Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54409 (KAR)

THE MANAGER UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD. v. SHANTKUMAR AND ORS

MFA/200465/2020 · 2026-01-29

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #! $$ %&' () $$ %&' ( ) !" #$% ! " ! & " '"' ( ! ) '*!+ ,$" , Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) - !" " )! )!" - #($ $ ! ) ' ,+,+ )%)( ) - !" #$$ & " ) (. . ) ( $ + (%$( " ' + (%(( " ' ' !" (()( + ( ( %)# + / " '" " ( " " ( )# + " " " ( ) ( ! ) '*!+ ,$%" , - 3 - ) - !" " ( " )! ),!" - #($ 0 0( !"#$% #( '+ ! #( " '"' . ) (( ( (%$( " + $)# + " + " " ' + ' ' !" (%(( (()( " ' + , - 4 - , 1 ' ! ( 2343566357458358949:;<=><?>23@=A;B3:>5:A5C58A A5>3A (%(( 9: <(()( <: >23 ?973 <? 3:9<8 9D97 '=A;3 0 ' 0 5> 545D5E57F5: 5C58A9:; G<B63:45>9<:><>23G759B5:> <8 >23 45E3 <? G<:D3:93:G3 658>934 583 83?3883A C9>2 83?383:G3><>239885:EH3?<83>2389H=:57 $ > 94 >23 G543 <? >23 G759B5:> >25> <: ( >23 G759B5:>C5483>=8:9:;?8<B545D5E57F5:><=74<<8 9775;3<: 294 B<><8GFG73 H3589:; <!#)#$ 5:A 5> >25> >9B3 5:<>238 B<><8GFG73 H3589:; <#)"#% G5B3 ?8<B <66<49>3 49A3 A5423A 5;59:4> >23 B<><8GFG73 <? >23 G759B5:> 5:AG759B5:>4=4>59:3A9:@=89345:A>2383?<83 >23G759B5:>254 ?973A <(()( =:A38 3G>9<: ($# <? >23 <><8 329G734G> (?<842<8> I>23G>J 433E9:;G<B63:45>9<: 23G759B63>9>9<:C54G<:>34>3AHF>238346<:A3:>4: <8A38 >< 34>5H7942 294 G543 >23 G759B5:> 3K5B9:3A 29B437? 54 +(5:A3K5B9:3A<:3B<83C9>:34454+5:A68<A=G3A - 5 - A<G=B3:>4 5:A >23 45B3 C383 B58E3A 54 K4( >< <<857<8A<G=B3:>58F3D9A3:G3C5468<A=G3A<:H3257?<?>23 8346<:A3:>4 23 89H=:57 5?>38 G<:49A389:; >23 B5>38957 <: 83G<8A HF@=A;B3:>5:A5C58AA5>3A(%((577<C3A>23 G759B 63>9>9<: 9: 658> 2<7A9:; >25>>23 G759B5:> 94 3:>9>73A ?<8 G<B63:45>9<:<? 4( ( %)#C9>29:>3834>5>/6385::=B ?8<B>23A5>3<??979:;<?>23G759B63>9>9<:>97783579L5>9<: 3379:;5;;893D3AHF>23@=A;B3:>5:A5C58A65443AHF >2389H=:57C9>283;58A><795H979>F >23:4=85:G3<B65:F254 683?3883A <) 5:A <: >23 <>238 25:A >23 G759B5:> 254 683?3883A <) 433E9:; 3:25:G3B3:><?G<B63:45>9<: >94G<:>3:A3AHF>237358:3AG<=:437?<8>23:4=85:G3 <B65:F>25>>2389H=:572545C58A3A9:>3834>5>>2385>3<? / 638 5::=B C29G2 83M=9834 >< H3 9:>38?383A C9>2 9: >294 566357 % 5D9:; 2358A >23 7358:3A G<=:437 5663589:; ?<8 >23 658>934 5:A >5E9:; 9:>< G<:49A385>9<: >23 ?9:A9:; 83G<8A3A HF >23 89H=:57 9> 94 :<> 9: A946=>3 >25> >23 G759B5:> 4=4>59:3A 9:@=8934 <: 5GG<=:> <? 8<5A >85??9G 5GG9A3:> <GG=883A <: - 6 - (5:A>23G759B63>9>9<:94?973A=:A383G>9<:($# <?>23G>:>25>D93C<?>23B5>>38 >5E9:;9:><G<:49A385>9<: >23A3G7585>9<:<?75C9:>23G543<? ' 4 836<8>3A9: ($% 5B<?>23D93C >25>>238346<:A3:>N:4=85:G3<B65:F254><9:A3B:9?F>23 <C:38<?>23D329G732383?<83 >23G<:>3:>9<:85943AHF>23 7358:3AG<=:4375663589:;?<8>239:4=85:G3G<B65:FG5::<>H3 5GG36>3A9:4<?5854795H979>F94G<:G38:3A : G583?=7 G<:49A385>9<: <? >23 9:@=8F 4=4>59:3A HF >23 G759B5:>54638>23C<=:AG38>9?9G5>35>K5:A>23A945H979>F G38>9?9G5>368<A=G3A5>K B5E349>G7358>25>>23G759B5:> 2544=4>59:3AA945H979>F><5:3K>3:><?/:>25>D93C<? >23 B5>>38 >23 M=5:>=B <? G<B63:45>9<: 5C58A3A ><C58A4 7<44<?358:9:;A=3><A945H979>F254><H383#5443443A5:A45B3 945889D3A5> 4( $ )#$K(K(%K/ >5E9:;9:>< 5GG<=:>>23B=7>967938><H3566793A><>23G543<:25:A94(% 54 638 >23 @=A;B3:> <? >23 <:1H73 =683B3 <=8> 9: D 836<8>3A9:'(:4<?5854<>238235A4 - 7 - 583 G<:G38:3A :< 9:>38?383:G3 94 G5773A ?<8 GG<8A9:;7F >23 G759B5:>94237A3:>9>73A?<8><>57G<B63:45>9<:54:<>3AH37<C, 35A4 B<=:> 9: =6334 59:5:A4=??389:; <44 <? 358:9:;4 A=89:; 759A =6 6389<A $ <44 <? ?=>=83 <? 358:9:;4 A=3 >< A945H979>F ( $ <C58A4A93>5:A5>>3:A5:>G258;34 3A9G573K63:434 $ <>57 ( % % :>23834=7> 6544>23?<77<C9:;, 923663574583577<C3A9:658> 99 23 G759B5:> 9: <) 94 237A 3:>9>73A?<8><>57G<B63:45>9<:<? 4( % %)#C9>29:>3834>5> /6385::=B?8<B>23A5>3<?G759B63>9>9<:>97783579L5>9<: 54 5;59:4> >23 4=B <? 4( ( %)# C9>2 9:>3834> 5> / 638 - 8 - 5::=B 5C58A3A HF >23 89H=:57 : 577 <>238 83463G>4 >23 '=A;B3:>5:AC58A65443AHF>2389H=:5783B59:4=:57>383A 999 238346<:A3:>N:4=85:G3<B65:F94A983G>3A>< 9:A3B:9?F>23<C:38<?>23D329G739:M=34>9<:5:AA36<49>>23 5C58A 5B<=:> C9>29: 5 6389<A <? 49K C33E4 ?8<B >23 A5>3 <? 83G396><?5G38>9?93AG<6F<?>294<8A38 9D 23 '=A;B3:> 5:A C58A 65443A HF >23 545D5E57F5: 9: <(()( A5>3A (%(( 4>5:A4 B<A9?93A545H<D3 9D 235B<=:>9:A36<49>9:<)H3 >85:4B9>>3A><>23G<:G38:3A89H=:57 *( %' ! 45G 94><,(7<,( ,!