- 1 - !!" #$% % $ &' &()*+ & ) , ! " # #### ! $ % # "! # # ! "" # # ! & ' # ( Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # ) # # ) # ! # # !* " ### $! # ! & ' ( # # " + $""!"" $!! "!"" $""!"" # ,- # # ) # # $ $"$ $" $ ! ! $ +# + $."!"$ # # # / / 0 # - 3 - 12, 34-2-256 2, 72849:694; 4<-256 " 57 1=;=-2>= =?=;2@:;=@,1==612-="!"$-5A:=,1-143;5<44926?, =?=26,- -14 34-2-2564;,=<<:,49 5, -5 26 5$."!"$ =;2,26? 5:- 57 ;2B4 5$""!"" ;4?2,-4;49C>58?:BC=D582<475;-1457746<43:62,1=C84 :694; 4<-256, $ $"$ $" $ ! =69 ! ;E 4<-256 $ 57 346926? 56 -147284 57 ;26<23=8 4625; 2F28:9?4=69=-2G=>=3:;= " 14 =C;29?49 7=<-, 57 -14 <=,4 =;4 -1=- ;4,356946- 5" 859?49 -14 <5B38=26- C475;4 -14 ;4,356946-582<456! !$"!""=884?26?-1=-,142,-14 ;4,2946- 57 =6912 =?=; 12@=;@1=6= 5=9 2G=>=3:;= =69-1434-2-2564;,=;414;642?1C5:;, 6! !$"!""=- =C5:-/!!=BE2-1;4?=;9-53=,,26?579;=26E=-4;56 = ;5=9 -14;4 E=, = A:=;;48 C4-E446 -14 34-2-2564;, =69 ;4,356946- 5" - -1=- -2B4 =88 -14 34-2-2564;, =C:,49 ;4,356946- 5" 26 728-1> 8=6?:=?4 =69 =,,=:8-49 14; C> 1=69, =69 ,-564, , ,:<1 ,14 859?49 -14 <5B38=26- - 4 - =?=26,- -14 34-2-2564;, C475;4 -14 ;4,356946-582<4 26 ;2B4 5$""!"" 75; -14 =75;4B46-25649 57746<4, :C,4A:46-8> -14 ;4,356946-582<4 <5B384-49 -14 26F4,-2?=-256=698=29<1=;?4,144-=?=26,--1434-2-2564;, 75;-14=75;4B46-2564957746<4,<<5;926?8>-1484=;649 =?2,-;=-4 -55@ <5?62D=6<4 57 -14 =75;4,=29 57746<4, ??;24F49 C> -14 ,=B4 -14 34-2-2564;, 3;474;;49 -12, 34-2-256 $ 4=;9 -14 84=;649 <5:6,48 75; -14 34-2-2564;, =69 84=;649 2?1 5:;- 5F4;6B46- 84=94; 75; -14 ;4,356946-5-=-4 3=;- 7;5B :;?26? ,4F4;=8 <56-46-256, 84=;649 <5:6,48 75; -14 34-2-2564;, <56-46949 -1=- -14;4 E=, = 856? ,-=6926? 92,3:-4 C4-E446 -14 34-2-2564;, =69 ;4,356946- 5" 26 ;4,34<- 57 3=,,26? 57 9;=26 E=-4; 26 7;56- 57 -142; 15:,4, 56 -14 ;5=9 <<5;926? -5 12B = <5B38=26- 1=, C446 859?49 C> =<<:,49 5 =?=26,- ;4,356946- 5" =69 14; 7=B28> B4BC4;, C475;4 -14 - 5 - ;4,356946-582<4 E12<1 E=, ;4?2,-4;49 26 ;2B4 5$"!""75;-14,2B28=;57746<4,-14,=B42,346926? 75; <56,294;=-256 , = <5:6-4; C8=,- -12, <5B38=26- 1=, C446 72849 C> ;4,356946- 5" <<5;926? -5 -14 84=;649 <5:6,48 34-2-2564; 5,$ =69 24 =<<:,49 5,$ =69 =;4 -14 ,-:946-, 57 =;=B492<=8 <246<4 =69 -14> =;4 3:;,:26? -142; ,-:924, =- 2G=>=3:;= =69 -14> E4;4 65- 26F58F49 26 =884?49 57746<4, 5 -1=- 4774<- 14 3;59:<49 -14 26-4;6,123 ;435;-, =69 <4;-272<=-4, <<5;926?8> 14 3;=>,-5=885E-1434-2-256 84=;649 2?1 5:;- 5F4;6B46- 84=94;=334=;26?75;;4,356946-5-=-45335,49-14 34-2-256 =884?26? -1=- 65E -14 26F4,-2?=-256 2, <5B384-49 =69 <1=;?4 ,144- 1=, C446 72849 =?=26,- =88 -14 =<<:,49 24 -14 34-2-2564;, =69 -14;4 2, = ,34<272< 5F4;- =<- 75;-1<5B26? =?=26,- -14B 26 -14 <1=;?4 ,144- <<5;926?8>143;=>,-592,B2,,-1434-2-256 1=F4?2F46B>=6H25:,<56,294;=-256C5-156 -14 ,:CB2,,256, B=94 C> -14 84=;649 <5:6,48 75; -14 - 6 - ;4,34<-2F4 3=;-24, =69 34;:,49 -14 95<:B46-, B=94 =F=28=C8456;4<5;9 * , <5:89 C4 ?=-14;49 7;5B ;4<5;9, 2- 2, 65- 92,3:-4 -1=- -14 34-2-2564;, =69 ;4,356946- 5" =;4 642?1C5:;,=69-14;42,=856?,-=6926?92,3:-426;4,34<- 57 3=,,26? 57 9;=26 E=-4; 56 -14 ;5=9 26 7;56- 57 -142; 15:,4, 9B2--498> 34-2-2564; 5 1=, 72849 = <=,4 =?=26,- ;4,356946- 5" =69 14; 7=B28> B4BC4;, C475;4 859?26? -12, <5B38=26- E12<1 E=, ;4?2,-4;49 26 ;2B4 5$"!"" , ,:<1 2- 2, <84=; -1=- 9:4 -5 F46?4=6<4 C4-E446 -14 3=;-24, -14> C5-1 1=F4 72849 -14 <=,4 =69 <5:6-4;<=,4,5;45F4;-14;4=;4 =884?=-256, B=94 5:- =?=26,- =<<:,49 5, =69 " -1=- -14> 1=F4 =,,=:8-49 ;4,356946- 5" E2-1 C;2<@, 15E4F4; -14 ;4,356946-5"92965-,:,-=26=6>C844926?26G:;24,14 E5:69<4;-272<=-438=<49C>-149432<-,-1=--14;42, 568>-4694;64,,56-1434;,5657;4,356946-5" 5;45F4; -14 B=;@, <=;9 =69 26-4;6,123 <4;-272<=-4,57=<<:,495,$=6934-2-2564;5,$=69 - 7 - <84=;8> 9432<- -1=- -14> =;4 -14 ,-:946-, 57 =;=B492<=8 <246<4=693:;,:26?-142;,-:924,6,:<1<2;<:B,-=6<4 -1435,,2C282->577=8,42B382<=-2565:-57F46?4=6<4<=665- C4;:8495:- . 65F4;=8834;:,=857-14B=-4;2=8,56;4<5;9 =B57-14<56,294;49F24E-1=--14<56-26:=-25657<;2B26=8 3;5<44926?,=?=26,-=<<:,495,"-534-2-2564;5,"-5 2, =C:,4 57 3;5<4,, 57 5:;- ,26<4 -14 ,=B4 2, B=6274,-8> 7;2F585:, F4H=-25:, =69 26,-2-:-49 E2-1 -14 :8-4;25;B5-2F475;E;4<@26?F46?4=6<426<4-14;42,65 ,34<272<5F4;-=<-=?=26,-=<<:,495,$=69=69-15:?1 2-2,=884?49-1=-=<<:,495"=,,=:8-49E2-1=C;2<@65 ,:<1 26G:;> 75:69 56 -14 34;,56 57 ;4,356946- 5" 4H<43--4694;64,,E12<1E=,=884?498><=:,49C>=<<:,49 5 E2-1 ,-56446<4 -14 <5B38=26- ,15E, -1=- -14 ,=B4 2, B=6274,-8> 7;2F585:, F4H=-25:, =69 26,-2-:-49 E2-1 =6 :8-4;25; B5-2F4 C;4=@26? F46?4=6<4 1446-2;4=884?=-25626-14 =69<1=;?4,144-=<<43-49 56 -142; 7=<4 F=8:4 4F46 -146 -14 ,=B4 95 65- - 8 - <56,-2-:-4 =6 57746<4, <1=;?4 ,144-49 =?=26,- 34-2-2564; 5," -5 =<<:,49 5," -5 <<5;926?8> 3;5<449-53=,,-1475885E26?/ 2 1434-2-2562, 22 14 34-2-256 26 ;4,34<- 57 34-2-2564; 5=<<:,49 5 2, =69 3;5<44926?,=?=26,-12B,1=88<56-26:4 222 143;5<44926?,=?=26,--1434-2-2564;5," -5 =<<:,49 5," -5 26 5$."!"$ =;2,26? 5:- 57 ;2B4 5$""!"" ;4?2,-4;49 C> 58?:BC=D 582<4 75; -14 57746<4, 3:62,1=C84 :694; 4<-256, $ $"$ $" $ ! =69 ! ;E4<-256$57346926?56-14728457 ;26<23=8 4625; 2F28 :9?4 =69 =- 2G=>=3:;=2,14;4C>A:=,149 -* &% ) % #2,-5/85/" /