Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54356 (KAR)
SAGAR PATIL v. SHIVAJI AND ANR
MFA/201320/2022 · 2026-01-14
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54356 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54356 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
##
$%&
'
! ! "
#
$ #
%
& ' ( '% )$
'*+* $
'*+*$%
"
&,
%-%(%
$
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
&&
$) $& ! # &
& #
%*% % #
# % %% &
. #
& #
/ #
012344536123712189:;<:=<05>;?9@58<38?3A37? ?3<5? %*% % 18
:% %% :8 <05 =165 := 653785?718B1436581:71C16#;?9538?#3<363D;7391 0575183=<57 75=5775? <: 32 E71D;836. 9738<189 B:@45823<1:8<:<05B631@38<
&:7 <05 23F5 := D75C1<G <05 437<152 18 <05 344536 20366 D5 75=5775? <: 18 <57@2 := <0517 2<3<;2 38? 738F189D5=:75<0571D;836
< 12 <05 B325 := <05 B631@38< <03< :8 %$$$%$( <05 B631@38< A32 47:B55?189 :8 012
- 3 -
@:<:7BGB65D53718975912<73<1:8
:'*- '%)%<:A37?2 0388;7 C166395 =7:@ ;@383D3? 38? 3< <03< <1@5 <05 71?57 := <05 :8?3
0185 @:<:7BGB65 D537189 75912<73<1:8
:' ( '% )$?7:C5<05231?@:<:7BGB6518 3732038?85961958<@3885738?032?3205?393182<<05 @:<:7BGB65 := <05 B631@38< 8 3BB:;8< := <05 231? 3BB1?58< <05 B631@38< 032 2;2<3185? 9715C:;2 18>;7G 58B5 <05 B631@38< 032 =165? :% %% 255F189 B:@45823<1:8
=<57 257C1B5 := 8:<1B5 <05 7524:8?58<2 03C5 58<575? 34453738B5 38? <05 7524:8?58< ' 82;738B5 :@438G 032 B:8<52<5? <05 @3<<57 05 B631@38< 032 5H3@185? <A: A1<852252 32 $ 38? 38? 9:< @37F5? $ ?:B;@58<2 32 H2$ <: $
: :736 :7 ?:B;@58<37G 5C1?58B5 032 D558 3??;B5? :8 <05 437< := <05 7524:8?58<2 05 71D;836 3=<57 B:821?57189 <05 @3<57136 :8 75B:7? DG 1<2 >;?9@58< 38? 3A37? ?3<5? %*% % 366:A5? <05 B631@ 45<1<1:8 38? 3A37?5? B:@45823<1:8:=2$$+%%% 'A1<018<5752<3<<0573<5:=
- 4 -
-I 457 388;@ =7:@ <05 ?3<5 := B631@ 45<1<1:8 <166 75361J3<1:8 &556189 399715C5? DG 183?5K;3BG := B:@45823<1:8 @3?5 DG <05 71D;836 <05 34456638< B631@38<032475=5775?<012344536 * 537? 71 38>55C 3<16 <05 653785? B:;8256 344537189 =:7 <05 34456638< B631@38< 38? @<38955<3 03?73205<<G <05 653785? B:;8256 344537189 =:7 7524:8?58<
: 82;738B5:@438G
- <12B:8<58?5?DG7138>55C3<16<05653785? B:;8256 344537189 =:7 <05 34456638< B631@38< DG 18C1<189 <05 3<<58<1:8 <: H- ' A:;8? B57<1=1B3<5 H) ' ?12B03795 2;@@37G 38? 32 2;B0 2;D@1<<5? <03< <05 K;38<;@:=B:@45823<1:83A37?5?DG<0571D;836:8366 <05 053?2 32 457 437397340
:$- := <05 1@4;985? >;?9@58<75K;1752<:D558038B5?18<012344536 )
@<38955<3 03?732055<G 653785? B:;8256 344537189 =:7 7524:8?58< : L
- 5 -
82;738B5 :@438G 2:;90< <: >;2<1=G <05 1@4;985? >;?9@58<38?3A37?@3?5DG<0571D;836 + 8 <05 6190< := <05 2;D@1221:8 @3?5 DG <05 653785? B:;8256 =:7 <05 437<152 1< 12 8:< 18 ?124;<5 32 <:
<05 :BB;7758B5 := <05 3BB1?58< :8 %$$$%$( A057518 <05 B631@38< 032 2;2<3185? 18>;7152 32 2<3<5? 18 4395 :$ :=<051@4;985?>;?9@58<43225?DG<0571D;836 8B375=;6B:821?573<1:8:=<05?123D161<GB57<1=1B3<532457 H$% 38?
<05 ?12B03795 2;@@37G 47:?;B5? 3< H) 3@ :=<05 C15A <03< <0534456638< B631@38<12 58<1<65? =:7 58038B5?B:@45823<1:818<012344536 ( 3F18918<:B:821?573<1:8<053BB1?58<12:=<05 G537%$(<0518B:@5:=<05B631@38<032<:D5<3F5818 <05 6190< := <05 9;1?561852 122;5? DG <05 3783<3F3 <3<5 5936 57C1B52 ;<0:71<G 3< 2$ *% ' 457 @:8<0 05 3447:4713<5 @;6<146157 34461B3D65 12 $+ 32 <05 395 := <05 B631@38< A32 G5372 3< <05 <1@5 := <05 3BB1?58< 05 ?:B<:7 032 ?54:25? <03< <05 B631@38< 032 2;2<3185? ?123D161<G <: 38 5H<58< := $I <: <05 A0:65 D:?G
- 6 -
:A5C57<0571D;836032<3F58<05?123D161<G3<*I05 231? 3245B< 032 D558 75B:821?575? 18 <05 6190< := <05 =73B<;7538?<05:<05718>;71522;2<3185?DG<05B631@38< 2 457 H2) 38? $% <05 ?123D161<G A:;6? D5 <3F58 3< %IBB:7?1896G<05K;38<;@:=B:@45823<1:875K;1752 <:D5753225225?32=:66:A2 ()*+ ,-./ 31838?2;==57189 2*%%%% ' :22 := 53781892 ?;7189 631? ;4 4571:?2$ *%H 2 ()*% ' :22:=3@581<152 2*%%%% ' :22 := =;<;75 := 53781892 2$ *%H$H$+H%I 2*)%% ' :A37?2?15<38?3<<58?38<B037952 2$*%%% ' 5?1B365H458252 2 *%+ ' :<36 5223A37?5?DG71D;836 8038B5@58< 2)- ' 2 -%%% ' +0! ! 1
0;2 <05 B63@38< 12 58<1<65? =:7 58038B5? B:@45823<1:8:=+0! ! 1A1<018<5752<3<<0573<5 :=-I457388;@ $% 8<05752;6<4322<05=:66:A189
- 7 -
0534453612366:A5?18437< 05 34456638< B631@38< 12 58<1<65? =:7 58038B5? B:@45823<1:8:=+0! ! 1A1<018<5752<3< <05 73<5 := -I 457 388;@ =7:@ <05 ?3<5 := 45<1<1:8<166<05?3<5:=75361J3<1:8:A5C5732 457 <05 3A37? @3?5 DG <05 71D;836 <05 34456638< B631@38<1258<1<65?=:7:86G*%I:=<05 58038B5?B:@45823<1:8 524:8?58<
: ' 82;738B5 :@438G 12 ?175B<5? <: ?54:21< <05 3=:75231? B:@45823<1:8 3@:;8<A1<01821HA55F2=7:@<05?3<5:=75B514< :=B57<1=15?B:4G:=<012>;?9@58<
*1 $&
12<
:$6
:-