Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54333 (KAR)
SNJEEVKUMAR v. THE DIVISIONAL MANAGER THE UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. LTD., AND ORS
RP/200015/2024 · 2026-01-13
R Nataraj
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54333 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54333 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!! %&
'& %& (
%&
%&
%& )
'
&
! "#$%
! ! &"
'
(
%
! ! "!)
""
"
! #$%*%
"
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
! ! *
! ! ) ! ! $
! +
! ! ! ""
! ,
! !! !! ! ! "
#%*
-
! #$%* &"
' !. %/
%*%*
" (
"
! %%
0 ! %
" "
**0* "
**,** ' ( !! "
"" ! " ! . - 3 -
('
&
! "#$%
! ! &" '
(
%
! ! "!)
""
! "
! #$%*%
"
! ""
+ ! "" ! ! ! ! "
#%* &" ' !. %/
%*%*
" (
"
! %% 0 ! %
" "
**0*
"
*%%** ' ( !! "
"" ! " ! . - 4 -
'
&
! "#$%
! ! " '
(
%
! ! "!)
""
! "
! #$%*%
"
+
! ! !! ! ! "
#%*
-
! #$%*%
"
' !. %/
%*%*
" (
"
! %% 0 ! %
" "
**0*
"
*%%** ' ( !! "
"" ! " ! . - 5 -
'
&
! "#$%
! ! "
'
(
%
! ! "!)
""
! "
! #$%*%
"
! ! ! " ! !! ! ! "
#%*
"
' !. %/
%*%*
"(
- 6 -
"
! %% 0 ! %
" "
**0*
"
** $** ' ( !! "
"" ! " ! . )'
&
! "#$%
! ! "
'
(
%
! ! "!)
""
! "
! #$%*%
"
+
"
! ! !! ! ! "
#%*
! - 7 -
! #$%*
"
' !. %/
%*%*
" (
"
! %% 0 ! %
" "
**0*
"
*%%** ' ( !! "
"" ! " ! . "
1!
234353673893:7:7;<4=53>7?3@433A7<B536738;>:23 CD@BE3<: @=:3@ **0* 9=443@ 7<
;4**,** ** $** *%%** *%%**=<@*%%**
2353673893:7:7;<357<=??:234393:7:7;<474:23 ;8<35 ;> :23 ;>>3<@7<B 6327F?3 827F2 8=4 7<6;?63@ 7< = 5;=@:5=>>7F=FF7@3<: ;FFD553@;< %%%*%0 274 ;D5: =>:35<;:7F7<B:23@3>3<F3;>:237<4D535:2=::23@57635;>
- 8 -
:23;>>3<@7<B6327F?3@7@<;:9;443446=?7@@5767<B?7F3<F3 :; @5763 = 2=G=5@;D4 6327F?3 =<@ :=A7<B <;:3 ;> :23 =H43<F3 ;> :23 ;8<35 7< :23 95;F33@7<B4 23?@ :2=: :23 ;8<35 2=@ <;: :=A3< 4D>>7F73<: F=53 HI 3<:5D4:7<B = 2=G=5@;D46327F?3:;=9354;<82;8=4<;:=D:2;57G3@:; @57637:=<@2=@:2353HI67;?=:3@:23:35E4=<@F;<@7:7;<4 ;>:237<4D5=<F39;?7FI2353>;53:274;D5:@753F:3@:23 7<4D535:;9=I=<@53F;635:23F;E93<4=:7;<
23 536738 93:7:7;<35 2=4 <;8 >7?3@ :2343 93:7:7;<4 F;<:3<@7<B :2=: 7< ;4**$$* =<@ **$0*827F2=5;43;D:;>F?=7E93:7:7;<4>5;E:23 4=E3 =FF7@3<: :23 76747;< 3<F2 ;> :274 ;D5: 2=@ 935D43@ :23 @5767<B ?7F3<F3 =<@ 2=@ 23?@ :2=: :23 @57635 9;443443@ = 6=?7@ @5767<B ?7F3<F3 : 74 :2353>;53 95=I3@ :2=::23CD@BE3<:9=443@7<:23=H;63=993=?47<4;>=5=4 7:53?=:34:;@753F:7<B:237<4D535:;9=I=<@53F;635>5;E :23;8<35;>:236327F?3H3E;@7>73@
23?3=5<3@F;D<43?>;5:2393:7:7;<35537:35=:3@ :23 =H;63 F;<:3<:7;<4 =<@ 4DHE7::3@ :2=: 7< 6738 ;> :23
- 9 -
>7<@7<B =?53=@I 53F;5@3@ HI :23 76747;< 3<F2 ;> :274 ;D5::2=::237<4D53574?7=H?3:;9=I:23F;E93<4=:7;<=4 :23@57635;>:236327F?39;443443@6=?7@@5767<B?7F3<F3=4 ;<:23@=:3;>:23=FF7@3<::23CD@BE3<:49=443@7<
;4**,** ** $** *%%** *%%** =<@ *%%** H3 5367383@ =<@ E;@7>73@
23 ?3=5<3@ F;D<43? >;5 :23 7<4D535 @;34 <;:
@749D:3 :2=: :23 76747;< 3<F2 ;> :274 ;D5: 827?3 F;<47@357<B ;4**$$*=<@**$0*2=@ 23?@:2=::237<4D53574?7=H?3:;9=I:23F;E93<4=:7;<=4 :23@57635;>:236327F?39;443443@6=?7@@5767<B?7F3<F3
< 6738 ;> :23 =H;63 :23 CD@BE3<: @=:3@ **0* 9=443@ HI :274 ;D5: 7<
;4**,** ** $** *%%** *%%** =<@ *%%** =53 E;@7>73@ =<@ :23 7<4D535 74 @753F:3@ :; 9=I :23 F;E93<4=:7;< @3:35E7<3@ :23537< 274 74 2;83635 4DHC3F: :; 9=IE3<: ;> F;4: ;> 4%*****9=I=H?3HI:2393:7:7;<3523537<:;:237B2
- 10 -
;D5: !3B=? 3567F34 ;EE7::33 =?=HD5=B7 3<F2 =?=HD5=B787:27<;<3833A>5;E:;@=I
!74:;<%** >;5F;E9?7=<F3
*' +!, ! ! !74:;%?;%