- 1 - !""# $%& & % '!(')*+!( ' * , ! " # $! " $ #% Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $ #& " $! # ' ( $ ) *$$ *$$ ' ( ) * # *( ) * (!) ! & & * * ** () () () ! %& * & * * + * ,-./ * ! 0 - 3 - 0 1 $ 23456/3/3,7348396:-7:6.6;/3,7#,8 & <= /26 56/3/3,76.4 >;;-46: ,4 /, " 8,. ?.>7/ ,8 >7/3;35>/,.=<>39 37 .3@6 ,& & :>/6: "& .6?34/6.6:<=6A>.>355>.>?3,93;63B>=>5-.>8,./26 ,8867;645-7342><96-7:6.6;/3,74()()() >7:. C6;/3,7%&,8 & 26 8>;/->9 @>/.3D ,8 /26 ;>46 34 /2>/ /26 @>..3>?6 ,8 ;,@59>37>7/.>/23@> >7: 56/3/3,76. , >;;-46: , C>4 4,96@73E6: 37 /26 =6>. & >7: 56/3/3,76.,4/,>.6/268>@39=@6@<6.4,856/3/3,76. , >7: /26= C6.6 ;,.:3>9 8,. 4,@6 /3@6 -<46F-67/9= 26.2-4<>7:>7:56/3/3,76.,4/,"4/>./6:/,2>.>44/26 ;,@59>37>7/<,/252=43;>99=>7:@67/>99=/34/26456;383; ;>46,8/26;,@59>37>7//2>/,7&>/><,-/0&& 5@ /26 56/3/3,76.4 2>A6 >44>-9/6: 26. ,-/.>?6: 26. @,:64/= >7: ?>A6 9386 /2.6>/ *-./26. /26= 8,.;3<9= 47>/;26:26.?,9:;2>37<=:6@>7:37?>::3/3,7>9:,C.=,8 - 4 - 4&&&&& 4 4-;2 :-6 /, 37/,96.><96 52=43;>9 >7: @67/>9 2>.>44@67/ 426 C67/ /, 26. 5>.67/>9 2,@6 >7: >:@3//6:/, /26 ,A6.7@67/ ,453/>9 >/ 6A>.>355>.>?3 8,. 83.4/ >3: 26.6>8/6. ,7 "& 426 9,:?6: /26 ;,@59>37/ >?>374/ /26 56/3/3,76.4 <68,.6 /26 .645,7:67/ ,93;6 7 /26 4/.67?/2 ,8 /26 4>3: ;,@59>37/ /26 .645,7:67/,93;6 .6?34/6.6: /26 ;>46 37 .3@6 , & & 8,./26>8,.6@67/3,76: ,8867;64A6.437;6 /26 .6?34/.>/3,7,8*/26.645,7:67/,93;6>.6@>G37?26;/3; >//6@5//,>..64//2656/3/3,76.444-;2,7>55.626743,7 ,8>..64//2656/3/3,76.4>55.,>;26:::934/.3;/>7: 6443,74-:?63B>=>5-.>8,.?.>7/,8>7/3;35>/,.=<>3937 .9 34;,""# & C23;2 C>4 .6B6;/6: A3:6 ,.:6. :>/6:"&&67;6/23456/3/3,7 6>.: 96>.76: ;,-7469 8,. /26 56/3/3,76.4 >7: 96>.76: 3?2 ,-./ ,A6.7@67/ 96>:6. 8,. /26 .645,7:67//>/6 - 5 - # 6>.76: ;,-7469 8,. /26 56/3/3,76.4 .63/6.>/6: /26>A6.@67/4@>:637/2656/3/3,7>7:5.>=4/,>99,C/26 56/3/3,7 96>.76: 3?2 ,-./ ,A6.7@67/ 96>:6.,55,46:/26<>3956/3/3,7>7:5.>=4/,:34@344/26 4>@6 2>A6?3A67@=>7D3,-4;,743:6.>/3,7<,/2,7 /264-<@3443,74@>:6<=96>.76:;,-74698,./26.6456;/3A6 5>./364>7:/26:,;-@67/4>A>39><96,7.6;,.: " 4 ;,-9: <6 ?>/26.6: 8.,@ .6;,.:4 /26 56/3/3,76.4>.67,76,/26./2>7/262-4<>7:>7:379>C4,8 /26 ;,@59>37>7/.>/23@> 2,-?2 /26 ;,@59>37>7/ >7: 56/3/3,76.,@>..36:37/26=6>.&426C>4.643:37? ;,.:3>99= >9,7? C3/2 56/3/3,76.4 -6 /, /26 @>/.3@,73>9 :345-/6/265.6467/;,@59>37/349,:?6:,7"&37 .6456;/ ,8 /2637;3:67/:>/6: & 756.-4>9 /26 ;,@59>37/ >A6.@67/4 .6A6>9 /2>/ ,79= 4,@6 ,@73<-4 >996?>/3,74 2>A6 <667 @>:6 >?>374/ /26 56/3/3,76.4 26.68,.6 /26 ;-4/,:3>9 37;>.;6.>/3,7 ,8 /26 56/3/3,76.4 - 6 - :,647,/;>998,.74-;2;3.;-@4/>7;64C3/2,-/6D5.64437? >7=,5373,7,7/26@6.3/4,8/26;>464-883;6/,2,9:/2>/ /2656/3/3,76.4 >;;-46:,4/,">.667/3/96:8,.?.>7/,8 >7/3;35>/,.=<>39 26.3@37>96/3/3,734 % 26 .645,7:67/,93;6 >.6 :3.6;/6: /, .696>46 /26 56/3/3,76.4 >;;-46: ,4 /, " 37 /26 6A67/ ,8 /263. >..64/ 37 .3@6 ,& & :>/6: "& .6?34/6.6: <= 6A>.> 355>.>?3 ,93;6 3B>=>5-.> 8,. /26 ,8867;64 5-7342><96-7:6.6;/3,74()()()>7: . C 6;/3,7 %& ,8 & 4-<B6;/ /, /26 8,99,C37? ;,7:3/3,740 3 26 6/3/3,76.4 >;;-46: ,4 /, " 42>99 >556>. <68,.6 /26 7A64/3?>/37? 883;6. C3/237:>=48.,@/26:>/6,8.6;635/,8 /26;,5=,8/234,.:6.>7:42>996D6;-/6> 56.4,7>9<,7:8,.>4-@,84&&&&& (-5664 76 >G2 ,79=) 6>;2 C3/2 /C, 4-.6/3648,./2693G64-@/,/264>/348>;/3,7 ,8/2637A64/3?>/37?,883;6. - 7 - 33 6/3/3,76.4 42>99 .6?-9>.9= >556>. <68,.6 /26 .3>9 ,-./ C3/2,-/ 8>39 -79644 6D6@5/6: <= /26 .3>9 ,-./ 8,. A>93: .6>4,74 333 6/3/3,76.4 42>99 7,/ />@56. C3/2 /26 5.,46;-/3,7 C3/764464 >7: /26= 42>99 ;,,56.>/6C3/2/26,93;68,.37A64/3?>/3,7 >7: >556>. <68,.6 /26@ C2676A6. ;>996: -5,7 3A 2656/3/3,76.442>997,/37A,9A63743@39>. ,8867;64378-/-.6 -+ '& * & 34/,09,0