Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54445 (KAR)
RANGHAVENDER v. MOHAMMED IBRAHIM AND ANR
MFA/201188/2024 · 2026-01-08
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54445 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54445 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
# $
""
%$& '
!""
#
"
$
" % &'" () * ))
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
"&
+)*
"
"
" , ) & '"
""- %(
""+)* ! #
""(
'. **)
&$
' '" #$ '
" ,""&"
'
%
&
**
"
%
,*
"
'%
'
'
% &
"
/"% % 012 /"% %""
- 3 -
#/"% %$
34 56078019 7: 71 0;;406 5306641<71< 934 %=2<8419 012 >0?2 ;0::42 @A 934 640?142 ?7157;06 7:9?759 012
4::7B1:%=2<4012
0753=?#34154CB?93?4C4??429B 0:/934?7@=106$71B,*20942**
34 C059: BC 934 50:4 0?4 9309 B1 *** 93456078019:=CC4?4271D=?74:710?B029?0CC7505572419B1 934 0753=?3012?0@0120 ?B02 >341 0 6B??A @40?71< ?4<7:9?097B1 B() *
2?7E41 71 0 ?0:3 012 14<67<41980114? ?01BE4?37:678@:>376434>0:;=:371< 37:8B9B?5A564
>3753302<B142?AB1C=463456078019 5607842930934>0:>B?F71<0:02?7E4?012>0:40?171<0 8B1936A 715B84 BC :*
*** 9B :)
*** 4 934?4CB?4 C7642 0 56078 ;49797B1 =124? 4597B1 BC 934 B9B? 437564: 59 5607871< 5B8;41:097B1 BC :
**
*** C?B8 934 B>14? 012 934 71:=?4? BC 934 BCC41271<E437564
- 4 -
3456078;49797B1>0:5B194:942@A93471:=?4? BC934BCC41271<E437564B1E0?7B=:<?B=12:0125B1941242 9309934560780193025B66=242>793934;B6754012<49971< 0 C06:4 50:4 ?4<7:94?42 0<071:9 ?4:;B12419 B 9 >0:
C=?934? 5B1941242 9309 9>B E437564: >4?4 71EB6E42 71 934 05572419 012 934?4CB?4
934 B>14? 012 71:=?4? BC 934 8B9B?5A564 >4?4 06:B ;?B;4? 012 1454::0?A ;0?974: 34 71:=?4? 06:B 0664<42 9309 934 2?7E4? BC 934 6B??A 272 1B9 ;B::4:: 0 E0672 0124CC4597E42?7E71< 6754154012 9309 934 E437564 272 1B9 30E4 0 E0672 C7914:: 54?97C75094 9B ;6A 934 E437564B10;=@675?B02906:B0664<429309934?4>0:0 E7B6097B1BC9345B12797B1:BC934;B675A
34 ?7@=106
0C94? 5B1:724?71< 934 5B194197B1:
=?<42
3462930993456078019302:=CC4?4271D=?74:9B934 678@01234302=124?<B1408;=9097B1BC934?7<3964<9 934?4CB?4
0::4::4293427:0@7679A:=CC4?42@A93456078019 09 ,*G @A 9?40971< 79 0: 0 :5342=642 71D=?A =124? 934 &B?F841/: B8;41:097B1 59 , 34 ?7@=106
- 5 -
0::4::42 934 715B84 BC 934 56078019 09 0 :=8 BC :
)*0120>0?242934CB66B>71<5B8;41:097B1 (
)*+, -./0 * 41906:3B5F0120<B1A :)*
***H** * 071I:=CC4?71< :)*
***H** * 427506099412019J:012 1B=?7:384194K;41:4:
:*
***H** *
"B::BC715B842=?71<6072=; ;4?7B2 :
)**H** *)
"B::BCC=9=?4715B84 :
)**H** *
"B::BC67C408417974:I;640:=?4 :)*
***H** * 4275064K;41:4:
:)
)
***H** * 7:C7<=?097B1 :)*
***H** *,
"B::BC4K;459097B1BC67C4 :)*
***H** * 'B??97C75706"78@ :
)*
***H**
0*( ,1!12!3
) 34 ?7@=106 27?45942 934 71:=?4? BC 934 BCC41271<E4375649B;0A9345B8;41:097B1:
)
*** 06B1<>7937194?4:909934?094BCG;4?011=8
C?B8934 2094BC93456078;49797B197669342094BC?4067L097B1
471< 0<<?74E42 @A 934 M=019=8 BC 5B8;41:097B10>0?242
934560780197:@4CB?4937:5B=?9
- 6 -
34640?1425B=1:46CB?934560780195B1941242 9309 934 ?7@=106 5B8879942 01 4??B?
71 1B9 0;;6A71< 934 1B97B106715B84;?4:5?7@42@A934B=?9CB?:499648419BC 27:;=94:09"BF20609>37537:0:=8BC:
)*
34 5B19412: 9309
>341 934 ?7@=106 302 0:54?907142 934 27:0@7679A 09 ,*G
934 56078019 >0:
41979642 9B 934 6B:: BC C=9=?4 ;?B:;459:
34
934?4CB?4 5B19412: 9309 9345B8;41:097B1 0>0?242 @A934 ?7@=106 30: 9B @4 41301542 @A C059B?71< 934 6B:: BC C=9=?4 ;?B:;459:
, 934 640?142 5B=1:46 CB? 934 71:=?4? 5B1941242 9309 934 ?7@=106 302 0>0?242 4K54::7E4 5B8;41:097B1=124?E0?7B=:3402:
B14BC>3753>0:6B::
BC 715B84 2=?71<9346072=; ;4?7B2
>3753 >0: 90F41 CB? 140?6A8B193:012934B934?>0:9345B:9BC010?97C75706 678@
* 4 5B19412: 9309
>341 934 56078019 302 =124?<B140108;=9097B1
934M=4:97B1BC6B::BC715B84
- 7 -
2=?71<9346072=;;4?7B2BC:7K8B193:>B=621B90?7:44 C=?934? 5B19412: 9309
71 :78760? 57?5=8:90154:
B=?9:
30E4 5B1:7:94196A 0554;942 934 6B:: BC 715B84 B16A CB? 0 ;4?7B2 BC 93?44 8B193: 012 1B9 CB? :7K 8B193: 4 06:B 5B19412: 9309 934 ?7@=106 302 0>0?242 0 :=8 BC :
)*
*** 9B>0?2: 0?97C75706 678@ >793B=9 934?4 @471< 01A@0:7:45B19412:93090:=8BC:
**
***>B=62 @4 0;;?B;?7094 9B>0?2: 934 5B:9 BC 934 0?97C75706 678@ 4 934?4CB?4
5B19412:9309
7C937:B=?9>4?49B4130154934 5B8;41:097B1
937: B=?9 80A 5B1:724? 934 M=019=8 BC 5B8;41:097B1 06?402A 0>0?242
0: 01 4K4?57:4 =124? 4597B1 BC 934 B9B? 437564: 59 7: 9B 0>0?2 D=:9 5B8;41:097B1 012 1B9 4KB?@79019 012 4K54::7E4 5B8;41:097B1
&4 30E4 5B1:724?42 934 :=@87::7B1: BC 934 640?142 5B=1:46 CB? 934 56078019 0: >466 0: 934 640?142 5B=1:46CB?934?4:;B12419
- 8 -
340557241971M=4:97B17:1B927:;=942@A934 71:=?4? 9 7: 06:B 1B9 71 27:;=94 9309 934 56078019 302 :=CC4?42 01 08;=9097B1 BC 934 ?7<39 678@ 34 56078019 5607842930934>0:02?7E4?012934?4CB?4
934C=1597B106 27:0@7679A :=CC4?42 @A 378 7: ?7<396A 0::4::42 @A 934 ?7@=10609,*G34?7@=106
>37645B1:724?71<9346B::
BC715B84BC93456078019
8=:930E40;;67429341B97B106 715B84 0: 5B1:724?42 @A 937: B=?9 71 50:4: ?4C4??42 CB? :499648419 @4CB?4 934 "BF 20609 55B?271<6A
0 :=8 BC :
)* 7: 5B1:724?42 0: 934 1B97B106 715B84 BC 934 56078019:?7<396A5B1941242@A934640?1425B=1:46CB? 934 56078019 :7154 934 56078019 30: :=CC4?42 01 08;=9097B1 BC 934 ?7<39 64<
37: 27:0@7679A 7: ?7<396A 5B1:724?4209,*G34?4CB?4
93456078019>0:419796429B 6B::BCC=9=?4;?B:;459:0:3462@A934B1J@64;4KB=?9 7193450:4BC
! 012 5B1:4M=4196A 934 56078019 7: 41979642 9B 6B:: BC C=9=?4 ;?B:;459:09 934 ?094 BC *G 55B?271<6A
934 715B84 BC 934 56078019
- 9 -
B=<399B30E4@4415B1:724?4209:,
,)*;4?8B193
71549345607801930::=CC4?42,*GC=1597B10627:0@7679A 34 >B=62 @4 41979642 9B 0 :=8 BC :
,)) ;4? 8B193 012 5B1:4M=4196A
934 6B:: BC C=9=?4 715B84 >B=62 @4 0 :=8BC,1 !1
!45
: ?4<0?2: 934 5B8;41:097B1 0>0?242 @A 934 ?7@=106 9B>0?2: :3B5F 012 841906 0<B1A
;071 012 :=CC4?71<
8427506 099412019 012 1B=?7:38419 4K;41:4: 6B:: BC 08417974: BC 67C4 8427506 4K;41:4: 012 27:C7<=?097B1
934:0847:1B927:9=?@42B>4E4?
9346B::
BC 715B84 2=?71< 934 6072=; ;4?7B2 BC 93?44 8B193: 24:4?E4:9B@42494?87142090:=8BC, !625
012 9345B:9BC9340?97C75706678@24:4?E4:9B@45B1:724?4209 0 :=8 BC ,
!!5 C >4 5B1:724? 934 0@BE4
934 9B906 5B8;41:097B1 ;0A0@64 7156=271< 934 5B8;41:097B1 0>0?242 @A 934 ?7@=106 =124? B934? 3402: >B=62 @4 0 :=8 BC :
,,
)* 012 7: ?B=1242 BCC 9B 0 :=8 BC , !!5 1 B=? B;717B1
934 5B8;41:097B1 2494?87142 @A =: 7: D=:9 012 ?40:B10@64 34?4CB?4
934
- 10 -
0;;406C7642@A9345607801924:4?E4:9B@4066B>4271;0?9 012 934 5B8;41:097B1 0>0?242 @A 934 ?7@=106 24:4?E4:
9B@441301542@A0:=8BC:
)
***
B1:4M=4196A 934 56078019 7: 41979642 9B 41301542 5B8;41:097B1
>3753 7: ?42494?87142 0: CB66B>: (
)*+, -./0 * 41906:3B5F0120<B1A :)*
***H** * 071I:=CC4?71< :)*
***H** * 427506099412019J:012 1B=?7:384194K;41:4:
:*
***H** *
"B::BC715B842=?71<6072=; ;4?7B2 :
)*H** *)
"B::BCC=9=?4715B84 :
,**H** *
"B::BC67C408417974:I;640:=?4 :)*
***H** * 4275064K;41:4:
:)
)
***H** * 7:C7<=?097B1 :)*
***H** *, 'B??97C75706"78@ :
**
***H**
0*( ,
!44!23
./+)+ , !!3
) 55B?271<6A
937: 0;;406 7:
34 5B8;41:097B1 BC :
)
*** 0>0?242 @A 934
- 11 -
?7@=106 7: 41301542 9B 0 :=8 BC :
**
*** 34 71:=?4?7:27?459429B24;B:79934413015425B8;41:097B1 BC:
)
***@4CB?4934?7@=10606B1<>7937194?4:909 934?094BCG;4?011=8C?B89342094BC56078;49797B1 97669342094BC24;B:79
>793710;4?7B2BC*20A:C?B8934 2094 BC ?4547;9 BC 0 5B;A BC 937: B?24? '07671< 937:
934 7194?4:9 :3066 @4 5065=60942 09 G ;4? 011=8 012 934 4K54::7194?4:9;072:3066@4?45BE4?42C?B8934:060?ABC 934 ;4?:B1 ?4:;B1:7@64 CB? 934 2460A 71 24;B:7971< 934 5B8;41:097B1
+5 % &
+5 % $&
"7:9B 6B