- 1 - !"!# $%"" && '&( ) !"#$ % & ' " ((( ( ( !"#) ( # !"#$ * ((( !" + ( ( *" !"* ( ( ! !"* % & , "- ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - , "## , ( " #$ #" "$"##) , ") #) ##) *##$ & ' , , ( . " % /01 123456 788279 01 8:2;2::26 <= 62;25675> 4 " 3/79925?05?>/2@A6?B25>756623:2267>26" #$ #"871126 05 4 "$"##)<=660>04579 01>:03>A6?20@78A:C;4: <:2D0>= E>/2 ,0:1> 882997>2 4A:>FG H/03/ 345;0:B26 >/2 @A6?B25> 756 4:62: 67>26 ") #) ##) 871126 05 4 *##$<=660>045790D09A6?2&: 5 '0@78A: C;4:<:2D0>=E>/2:0794A:>FG /2 89705>0;; /71 ;0926 >/2 1A0> ;4: 87:>0>045 756 1287:7>2 8411211045 4; /2: "*:6 1/7:2 05 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>=345>25605?>/7>62;25675>4 "0 2 78829975>/2:20501 /2: <:4>/2: 756 62;25675> 4 01 H0;2 4; 62;25675> 4 " 62;25675> 4 * 01 >/2 10<905? 4; <4>/ 89705>0;; 756 62;25675> 4 " 756 62;25675> 41 + 756 7:2 >/2 67A?/>2:1 4; - 3 - 62;25675>41 "756 334:605?>4>/289705>0;;9756<27:05? = 4 +" B271A:05? 73:21 $ ?A5>71 756 9756 <27:05? = 4 +" B271A:05? + 73:21 10>A7>26 7> 7I/7567I0 D0997?2J0@78A:C;4:<:2D0>=K>/21A0>8:482:>021LG7:2>/2 75321>:798:482:>0214;89705>0;;75662;25675>1 /2B4>/2:4; >/289705>0;;62;25675>41 "756*75?7DD7149684:>0451 4;/2:8:482:>=6A:05?/2:90;2>0B2756:2B70505?2M>25>4;"# 73:21 $ ?A5>71 05 9756 <27:05? = 4 +" :2B70526 05 /2: 57B2 1/2 6026 45 # #* ")!$ 756 62;25675> 4 " ?4> BA>7>26/0157B205:21823>4;>/28:482:>=H/03/01>/21A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>= 4H2D2: >/2 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1 345>05A26 05 8411211045 4; >/2 17B2 5 >/2 =27: ")) 62;25675>4 "2;;23>2687:>0>04505:21823>4;>/21A0>13/26A92 8:482:>= 756 7994>>26 + 73:21 4; 9756 >4 /01 145 05 = 4 +" 5 >/2 1>:25?>/ 4; >/2 17B2 62;25675> 4 " 1>7:>26 3970B05? :0?/> 4D2: >/2 :2B70505? 9756 <27:05? = 4 +"B271A:05?73:2$?A5>71 /21454;>/262;25675> 4 "6026011A29211>H4=27:18:04:>4>/2051>0>A>0454;>/21A0> 7>2: >/2 89705>0;; 05101>26 ;4: 87:>0>045 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>02105>/2=27:## 4H2D2:>/217B2H71841>84526 <=62;25675>4 "756;05799=625026 2532>/289705>0;;;0926 - 4 - >/21A0>;4:87:>0>0457561287:7>284112110454;/2:"*:61/7:2 05>/21A0>8:482:>021 * ;>2:12:D0324;1ABB451>/262;25675>178827:26 <2;4:2 >/2 >:079 4A:> 756 ;0926 H:0>>25 1>7>2B25> 345>25605? >/7>>/21A0>8:482:>0217:254>75321>:798:482:>0214;89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1 334:605? >4 >/2B 7> 54 8405> 4; >0B2 87:>0>045H712;;23>2605:21823>4;>/2170613/26A928:482:>021 71 3970B26 <= >/2 89705>0;; 334:605? >4 >/2 62;25675>1 452 066A7671/0D788775AB7?456A562:7:2?01>2:26?0;>6226 67>26 #" ")+#?0;>26>/29756<27:05?= 4 +B271A:05? ")73:2?A5>71>4>/2B4>/2:4;62;25675>4 "75?7DD7 A:05? /2: 90;2>0B2 1/2 1496 + 73:21 4; 9756 >4 452 0667887 7MB75 7957D7:05>/2=27:")$# 7>2:05>/2=27:")$+1/2 ?7D2 A8 /2: :0?/> 05 >/2 :2B70505? 8:482:>= >4 /2: 459= 145 62;25675>4 "<=H7=4;713/=7>79I0 5>/2=27:")$ 1/2 7?705 1496 73:21 4; 9756 4A> 4; >/2 = 4 +" /2 1706 75?7HH7 6026 45 # #* ")!$ 756 57B2 4; 62;25675> 4 " H71 25>2:26 05 05 :21823> 4; >/2 = 4 +" B271A:05? "# 73:2 $ ?A5>7 334:605?9= >/2 62;25675> 4 " 1A3322626 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>= 756 345>05A26 05 8411211045 4; >/2 - 5 - 17B2 5 >/2 =27: ")) 62;25675> 4 " 87:>0>04526 >/2 1A0> 13/26A928:482:>=<2>H225/01;7B09=B2B<2:1 /29756H71 1A< 60D0626 71 = 4 +" B271A:05? 73:2 $ ?A5>7 756 = 4 +" B271A:05? + 73:21 5 >/2 87:>0>045 >/2 9756 <27:05?= 4 +""H71?0D25>4/011457567;>2:/01627>/ 45 *##"## >/2 17B2 H71 1>75605? 05 >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675> 41 " + 756 > 01 345>25626 >/7> >/2 1A0> 13/26A928:482:>021H2:2;79925>4>/21/7:262;25675>16A:05? >/2 90;2>0B2 4; >/2 B4>/2: 4; 62;25675> 54 " 756 10532 >/25 >/2= 7:2 05 >/2 97H;A99 8411211045 756 25@4=B25> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A928:482:>0217567>548405>4;>0B2>/28:482:>021H2:2 05 @405> 8411211045 4; 89705>0;; 756 62;25675>1 2532 /2 8:7=1>4601B011>/21A0> + /2:0794A:>7;>2:3451062:05?>/2:0D798927605?1 ;:7B26 >/2 :292D75> 011A21 756 45 711211B25> 4; 4:79 756 643AB25>7:=2D062532623:226>/21A0>?:75>05?"*:61/7:205 >/2 1A0> 8:482:>021 756 4:62:26 ;4: 87:>0>0451 <= B2>21 756 <4A561 5 788279 >/2 ,0:1> 882997>2 4A:> 45 :2 788:2307>045 4; >/2 643AB25>1 756 2D062532 7D7097<92 45 - 6 - :234:6 601B01126 >/2 788279 756 >/2:2<= 345;0:B26 >/2 @A6?B25> 756 623:22 871126 <= >/2 :079 4A:> 2532 >/2 62;25675>4 "01<2;4:2>/014A:> 27:6 >/2 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 78829975>162;25675>1756:21845625>89705>0;; $ > 01 345>25626 <= >/2 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 78829975>>/7>>/2:0794A:>756>/2,0:1>882997>24A:>/7D2 ?:4119=2::26H/092871105?>/2@A6?B25><=623:2205?>/21A0> H0>/4A>788:2307>05?>/22D062532756643AB25>145:234:605 7 :0?/> 82:1823>0D2 334:605? >4 /0B >/2 1A0> ;4: 87:>0>045 01 54>B705>7057<92H0>/4A>3/79925?05?>/2>:751;2:4;>/2>0>924; 1A0>8:482:>02105;7D4A:4;>/262;25675>54 " 334:605?>4>/2 927:526 34A5129 >/2 >:079 4A:> /71 2::26 05 751H2:05? 7660>04579011A24 "45>/2?:4A56>/7>>/262;25675>4 "606 54> 8:4D2 >/7> /2 /71 92?799= 73JA0:26 :0?/>1 4D2: >/2 1A0> 13/26A928:482:>021756711A3//20154>>/27<149A>24H52:4; >/21A0>8:482:>02162180>2/273JA0:26>/28:482:>021>/:4A?/ M )>/2 D7:760713/=7> 79I0 2M23A>26 <= /01 B4>/2: ,A:>/2: >/2 2D062532 4; ( " 3927:9= 62803>1 >/7> <7126 45 M ) 799 >/2 :2D25A2 25>:021 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 - 7 - 7:2 B762 05 >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675> 4 " 71 1A3/ /2 87:>0>04526>/21A0>13/26A928:482:>021<2>H225/0B129;756/01 ;7B09= B2B<2:1 5 1A3/ 30:3AB1>75321 >/2 1A0> ;0926 <= >/2 89705>0;; 01 54> B705>7057<92 756 7334:605?9= 8:7=1 >4 601B011 >/21A0>;0926<=>/289705>0;; ! 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 :21845625> 1A<B0>>26 >/7> 89705>0;; 62;25675> 4 " 756 62;25675> 4 * <205? 3/096:25 4; 62327126 75?7DD7 7:2 25>0>926 ;4: "*:6 1/7:2273/05>/21A0>13/26A928:482:>02171>/20:B4>/2:6026 05>21>7>2 927D05? <2/056 /2: >/:22 3/096:25 2 ;A:>/2: 345>25626 >/7> 76B0>>269= >/2 B4>/2: 4; 89705>0;; 62;25675> 41 " 756 * /71 54> 2M23A>26 75= H099 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 756 <7126 45 M ) >/2 D7:760 >/2 62;25675>4 "25>2:26/0157B205>/2BA>7>045:2?01>2:756 1A<12JA25>9= 2;;23>26 7 87:>0>045 <2>H225 /0B129; 756 /01 ;7B09=B2B<2:1 >01345>25626>/7> 7182:>/2D7:76067>26 #$ ")$+ >/2 8:482:>= H71 BA>7>26 05 >/2 57B2 4; >/2 62;25675> 4 " 6A:05? >/2 90;2 >0B2 4; 89705>0;;F1 B4>/2: 1 1A3/0>01JA0>23927:>/7>>/262;25675>54 "01897=05?;:7A6 45>/289705>0;;756054:62:>4?:7<>/21A0>13/26A928:482:>021 - 8 - <= 3499A605? H0>/ :2D25A2 4;;030791 25>2:26 /01 57B2 05 >/2 :2D25A2 :234:61 756 >/2:27;>2: <= 87:>0>04526 >/2 17B2 <2>H225 /01 ;7B09= B2B<2:1 2532 /2 1A<B0>>26 >/7> >/2 :079 4A:> 756 >/2 ,0:1> 882997>2 4A:> /7D2 :0?/>9= 623:226 >/21A0> 334:605?9=/28:7=1>4601B011>/27882798:2;2::26 <=>/262;25675>1 ) 845 /27:05? 45 76B011045 >/01 4A:> ;:7B26 >/2 ;4994H05?1A<1>75>079JA21>04514;97H "# /7D2 ?0D25 B= 75M04A1 3451062:7>045 45 >/2 1A<B0110451 B762 <= >/2 927:526 34A5129 ;4: >/2 :21823>0D2 87:>021756>/2643AB25>17D7097<9245:234:6 "" 1 34A96 <2 ?7>/2:26 ;:4B >/2 :234:61 >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 7:2 >/2 129; 73JA0:26 8:482:>021 4; 452 75?7DD7H/401>/2B4>/2:4;89705>0;;62;25675>41 "756 - 9 - * >0154>056018A>2>/7>>/2170675?7DD7602605>21>7>2 > 01>/2345>25>0454;>/262;25675>4 ">/7>6A:05?>/290;2>0B2 4; 62327126 75?7DD7 1/2 ?7D2 A8 /2: :0?/> 05 >/2 1A0> 13/26A928:482:>021>4/0B<=H7=4;8713/=7>B79I07567;>2: >/2 /2:627>/ 05 >/2=27: ")!$ /2 1A3322626 >/28:482:>021 5 37:2;A9 82:A179 4; M ) >/2 57B2 4;>/2 62;25675> 4 " H71 25>2:26 05 >/2 BA>7>045 :2?01>2: 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 <= D0:>A2 4; 713/=7> 79I0 /2 17B2 01 67>26 #$ ")$+ 756 0BB2607>29= >/2 :2D25A2 25>:021 H2:2 B762 05 >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675> 4 " 4H2D2: >/2 1706 75?7DD7 6026 45 # #* ")!$ 6B0>>269= 75?7DD7 606 54> 2M23A>2 75= H099 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 5 1A3/ 30:3AB1>75321 0> 37554> <2 1706 >/7> >/2 75?7DD7 /76 H01/ >4 ?0D2 7H7= >/2 25>0:2 1A0> 8:482:>021 05 ;7D4A: 4; 62;25675>4 " /2D7:7608713/=7>B79I00154>1A884:>26<= 75=4>/2:643AB25>12M23A>26<=6232712675?7DD7756>/2 17B2 01 459= H:0>>25 <= :2D25A2 4;;032:1 H/092 BA>7>05? >/2 57B2 4; 62;25675> 4 " 05 :21823> 4; >/2 1A0> 13/26A92 8:482:>021 11A3/05B=3451062:26D02H>/2:0794A:>756 >/2 ,0:1> 882997>2 4A:> /7D2 :0?/>9= /296 >/7> >/2 62327126 75?7DD7602605>21>7>2756>/289705>0;;75662;25675>41 " - 10 - 756*7:2/2:3/096:257994;>/2B7:22JA799=25>0>926;4:"*:6 1/7:2 273/ 05 >/2 1A0> 8:482:>021 334:605?9= >/2 1A<1>75>079 JA21>0451 4; 97H :70126 7<4D2 7:2 751H2:26 05 >/2 52?7>0D2 /2 788279 973I1 B2:0>1 756 >/2 17B2 01 907<92 >4 <2 *+ '"( " B1: 01>4 "94 )