- 1 - ! "# #$$ %&%'$()* %( + !"#"$% & '#$ ( & )%'$**%$ **%$$ '$$+ $* Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $,## & ) ) - # ./0121/.2034/5/44/+1.60233/2728269011./:;+8</91=5 2>?;61127+21/+%'$**%$3200/+693720/**%$$@A1./ 47 /006=90 ;+8/ 21 272@;486 5=4 @4/B61A C4627 =;41D E./4/@A 1./ 4627 =;41 2>?;611/+ 1./ 4/03=9+/91!2>>;0/+ 5=4 1./ =55/9>/0 3;960.2@7/ ;9+/4 />16=90 ' 29+ $$+ 4E />16=9$*=54/B/916=9=5=44;316=92>1$,##5=4@4/B61A C1./>1D * ./ 2@46+8/+ 52>10 =5 1./ >20/ 24/ 1.21 4/03=9+/912>>;0/+ E20 E=4F698 20 98292E2+6 E=4F/4 21 =92029.2776 ./ =B/49</91 .2+ 029>16=9/+ .28A272F0.<6 @=9+ =5 0$%%%%%! 5=4 >=<37269291G0 +2;8.1/4 =9/ .4;016 2<@.=+.696 0 0;>. 1./ >=<37269291 0;@<611/+ 29 23376>216=9 1= 1./ 98292E2+6 /914/ =920292.2776 5=4 600;29>/ =5 @=9+ 1 1.21 16</ 1./ 4/03=9+/912>>;0/+ +64/>1/+ 1./ >=<37269291 1= 5;4960. 1./+=>;</910 27=98 E61. - 3 - 1./3.=1=8423.0>>=4+6987A1./>=<372692915;4960./+1.=0/ +=>;</910/0361/1./2>>;0/++/<29+/+677/8278421656>216=9 =5 0$%%%!5=4600;29>/=5.28A272F0.<6@=9+29+69616277A 0./+/<29+/+ 0"%%!1.4=;8.3.=9/./026+>=9B/40216=9 E20 4/>=4+/+ @A 1./ >=<37269291 69 .60 <=@67/ 29+ ./ 2334=2>./+ 1./ =F2A;F12 =76>/ 29+ 7=+8/+ 1./ >=<372691 69 46</ =*%$% 5=4 1./ 25=4/</916=9/+ =55/9>/0 ./4/251/4 1./ 233/77291!=76>/ >=9+;>1/+ 29 /914;01/+ <2.2H24 726+ 2 1423 29+ 244/01/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ 4/>=B/4/+ 1./ 12691/+ >;44/9>A ;@0/?;/917A 1./ 233/77291!=76>/ 726+ 2 >.248/ 0.//128269011./2>>;0/+5=41./25=4/026+=55/9>/0@/5=4/1./ 4627=;41 = 34=B/ 1./ >.248/0 7/B/7/+ 2826901 1./ 2>>;0/+ @/5=4/ 1./ 4627 =;41 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 69 1=127 /I2<69/+ $% E619/00/0200$1=$%<24F/+*'+=>;</91020I0$1= *'29+6+/91656/+,<21/4627=@:/>10200$1=, J 9 200/00</91 =5=427 29++=>;</9124A/B6+/9>/ 1./ 4627 =;41 2>?;611/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 5=4 1./ >.248/0 7/B/7/+ 2826901./4./026+:;+8</9160>.277/98/+@A1./=F2A;F12 691.60233/27 - 4 - " /24+ 7/249/+ 3/>627 >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 233/77291! =F2A;F1229+1./7/249/+>=;90/75=41./4/03=9+/91!2>>;0/+ 3241 54=< ;48698 0/B/427 >=91/916=90 7/249/+ 3/>627 >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 233/77291 346<2467A>=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./ :;+8</91 ;9+/4 1.60 233/27 0;55/40 54=< 3/4B/4061A 29+ 677/82761A 069>/ 1./ 4627 =;41 .2B/ 5267/+ 2334/>621/ 1./ /B6+/9>/692468.13/403/>16B//>=91/9+/+1.211.//B6+/9>/ =5 >=<37269291 29+ 1423 329>.292<2 E619/00/0 >21/8=46>277A /012@760./+1.211./2>>;0/++/<29+/+677/8278421656>216=929+ 270= 4/>/6B/+ 1./ 02</ 54=< 1./ >=<37269291 ./ 0/6H/4 =5 >;44/9>A 9=1/0 29+ 1./ >./<6>27 /I2<69216=9 =5 1./ .29+0 =5 2>>;0/+ >7/247A /012@760./+ 1./ 4/>=B/4A =5 12691/+ <=9/A 9 0;>. >64>;<0129>/ 1./ =55/9>/0 ;9+/4 1./ >1 >7/247A 34=B/+ @/A=9+2774/20=92@7/+=;@120./7+@A1./=9G@7/3/I=;41 691./>20/=5 69 !"#$!%!&29+@A1.60 =;41 69 ' () * *' *69+!,%!$!%!&>>=4+6987A./342A01= 277=E1./233/27 - 5 - ' 7/249/+ >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 4/03=9+/91 >=91/9+/+1.211./4627=;41251/4</16>;7=;07A/I2<696981./ /B6+/9>/ =9 4/>=4+ 468.17A 2>?;611/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 69 2 E/77 4/20=9/+:;+8</91E.6>.+=/09=1>2775=429A691/45/4/9>/21 1./.29+0=51.60=;41/>=91/9+/+1.21211./=;10/11./ 2>>;0/+ 60 9=1 2 3;@76> 0/4B291 069>/ 0./ E20 E=4F698 20 98292E2+60/4B291=9.=9=4246;<;41./41./+/<29+29+ 2>>/3129>/=5@46@/609=12127734=B/+069>/1./>=<37269291 0121/+ 1.21 1./ 2<=;91 E20 9=1 326+ 69 1./ =556>/ =5 2>>;0/+ 29+ 1./ 02</ E20 326+ 69 2 .=1/7 E.67/ 2>>;0/+ 29+ >=<37269291 34=>//+698 9/24 1./ +==4 =5 .=1/7 ;@0/?;/917A 1./233/77291!=76>/>2;8.1.=7+1./2>>;0/+29+<2+/./41= 061 =9 2 >.264 69 2 .=1/7 29+ 12691/+ >;44/9>A 9=1/0 E/4/ 4/>=B/4/+54=<1./12@7/90;>.>64>;<0129>/1./4/>=B/4A60 9=1 34=B/+ / 270= >=91/9+/+ 1.21 1./4/ E20 9= E=4F 3/9+/9>A 20 277/8/+ @A 1./ >=<37269291 ;41./4 1./ >=<37269291 .20 2+<611/+ 1.21 ./ 29+ 2>>;0/+ .2+ @//9 1= B246=;0=556>/05=4>=77/>16=9=54/>=4+05=4E.6>.1./A69>;44/+ /I3/90/000;>.1./34=0/>;16=9;11/47A5267/+1=34=B/1./ 8;671=52>>;0/+>>=4+6987A./342A01=+60<6001./233/27 - 6 - # .2B/ 86B/9 29I6=;0 >=906+/4216=9 @=1. =9 1./ 0;@<6006=90 <2+/ @A 1./ 7/249/+ >=;90/7 5=4 1./ 4/03/>16B/ 32416/029+1./+=>;</9102B2672@7/=94/>=4+ , 0 >=;7+ @/ 821./4/+ 54=< 4/>=4+0 1= 34=B/ 1./ >.248/07/B/7/+28269011./2>>;0/+1./34=0/>;16=9346<2467A 4/76/+=9 1./ /B6+/9>/ =5 $!>=<37269291 0* 29+ !1./ 329>. E619/00/0 5=4 /914;01</91 <2.2H24!I$ 0/6H/4 <2.2H24!I$ 29+ 4/>=B/4A =5 12691/+ <=9/A 20 3/4 # 9 >24/5;7 3/4;027 =5 1./0/ E619/00/0 2>>=4+698 1= $ =9 $%*%$% 1./ 2>>;0/+ @/698 29 98292E2+6 E=4F/4 +/<29+/+ 0$%%%! 54=< .6< 5=4 600;29>/ =5 .28A272F0.<6 @=9+29+1./026+>=9B/40216=9+/<29+E204/>=4+/+@A.6< 69 .60 <=@67/ 3.=9/ ./4/251/4 ./ 7=+8/+ 1./ >=<372691 .=;8. 1./ 3.=9/ >277 +/12670 24/ 6+/91656/+ 29+ <24F/+ 21 I*' 1./ 02</ += 9=1 +60>7=0/ 1./ >=9B/40216=9 ./7+ @/1E//9 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+>=<37269291 ;41./4 61 60 0121/+@A $ +;4698 1./ 1423 =5 2>>;0/+ 0./ +/<29+/+ 1./ @46@/ 2<=;91 =;106+/ 1./ .=1/7 29+ 0./ 4/>/6B/+ 1./ 02</ ./4/251/4 @20/+ =9 1./ 06892769014;>16=9 =5 $ 1./ =76>/ >2;8.1.=7+1./2>>;0/+29+<2+/./41=061=92>.264691./ - 7 - .=1/729+4/>=B/4/+1./12691/+>;44/9>A9=1/0=5 0"%%!=9 1./ 12@7/ 0* 29+ @/698 1./ 0.2+=E E619/00/0 1.=;8. 2>>=<3296/+ 1./ >=<37269291 29+ 2>>;0/+ 1./A .2B/ 9=1 E619/00/+1./+/<29+29+2>>/3129>/=5@46@/@A1./2>>;0/+ >>=4+6981=1./<1./A27=98E61.$29+2>>;0/+E/911= 1./ .=1/7 29+ 1./A 021 =9 2 @/9>. E./9 2>>;0/+ 29+ $ E/911=E24+01./+==4=51./.=1/7$82B/20689271=1./< 29+=76>/29+0;@0/?;/917A1./1423E20726+=91./2>>;0/+ 29+1./2<=;91E200/6H/+=91./12@7/@A<2F6981./2>>;0/+ 1=061=92>.264/9>/6160>7/241.210*29+E/4/270= 9=1 E619/00/+ 1./ +/<29+ =4 2>>/3129>/ =5 @46@/ @A 1./ 2>>;0/+ $% =+=;@11./4/>=B/4A=512691/+>;44/9>A9=1/0=5 0"%%! E20 <2+/ =9 1./ 12@7/ =5 1./ 026+ .=1/7 21 1./ 690129>/ =5 2>>;0/+ 29+ ./4 .29+0 E/4/ E20./+ E61. 0=+6;< >24@=921/ 76?;6+ E.6>. 1;49/+ 691= 369F >=7=;4 .21 610/75 >299=1 @/ 2 84=;9+ 1= @/76/B/ 1.21 1./ 2>>;0/+ 4/>/6B/+ 1./ @46@/069>/1./=76>/<2+/1./2>>;0/+1=061=92>.26429+ <2+/./41=372>/1./>./<6>2723376/+>;44/9>A9=1/0=91./ 12@7/29+4/>=B/4/+1./02</;41./41./=1./4E619/00/06/ - 8 - 0J1=1.=;8.0;33=41/+1./>20/=534=0/>;16=91./A24/ 9=129/A/!E619/00/01=1./69>6+/91./69B/0168216=9=556>/4! $% >21/8=46>277A 2+<611/+ 1.21 1./ 4/>=B/4A 329>.292<2 E209=1+42E9211./03=1=5142329+1./02</E20+42E921 1./903/>16=9;9827=E $$ 0 524 20 1./ 3/9+/9>A =5 1./ E=4F @/5=4/ 1./ 2>>;0/+60>=9>/49/+$0121/+69.60/B6+/9>/1.21./29+ 2>>;0/+.2+@//91=B246=;0=556>/05=4>=77/>16=9=54/>=4+05=4 E.6>. 1./A 69>;44/+ /I3/90/0 ./ 02</ >7/247A 4/B/270 1.21 1./>=<37269291.2+03/91292<=;915=4.2B69869>;44/+1./ /I3/9+61;4/5=4=@12696981./+=>;</9105=41./.28A272F0.<6 @=9+ 29+ 21 1.21 16</ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 270= 2>>=<3296/+ 1./ >=<37269291 ./9 1./ >=<37269291 .6<0/75 2+<611/+ 1.21 ./ 2>>=<3296/+ 1./ 2>>;0/+ 29+ 03/91 <=9/A 5=4 =@1269698 1./ @=9+ 1./4/ 60 9= ?;/016=9 =5 2>>;0/+ +/<29+698 677/827 8421656>216=91.211== 0"%%!54=<1./>=<37269291/9>/=9 =B/4277 /I2<69216=9 =5 1./ /B6+/9>/ 1./4/ 60 9= @/76/B2@7/ /B6+/9>/ 29+ >64>;<0129>/ 60 5=41.>=<698 =9 4/>=4+ 1.21 1./ 2>>;0/+ /61./4 +/<29+/+ =4 4/>/6B/+ 1./ 677/827 8421656>216=9 54=<1./>=<3726929120277/8/+@A.6< - 9 - $* =+=;@11./=9G@7/3/I=;41./7+691./>20/ =5 ;342</4/+/<29+=40=76>61216=9 610/752<=;9101=>=<<6006=9=5=55/9>/;9+/4/>16=9'=5 >1=E/B/4691./6901291>20/1./34=0/>;16=9270=5267/+1= 34=B/ 1./ +/<29+ =4 2>>/3129>/ =5 1./ @46@/ @A 1./ 2>>;0/+ @/A=9+ 4/20=92@7/ +=;@1 ++616=9277A 1./ 2>>;0/+ @/698 29 98292E2+6 E=4F/4 29+ E=4F698 =9 .=9=4246;< 20 3/4 1./ /B6+/9>/=5'!1./34=0/>;16=9270=5267/+1=/012@760. 1.210./6023;@76>0/4B291 $ ./=9G@7/3/I=;4169>20/=5 - . ) 4/3=41/+ 69 !%! / "# +726+1./+6>1;<1.211./34==5=5+/<29+ 29+2>>/3129>/=5677/8278421656>216=9@A23;@76>0/4B291202 52>1 69 600;/ @A 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 60 2 69 =4+/4 1= /012@760.1./8;671=51./2>>;0/+3;@76>0/4B291;9+/4/>16=9 '29+$$+629+66=51./>1 $J ./ =9G@7/ 3/I =;41 69 1./ >20/ =5 /'* . 4/3=41/+69!%!+ ,0# ./7+ 1.21 K2@0/9>/ =5 34==5 =5 +/<29+ 5=4 677/827 8421656>216=929+</4/3=00/006=9=44/>=B/4A=5>;44/9>A9=1/0 - 10 - 609=10;556>6/911=>=90161;1/0;>.=55/9>/29+1./34/0;<316=9 ;9+/4 />16=9 *% =5 1./ >1 >29 @/ +42E9 =97A 251/4 1./ +/<29+ 5=4 29+ 2>>/3129>/ =5 677/827 8421656>216=9 60 34=B/+ ;41./4 1./ =9-@7/ 3/I =;41 69 32428423. $# ./7+ 20 ;9+/4)! +0 ! " # - 11 - $" 1600/117/+3=0616=9=572E726++=E9@A1./=9-@7/ 3/I =;41 69 1./ 2@=B/ 026+ :;+8</910 1.21 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 <;01 /012@760. /2>. 29+ /B/4A >64>;<0129>/ 54=< E.6>. 1./ 34=0/>;16=9E29101./=;411=+42E2>=9>7;06=9=51./8;671 =4/=B/4 1./ =9-@7/ 3/I =;41 69 1./ >20/ =5 )''( )' 1 2 ) ) ) 4/3=41/+ 69 !%+& +%+&!./7+1.211./34==5=5+/<29+>299=1@/34=B/+ @A1.//B6+/9>/=5=1./4E619/00/0690;>./B/91;2761A1.=;8. 0;>.4/>=B/4A34=B/+1./@/9/561=5+=;@10.=;7+@//I1/9+/+ 1= 1./ 2>>;0/+ /4/ 2>>/3129>/ =5 29A 2<=;91 277/8/+7A @A E2A =5 +/<29+ E=;7+ 9=1 @/ 0;556>6/91 1= @4698 .=</1./>.248/0;9+/4/>16=90'29+$=51./>1 $ 91./2@=B/026+:;+8</911./=9G@7/3/I=;41 @A4/5/446981./:;+8</91=5 3 4/3=41/+69!%+ +!"%,./7+1.210;036>6=9.=E/B/4 842B/ >299=1 12F/ 1./ 372>/ =5 34==5 29+ 1./ 34=0/>;16=9 >299=1255=4+1=4/01610>20/691./4/27<=5C<2A@/K@;1.20 1=;3842+/61691./+=<269=5C<;01@/K14;/69=4+/41=01//4 >7/24 =5 29A 3=006@7/ 0;4<60/ =4 >=9:/>1;4/ 1 E20 ./7+ 1.21 - 12 - 1./ =;41 <;01 /90;4/ 1.21 <60>244628/ =5 :;016>/ 60 2B=6+/+ 29+65691./52>1029+>64>;<0129>/01E=B6/E024/372;06@7/ 1./91./@/9/561=5+=;@1<;01@/86B/91=1./2>>;0/+ $' .60@/6981./233/2728269012>?;611271./=9G@7/ 3/I=;41691./>20/=545 6) / 6 * 4/3=41/+ 69 !%! 7 &0+2 0;<<246H/+ 1./3469>637/01=/I/4>60/1./3=E/4@A1./33/7721/=;411= 691/45/4/691./=4+/4=51.//006=90=;416932428423. =, 20;9+/4) $7% & " ' & & & " ' ( & ) & * & ) + & & ( - 13 - ( # ( & (, $# ;41./4 1./ =9G@7/ 3/I =;41 69 1./ >20/ =5 ( 6) 6 * 4/3=41/+ 69 !%!" &""E.67/0;<<246H6981./3469>637/069+/27698 E61. 1./ 233/27 2826901 2>?;61127 69 32428423. =J* ./7+ 20 ;9+/4) $"!+ ' & ' ' -&#./-0/ 12/3 4 5 67 & 8 9 67 ' 9 67 # 9 - 14 - 67# ' 9 67 # ) 9 67# , $, /9>/>=77=>216981./3469>637/00;<<246H/+691./ 2@=B/:;+8</9101=1./52>1029+>64>;<0129>/0=51.60>20/ 2< =5 1./ B6/E 1.21 1./ 4627 =;41 468.17A 2334/>621/+ 1./ /B6+/9>/29+2>?;611/+1./2>>;0/+E.6>.+=/09=1>2775=429A 691/45/4/9>/211./.29+0=51.60=;41>>=4+6987A34=>//+ 1=32001./5=77=E698) ./46<692733/2760 ,) % ( & 601 =)$7 =)$)