- 1 - ! " ## $%& '( ## )* $%& ' ( !! "# !# !! ! " $%$&& !! $'(' # !! # ! ) )" $'('% ! " #* # Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & # ! !! + %%&% # '%% ! " " $ ) " " ! ! )* ' ( # !! # ! ) )" $'('% !! " # " $'('& !! ! " $%$&& !! $'(' ! "# !#* # - 3 - & # ! + %%&% ! # '%% # + $ ! ," !! !! + # -" + ./0/ 122/130 14/ 1450567 89: 8; :./ <9=7>/6: 16= 1?14==1:/=%%&%56 #8'%%86:./;53/ 8; :./ 8:84 @@5=/6: 315>0 45A9613$ 1: 1=7545 ./4/561;:/44/;/44/=:810B45A9613, 84 :./ 01C/ 8; A4/D5:E :./ 214:5/0 56 :./ 122/130 0.133 A/ 4/;/44/= :8 56 :/4>0 8; :./54 0:1:90 16= 416C567A/;84/:./45A9613 - 4 - & : 50 :./ @10/ 8; :./ @315>16: :.1: 86 F%G%% :./ @315>16: ?10 :41D/33567 56 1 @4950/4 D/.5@3/ A/14567 4/750:41:586 8)$&&$GF( ;48> 175617/41 :8 1>101>9=41 16= 1: :.1: :5>/ :./ 1:1 88=0 ! A/14567 4/750:41:586 8 $%$&& @1>/ ;48> 822805:/ =54/@:586 =45D/6 56 1 410. 16= 6/7357/6: >166/4 16= =10./= :8 :./ @4950/4 6 1@@896: 8; :./ 01>/:./@315>16:.10090:156/=745/D89056<945/016=10 09@. :./ @315>16: .10 ;53/= # 8'%% 0//C567 @8>2/601:586 ./ @315> 2/:5:586 ?10 @86:/0:/= AE :./ 4/0286=/6: 8 A/;84/ :./ 45A9613 ./ /D5=/6@/ .10 A//61==9@/=AE:./214:5/0:8/0:1A350.:./54@10/./ 45A9613 1;:/4 @8605=/4567 :./ >1:/4513 86 4/@84= AE 5:0 <9=7>/6:16=1?14==1:/=%%&%1338?/=:./@315> 2/:5:586 56 214: .83=567 :.1: :./ @315>16: 50 /6:5:3/= ;84 @8>2/601:5868;0'&(%$?5:.56:/4/0:1::./41:/8; GH 2/4 1669> ;48> :./ =1:/ 8; 2/:5:586 :533 4/135I1:586 //3567 17745/D/= AE :./ <9=7>/6: 16= 1?14= >1=/ AE - 5 - :./45A961310:8:./351A535:E:./609416@/8>216E.10 ;53/= 8%&%16=:./@315>16:.10;53/= 8%%0//C567/6.16@/>/6:8;@8>2/601:586 ' /14= :./ 3/146/= @8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ 214:5/0 G 45 9=140.16 :./ 3/146/= @8960/3 122/14567;84:./609416@/8>216E@86:/6=/=:.1:10 :./ @315>16: ?10 :41D/33567 56 @4950/4 D/.5@3/ ?.5@. 50 1 :4160284:D/.5@3/16=:./4/;84/:./45A9613897.:68::8 .1D/;5J/=:./351A535:E86:./8;;/6=567D/.5@3/./4/;84/ 0897.:;8456:/4;/4/6@/8;:.50894::5013081479/=AE :./3/146/= @8960/3 ;84 :./609416@/8>216E:.1: :./ 1?14= 8; @8>2/601:586 AE :./ 45A9613 50 86 :./ .57./4 05=/?.5@.4/K954/=:8A/56:/4;/4/=?5:.56:.50122/13 45#//4161789=1 13521:53:./3/146/=@8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ @315>16: 09A>5::/= :.1: :.897. :./ @4950/4D/.5@3/56K9/0:586501:4160284:D/.5@3/.8?/D/4 :./9631=/6?/57.:8;:./D/.5@3/56K9/0:586503/00:.16 - 6 - '%% C7 16= :./4/;84/ :./ @315>16: 50 /6:5:3/= ;84 @8>2/601:586:5013081479/=AE:./3/146/=@8960/3;84 :./ @315>16: :.1: 1?14= 8; @8>2/601:586 50 >/17/4 ?.5@.4/K954/=:8A//6.16@/=56:./122/13;53/=AE:./ @315>16:0//C567/6.16@/>/6:8;@8>2/601:586 ( 6 :./ 357.: 8; :./ 09A>500586 >1=/ AE :./ 3/146/=@8960/3122/14567;84:./214:5/0564/02/@:8;:./ 1479>/6:1=D16@/=AE:./3/146/=@8960/3122/14567;84 :./609416@/8>216E10:8:./;1@::.1::./D/.5@3/56 K9/0:586 50 1 @8>>/4@513 D/.5@3/:4160284: D/.5@3/ .8?/D/4 ;8338?567 :./ =/@3141:586 8; 31? >1=/ AE :./ 86,A3/ 924/>/ 894: 56 :./ @10/ 8; ! "#$ % &'( )%$*#(4/284:/=56+,-./,1>8; :./ D5/? :.1: 10 :./ 9631=/6 ?/57.: 8; :./ #/.5@3/ 56 K9/0:586 50 3/00 :.16 '%% C7 16= :./4/;84/ :./ 015= D/.5@3/ .10 :8 A/ @8605=/4/= 10 1 357.: >8:84 D/.5@3/ ./4/;84/ :./ @86:/6:5860 4150/= AE :./ 3/146/= @8960/3 122/14567;84:./609416@/8>216E@1668:A/1@@/2:/= - 7 - F 608;14101?14=8;@8>2/601:58650@86@/46/= :./ @315>16: ?10 /J1>56/= 10 ! 16= :./ :4/1:567 =8@:84 ?10 /J1>56/= 10 !G 1C567 56:8 @8605=/41:586 :./56<945/0090:156/=AE:./@315>16:102/4J!1> 8;:./D5/?:.1::./=501A535:E:816/J:/6:8;&%H.10:8 A/:1C/6:8>//::.//6=08;<90:5@/56@/:./1@@5=/6:50 8;:./E/14%%16=;8338?567:./795=16@/5009/=AE:./ )1461:1C1 :1:/ /713 /4D5@/0 9:.845:E :./ 56@8>/ 8; :./ @315>16: .10 :8 A/ :1C/6 1: 0&'%$ 2/4 >86:. 223E567:./122482451:/>93:5235/4102/4:./<9=7>/6:8; :./ 86-A3/ 924/>/ 894: 56 :./ @10/ 8; . 0 0 )(1 # # 24/284:/=56+/-3 . :8:./@10/86.16=101>8;:./D5/?:.1: :./ @315>16: 50 /6:5:3/= ;84 @8>2/601:586 :8?14=0 3800 8; /146567 @121@5:E 50 0GF&%%%$ 0&'%JJJ&%H 1C567 56:8 @8605=/41:586 :./ 745/D89056<945/0 090:156/= AE:./@315>16::./ 1?14=8; @8>2/601:586504/100/00/=10;8338?0 - 8 - +,-. /012 !15616=09;;/4567 0'%%%%$ 800 8; /1465670 =94567 315= 92 2/458=0&'%J& 0'%$ 8008;1>/65:5/0 0'%%%%$ 8008;;9:94/8;/1465670 0GF&%%%$ 8?14=0=5/:16=1::/6=16:@.147/0 0%%%%$ /=5@13/J2/60/0 0&F%%$ 9:94/>/=5@13/J2/60/0 0'%%%%$ 8:13 /001?14=/=AE45A9613 6.16@/>/6: 0F&F%$ 0'&(%$ . !! ' .90 :./ @31>16: 50 /6:5:3/= ;84 /6.16@/= @8>2/601:5868;. !! '?5:.56:/4/0:1::./41:/ 8;GH2/41669> % 6:./4/093:2100:./;8338?567 ./ 122/13 ;53/= :./ 122/3316:609416@/ 8>216E 56 8%&% 50 ./4/AE =50>500/= ./ 122/13 ;53/= AE :./ 122/3316:@315>16: 56 8%%50./4/AE1338?/=56214: - 9 - ./ 122/3316:@315>16: 50 /6:5:3/= ;84 /6.16@/= @8>2/601:5868;. !! '?5:.56:/4/0:1: :./ 41:/ 8; GH 2/4 1669> ;48> :./ =1:/ 8; 2/:5:586:533:./=1:/8;4/135I1:586 # ./ 122/3316: $ 609416@/ 8>216E 50 =54/@:/= :8 =/2805: :./ 1;84/015= @8>2/601:586 1>896: ?5:.56 05J ?//C0 ;48> :./ =1:/ 8; 4/@/52: 8; @/4:5;5/=@82E8;:.50<9=7>/6: # ./1>896:56=/2805:5;16EA/:4160>5::/=:8 :./45A9613 -' $& 50:838% !)