- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#! !" '&( ! "#$ % & ' ( ###( ! #( " ! #( ) Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( "" ' * $ ' ! "#$ ! ' "# &' ! "#) $ ) ! "#$ % ' ("+ ' )$ , , ' , , -. , - 3 - /& 012 34515167 12 8194: ;< 504 345151674= 244>17? 504 86996@17?=49148 ! " " #! $% " & '! ! ! ( ! ) *)+ $ , % +- 5 12 504 A675475167 68 504 345151674= 50B5 504 345151674=125046@74=B7:36224226=685049B7:2;4B=17? C=D4< 6 # E4B2C=17? (# BA=42 ( ?C75B2 B7: C=D4<6 # E4B2C=17?#?C75B2215CB54:B5D199B?4 6?1 D199B?4 0B0B3C= B9C> 125=1A5 B:?1=1 B7: C=D4< 6$ E4B2C=17? BA=42 ")?C75B2 215CB54: B5 - 4 - D199B?46:BEB7B0B9910B0B3C=B9C>125=1A5B:?1=1 5 128C=504=A67547:4:50B5504345151674=125046@74=68504 9B7:2;<D1=5C4686=B91;B:B54:# (## 4F4AC54:;< 012E6504=179B@B5466=GB0B74?CE175043=4247A4 68 B99 504 ;=6504=2 < D1=5C4 68 504 2B1: 1;B 504 345151674=121734BA48C93622422167B7:47G6<E47568504 3=634=5142B2B9B@8C96@74= " 012 ;417? 504 25B54 68 B88B1=2 504 ;=6504=2 68 504345151674=25B=54:561754=84=4175049B@8C93622422167 68504345151674=47A4504345151674=8194:6((68 ##!B?B1725012E6504=B7:;=6504=286=:4A9B=B5167B7: 17GC7A51677504;B21268504B:D1A468@499@1204=2B7: 8BE19< E4E;4=2 504 3B=5142 56 504 2C15 B==1D4: B5 B A6E3=6E124 B7: =4A6?71H4: 504 =1?05 B7: 3622422167 68 504 345151674= ;< D1=5C4 68 6=B9 1;B B7: B G6175 A6E3=6E124 34515167 ABE4 56 ;4 8194: C15 @B2 :4A=44: ;B24:67504A6E3=6E12434515167176((68##! 67 #((##! 5 12 8C=504= A67547:4: 50B5 :C=17? 504 918451E4 68 E6504= 68 504 345151674= 504 345151674= @B2 - 5 - B996@4: 56 =4EB17 17 504 3=634=5142 04=4B854= 504 ;=6504= 68 504 345151674= 7BE49< ;:C9 B044E B7: 012 86996@4=2 B=4 5=423B2217? B7: 966517? 504 A=632 8=6E 504 3=634=514268504345151674=04=486=4504345151674=8194: B A6E39B175 ;486=4 504 GC=12:1A5167B9 3691A4 B?B1725 504 BAAC24: 7 D14@ 68 504 8BA5 50B5217A4 504 3691A4:1: 765 5B>4 B7< BA5167 504 345151674= 8194: B A6E39B175 C7:4= 4A5167 ## 68 504 6:4 68 =1E17B9 =6A4:C=4 17 6((68#";486=4504::15167B91D19&C:?4B7:& 6C=50B0B3C=;B24:67@01A0B:1=4A5167@B2?1D4756 504 GC=12:1A5167B9 3691A4 56 A67:CA5 17D4251?B5167 =4?1254= 504AB24B7:2C;E15B=436=5 ) 5 12 504 A675475167 68 504 94B=74: A6C7249 86= 345151674= 50B5 :423154 504 6=:4= ;417? 3B224: ;< 504 94B=74: B?125=B54 504 817B9 =436=5 0B2 765 ;447 8194: ;< 504 GC=12:1A5167B9 3691A4 B7: 76 17D4251?B5167 0B2 ;447 A67:CA54: 47A4 B??=14D4: ;< 767A67:CA517? 68 504 17D4251?B5167B7:76781917?68504817B9=436=5:423154504 6=:4= 3B224: ;< 504 94B=74: B?125=B54 504 345151674= 12 - 6 - ;486=4 5012 6C=5 5 12 A67547:4: 50B5 504 A6?71HB7A4 12 5B>47;<50494B=74:B?125=B54B7:B:1=4A516712122C4: 56A67:CA5B717D4251?B5167B7:8194B=436=5 0B2;447 =4?1254=4:86=50468847A42C7:4=4A51672)#))* #) #=4B:@1504A5167()$68504 7:1B747B96:404 2BE4 0B2 765 AC9E17B54: 1756 B 817B9 =436=5 ;< 504 =42367:475 3691A4 04 =42367:475 3691A4 12 :C5< ;6C7: B7:6;91?B54:56:6:C=17?504A6C=2468152:C5142BD17? 765:67426504345151674=0B2B33=6BA04:50126C=5 94B=74: ::15167B9 6D4=7E475 :D6AB54=43=4247517?5045B54A67547:250B53C=2CB7556 504 6=:4= 3B224: ;< 504 94B=74: B?125=B54 B7 12 =4?1254=4:B7:17D4251?B516712173=6?=422817B9=436=512 <4556;48194:@01A0504<@199:6@15017B=4B267B;9451E4 512B926A67547:4:;<50494B=74:::15167B96D4=7E475 :D6AB5450B5504:123C5417IC42516712A1D19177B5C=4B7: C774A422B=19<5045B54EBA0174=<12C24:86=50434=267B9 D47?4B7A468504243=1DB543B=5142@01A01276534=E1554: AA6=:17?9<04244>2:12E122B96850434515167 - 7 - 4B=: 94B=74: A6C7249 86= 504 345151674= B7: 94B=74: ::15167B9 6D4=7E475 :D6AB54 B334B=17? 86= =42367:47562(56" 5B54B7:=42367:47562)56$ * 6:6C;515125=C450B5504345151674=A9B1E256 ;4 5046@74= 68504 9B7:2;<D1=5C4 681;B B7:504 A1D19 :123C54 0BD17? 47:4: 17 B A6E3=6E124 ;< D1=5C4 68 B A6E3=6E124:4A=44 512A9B1E4:50B5504BAAC24:34=2672 0BD4 EB:4 B7 B554E35 56 5=423B22 B7: 9665 504 25B7:17? A=632 68 504 345151674= 17 012 9B7:2 :423154 504 A6E3=6E124:C456@01A0504345151674=@B286=A4:568194 BA6E39B175C7:4=4A5167##68=;B24:67@01A0 504 17D4251?B5167 @B2 =484==4: C7:4= 4A5167 ( " 68 =B7: 12=4?1254=4:B7:17D4251?B516712347:17? 6 :6C;5 15 12 5=C4 50B5 17 A1D19 EB554=2 504=4 12 76 E4::917? 17 504 EB554=2 ;< 504 GC=12:1A5167B9 3691A4 ;C5 @047 B A6E39B175 12 96:?4: ;B24: 67 B A6E3=6E124 345151676=B:4A=44B994?17?A4=5B171994?B915142D169B51672 E12A0148 5=423B22 B7: B7< 3=6D121672 68 504 15 ;4A6E42B:C5<B7:6;91?B516768504=42367:475 3691A456 - 8 - 5B>474A422B=<BA51676=426175043=42475AB24@047 B A6E39B175 12 =4?1254=4: C7:4= 4A5167 ## 68 = 17D4251?B5167126=:4=4:15;4A6E42B:C5<B7:6;91?B5167 68 504 =42367:475 3691A4 56 8194 B =436=5 7 504 3=42475 AB24670B7:B33B=4759<504=41276:123C5450B5504=412 B A6E3=6E124 :4A=44 4754=4: 1756 ;45@447 504 3B=5142 042BE41276@B994?4:56;4D169B54:;<504;=6504=268 504 345151674= B2 504< 0BD4 1994?B99< 5=423B224: 1756 504 3=634=5142 B7: 0BD4 5B>47 B@B< 504 25B7:17? A=632 ABC217? 817B7A1B9 :BEB?4 86= @01A0 504 345151674= 0B2 17151B54: B A6E39B175 C7:4= 4A5167 ## 68 = B7: 17D4251?B51670B2;4476=:4=4:B7:B=436=512B@B154: 5 12 2447 50B5 504 3691A4 0BD4 765 A67:CA54: 504 17D4251?B5167 B7: 765 <45 8194: 504 817B9 =436=5 5 12 B 8C7:BE475B9 =C94 68 9B@ 50B5 504 5B54 EBA0174=< 504 =42367:475 3691A4B=46;91?B54:56A67:CA517D4251?B516717 B 51E4;6C7: EB774= B7: 2C;E15 5041= =436=5 8B1917? @01A00B=:201317A67D47147A4817B7A1B99622B7::BEB?4 A6C9: ;4 ABC24: B7: B926 EB< 94B: 56 8C=504= A=1E17B9 - 9 - AB242B?B17254BA0685043B=5142 851E49<17D4251?B516712 A67:CA54:B7:=436=5128194:5045=1B9A6C9:3=6A44:17504 =1E17B96C=5BD17?765:67426504=42367:475 3691A4 0BD4 8B194: 17 5041= :C5< 56 2C;E15 504 =436=5 @15017 B =4B267B;94 51E4 :423154 504 8BA5 50B5 504 0B2 ;447 =4?1254=4:67(((#"86=504B86=42B1:68847A42,0B5 12948556;4:674;<504=42367:475 3691A412562C;E15B 817B9 =436=5 ,04504= B AB24 12 EB:4 6= 765 12 504 :12A=45167 68 504 =42367:475 3691A4 ;B24: 67 504 17D4251?B5167 A67:CA54: ;< 504E AA6=:17?9< 5012 6C=5 :44E2 15 B33=63=1B54 56 :1=4A5 504 =42367:475 3691A4 56 A67:CA5 17D4251?B5167 B7: 2C;E15 B =436=5 17 BAA6=:B7A4 @1509B@56504GC=12:1A5167B96C=5 ! 6=504B86=42B1:=4B2672 3=6A44:563B22504 86996@17? B 04,=153451516712:123624:68 - 10 - ; @=15 68 EB7:BEC2 12 122C4: :1=4A517? =42367:475 6" 56 2C;E15 B 817B9 =436=5 B854= A67:CA517?50417D4251?B516717BAA6=:B7A4@150 9B@@150175@6E675028=6E504:B5468=4A4135 68BA63<6850126=:4= A 5 12 EB:4 A94B= 50B5 5012 6C=5 0B2 765 4F3=4224:B7<631716767504E4=15268504A1D19 :123C546=504A=1E17B991B;1915142 !)* ' !"( # "(!