Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54384 (KAR)
SRI.PEERSAPATEL v. SMT.RASOOL BEE AND ORS
RFA/200057/2019 · 2026-01-20
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54384 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54384 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$ %&" "
%&" !"'! $$
()"* +
! "
#
$%
Amended vide order dated 24.06.2025 Digitally signed by SACHIN Location:
HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! &%
"
'
$! "
$
#
$%
"
&
&%
"
#
%%
"
! '%&!%!$
- 3 -
( $
# !$!%)
#
(!%)
#
"
#
* #
# +,- * #
#
"& * #
#
./01+2,32442,5(!%)5,3./421/543.//,256 2721#8-9/2,.233+086.+:421/-3.2:+00/+1;.+11/,92,9+, 56-/6-+3/-!$!%)<=>.2;.3./01+2,3>+:6/?/;3/- 8,-/66-/681/+ +,-- 54 ! ./ :823 2, 5(!%) >+: 421/- 456 -/;1+6+325, 3.+3 3./ 01+2,3244 2: 3./ +<:5183/ 5>,/6 2, 05::/::25, 54 3./ :823 0650/632/: +,- 35 -/;1+6/ 3.+3 3./ :+1/-//--+3/-((&(+,-!@%&(+6/,811+,- 752- +,- ,53 <2,-2,9 5, 3./ 01+2,3244 +,- 35 56-/6
- 4 -
6/;3242;+325,54/,362/:2,3./6/7/,8/6/;56-:+,-6/:356/ .2:,+A/ ' ./ 01+2,3244 ;1+2A/- 3.+3 3./ :823 0650/632/: >/6/3./1+,-54.2:4+3./6/;1+2A/-3.+3.2:8,;1/ ;1+2A2,935</.2:98+6-2+,.+-:51-3./:8230650/632/:35 5,/.27+6+=+>.52:3./4+3./6543./-/4/,-+,35$5, ((&(1+2,3244;1+2A/-3.+3.2:8,;1/;581-,53.+7/ <//,3./98+6-2+,+:.2:A53./6>+:+127/+33./32A/54 3./ :+1/ +,- >+: 3./ ,+386+1 98+6-2+, / +1:5 ;1+2A/- 3.+3 .2: 8,;1/ .+- :51- 3./ 0650/63= >23.583 5<3+2,2,9 0/6A2::25, 54 3./ 5863 +: 06/:;62</- 8,-/6 3./ 8+6-2+,:.20 +,- +6-: ;3 / +1:5 ;1+2A/- 3.+3 .2: 8,;1/.+-/B/;83/-+,53./6:+1/-//--+3/-!@%&(2, 4+7586543./.8:<+,-54-/4/,-+,35/;1+2A/-3.+3 ./>+:8,+>+6/543./+456/:+2-4+;3:+:./>+:+A2,56 -862,9 3./ =/+6 (&( +,- ( 6/:0/;327/1= / +1:5 ;1+2A/-3.+3-8/354+A2,/./+15,9>23..2:A53./61/4335 +,9+156/+,-6/386,/-<+;C3581<+69+2,(@@+,-3.+3 ././+6-68A56:+<5833./:+1/543./:8230650/632/:+,-
- 5 -
3./6/+43/67/6242/-465A3./5442;/543./ +:21-+6>.5351- .2A 3.+3 3./6/ >+: ,5 6/;56- 2, 6/:0/;3 54 3./ :823 0650/632/: ./6/+43/6 ./ >/,3 35 .233+086 +18C +,- 458,- 3.+3 +11 3./ 6/7/,8/ 6/;56-: >/6/ :/,3 35 3./ +- +;./62+1+921+2,3244;1+2A/-3.+3./>+:21123/6+3/+,- 3./6/456/ >+,-/6/- 465A 5442;/ 35 5442;/ 2, :/+6;. 54 3./ 6/;56-:+,-3./6/456/3./6/>+:-/1+=2,4212,93./:823 $ ./-/4/,-+,35:!'+,-;5,3/:3/-3./ :823 +,- 421/- + >6233/, :3+3/A/,3 ./ -/4/,-+,3 5 421/-58,-/66-/681/+ +,-- 54 356/?/;33./01+2,3+:23>+:<+66/-<=3./1+>5412A23+325, +,-3./6/>+:,5:8<:2:32,9;+8:/54+;325,4563./01+2,3244 35 ://C-/;1+6+325, 54.2: 3231/35 3./ :8230650/632/: ./ +0012;+325, >+: ;5,3/:3/- <= 3./ 01+2,3244 >.5 ;5,3/,-/- 3.+312A23+325,</2,9D8/:325,544+;3+,-1+>;+,,53</+ 9658,-356/?/;33./01+2,3/+1:5;1+2A/-3.+3./;+A/ 35 C,5> +<583 3./ ;1+2A 54 3./ -/4/,-+,3: 5,1= 5, '%%'!%& >./, +, /,-56:/A/,3 >+: 2::8/- <= 3./ 6/7/,8/ +83.56232/: 3.+3 3./ 0650/632/: 2, D8/:325, >+:
- 6 -
:51-<=3./8,;1/543./01+2,3244/3./6/456/;1+2A/-3.+3 +43/6 ;5A2,9 35 C,5> 54 3./ +<57/ 4+;3 ./ .+- 421/- 3./ :823>23.2,3.6//=/+6:+,-./,;/3./:823>+:>/11>23.2, 12A23+325, & ./ 362+1 5863 2, 3/6A: 54 3./ 56-/6 -+3/- !$!%)6/?/;3/-3./01+2,38,-/66-/681/+ +,- - 54 5, 3./ 9658,- 3.+3 3./ 01+2,3244 .+- 421/- 3./:8232,3./=/+6!%)35+,,81+:+1/-//-543./=/+6 (&( +,- ( 3 ./1- 3.+3 01+2,3244 >+: $ =/+6: 51- >.2;.
>+: /72-/,3 465A 3./ :+1/ -//- +,- ./ 3./6/456/ A8:3.+7/421/-3./:823>23.2,3.6//=/+6:465A3./-+3/ 54 ./ +33+2,2,9 3./ +9/ 54 A+?5623= ./ 362+1 5863 3./6/456/ ./1- 3.+3 3./ :823 421/- <= 3./ 01+2,3244 >+:
.50/1/::1= <+66/- <= 3./ 1+> 54 12A23+325, +,- ./,;/ 065;//-/- 35 6/?/;3 3./ 01+2,3 2, 3/6A: 54 3./ 2A089,/- 56-/6/2,9+9962/7/-<=3./:+A/3./01+2,32442:</456/ 3.2:5863
/+6,/-;58,:/14563./01+2,3244;5,3/,-/-3.+3 3./ 8,;1/ 54 3./ 01+2,3244 .+- :51- 3./ :823 0650/63=
- 7 -
;1+2A2,935</3./A2,5698+6-2+,3.589.+33.+3052,32, 32A/ 3./ A53./6 54 3./ 01+2,3244 >+: +127/ / ;5,3/,-:
3.+3 3./ 01+2,3244*: 8,;1/ -2- ,53 5<3+2, 0/6A2::25, 54 3./ 5863+,-./,;/3./:+1/-//-2,4+7586543./-/4/,-+,3: 2: ,811+,-752-+,-./,;/3./:823456-/;1+6+325, >+: A+2,3+2,+<1/ / +1:5 ;5,3/,-: 3.+3 3./ 362+1 5863 ;581-,53.+7//,3/63+2,/-3./+0012;+325,+:3./2::8/54 12A23+325,>+:+A2B/-D8/:325,544+;3+,-1+>+,-23>+: 4563./01+2,324435/:3+<12:.-862,93./;586:/54362+13.+3 ./;+A/35C,5>+<5833./36+,:+;325,:<6589.3+<583<= .2:8,;1/>23.2,3.6//=/+6:06256353./-+3/544212,93./ :823 / 3./6/456/;5,3/,-: 3.+33./ 362+1 5863 ;581- ,53 .+7//B/6;2:/-?862:-2;325,+,-6/?/;3/-3./01+2,3 @ / .+7/ ;5,:2-/6/- 3./ :8<A2::25,: 54 3./ 1/+6,/- ;58,:/1 456 3./ 01+2,3244 / +1:5 0/68:/- 3./ 6/;56-: 54 3./ 362+1 5863 +: >/11 +: 23: 56-/6 -+3/- !$!%) ) 0/68:+1 54 3./ 01+2,3 :.5>: 3.+3 3./ 01+2,3244 .+-;+3/9562;+11=:3+3/-3.+33./:8230650/632/:>/6/:51-
- 8 -
<= .2: 8,;1/ +: 3./ 98+6-2+, 54 3./ 01+2,3244 ./ 01+2,3244 .+:+1:5+7/66/-3.+3./+,-.2:A53./61/4335+,9+156/ -8/ 35 -6589.3 +,- 3./6/+43/6 6/386,/- 35 81<+69+ 2, (@@ +,- 3.+3 01+2,3244 8:/- 35 95 35 .2: 7211+9/ / .+:
+1:5 ;1+2A/- 3.+3 3./6/ >/6/ 68A56: 3.+3 3./ :823 0650/632/: >/6/ :51- +,- 3.+3 ./ :8:0/;32,9 :5A/ 4581 01+= >/,3 35 3./ 6/7/,8/ +83.56232/: +,- 6/D8/:3/- 456 -5;8A/,3:2,6/:0/;3543./:8230650/632/: ./6/456/3./ 01+2,3244589.335.+7/2,232+3/-+;325,>23.2,+6/+:5,+<1/ 32A/ 56 +3 1/+:3 2, 3./ =/+6 (@@ <= >.2;. 32A/ ./ .+- +33+2,/- 3./ +9/ 54 A+?5623= ./ 01+2,3244 .+: :1/03 57/6 .2: 629.3: 465A 3./ =/+6 (@@ 3211 3./ =/+6 !%) +,- 3./6/456/ 3./ :823 >+: .50/1/::1= <+66/- <= 3./ 1+> 54 12A23+325, ./01+2,3244;+,,53;1+2A3.+3./-2-,53C,5> +<5833./36+,:+;325,<6589.3+<583<=.2:8,;1/2,4+7586 54 3./ -/4/,-+,3 5' +: 15,9 06256 35 3./ 4212,9 54 3./ :823 3./ 6/7/,8/ -5;8A/,3: >/6/ +16/+-= 36+,:4/66/- 35 3./,+A/543./-/4/,-+,3:+,-3./01+2,3244>+:<58,-35 .+7/C,5>1/-9/+<5833./36+,:+;325, ./362+15863.+:
- 9 -
+006/;2+3/-3./+<57/D8/:325,2,+11/+6,/:3,/::+,-.+: 629.31= 6/386,/- + 42,-2,9 3.+3 3./ 01+2,3244 .+- ,5 :8<:2:32,9;+8:/54+;325,+,-3.+33./:823>+:.50/1/::1= <+66/-<=3./1+>5412A23+325, ( 5,:/D8/,31=>/-5,53://+,=?8:3242;+325,35 2,3/64/6/ >23. 3./ 2A089,/- 56-/6 0+::/- <= 3./ 362+1 5863 ;;56-2,91=3.2:+00/+12:
,) ("*
"
,) (!"'!*
"
2:3515!