9D42:;4525AB6724@A<93842J<@42=6;A2@9624?2425 E@673=6722F@529:2;942:;45E;<85=<A=6396@362672?3:66736 672 95@:3 34 A234@9D 42D@=6436@;9 ;% /- E3= @9F;8F25 @9 672 3::@5296 395 3::;45@9D8B =;<D76 ?;4 @9624?2429:2 9 ;4524 6; =<A=6396@362 672@4 :3=2 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D ?;4 672 3>>288396= >83:2= 428@39:2 ;9 672 <5DC296 ;? 672 ;91A82 <>42C2 ;<46 @9 '()
; %! / 53625 ! !! ! 395 :;9629525 6736 672
- 7 -
?@95@9D42:;4525AB6724@A<93842J<@42=6;A2@9624?2425E@67 @967@=:3=2 / '24 :;9643 4@ =>388@ 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D?;467242=>;952969=<439:2:;C>39B=6429<;<=8B :;9629525 6736 672 95@:3 :34 A234@9D 42D@=6436@;9 ;
% /-73=A229?38=28B@C>8@:36256;=2:<42:;C>29=36@;9AB 672:83@C396=395@967@=42D345@6@=:;9629525AB6728234925 :;<9=28 6736 672 4@A<938 3?624 :;9=@524@9D 672 C3624@38 ;9 42:;4573=344@F25363:;9:8<=@;9673667242E3=9;53C3D2 :3<=256;67236395@:3:34E7@:7E;<85=<A=6396@3626736672 =3@5 F27@:82 E3= 9;6 @9F;8F25 @9 672 3::@5296, 3::;45@9D8B =;<D76?;45@=C@==38;?6723>>238=
9 67@= 42D345 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D ?;4 672 42=>;95296 ;!>83:2=428@39:2;9672<5DC296;?67@=;<46 @9 672 :3=2 ;? 42>;4625 @9 395 34D<25 6736 672?@95@9D42:;4525AB6724@A<93842J<@42=6;A2:;9?@4C25@9 672=23>>238=29:2=;<D76?;45@=C@==38;?6723>>238=
96728@D76;?672=<AC@==@;9C352AB6728234925 :;<9=28=?;4672>346@2=@6@=9;6@95@=><623=6;672?3:66736
- 8 -
67252:23=25 <=<?7393958@B3=739E242>4;:225@9D@939 <6;4@:H=73EA234@9D42D@=6436@;9 ;%!/;9@534 <C93A35 4;35 ;9 ! 72 4@A<938 5@=C@==25 672 :83@C >26@6@;9= ;9 672 =;82 D4;<95 6736 672 + E3= ?@825 A2B;95!53B=395?<46724672>39:7393C3E3=:;95<:625 3?624 83>=2 ;?- 53B= ;? 3::@5296 395 67242?;42 672 4@A<938 52:8@9256;@9624?242E@67672:83@C>26@6@;9= ! 9:342?<8:;9=@52436@;9;?672?@95@9D42:;4525AB 672 4@A<938 36 >343D43>7 ;= - 395 !% E;<85 @95@:362 67366725283B@9?@8@9D672:734D2=7226:399;6A23D4;<95?;4 529B@9D :;C>29=36@;9 ;4 5@=><6@9D 672 @9F;8F2C296 ;? 672 F27@:82@9J<2=6@;93=@6@=6725<6B;?672>;8@:23<67;4@6@2=6; 63H2 3>>4;>4@362 3:6@;9 ?;4 ?@8@9D ;? 672 :734D2=7226 @CC25@3628B 3?624 672 :;C>826@;9 ;? @9F2=6@D36@;9 9=;?34 3= 672 34D<C296 35F39:25 AB 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D ?;4 672 42=>;952969=<439:2 :;C>39B 3= 6; @C>8@:36@;9 ;? 672 95@:3 :34 @9 672 3::@5296 73F2 :342?<88B 2K3C@925 672 + =<>>;4625E@67672:;C>83@96E7242@9@6@=:82348B=63625@9672 :;C>83@96395672+6736;9236395@:3:3473=53=7256;
672 3<6; @9 E7@:7 672 52:23=25 E3= 643F288@9D 7;<D7 672
- 9 -
42D@=6436@;99<CA24;?672:3473=9;6A229C296@;925@9672 :;C>83@96 7;E2F24 6736 @6=28? :399;6 A2 3 D4;<95 6;5@=C@== 672:83@C>26@6@;9=;9672=;82D4;<953=67252:23=25395672 @9I<425 >24=;9= E242 643F288@9D @9 672 <6; 4@:H=73E 73F2 ?288 5;E939538=;@6@=9;6@95@=><626736672=3@595@:3:34439 3E3B?4;C672=>;6395672=3@53=>2:6:399;6A2@D9;425AB 63H@9D @96; 672 2F@529:2 ;? '# 6; '#% 9 67@= 42D345 ?@95 ?;4:2 @9 672 =<AC@==@;9 C352 AB 672 8234925 :;<9=28 ?;4 6723>>288396= % 7;<D7 672 8234925 :;<9=28 3>>234@9D ?;4 672 42=>;952969=<439:2 :;C>39B >83:2= 428@39:2 ;9 672 <5DC296 ;?
67@= :;<46 @2 (42?24425 =<>43) 7;E2F24 672 ?@95@9D 42:;4525 AB 672 4@A<938 @9 672 >42=296:3=2=:399;6A23::2>625=;828B;9672D4;<956736672 :83@C396= 73F2 :;CC@6625 3 ?43<5 52=>@62 672 ?3:6 6736 672 4@A<938 73= 344@F25 36 672 :;9:8<=@;9 6736 672 :734D2=7226 73= A229 ?@825 395 >39:7393CC3 E3= 543E9 3?624 !53B= E7@:742J<@42=6;A2=264@D76@9672=23>>238=29:2@6@=3?@6 :3=2 6; 42C395 672 C36624 6; 672 4@A<938 ?;4 3==2==C296 ;? :;C>29=36@;9@93::;4539:2E@6783E
- 10 -
967242=<86672?;88;E@9D
(@) 723>>238@=388;E25@9>346, (@@) 72:;CC;9<5DC2963953E34553625 !- ! >3==25 @9 $ ;=%! 395 %! ;9 672 ?@82 ;? 672 29@;4 @F@8 <5D2 395 <C93A35@=7242AB=263=@52395672C36624 @=42C@66256;6724@A<938?;4?42=7:;9=@52436@;93= 6;3E345@9D;?:;C>29=36@;96;672:83@C396=3956; >3==3>>4;>4@362;4524=@93::;4539:2E@6783E, (@@@) @9:2672:83@C>26@6@;9=342;?672B234 ! 395 672 >346@2= 342 42>42=29625 674;<D7 672@4 :;<9=28= 672 >346@2= 342 5@42:625 6; 3>>234 A2?;42 6724@A<938;9/ !! !36 3C, (@F) 724@A<938@=42J<2=6256;2K>25@62672 7234@9D395:;C>8262672>4;:225@9D=366722348@2=6
!* '! !) #
$ @=6 ;8 ; '