Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54405 (KAR)

CHOODAMANI PATIL W/O MALLIKRAJUN PATIL v. ABDUL WAHID S/O MD. ISMAIL AND ORS

MFA/201621/2016 · 2026-01-12

E S Indiresh

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " ## $%& '( ## ) )$%& ' ( ! " # #$ % $& '#' () #*+*% % $ #%*+ () #*+*% Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - " && ++ , - #*+*% " &". ! " %) $ & & %'"%$ & & & /+0 % " + %! & % # 01 )' ) ( && ++ , && #*+*% $ - 3 - % * #*+*% & $ '#' () #*+*% " $ #%*+ () #*+*% % %. "% % )" && $ & & %'"%$ & & # " + %! #%! + %! & & & 2 & & & & 3 - 4 - 4565 7885796 7:5 7:;6;<= />? /@ ?45 A>B=C5<? 7<B 7D7:B B7?5B " + %! ;< /+0 % /< ?45 @;95 /@ :;<E;879 5<;/: ;F;9 >B=5 7<B 797G>:7=; @/: 64/:?H:;G><792$799/D;<=?45E97;C85?;?;/<;<87:? 45 :595F7<? @7E?6 @/: 7BA>B;E7?;/< /@ ?4565 7885796 7:5 ?47? /< '% % ?45 E97;C7<? 7<B 45: 4>6G7<B#799;I7:A>< 7?;9D5:58:/E55B;<=?/D7:B65D7:=; /9/<J7<B7??47??;C57C/?/:EJE95G57:;<=:5=;6?:7?;/< /#"0#' *E/C;<=@:/C/88/6;?5B;:5E?;/<B7645B ?/?45E97;C7<?7<B/<7EE/><?/@?4567C56456>6?7;<5B =:;5F/>6 ;<A>:;56 7<B 76 6>E4 7BC;??5B ?/ : :55?; 45??75 5C/:;79 EE;B5<? 7:5 7<B 5<5:79 9;<;E 7<B 7?4; /68;?79 ? ;6 796/ 6?7?5B ?47? :;C5 /%00 % D76 :5=;6?5:5B 7=7;<6? ?45 :;B5: /@ ?45 C/?/:EJE95 ? ;6 ?45 E765 /@ ?45 E97;C7<? ?47? ?45 E97;C7<? D76 4795 7<B 4579?4J 7<B /< 7EE/><? /@ ?45 7995=5B 7EE;B5<? 645 ;6 ><7G95 ?/ 957B ?45 </:C79 9;@5 - 5 - 5<E5?45E97;C7<?476@;95B/+0 %G5@/:5?45 :;G><79655I;<=E/C85<67?;/< " @?5: ;66>7<E5 /@ 6>CC/<6 ?45 :568/<B5<?6 5<?5:5B 78857:7<E5 7<B @;95B B5?7;95B D:;??5< 6?7?5C5<? E/><?5:;<= ?45 7F5:C5<?6 C7B5 ;< ?45 E97;C 85?;?;/< < /:B5:?/56?7G9;6445:E765?45E97;C7<?5K7C;<5B45:659@ 76 %7<B?45?:57?5BB/E?/:76 7<B=/?C7:I5B % B/E>C5<?6 76 K6 % ?/ % / /:79 5F;B5<E5 D76 7BB>E5B GJ ?45 :568/<B5<?6 4/D5F5: GJ E/<65<? ?45 <6>:7<E5 /9;EJ5:?;@;E7?5D76C7:I5B76K% 45 :;G><79 7@?5: E/<6;B5:;<= ?45C7?5:;79 /< :5E/:B GJ ;?6 A>B=C5<? 7<B 7D7:B B7?5B " + %! 799/D5B ?45 E97;C 85?;?;/< ;< 87:? 7<B 459B ?47? ?45 E97;C7<? ;6 5<?;?95B @/: ?/?79 E/C85<67?;/< /@ 6%+' !# D;?4 ;<?5:56? 7? !1 87 @:/C ?45 B7?5 /@ E97;C 85?;?;/< ?;99 ?45 :579;L7?;/< /@ 5<?;:5 E/C85<67?;/< 7C/><? &559;<= 7==:;5F5B GJ ?45 E/C85<67?;/< 7D7:B5B GJ?45:;G><7976;<7B5M>7?5?45E97;C7<?4768:5@5::5B & / %!% %! 655I;<= 5<47<E5C5<? /@ ?45 - 6 - E/C85<67?;/< 7<B ?45 <6>:7<E5 /C87<J G5;<= 7==:;5F5B GJ ?45 ;C8>=<5B A>B=C5<? 7<B 7D7:B /< ?45 =:/><B /@ 9;7G;9;?J 476 8:5@5::5B & / '! %' 5<E5?456578857967:5G5@/:5?4;6/>:? * 457885997<?E97;C7<?;<&/ %!% %! ;6 65:F5B G>? :5C7;<5B 7G65<? 5<E5 457:B :; 47:7<7G767887 7?;9 957:<5B E/><659 78857:;<= @/: ?45 7885997<?# <6>:7<E5 /C87<J ;< & / '! %' ! ? ;6 7:=>5B GJ ?45 957:<5B E/><659 78857:;<= @/: ?45 <6>:7<E5 /C87<J ?47? ?45 7D7:B /@ E/C85<67?;/< GJ ?45 :;G><79 ;6 D;?4/>? E/<6;B5:;<= ?45 @7E?>797685E?6/<:5E/:B?47??45E97;C7<?;68:7E?;E;<=76 7< BF/E7?5 7<B@>:?45: </ B;67G;9;?J 476 G55< /EE>::5B ?/ ?45 ;<A>:5BE97;C7<? 7<B ?45:5@/:5 ?45 67;B 7685E? /@ ?45 C7??5: ;6 ?/ G5 E/<6;B5:5B GJ ?4;6 />:? ? ;6 796/ 7:=>5B GJ ?45 957:<5B E/><659 78857:;<= @/: ?45 <6>:7<E5/C87<J?47??45/D<5:/@?45F54;E95?4/>=4 78857:5B 476 </? 8:/B>E5B ?45 :595F7<? B/E>C5<?6 - 7 - 87:?;E>97:9J?45B:;F;<=9;E5<E5/@?45:;B5:/@?45/@@5<B;<= F54;E95 7<B ?45:5@/:5 ;? ;6 7 E957: F;/97?;/< /@ ?45 8/9;EJ E/<B;?;/< 7<B ?45:5@/:5 6/>=4? @/: ;<?5:@5:5<E5 /@ ?4;6 />:? ' < ?45 9;=4? /@ ?45 6>GC;66;/< C7B5 GJ ?45 957:<5BE/><65978857:;<=@/:?45 <6>:7<E5/C87<J7<B 47F;<=?7I5<</?5/@?45@;<B;<=:5E/:B5BGJ?45:;G><79 ;? D/>9B ;<B;E7?5 ?47? ?45:5 ;6 </ B;68>?5 76 ?/ ?45 /EE>::5<E5/@?457EE;B5<?/< '% % 7<B766>E4?45 E97;C7<? 476 6>6?7;<5B ;<A>:;56 /<7EE/><? /@ ?45 7995=5B 7EE;B5<? 5<E5 7C /@ ?45 F;5D ?47? ?45 :576/<6 766;=<5B GJ ?45 :;G><79 76 ?/ ;66>5 /% ;6 A>6? 7<B 8:/85:7<B?4567C5B/</?:5M>;:56?/G5;<?5:@5:5BD;?4 ;< ?4565 7885796 /D5F5: ;<6/@7: 76 ?45 M>7<?>C /@ E/C85<67?;/< 7D7:B5B GJ ?45 :;G><79 ;6 E/<E5:<5B ?45 E97;C7<? 476 5K7C;<5B ?45 5<;/: :?4/85B;E /<6>9?7<? $D4/476;66>5B?45;67G;9;?J5:?;@;E7?57?K %% D4;E4 C7I56 ;? E957: ?47? ?45 E97;C7<? 476 6>@@5:5B - 8 - B;67G;9;?J ?/ 7< 5K?5<? /@ +1 ?/ ?45 D4/95 G/BJ 7<B ?45 67C5E7<</?G5;<?5:@5:5BD;?4;<?45657885796 + <6/@7:76?456>GC;66;/<C7B5GJ?45957:<5B E/><659 78857:;<= @/: ?45 <6>:7<E5 /C87<J ?47? ?45 /D<5:/@?45F54;E95476</?8:/B>E5B?45B:;F;<=9;E5<E5 ;<6/@7:76?45:;B5:/@?45/@@5<B;<=F54;E95;6E/<E5:<5B ?45 67;B 7685E? E7<</? G5 E/<6;B5:5B GJ 9//I;<= ;<?/ ?45 :576/<6 766;=<5B GJ ?45 :;G><79 7? 87:7=:784 /@ ?45 ;C8>=<5B A>B=C5<? 7<B ?47? 787:? ?45 <6>:7<E5 /C87<J 476 </? ?7I5< 6?586 ?/ 7BB>E5 5F;B5<E5 /:799J ;<6/@7: 76 ?45 67;B 7685E? /@ ?45 C7??5: M>56?;/<;<= ?45 B:;F;<= 9;E5<E5 /@ ?45 :;B5: /@ ?45 /@@5<B;<= F54;E95 ;6 E/<E5:<5B < ?47? F;5D /@ ?45 C7??5: 7C /@ ?45 F;5D ?47??45=:/><B6>:=5BGJ?45 <6>:7<E5/C87<J;<& / '! %'E7<</?G57EE58?5B 0 <6/@7:76?455<47<E5C5<?/@E/C85<67?;/<;< & / %!% %! ;6 E/<E5:<5B ;? ;6 </? ;< B;68>?5 ?47? ?45 E97;C7<? D76 7=5B 7G/>? J57:6 7<B ?45 :;G><79 ?7I;<= ;<?/ E/<6;B5:7?;/< ?45 B58/6;?;/< /@ - 9 - 476 7D7:B5B A>6? E/C85<67?;/< ?/ ?45 E97;C7<? 7<B ?45:5@/:5 7C /@ ?45 F;5D ?47? </ ;<?5:@5:5<E5 ;6 E7995B @/:;<&/ %!% %! % 5<E5G/?4?457885796@7;97<B7:57EE/:B;<=9J B;6C;665B %% 45 7C/><? ;< B58/6;? C7B5 GJ ?45 <6>:7<E5 /C87<JG5@/:5 ?4;6 />:? ;@7<J G5 ?:7<6C;??5B?/ ?45 :;G><79@/:B;6G>:65C5<? *' $& ;6?/%9/"