- 1 - !"!# $%"" % &' &()* &) + ! " # $ % Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & & '(" & # $ &) * &% & !(&$% ( &$% +, " $!" " %&& & & && ! !+ !!("!"!, - .& & / / 0 123 45626278 23 92:5; <8;5= 5>6278 ( 79 1?=?62@? ?A?=2B<=?B31??8126?" 355B28A67C<?314=7>55;28A3 ?A?2836615456262785=3 ?>><35;7367287!" " $?=2328A7<679=2D57+, "%=5A2365=5;E@2=F?=7:2>5 458;28A7861592:5795827=2G2:<;A5?8;&?8G2$97= - 3 - E=5G26@ H615 =2?: 7<=6I% 97= 615 79958>53 4<8231?E:5 <8;5= 35>62783! !+ !!("!?8;"= F5>6278!,79 15 ?E=2;A5; 9?>63 79 615 >?35 ?=5 61?6 78 " ""?6?E7<6+""4D615456262785=3 ?>><35;73 67 6?B28A <8;<5 ?;G?86?A5 79 ?E358>5 79 1<3E?8; ?8; >12:;=58 79 >7D4:?28?86 28 615 17<35 5865=5; 615 17<35 56262785=73:?445;615>7D4:?28?86?8;4<315;15=36?628A ?E7<6 615 >?35 92:5; ?A?2836 12D ?3 3<>1 315 95:: ;7F8 56262785=73?8;?E<35;15=2892:61@:?8A<?A5456262785= 73 B2>B5; 15= ?8; 456262785= 7 A?G5 :295 61=5?6 67 15= 1<3E?8; 158 315 6=25; 67 :7>B 615 ;77= 456262785= 7 4<8>15; 78 15= E?>BE785 ;<5 67 F12>1 315 A76 2865=8?: 28J<=@661?662D57851?=?8?44? 7155D?8?A7<;?1?3 =53><5; 615 >7D4:?28?86 6 23 9<=615= 36?65; 61?6 615 456262785=3 1?G5 E=7<A16 615 ?=D3 ?8; >12::@ 47F;5= F261 ?8 28658627867;7?F?@615:29579>7D4:?28?86I31<3E?8;58>5 615>7D4:?28?86:7;A5;?>7D4:?286?A?2836456262785=7367 E597=5615=53478;586'47:2>5861536=58A61796153?2; >7D4:?286 & >?D5 67 E5 =5A2365=5; 28 =2D5 7+, " - 4 - ;?65; """ ?A?2836 615 456262785=3 ?8; 7615=3 97= 615 79958>53 4<8231?E:5 <8;5= 5>62783 ! !+ !( !!( !+ "+ "! ?8; " = F 5>6278 !, 79 965= =5A236=?6278 79 & =53478;586 7.47:2>5 >78;<>65; 28G5362A?6278 ?8; :?2; >1?=A5 31556 ?A?2836 615 456262785=3 97= 61579958>534<8231?E:5<8;5=35>62783! !+ !!("! ?8; " = F 5>6278 !, 79 AA=25G5; E@ 615 3?D5 615 456262785=34=595==5;612345626278 5?=; :5?=85; >7<835: 97= 615 456262785=3 615 :5?=85;2A17<=67G5=8D586:5?;5=97==53478;5867' 6?65?8;:5?=85;>7<835:97==53478;5867 ! 4?=6 9=7D <=A28A 35G5=?: >7865862783 :5?=85; >7<835: 97= 615 456262785=3 1?3 >78658;5; 61?6 28 G25F 79 615 >2G2: ;234<65 28 =5345>6 67 615 :?8;5; 4=745=6253 E5?=28A @7( D5?3<=28A!?>=53 A<86?3326<?65;?62=F?= ?:<B?8;615:?8;E5?=28A5>62787 D5?3<=28A,?>=53 ( A<86?3 79 5=?D?=?3 G2::?A5 E56F558 456262785= 7! ?8; 1<3E?8;79=53478;5867?9?:35>7D4:?2861?3E558972365; E@=53478;5867?8;?687472867962D5615456262785=3?=5 28G7:G5;28615?::5A5;79958>5K>5466157D82E<3?::5A?62783 - 5 - 877615= D?65=2?:397=61>7D28A28615>1?=A531556 33<>1154=?@367C<?316154=7>55;28A3 :5?=85; >7<835: 97= =53478;586 7 G515D586:@ 744735; 615 45626278 5 36?65; 61?6 617<A1 615 ;234<65E56F558615456262785=3?8;615>7D4:?28?86?445?=367 E5>2G2:7861592=36E:<31615>=2D28?:D762G52397=61>7D28A78 615 4?=6 79 615 456262785=3 78 45=<3?: 79 615 >1?=A5 31556 D?65=2?:3>>7=;28A:@154=?@367;23D23361545626278 15 :5?=85; ?:37 744735; 615 45626278 ?8; 4=?@367;23D23361545626278 + 1?G5A2G58D@?8K27<3>7832;5=?6278E76178615 3<ED2332783 D?;5 E@ 615 :5?=85; >7<835: 97= 615 =5345>62G5 4?=6253?8;?:3745=<35;615D?65=2?:34:?>5;E597=561237<=6 ( 3>7<:;E5A?615=5;9=7D=5>7=;3615=523?>2G2: ;234<6528=5345>679?E7G5D5862785;:?8;3E56F558456262785= 7! ?8; 1<3E?8; 79 =53478;586 7 3 78 """ 456262785= 7! G23265; 615 925:; 97= 1?=G53628A 28 615 3<EJ5>6 :?8;615=5F?3?C<?==5:E56F5586151<3E?8;79=53478;586 7 ?8; 456262785= 7! >>7=;28A:@ 615 >7<865= >7D4:?2863 - 6 - ?=5 ?:37 :7;A5; 28 61?6 =5A?=; 6 4=53586 615 7:2>5 1?G5 28G5362A?65; 615 D?665= ?8; :?2; >1?=A5 31556 28 615 >?35 17<A1 26 23 >78658;5; E@ 615 :5?=85; >7<835: 97= 615 456262785=3 61?6 ? >2G2: ;234<65 23 458;28A E56F558 456262785= 7! ?8; 1<3E?8; 79 =53478;586 7 78 45=<3?: 79 615 >7D4:?286 ?8; >1?=A5 31556 D?65=2?:3 615=5 ?=5 4=2D? 9?>25 D?65=2?:3 97=61>7D28A ?A?2836 615 456262785=3 97= 615 79958>53 615@1?G5E558>1?=A5; , <?3128A615>=2D28?:4=7>55;28A323>?::5;97=78:@ 28?>?35F15=5615>7D4:?286;753876;23>:735?8@79958>57= 239=2G7:7<3G5K?627<37=744=5332G59615?::5A?627833567<6 28615>7D4:?286;7876>783626<6579958>579F12>1>7A82L?8>5 1?3 E558 6?B58 E@ 615 D?A236=?65 26 23 7458 97= 6123 7<=6 67 C<?316153?D562387685>533?=@61?6?D562><:7<3?8?:@323 79>?35317<:;E5;785E597=56=2?:67928;7<6F15615=615>?35 F7<:;58;28>78G2>62787=?>C<266?:926?445?=378?=5?;28A 79615>7D4:?286?8;>7832;5=?627879615?::5A?6278615=52828 615:2A167961536?65D586D?;5787?6161?661528A=5;2586379 61579958>5?=5;23>:735;615=5F7<:;E587J<36292>?627897=6123 7<=6672865=95=5?315:;28615>?3579 - 7 - =547=65;28 " 8 615 2836?86 >?35 615 >1?=A5 31556 D?65=2?:3 ;23>:7353 ? >?35 ?A?2836 615 456262785=3 97= 615 79958>53615@?=5>1?=A5;83<>1>2=><D36?8>56153?D51?3 67 E5 65365; 28 ;56?2:5; 6=2?: 58>5 F2617<6 5K4=53328A ?8@ 7428278 78 615 D5=263 79 615 >?35 3<992>5 67 17:; 61?6 615 4=7>55;28A3>?8876E5C<?315;?6612336?A5>>7=;28A:@615 45626278:?>B3D5=263?8;6153?D523!"#"$! ,* &") " 2367/:7/" /