Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54392 (KAR)
THE DIVISIONAL CONTROLLER v. LAKSHMI AND ANR
MFA/200493/2018 · 2026-01-14
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54392 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54392 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$
" %%
&
'
( )* %%
&
'(
)
*
! "
" #$%#%&$%
#$%#%%'(
)
# ('!(
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! *
# ($+
! ,$
$++!+,
'!+,
" *
$ !+%
)
*
, )
# ('!(
! *
- 3 -
# ($+
!'+!!+! !#
,$
$++!+,
'!+,
*
$'!+%
*
-*
" ./0/ 122/130 14/ 1450567 89: 8; :./ <8==86 >9?7=/6: 16? 1@14? ?1:/? $++!+, 56
8$ !+%
@ 8$'!+% 86 :./ ;53/ 8; :./ ??5:58613 50:45<: 16? /005860 *9?7/ 16? ??5:58613 1:15<.941338@567:./<315=2/:5:586056214:16? 1@14?567<8=2/601:586:8:./<315=16:0 ! : 50 :./ <10/ 8; :./ <315=16:0 :.1: 86 +!+$ ?45A/4 8; :./ B90 B/14567 8#$''$
- 4 -
?48A/5:5616/7357/6:=166/416?1009<.?10./?:8:./ 965: B/14567 8#$%%&$% 16? #$%%%'( @.5<. @10 214C/? 86 56?.16884#5479221 481? 16? 86 1<<896: 8; :./ 01=/ :./ <315=16: 56 8$'!+% 090:156/? 56>945/0 16? :./ 965: @10 ?1=17/? /6</ :./56>94/?<315=16:.1024/;/44/? 8$'!+%16? :./8@6/48;:./965:.1024/;/44/? 8$ !+% 0//C567 <8=2/601:586 96?/4 /<:586 %% 8; :./ 8:84 /.5<3/0<: $ ./ <315= 2/:5:5860 @/4/ <86:/0:/? BD 4/0286?/6: 8!#
842841:586 ' ./ 45B9613 1;:/4 <8605?/4567 :./=1:/4513 86 4/<84? BD >9?7=/6: 16? 1@14? ?1:/? $++!+, .10 1@14?/?<8=2/601:5868;0+++++#:8:./<315=16:56
8$'!+% 16? 0( ++# :8 :./ <315=16: 56
8$ !+% 16? ?54/<:/? B8:. :./ 4/0286?/6:0 :8 ?/2805::./01=///356717745/A/?BD:./;10:/6567:./ 351B535:D 86 :./ ?45A/4 8; :./ B90 56 E9/0:586 :./ 842841:586.1024/;/44/?:./0/122/130
- 5 -
.1A/ ./14? 45 .14161B101221 1:53 3/146/? <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ 122/3316:#
842841:586 .897.:./4/0286?/6:014/0/4A/?4/=156/?1B0/6: % 45 .14161B101221 1:53 3/146/? <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ 122/3316: 09B=5::/? :.1: :./ 965: @10214C/?13=80:=5??3/8;:./481?56E9/0:58616?10 09<.:./45B9613897.::8.1A/./3?:.1::./?45A/48;:./ 965: .10 1308 <86:45B9:/? ;84 :./ 133/7/? 1<<5?/6: 16? 1<<84?5673D0897.:;8456:/4;/4/6</8;:.50
894::501308 1479/?BD:./3/146/?<8960/3122/14567;84:./122/3316: 56 8!++'&'!+( :.1: :./ <315=16: .10 68: /F1=56/?:./?8<:845608;14101@14?567<8=2/601:586;84 :./ 56>94D 090:156/? BD ./4 16? 10 09<. 0897.: ;84 56:/4;/4/6</8;:.50
894: , 6 :./ 357.: 8; :./ 09B=500586 =1?/ BD :./ 3/146/? <8960/3 122/14567 ;84 :./ 122/3316: 56 84?/4 :8 160@/4 :./ E9/0:586 4150/? BD :./ 3/146/? <8960/3 10 :8 ;10:/6567 :./ 351B535:D 86 :./ ?45A/4 8; :./ 965: 50 <86</46/?.1A/<14/;933D/F1=56/?F'#
45=//:1530
- 6 -
84=@./4/56:./0C/:<.50248A5?/?1:2141+@./4/565: 500.8@6:.1::./965:@10214C/?13=80:56:./C1<.1 481? 86 5479221#56?.16884 481? : 50 1308 4/;3/<:/? 56 :./0C/:<.10:8:./6/7357/6</86:./214:8;:./?45A/48; :./ B90 6 :.1: A5/@ 8; :./ =1::/4 :1C567 56:8 <8605?/41:586:./;1<:913102/<:0864/<84?16?:./;56?567 4/<84?/? BD :./ 45B9613 1= 8; :./ A5/@ :.1: 68 56:/4;/4/6</ 50 <133/? ;84 5608;14 10 :./ 351B535:D 50 <86</46/? ( 608;14 10 :./ 1479=/6: 1?A16</? BD :./ 3/146/?<8960/3122/14567;84:./122/3316:10:81@14?567 8; <8=2/601:586 56
8$'!+%
8!++'&'!+(1;:/4<8605?/4567:./61:94/8;56>945/0 090:156/?BD:./<315=16::./4/561=8;:./A5/@:.1: 68 56:/4;/4/6</ 50 <133/? ;84 @5:.
4/02/<: :8 E916:9= 8; <8=2/601:586 & <<84?5673DB8:.:./122/13014/?50=500/?10 ?/A85?8;=/45:0
- 7 -
+ ./1=896:56?/2805:5;16DB/:4160=5::/?:8 :./45B9613;84?50B940/=/6:
+) & (
"
50: 83 8!+