Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54389 (KAR)
SRI SURESH S/O LATE MANIKRAO v. NARAYAN RAO AND ORS
RFA/200054/2017 · 2026-01-14
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54389 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54389 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$
#$ %
""
&"'"( )
! " #
!$%&%#
'
#&
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! $%&%#
(
%)
! $%&%#
*
#)
+##
,
"
" &
"
"
$#%&
-
"
)
+%
#
-)
+$%
- 3 -
%
)
!" $%&%#
! . . / ),,& , - %
"/ ,-,, " . ../ ,,, #
. . 0) . "
! ,##,
! ! ),0 .! 1
. . ! ! "
2 !! 3* 2 !! - 4 -
$ 2 !! 4567 8398::;83 ;),0;3945:875;:945 <83(86 7 538;< 8=87 !>*?5 3* ! 8* < 4 @ :875* 948@ 665 7 (4 7753?83? 945 A>*?B539 3* *5(<55 * 95* ,##, 'C D48(4 9458< @>89 :;< 6 <9898;3 D @ *8@B8@@5* , 45 6 <985@ @4 77 453(5:;<94 '5 <5:5<<5* 9; @ 945CD5<5 << C5*'5:;<59459<8 7;><9 - 45 @>89 83 ;),0 D @ :875* :;< 6 <9898;3 3* @56 < 95 6;@@5@@8;3 ;: 945 @>89 6<;65<985@ D48(4D5<5@8E@4;66<5B8@5@ 3* 4;>@5@89> 95*'5483* 945@4;66<5B8@5@9D @945(;395398;3;:94567 8398::@ 94 9 945 @>89 6<;65<985@ D5<5 ;D35* 3* 6;@@5@@5* 'C 9458<: 945< 3*94 9 :95<48@*5 94945C <55398975*9;
@4 <5 7;3?D894945*5:53* 39;@,- 3*# # 45@>89D @(;395@95*'C*5:53* 39;D4;
(7 8B5*94 9945<5D @ 6<8;<6 <9898;3;3,0-00 3*
- 5 -
77 945 '<;945<@ 3* 945 *5:53* 39 ; 4 * @56 < 95* :<;B 945 : B87C 3* 4 * *8=8*5* 9458< <5@65(98=5 6<;65<985@ 5 (;3953*5* 94 9 @ 65< 945 @ 8* 6 <9898;3 @4;6 9 7; 9; ) D5<5 77;995* 9; 945 @4 <5 ;: 945 67 8398::@ 3* 9458< B;945< B9 >3* ' 8 5 7@;
(;3953*5* 94 9 945 @ 8* @4;6@ <5 *5B;78@45* 'C 945 >38(86 789C :;< 945 6><6;@5 ;: <; * D8*5383? 3* 945<5:;<5945@ 8*@4;6@*;3;95E8@9 @;:3;D@<5? <*@ 9454;>@5 97;45(7 8B5*94 9 @65<9456 <9898;3 * 95*,0-00945@ B5D @ 77;995*9;48@@4 <5 3* 94 9454 **5=57;65*945@ 8*6<;65<9C % <5A;83*5< D @ :875* 9; 945 D<89953 @9 95B539 'C 945 67 8398:: ; *B89983? 945 5E5(>98;3 ;:
945 6 <9898;3 * 95* ,0-00 ;D5=5< 45 (;3953*5* 94 994;>?4945@>89@4;6@ 9;@9;)D5<5 77;995*9;
9458<@4 <5@89D @945*5:53* 39;D4;D @<5(58=83?
945 <539@ :<;B 945 953 39@ 83 945 @ 8* @4;6@ 5 7@; (7 8B5* 94 9 945 *5:53* 39 ; D @ 83 6;@@5@@8;3 ;:
4;>@5D48(4D @7 <?5835E9539 3*945<5:;<5(;3953*5*
- 6 -
94 9 945 *5:53* 39 ; D @ 3;9 5398975* 9; '5 83 6;@@5@@8;3;:@>(4 4>?56;<98;3;:9454;>@5 ) @5* ;3 945 <8= 7 (;395398;3@ 945 9<8 7 ;><9 :< B5*945:;77;D83?8@@>5@
!"" !#! $ %
&
- 7 -
3 @>66;<9 ;:945 @@5<98;3@ B *5 83 945 67 839 94567 8398::;D @5E B835* @" 3*9D;D8935@@5@ D5<5 5E B835* @ ", 3* "- 45 67 8398:: ;
B <F5* 5E48'89@ 9; 45 D8:5 3* @;3 ;: 945 *5:53* 39 ; D5<5 5E B835* @ " 3* ", 3* D8935@@D @5E B835* @"-45*5:53* 39;@ 3* ,B <F5*5E48'89@9;& & @5* ;3 945 ;< 7 3* *;(>B539 <C 5=8*53(5 945 9<8 7 ;><9 457* 94 9 945 *5:53* 39 ; 4 * 6<;=5* 94 9945@>896<;65<985@D5<56 <9898;35*;3,0-0083 95<B@;:E9 7@;457*94 9945@>89@4;6@ 97;@ 9; ) D5<5 *5B;78@45* 'C 945
>38(86 789C D48(4 D @ 5=8*539 :<;B 75995< * 95* -,0 E 9 D @ :><945<457*94 99454;>@5 97;D @ 77;995*9;945 @4 <5 ;: 945 *5:53* 39 ; 3* 945<5:;<5 945 67 8398::@ <5 3;9 5398975* 9; @4 <5 83 945 @ 8* 6<;65<9C ;3@5G>5397C 89 *8@B8@@5* 945 @>89 83 95<B@ ;: 945 8B6>?35* A>*?B539 3* *5(<55 583? ??<85=5* 'C 945
- 8 -
A>*?B539 3**5(<5594567 8398::@ <5'5:;<5948@(;><983 948@ 665 7 0
5 <35* (;>3@57 :;< 945 67 8398::@ (;3953*5* 94 9 945 @>89 6<;65<985@ <5 3;9 *5B;78@45* 'C 945 >38(86 789C @ (;3953*5* 5 4;D5=5< @>'B89@ 94 9 6;<98;3 ;: 945 @>89 6<;65<9C D @ *5B;78@45* 3* 945 <5B 8383? 6;<98;3 @9877 5E8@9@ 3* 453(5 945 67 8398::@ <5 5398975* 9; 6;@@5@@8;3 ;: 945 6<;65<9C 'C (7 8B83? 9458< @4 <5 945<583 5 7@; (;3953*@ 94 9 @@>B83?
94 9 945 67 8398::@D5<5?8=53 @4 <583945@>89@4;6@945@4;6@ 94 9:5779;945@4 <5;:9458<B;945<D @ 7@;9;'5*8=8*5* '59D553 945 67 8398::@ 3* 945 *5:53* 39 ; @ D577 @ 945 ;945< *5:53* 39@ 5 945<5:;<5 (;3953*5* 94 9 945 8B6>?35*A>*?B539 3**5(<556 @@5*'C9459<8 7(;><98@ D894;>9 66<5(8 983?945 ';=5: (9@ 3*453(5945@ B5 D << 39@8395<:5<53(5 ' 945 75 <35* (;>3@57 :;< *5:53* 39 ; @>'B8995* 94 9 945 67 8398:: ;, 48B@57: 4 * @>'B8995* 75995< 9 E '5:;<5 945
>38(86 7
- 9 -
;BB8@@8;35<D45<583454 * (F3;D75*?5*945: (994 9 945 @>89 @4;6@ D5<5 *5B;78@45* :;< 945 6><6;@5@ ;: D8*5383? 945 <; * 3* 94 9 45 4 * B *5 <5G>5@9 :;< 6 CB539 ;: 945 (;B653@ 98;3 5 945<5:;<5 @>'B89@ 94 9 5=53 @ 65< 945 >3*5<@9 3*83? ;: 945 67 8398::@ 945 @>89 6<;65<9C 3 B57C 945 @4;6@ *; 3;9 5E8@9 3* 453(5 945 67 8398::@ <5 3;9 5398975* 9; (7 8B 6 <9898;3 ;: 945 @>89 6<;65<985@5 7@;(;3953*@94 9 779456<;65<985@D48(4 '57;3?5* 9; 945 : B87C D5<5 @>'A5(9 9; 6 <9898;3 @ 65< E 45<5:;<5 89 ( 33;9 3;D 785 83 945 B;>94 ;: 945 67 8398::@ 94 9 945 @>89 6<;65<985@ <5 78 '75 9; '5 6 <9898;35* 3@;: < @ 945 (;395398;3 ;: 945 67 8398::@ 94 9 945 @4;6@ 94 9 :577 9; 945 @4 <5 ;: 945 B;945< D @ 3;9 6 <9898;35* 45 (;3953*@ 94 9 94;@5 @4;6 6<;65<985@ (G>8<5*D5<5 7@;*5B;78@45*'C945
>38(86 789C:;<945 6><6;@5 ;: <; * D8*5383? 3* 945<5:;<5 3; @>89 :;< 6 <9898;3 8@ B 839 83 '75 83 <5@65(9 ;: 3;3+5E8@983? 6<;65<9C
- 10 -
, "5 4 =5 (;3@8*5<5* 945 @>'B8@@8;3@ ;: 945 75 <35* (;>3@57 :;< 945 67 8398::@ 3* 94575 <35*(;>3@57 :;<945*5:53* 39; - 456;839@94 9 <8@5@:;<;><(;3@8*5< 98;3 <5
"45945< 67 8398::@ 4 * *B8995* 945 6 <9898;3 ;: 945 6<;65<985@ ;: 945 : B87C >3*5< E 3* 8: C5@ D45945< 945 67 8398::@ <55398975*:;< @4 <58394583 945@>896<;65<985@H ,
"45945< 94567 8398::@ <55398975*:;< @4 <583945@4;6@94 9:5779;945@4 <5 ;: 9458< *5(5 @5* B;945< D4; *85* 8395@9 95H # 4567 8398::@(7 8B5*8394567 83994 9945@>89 6<;65<985@D5<53;96 <9898;35*D4875 77;945<6<;65<985@;:
945: B87CD5<56 <9898;35*3<567C945*5:53* 39;
:875* D<89953 @9 95B539 B5398;383?
83 ?<5 9 *59 87 94 9 945 6<;65<985@ ;: 945 : B87C D5<5 *8=8*5* 83 95<B@ ;:
*;(>B539D48(4D @<5(;<*5*;3,0-004567 8398::
; D4; :875* <5A;83*5< 9; 945 D<89953 @9 95B539
- 11 -
@65(8:8( 77C =5<<5* I( )*+
, -. .! / !#! (
0 )* ! / !#!J 5 7@; @9 95* I( )
! / !#! $
1)1 !""%2 !""%# , -. $ ,
1)1 !""% !""%& $
+ + .0 1)1 !""%
!""% ( .*
!""&234 !"
"2 3$4
- 12 -
+0
5$
*6
( 0
J % 5 :><945< *5385* 94 9 945 @4;6@ 94 9 D5<5 77;995*9;945@4 <5;:9458<B;945< 3*945@4;6@ 77;995* 9; 945B D5<5 *8@B 3975* 'C 945
>38(86 789C 5 @65(8:8( 77C (7 8B5* 94 9 3; @4;6@ D5<5 *8@B 3975* 5 (7 8B5*94 9 :95<945*5 94;:48@B;945<9459D;@4;6@ 94 9D5<5 77;995*9;45<@4 <5D5<59;'5*8=8*5* B;3?@9 945 67 8398:: ; 3* *5:53* 39 ; 9 8@ 945<5:;<5 5=8*539 94 9 67 8398::@ @ D577 @ *5:53* 39 ; <5 ;=5<945: (994 99456<;65<985@;:945 : B87C D5<5 :>77C *8=8*5* 83 95<B@ ;: 945 6 <9898;3 * 95* ,0-00 45<5:;<5 945 67 8398::@ ( 33;9 83898 95 ;35 B;<56<;(55*83?:;<6 <9898;3;:945@4;6@94 9:5779;9458< @4 <5 83 95<B@ ;: E ;3@5G>5397C 945 67 8398::@ <5 3;9 5398975* :;< (7 8B83? 3C @4 <5 83 945 @4;6 '5 <83? - 13 -
;@0+,+#- 0+,+#% 0+,+# 3* 0+,+#, 45<5:;<5 945 :8<@9 6;839 :;< (;3@8*5< 98;3 8@ 3@D5<5* ? 83@9 945 67 8398::@ 3*898@457*94 994567 8398::@ <53;95398975*9;
(7 8B 9458< @4 <5 83 945 :;<5@ 8* 6<;65<985@ ;D5=5< 8: 945 67 8398::@ <5 8395<5@95* 9; 6<;95(9 9458< 6;@@5@@8;3 945CB C9 F535(5@@ <C@956@ @6<;=8*5*837 D ) 3@;: < @945@5(;3*6;839:;<(;3@8*5< 98;38@ (;3(5<35*94567 8398::@ 3*945*5:53* 394 =5 *B8995* 945 : (9 94 9 9D; @4;6@ '5 <83? ;@0+,+#) 3* 0+,+# D5<5 77;995*9;945@4 <5;:9458<B;945<B9>3* ' 8 58945<94567 8398::@3;<945*5:53* 39;4 =5(7 8B5* 94 9 B9 >3* ' 8 4 * 5E5(>95* 3C 95@9 B539 '5G>5 9483? 45< 8395<5@9 83 945 9D; @4;6@ B5398;35* ';=54;>?4945<58@ B5398;383E94 9945@4 <5 ;:67 8398::;,D @ (G>8<5*'C945
>38(86 789C945<58@ 3;9483? 9; @4;D 94 9 945 @4;6@ 94 9 :577 9; 945 @4 <5 ;:
B9 >3* ' 8 D5<5 7@; (G>8<5* ;< >@><65* 'C 945 >38(86 789C :;<9456><6;@5@ ;: <; *D8*5383?
65<>@ 7 ;:9455=8*53(5;:",D;>7*@4;D94 9945@>89@(45*>75
- 14 -
6<;65<9CB5 @><5@:<;B5 @99;D5@9):559 3*3;<949;
@;>94--:5595 *B8995*I( 2/ 6 J ;D5=5< 83 3;945< '<5 94 45 *56;@5* I $ $ 2/J 3 =85D ;: 945 : (9 94 9 945<5 8@ 3; B 95<8 7 67 (5*'C945*5:53* 39; ';>99453;3+5E8@953(5;:
9456<;65<9C94 9:5779;945@4 <5;:B9>3* ' 8945 @>89 :875* :;< 6 <9898;3 ;: 945 @4 <5 ;: B9 >3* ' 8 ( 33;9 '5 *8@B8@@5* ;>9+<8?497C : B9 >3* ' 8 4 * *85* 8395@9 95 9453 'C =8<9>5 ;: 5(98;3 % ;: 945 83*> >((5@@8;3 (9 945 67 8398::@ @ D577 @ 945 *5:53* 39 ;@, 3*- 3*945B;945<;:945*5:53* 39;#D5<5 5398975* 9; 3 5G> 7 @4 <5 45<5:;<5 @>'A5(9 9; 945 @(5<9 83B539 ;: 945 = 87 '8789C5E8@953(5 ;: 945 6<;65<985@94 9:5779;945@4 <5;:B9>3* ' 8945@>89 ( 3'5*8@6;@5*;:4;7*83?94 994567 8398::@ @D577 @945
@ ;: 945 *5:53* 39 ; 3* 945 * >?495<@ ;: B9
- 15 -
>3* ' 8 <5 5398975* 9; 5G> 7 @4 <5 83 945 6<;65<985@ D48(4 <5*5@(<8'5* @895B;@0+,+)- 3*0+,+)#D48(4 :5779;945@4 <5;:B9>3* ' 8 & 3=85D;:945 ';=5948@ 665 78@*8@6;@5*;: ;3945:;77;D83?95<B@ 8 45 (7 8B ;: 945 67 8398::@ 83 <5@65(9 ;: 945 @4;6@'5 <83?;7*;@0+,+#-0+,+#%0+,+# 3*0+,+#,8@*8@B8@@5*98@4;D5=5<;653:;< 945 67 8398::@ 9; 9 F5 35(5@@ <C @956@ @ 6<;=8*5*837 D9;6<;95(99458<989759;945@ 8* 6<;65<9C8:89;< 3C6;<98;3;:895E8@9@ 88 4567 8398::@ 3*945*5:53* 39; @D577 @ 945* >?495<@;:B9>3* ' 8 <55398975*9;
#94@4 <5839459D;@4;6@;:B9>3* ' 8 3 B57C 0+,+#);7* 3* 0+,+#;7* 35D 3>B'5<@0+,+)- 3*0+,+)#8:89;< 3C6;<98;3 ;:895E8@9@
- 16 -
::8(58@*8<5(95**< D *5(<55 <985@9;'5 <9458<;D3(;@9@
*' & (
*' & %(
8@9;7;)