Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54444 (KAR)
UNION OF INDIA AND ORS v. VISHWANATH S/ SHANKRAPPA
WP/201896/2019 · 2026-01-09
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54444 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54444 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$%" "
$%" !"&! ' (
! " # $ %
&'(
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
" #
%
(
)
* )
+! ))
,-
&
& . $
$
. $
$
#
&. $
$%
/01 23404056 01 70839 :/;8836<06< ;6 5=93= 9;439 +! 2;1139>?4/3364=;8 9@06014=;40A3=0>B6;8 ;6<;85=3 C75= 1/5=4 ,=0>B6;8-D 06 =0<06;8 2280:;4056 5)) ;69 45 EB;1/ 4/3 5=93= 9;439 ( 2;113906 5(
/3 7;:41 4/;4 :;6 >3 <;4/3=39 7=5@ 4/3 2=5:33906<1 >375=3 4/3 =0>B6;8 ;=3 4/;4 4/3 =312569364
- 3 -
F;1;22506439;1;=;@06 ;G3A;G3;>1364397=5@ 9B4031>34F336) '45)';69;1;=31B84 /3 F;1 2B4 577 9B4? 7=5@ 45 ( ;69 901:02806;=? 2=5:33906<1 F;1 06040;439 ;<;0614 /0@ /3 01:02806;=? B4/5=04? 2;1139 ;6 5=93= 57 236;84? =314=;0606< =312569364 7=5@ 4;G06< B2 32;=4@364;8 H;@06;405675=;23=05957!?3;=1/01F;1:/;8836<39 >? 4/3 =312569364 >375=3 4/3 22388;43 B4/5=04? F/5 @5907039 04 45 ;6 5=93= 57 I:361B=3J /3 234040563= 4/3=375=3 70839 5() F/0:/ F;1 90125139 57 >?4/3=0>B6;8A0935=93=9;439(/3=3;743= 04;223;=14/;44/3=312569364F;1654<=;64394/32B4577 9B4? ;885F;6:3 ;69 4/3=375=3 /3 70839 5) /3=0>B6;80643=@1574/35=93=9;439+! /389 ;175885F1&
- 4 -
!"#$%"&' %&&%"&! ( )
% *+ ,
! =3A03F23404056F;170839>?4/3234040563=106 3A03F 2280:;4056 5)( 45 =3A03F 4/3 5=93= 2;1139 06 =0<06;8 2280:;4056 5)) /3 1;@3 F;1 901@01139 F04/ :5141 57 Rs. A093 5=93=9;439(
' 306< ;<<=03A39 >? 4/3 1;09 5=93= 4/3 234040563=1;=3>375=34/015B=4
/383;=639 11014;64580:045=363=;857690;
75=4/3234040563=11B>@044394/;4B693=4/3 32;=4@36457 5141 =;@06 ;G 3A;G1 #569B:4 ;69
6<;<3@364% B831 C75= 1/5=4 ,B831 -D 4/3 =312569364 01
- 5 -
36404839568? 45 K - 2;?@364 75= 4/3 23=059 57 2B45779B4?;694/;44/31;@3012;09454/3=312569364 34/3=375=3:56436914/;44/3=3125693640165436404839 45;6?7B=4/3=2;?@364
( 3;=639 :5B6138 75= 4/3 =312569364 /5F3A3= 564/354/3=/;691B>@044394/;44/35=93=572B45779B4? F;1 06 4/3 80</4 57 4/3 901:02806;=? 2=5:33906<1 06040;439 ;<;0614 4/3 =312569364 3 :5643691 4/;4 65F 4/3 2B601/@364 0@25139 >? 4/3 01:02806;=? B4/5=04? /;1 >336 @5907039 45 ;6 5=93= 57 :361B=3 ;69 4/3=375=3 4/3 =312569364 01 36404839 45 4/3 2;? ;69 54/3= ;885F;6:31 9B=06<4/323=059F/36/3F;12B45779B4?34/3=375=3 :56436914/;44/30@2B<6395=93=2;1139>?4/3=0>B6;8 01 LB14 ;69 2=523= ;69 4/;4 4/3 234040563=1 /;A3 654 :/;8836<39 4/3 5=93= 9;439 ( 2;1139 06
5()
- 6 -
) 3 /;A3 :561093=39 4/3 1B>@0110561 57 4/3 83;=639 9904056;8580:045=363=;857690;;223;=06<75= 4/3234040563=1;694/383;=639:5B613875=4/3=312569364
693= B831 4/3 234040563=1 ;=3 36404839 45 2B4577 ; =;@06 ;G 3A;G 7=5@ 9B4? ;69 4/3 2=5:39B=3012=31:=0>39;175885F1& I&%. /&01 1
2*
3*(4
/0
4
/0
* 5 4
.*
** )) 3*(
3
. 3 . 3-6* 1
/%0 . 3 .
3-6*
- 7 -
3-/&0
*
1 1
/+0 3*(
- 5 %'7
$
1 8 6 4
.*
9"1 1
*
5
9"4
/0 -
'"7
9"
3*(
/0 -
'"7
9"
3*(
- 8 -
:&6
-
/0 /0*
: %
; 3*(
*
4
.* 3*( ) 5
-
4
.* * 3*(
3*(
*
/<0 *
3*(
* 5
*
*
/'0 *
3*( *
5 8 =
- 9 -
5 3*(
* 3*( *
1 *
4
.*
5
8
:
3*(
8
*
) -
*-/+0 ( 3*(
* 82*
:
3*( ; ;
- J
+ /3 =312569364 F;1 A010439 F04/ ;6 5=93= 57 2B601/@364 >? F/0:/ /3 F;1 =314=;0639 7=5@ 4;G06< B2 932;=4@364;8 3H;@06;40561 75= ; 23=059 57 4/=33 ?3;=1 /01 5=93= F;1@5907039 >? 4/3 22388;43 B4/5=04?45 ;6
- 10 -
5=93=57:361B=3@3;606<4/3=3>?4/;44/35=93=2B4406< 57 4/3 =312569364 577 9B4? F;1 908B439 /01 F;1 :/;8836<39>375=34/3=0>B6;806 5()F/0:/ B2/389 4/3 5=93= ;69 90=3:439 4/3 234040563=1 45 2;? 4/3 1;8;=? ;69 54/3= ;885F;6:31 9B=06< 4/3 23=059 4/3 =312569364F;12B45779B4?06:34/3234040563=1909654 :5@28? F04/ 4/3 ;>5A3 4/3 =312569364 70839
5) :8;0@06< 4/3 2;? ;69 54/3= ;885F;6:31 75= 4/3 2B4577 23=059 F/0:/ F;1 <=;6439 7 4/3 234040563=1 /;A3 :/5136 45 2B4577 4/3 =312569364 7=5@ 9B4? 45 36;>83 4/3@ 45 :569B:4 ;6 36EB0=? ;69 07 4/3 =312569364F;165454/3=F0133@285?399B=06<4/323=059 F/36 /3 F;1 2B4577 9B4? /3 F;1 2=3A36439 7=5@ 23=75=@06< /01 9B4031 5F 4/;4 4/3 5=93= 57 4/3 901:02806;=?;B4/5=04?F;1@590703945;65=93=57:361B=3 F/0:/ 06 13=A0:3 LB=012=B936:3 9531 654 ;@5B64 45 ;6? 2B601/@364 4/3 =312569364 01 36404839 45 4/3 2;? ;69 54/3=;885F;6:3175=4/323=059F/36/3F;12B45779B4? /3=375=3 4/3 =312569364 F;1 36404839 45 4/3 2;? ;69
- 11 -
54/3= ;885F;6:31 9B=06< 4/3 236936:? 57 4/3 901:02806;=? 2=5:33906<1
64/;4A03F574/3@;443=F395654133;6? 3==5= 06 4/3 5=93= 2;1139 >? 4/3 =0>B6;8 90=3:406< 4/3 234040563=1 45 2;? 4/3 1;8;=? ;69 54/3= ;885F;6:3 45 4/3 =312569364 36:3 4/3 23404056 8;:G1 @3=04 ;69 01
*+ '"(
"
*+ '!"&!(
"
0145&85&!