- 1 - !!" #$%% $ &' &()* &) + !" ! !" !# $ !" # ! $ !# %&&"' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # !# %&&"' ( ) * $ !" $ ! !% $ !" ( ) $+ $!* $ ! $ #!&! $ $ $ $ !#!&!# $ $$ #' ! &# &% # $ $ ! % - 3 - $ , , - ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/7289582: 2;3/45 ! 46 .<:<3/=< <><:/? 9:<?0.< <5./3<!&! 34@9<0.3.21:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0<;;9028 40! 34 % /5 4#!&! <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4!#!&!# :2>/032:28 B= <0<C<?<7=<5 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 #' ! &# <58 &% :D 2;3/45 # 46 1258/5> 45 3.2 6/72 46 /C/7 98>2 <58 $<0<C<?<7=<5 ! .2 <B:/8>28 6<;30 46 3.2 ;<02 <:2 3.<3 :201458253 4! A<::/28 <;;9028 4:<C225 45 &#!&!! <3 9A5<B<8 .2:2<632: 0.2 03<:328 34 :20/82 /5 3.2 A<3:/A45/<7 .4A2 <745> D/3. .2: .90B<58 <58 123/3/452:0 .2 123/3/452:0 <58 .2: .90B<58 D2:2 ;4:8/<77=7/C28D/3..2:64:04A23/A2.2:2<632:<;;9028 4<88/;32834B<8C/;20<5803<:32834.<:<00.2:B43. 1.=0/;<77= <58 A253<77= 23/3/452: 40 34 <;;9028 - 4 - 40!34#/2A43.2:/57<D<58B:43.2:/57<D<58./0 D/62D./72/53.2.4902/5032<846<8C/0/5><;;90284 3.2=/503/><328./A34.<:<00:2014582534! 5 "&%!&!# <3 <B493 !,&& 1A D.25 :2014582534!D<025><>28/5;44?/5><7746<098825 <;;9028 4 03<:328 34 @9<::27 D/3. .2: 45 /534E/;<3/45 <00<97328 .2: <58 3.:4D5 .2: 493 6:4A 3.2 A<3:/A45/<7 .4A2.49>.:2014582534!/564:A283.20</8<012;3 34 3.2 43.2: <;;9028 3.2= <704 <B9028 <58 /5097328 .2: 009;.0.2748>283.2;4A17</53B264:23.2:201458253 47/;2 45 !"&%!&!# D./;. D<0 :2>/032:28 /5 :/A2 4!#!&!# 64: 3.2 46625;20 <64:2A253/4528 46625;20 <></503 3.2 123/3/452:0 <58 <;;9028 4 9B02@92537= 3.2 :20145825347/;2 /5C203/><328 3.2 ;<02 <58 7</8 ;.<:>20.223<></5033.2.90B<58<;;90284<583.202 123/3/452:0B=<::<=/5>3.202123/3/452:0<0<;;902840! 34%;;4:8/5>7=3.272<:528<>/03:<32344?;4>5/F<5;2 46 3.2 <64:20</8 46625;20 >>:/2C28 B= 3.2 0<A2 3.2 123/3/452:01:262::283./0123/3/45 - 5 - # 2<:8 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 72<:528/>.49:34C2:5A25372<82:64:3.2:201458253 4G 3<32<5872<:528;49502764::2014582534! 1<:3 6:4A 9:>/5> 02C2:<7 ;453253/450 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 ;45325828 3.<3 2E;213 04A2 4A5/B90<772><3/450<></5033.2123/3/452:0<B0479327=54 09;. A<32:/<70 <:2 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 3.2A 64: 3.2 46625;20 3.2= .<C2 B225 ;.<:>2 0.22328 2<704 ;453258283.<3<;;902840<58%/20/032:/57<D<58 .2: .90B<58 <:2 :20/8/5> <3 25><79:9 <58 3.2= <:2 54 D<=;4552;328343.2<772>28/5;/825325;2;453/59<3/45 461:4;228/5>0<></5033.2123/3/452:0/0543./5>B93<B902 46 1:4;200 46 49:3 ;;4:8/5>7= .2 1:<=0 34 <774D 3.2 123/3/45 % 72<:528;49502764::2014582534! ;45325828 3.<3 54D 3.2 /5C203/><3/45 /0 ;4A172328 <58 ;.<:>2 0.223 .<0 B225 6/728 .2 03<32A253 46 2=2D/3520020 ;72<:7= :2C2<7 3.<3 123/3/452: 40 34 B2/5> 3.2 /57<D0 3.2= 0.<:28 3.2 ;4AA45 :446 D/3. - 6 - :201458253 4! <58 <;;9028 4 <58 3.2= .<C2 B225 1<:3/;/1<328/53.2<772>28/5;/8253B=/503/><3/5><;;9028 4 2 <704 ;45325828 3.<3 3.2.90B<5846 :201458253 4! ;453:<;328 3.2 02;458 A<::/<>2 D./;. D<0 2532:3</528 B= 123/3/452: 40 34 25;2 .2 1:<=0 34 8/0A/003.2123/3/45 " 2<:528 />. 49:3 4C2:5A253 72<82: <112<:/5>64::2014582534 3<3241140283.2123/3/45 <581:<=0348/0A/003.20<A2 .<C2>/C25A=<5E/490;450/82:<3/45B43.45 3.2 09BA/00/450 A<82 B= 3.2 72<:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/C2 1<:3/20 <58 12:9028 3.2 84;9A2530 A<82 <C</7<B7245:2;4:8 ' 0;4978B2><3.2:286:4A:2;4:80:201458253 4! B2/5> 3.2 D/62 46 <;;9028 4 748>28 3.2 ;4A17</5<53 <772>/5> 3.<3 <632: .2: A<::/<>2 0.2 D<0 :20/8/5> <745> D/3. .2: .90B<58 <58 .2: /57<D0 /2 123/3/452: 40 34 /2 <;;9028 40! 34 # /5 3.2 - 7 - A<3:/A45/<7 .4A2 $4: 04A2 3/A2 0.2 :20/828 ;4:8/<77= D/3. <;;9028 <58 3.2:2<632: .2: .90B<58 03<:328 34 .<:<00 .2: <58 123/3/452: 40 34 /503/><328 <;;9028 4 34.<:<00.2: 8A/33287= 123/3/452: 40 34 <:2 :20/8/5><745>D/3.<;;90284<58:2014582534! & 2<:528;49502764::2014582534!17<;283.2 1.434>:<1.0 <58 03<328 3.<3 3.2 .90B<58 46 :201458253 4! ;453:<;328 3.2 02;458 A<::/<>2 5 09;. ;/:;9A03<5;203.20<A2D4978543.<C28452B=<;;9028 4 D/3.493 B:/5>/5> /3 34 3.2 ?54D728>2 46 123/3/452: 40 34 25;2 3.2:2 <:2 A<32:/<70 64:3.;4A/5> <></503 123/3/452: 40 34 .2 03<32A253 462=2D/35200<704:2C2<703.2<;346123/3/452:4034 25;2 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 ;<5543 B2 @9<0.28 <></503 123/3/452: 40 34 <;;9028 40! 34 # 4D2C2: 123/3/452:40#<58<;;90284<58%<:2;45;2:528 <8A/33287=3.2=<:2:20/8/5><325><79:9<583.2:2/0457= 4A5/B90 <772><3/45 <></503 3.2A 3.<3 D.25 :201458253 4! ;<7728 3.2A 4C2: 1.452 B= /564:A/5> 3.2 <;3 46 - 8 - <;;90284.90B<583.2=<B9028.2:<58343.<32662;3 5409;.;<77823</704:84;9A2530.<C2B22569:5/0.28B= 3.21:402;93/453409B03<53/<323.20</8<772><3/45 509;.;/:;9A03<5;23.245-B7212E49:3/5 3.2 ;<02 46 :214:328 /5 ! "#$ %& <3 1<:<>:<1. 4% .278 3.<3 3.2 49:3 0.4978 B2 ;<:2697 /5 1:4;228/5> <></503 3.2 8/03<53 :27<3/C20 /5 ;:/A20 12:3</5/5> 34 A<3:/A45/<7 8/019320 <58 84D:= 82<3.0 .2 :27<3/C20 46 3.2 .90B<58 0.4978 543 B2 :4128/5 45 3.2 B<0/0 46 4A5/B90 <772><3/450 957200 012;/6/; /503<5;2 46 3.2/: /5C47C2A253 /5 3.2 ;:/A2 <:2 A<82 493 3 /0 <7040233728 140/3/45467<D3.<3/6<12:045/0A<82346<;2<;:/A/5<7 3:/<7 45 04A2 >252:<7 <58 0D221/5> <772><3/450 D/3.493 B:/5>/5> 45 :2;4:8 <5= 012;/6/; /503<5;20 46 ;:/A/5<7 ;4589;3 /3 /0 543./5> B93 <B902 46 1:4;200 46 3.2 49:3 .249:301402<893=3409BH2;33.2<772><3/4572C27728/5 3.2;4A17</5334<3.4:49>.0;:93/5=346/58493D.23.2: - 9 - 3.2:2 /0 <5= ></5 46 3:93. /5 3.2 <772><3/450 4: D.23.2: 3.2= <:2 A<82 457= D/3. 3.2 0472 4BH2;3 46 /5C47C/5> ;2:3</5 /58/C/89<70 /5 < ;:/A/5<7 ;.<:>2 A4:2 1<:3/;97<:7= D.25<1:402;93/45<:/026:4A<A<3:/A45/<78/01932 ! $9:3.2:3.245IB72 12E49:3 /5 3.2 ;<0246 '( # :214:328/5 )*$$+*).278/51<:<40!<58! <09582:, ) ! " # $% & - 10 - $' $' $% ( ,) ! *+, # ! ( - . ! *+, # /. " 0 ! . . ! *+, # . # - # 1 - 11 - 3/00233728140/3/45467<D3.<349:30.<C234 B2;<:2697<58;<93/490/582<7/5>D/3.;4A17</53<58A903 3<?2 1:<>A<3/; :2<7/3/20 /534 ;450/82:<3/45 D./72 82<7/5> D/3. A<3:/A45/<7 8/019320 D.2:2 3.2 <772><3/450 .<C2 34 B20;:93/5/F28D/3.>:2<3;<:2<58;/:;9A012;3/45/54:82: 341:2C253A/0;<::/<>246H903/;2<58<B902461:4;20046 49:3 # 5A=;450/82:28C/2D;453/59<3/4546;:/A/5<7 1:4;228/5><></5033.2123/3/452:40#<58/2<;;9028 40 <58 % /0 543./5> B93 <B902 46 1:4;200 46 49:3 ;;4:8/5>7=3.264774D/5>+ / .2123/3/45/0 - // .2123/3/45/5:2012;346123/3/452:4034 <;;9028 40! 34 # /0 .2:2B= <58 3.2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 3.2A 0.<77 ;453/592 /// .2 1:4;228/5>0 <></503 123/3/452: 40# <58 <;;9028 40 <58 % /5 - 12 - 4#!&! <:/0/5> 493 46 :/A2 4!#!&!# :2>/032:28 B= <0<C<?<7=<5 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.<B72 9582: 2;3/450 #' ! &# <58 &% :D 2;3/45 #46 1258/5>453.26/7246/C/7 98>2 <58 $ <0<C<?<7=<5 /0 .2:2B= @9<0.28 ,* &%) % /034, 74, ,