- 1 - ! " #$!! $%% & &'%()*&( + ! " # $ !% & ! " # $ % '#($% & % ) ( ! ! & &% ) % %% !% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % &* + & & !$ ,-. /001/2 -. 3-214 56 7,1 /00122/87 9:;02/-8/87 <841= 197-:8 ' :3 :41 :3 =-;-8/2 =:914<=1 #3:= .,:=7>=?$9,/2218@-8@7,1A<4@;187:3/9B<-77/20/..14 -8 =-;-8/2 /.1 : ((C!' 4/714 ( ! ! 56 7,1 442 -D-2&<4@1E&%/2/5<=/@-#3:=.,:=7>7,1=-/2 :<=7?$ F,1=156 7,1 =-/2 :<=7 ,/. /9B<-7714 7,1 =1.0:84187 /99<.14 3:= 7,1 :331891 0<8-.,/521 <841= 197-:8 ! :3 1@:7-/521 8.7=<;187. 97 !! #3:= .,:=7>7,1 97?$ %:= 7,1 ./G1 :3 9:8D18-1891 7,1 0/=7-1. /=1 =131==147:/.01=7,1-==/8G.513:=17,1=-/2:<=7 ,1 3/97</2 ;/7=-H :3 7,1 9/.1 -. 7,/7 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 /84 7,1 /99<.14 /=1 G8:F8 7: 1/9, :7,1= ,1 /99<.14 F/. 4:-8@ =1/2 1.7/71 5<.-81.. /84 F/. -8 - 3 - 8114:3;:816 99:=4-8@26:8! ( !',1=1B<1.714 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 7: /4D/891 7,1 ,/84 2:/8 :3 . :8 9:84-7-:8 7:=10/6 7,1 ./;1 F-7,-8 :81 ;:87, <1 7: /9B</-87/891 F-7, 7,1 /99<.14 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 /4D/8914 7,1 2:/8 /;:<87 :3 . 7:,-;/84-8=17<=87,1/99<.14-..<14/9,1B<151/=-8@ : ((' 4/714 ! !' 4=/F8 :8 7/71 /8G :3 641=/5/4<01=/=G17 =/89,/2/5<=/@--83/D:<=:3 7,19:;02/-8/87 ,19:;02/-8/870=1.187147,1./;13:= 189/.,;187 ,:F1D1= 7,1 ./;1 F/. =17<=814 F-7, /8 184:=.1;187 >0/6;187 .7:0014 56 =/F11? 4/714 C I !' ,1 ./-4 /.0197 F/. -83:=;14 56 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 7: 7,1 /99<.14 56 -..<-8@ 21@/2 8:7-91 4/714 I !' 1.0-71 =191-D-8@ 7,1 21@/2 8:7-91 7,1 /99<.14 3/-214 7: ;/G1 0/6;187 . .<9, 9:;02/-8/87 3-214017-7-:8<841=197-:8:3= 3:=7,1:331891 0<8-.,/521<841=197-:8!:3 97 ( : 0=:D1 7,1 9:;02/-87 513:=1 7,1 =-/2 :<=7 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 1H/;-814 ,-;.123 /. * ! /84 /2.: :81 - 4 - ;:=1 F-781.. /. * /84 @:7 ;/=G14 4:9<;187. /. H. !7: :F1D1=/99<.141H/;-814:81F-781..:8 ,-. 51,/23 /. * ! /84 @:7 ;/=G14 4:9<;187. /. H. !7: 8 /00=19-/7-:8 :3 :=/2 /84 4:9<;187/=6 1D-41891 7,1 =-/2 :<=7 /9B<-7714 7,1 /99<.14 3:= 7,1 :331891 0<8-.,/521 <841= 197-:8 ! :3 97 @@=-1D14 56 7,1 ./;1 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 /00122/87 -. 513:=17,-.:<=7 I 1/=4 21/=814 9:<8.12 3:= 7,1 /00122/87 9:;02/-8/87 /84 21/=814 9:<8.12 3:= 7,1 =1.0:84187 /99<.14 ' 0/=7 3=:; <=@-8@ .1D1=/2 9:87187-:8. 7,1 21/=8149:<8.123:=7,1/00122/870=-;/=-269:87187147,/7 7,19,1B<1-8B<1.7-:8 H !/84.-@8/7<=1:37,1/99<.14 :8 -7 -. 8:7 4-.0<714 56 7,1 /99<.14 . .<9, -8-7-/2 0=1.<;07-:8 3/D:<=. 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 7,1 ./;1 F/. 8:7 =15<7714567,1/99<.145602/9-8@0=:5/5214131891 ,1 - 5 - =-/2 :<=7 512-1D-8@ :8 7,1 1D-41891 :3 /99<.14 /84 7,1 4:9<;187/7H (/9B<-77147,1/99<.14:87,1@=:<84 7,/7 7,1 9,1B<1 -8 B<1.7-:8 F/. -..<14 /. / .19<=-76 -8 =1.0197 :3 0=:01=76 7=/8./97-:8. . .<9, ,1 0=/6. 7: /22:F7,1/001/2 21/=8149:<8.123:=7,1=1.0:84187 /99<.14 .<5;-7. 7,/7 7,1 =-/2 :<=7 /371= ;17-9<2:<.26 1H/;-8-8@ 7,1 1D-41891 :8 =19:=4 =-@,726 /9B<-7714 7,1 /99<.14 F,-9, 4:1. 8:7 9/22 3:= /86 -871=31=1891 /7 7,1 ,/84. :3 7,-. :<=7 99:=4-8@26 0=/6. 7: 4-.;-.. 7,1 /001/2 C ,/D1@-D18;6/8H-:<.9:8.-41=/7-:85:7,:8 7,1 .<5;-..-:8. ;/41 56 7,1 21/=814 9:<8.12 3:= 7,1 =1.0197-D1 0/=7-1. /84 /2.: 7,1 4:9<;187. /D/-2/521 :8 =19:=4513:=17,-.:<=7 ! . 9:<24 51 @/7,1=14 3=:; 7,1 1D-41891 :3 * !9:;02/-8/87 7,1 9,1B<1 -8 B<1.7-:8 /2:8@ F-7, 7,=11 :7,1= 9,1B<1. -..<14 56 7,1 /99<.14 7: 7,1 - 6 - 9:;02/-8/87-8=1.0197:37=/8./97-:8:3./2101=7/-8-8@7: 2/84 51/=-8@ 6 : ( %<=7,1= H ( 4-.92:.1. 7,/7 /99<.14 ,/. -..<14 / 21771= 7: ,-. /8G1= :8 ! I !' =1B<1.7-8@ 7: .7:0 0/6;187 -8 =1.0197 :3 3:<= 9,1B<1. -892<4-8@9,1B<1-8B<1.7-:8- 1 H ! !! 87,1:7,1=,/84-7-.9/.1:37,19:;02/-8/87 7,/77,19,1B<1-8B<1.7-:8F/.-..<14-8=1.0197:3,/84 2:/83:= / .<;:3 . F,-9,F/./4D/8914 56 7,19:;02/-8/87:8! ( !' ,19:;02/-87/D1=;187. /84 9=:.. 1H/;-8/7-:8 :3 7,1 9:;02/-8/87 @:1. 9:87=/4-97:=6 7: ,-. 9=:.. 1H/;-8/7-:8 :=1:D1= 7,1 /99<.14/2.:02/9147,14:9<;187./7H. !7:921/=26 =1D1/2 7,/7 9,1B<1 -8 B<1.7-:8 /2:8@ F-7, 7,=11 :7,1= 9,1B<1.-..<14/..19<=-767:7,19:;02/-8/87-8=1.0197:3 0=:01=767=/8./97-:8 ! : 4:<57 -8 ! :3 97 -8-7-/2 0=1.<;07-:8 /=-.1.-83/D:<=:37,19:;02/-8/87 :F1D1=7,1./;1-. =15<77/2 -8 8/7<=1 56 02/9-8@ / 0=:5/521 4131891 8 7,1 - 7 - -8.7/87 9/.1 7,1 /99<.14 ,/. 02/914 0=:5/521 4131891 F-7,4:9<;187./7H. !7: ,-./.0197:37,1;/771= -. 41/27 -8 417/-2 56 7,1 =-/2 :<=7 /84 /9B<-7714 7,1 /99<.14 3-84 8: @::4 @=:<84. 7: -871=31=1 F-7, 7,1 -;0<@814A<4@;187:3/9B<-77/2 ! 99:=4-8@267,1/001/22/9G.;1=-7/84./;1-. ,) &!( ! ! &