- 1 - ! "# "#$ !! %!& ' ! " " # $ % &'!(! )" Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ) ) *') + "(!" ) ) ) ("(,"("( ) )) ) ) - - $# - ! ./ 0/1/20324 52 6+ "(!" 7/168/ 4./ 9/382/0 /2568 5:59 ;0</ 320 ) ;00/75.39 =./2>/1684. 8/1/88/0 3? @8539 6;84AB .3? >.399/2</0 3 C;0<D/24 320 0/>8// 034/0 ("(,"("( E3??/0 4./8/52 7FG.5>.4./?;54168E38454562G3?0/>8//052E38432054 G3?./904.34E93524511?G/8//24549/046!" "+4.320, "+4. ?.38/524./?;54E86E/845/? " ./E3845/??.399./2>/1684.7/8/1/88/03?E/8 4./58832H7/168/4./85396;84168>62:/25/2>/ - 3 - , ./ E93524511? 159/0 3 ?;54 52 6+ "(!" 7/168/ 4./ 8539 6;84 168 E38454562 320 ?/E3834/ E6??/??562614./58?.38/524./?;54?>./0;9/E86E/845/? % ./?;54E86E/845/?38/;8:/F6!!! "( !#! D/3?;852< 3>8/? ,( <;243? 320 ;8:/F 6!% ! !# D/3?;852<3>8/?<;243?613<;85993</;00/75.39 39;H 2/ 305G393EE3 3459 G3? E86E6?54;? 61 4./ 13D59F / .30 4G6 G5:/? 23D/0 32<3DD3 320 //93DD3 //93DD3 5? E93524511 6! 320 4./ E93524511 6"5?./803;<.4/8264./803;<.4/861E935245116!5? 305G393DD3G.605/0376;4!"F/38?E8568464./034/ 6115952<61?;54./0/1/203245??6261305G393EE33459 4.86;<..5?158?4G51/32<3DD314/80/34.61.5?158?4 G51/305G393EE33459D3885/04./E935245116!320186D 4./?350G/096>H4./E935245116"G3?7682./E86E/84F 7/3852< ;8:/F 6!!! G3? >;945:34/0 7F 305G393EE3 3459 3? 3 4/2324 / 05/0 52 4./ F/38 !*+( 14/8 .5? 0/34. 4./ 0/1/20324 G3? >;945:3452< 4./ 9320 3? 4/2324 ./ 6>>;E32>F 85<.4 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F G3? - 4 - <8324/07F4./ 320857;239;00/75.395213:6;8614./ 0/1/20324320.5?C;2568;2>9/3./73<6;03320D;434562 G3? /11/>4/0 3>>68052<9F 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F ./E86E/84F7/3852<;8:/F6!% !5?13D59FE86E/84F 61 305G393EE3 320 314/8 .5? 0/34. 4./ 0/1/20324 320 3./73<6;03 4./ C;2568 ;2>9/ 61 4./ 0/1/20324 ?;>>//0/0 46 4./ ?350 E86E/84F 2 4./ F/38 !**' 4./ 0/1/20324 320 3./73<6;03 05:50/0 4./ 376:/ ?350 E86E/845/? ? E/8 4./ ?350 E38454562 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? G/8/ 399644/0 46 4./ ?.38/ 61 0/1/20324 ./ E93524511? >935D/0 4.34 4./F G/8/ 264 3G38/ 61 4./ E38454562 320 ./2>/4./8/G3?26I;/?4562614./F<5:52<;E4./5885<.4? 52 4./ ?350 E86E/845/? ./ E86E/84F 7/3852< ;8:/F 6!% ! !# 5? ?54;34/0 30C3>/24 46 4./ :5993</ 320 4./ 0/1/20324.3?7//2?/9952<E964? 524./?3509320G54.6;4 4./ H26G9/0</ 61 E93524511? 2 4./ F/38 "(!( 4./ 0/1/20324 674352/0 ?5<234;8/? 61 E93524511? 3<8//52< 46 >62?48;>4 3 .6;?/ 168 4./ E93524511? 52 4./ ?350 E86E/84F ;4 4./ 0/1/20324 .3? 264 <8324/0 32F ?.38/ 46 4./ - 5 - E93524511? 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 268 <64 >62?48;>4/0 4./ .6;?/./8/168/4./E93524511?159/04./?;54>935D52<4.34 4./F38//24549/0168! ,80?.38/524./?;54E86E/845/?320 4./FE83F/01680/>8//52<4./?;54 ./ 0/1/20324 3EE/38/0 52 4./ ?;54 7/168/ 4./ 85396;844.86;<..5?>6;2?/9320159/0G8544/2?434/D/24 0/2F52< 4./ >624/24562? 61 4./ E93524511? 6G/:/8 54 5? 30D544/04.3432<3DD3G3?4./9/<399FG/00/0G51/61 305:393EE33204.86;<.4./58G/096>H4./0/1/20324G3? 7682 ;4 54 5? 0/25/0 4.34 4./ 305G393EE3 D3885/0 E93524511 6! 320 4.34 4./ E93524511 6" 5? 9/<545D34/ 03;<.4/861305G393EE345?>624/20/04.340;852<4./ 951/ 45D/ 61 32<3DD3 305G393EE3 >3D/ 52 599/<39 8/934562?.5EG54.4./E935245116!3206;461?;>.599/<39 8/934562?.5E 4./ E93524511 6" G3? 7682 ./8/ G3? 26 D38853</ 7/4G//2 E93524511 6! 320 305G393EE3 ./ E93524511 6! 5? 264 9/<399F G/00/0 G51/ 61 305G393EE3 320 ./2>/ 4./ E93524511? .3:/ 264 ?;>>//0/0 46 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? ./ E935245116" 7/52< 599/<545D34/03;<.4/8 - 6 - 61 305G393EE3 5? 264 /24549/0 46 32F ?.38/ 52 4./ 32>/?4839E86E/845/?45?30D544/04.34305G393EE3G3? >;945:3452< 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852< 6!!! 3? 4/2324 6G/:/8 314/8 4./ 0/D5?/ 61 305G393EE3 4./ 23D/ 61 4./0/1/203243962<G54..5?;2>9/3./73<6;035?85<.49F D;434/0 52 8/:/2;/ 8/>680? 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F 4 5? 32>/?4839E86E/84F614./0/1/203243962/./0/1/20324 5?4./629F9/<39./5861305G393EE3./8/G3?E38454562 7/4G//24./0/1/20324320.5?;2>9/524./F/38!**'320 524./?350E384545624./?;54E86E/845/?1/99464./?.38/61 4./ 0/1/20324 ./ E93524511? G/8/ 3G38/ 61 4./ ?350 E38454562 7;4 4./F 050 264 >.66?/ 46 159/ ?;54 G54.52 !" F/38?186D4./034/61E38454562524./F/38!**'3203? ?;>.4./?;545?7388/07F95D543456245?0/25/04.344./ 0/1/20324 674352/0 ?5<234;8/? 61 4./ E93524511? 62 4./ E8/4/J4 4.34 ./ G6;90 </4 4./ .6;?/ >62?48;>4/0 52 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852< 6!% ./8/ G3? 26 >3;?/ 61 3>4562168 4./?;54 ./?;5461 4./ E93524511? 5? 139?/ 320 - 7 - 4./8/168/ 4./ 0/1/20324 E83F/0 168 05?D5??39 61 4./ ?;54 G54.>6?4 ' 2 4./ 73?5? 61 4./ E9/3052<? 61 764. 4./ E3845/?4./85396;84183D/04./16996G52<5??;/?32032 30054562395??;/ K !" # $# % & ' - 8 - ( L ) + 2 ?;EE684 61 4./ >3?/ 61 E93524511? 4./F G/8/ /J3D52/0 3? ! 320 " 8/?E/>45:/9F 320 E860;>/0 06>;D/24? 34 J?! 46 !% 6G/:/8 4./ /:50/2>/ 61 ! G3? 05?>380/0 2 4./ 64./8 .320 4./ 0/1/20324 G3? /J3D52/0 3? ! 7;4 ./ 050 264 E860;>/ 32F 06>;D/2438F/:50/2>/62.5?7/.391 14/8./3852<4./38<;D/24?61764.4./E3845/? 32062>62?50/852<4./683932006>;D/2438F/:50/2>/62 8/>680 4./8539 6;8432?G/8/0 5??;/? 6! " 320% 52 4./ 31158D345:/ 320 4./ 3005456239 5??;/ 52 4./ 2/<345:/ 3200/>8//04./?;5461E93524511?<832452<?.38/?464./D * /52< 3<<85/:/0 7F 4./ 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24 3200/>8//4./0/1/20324.3?>6D/;EG54.4./E8/?/24 3EE/3962?/:/839<86;20?;8</0524./3EE/39320E83F/0 - 9 - 168?/4452<3?50/4./5DE;<2/0C;0<D/243200/>8//320 4./8/7F4605?D5??4./?;54 !( /380 38<;D/24? 61 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9 168 764. 4./ E3845/? /8;?/0 4./ 6839 320 06>;D/2438F /:50/2>/ 62 8/>680 ./ 629F E6524 168 >62?50/834562 52 4.5? 3EE/39 5? KG./4./8 4./8/ G3? ?;115>5/24 /:50/2>/ 7/168/4./85396;84460/>8//4./?;54168E38454562ML !! ?E/84./>3?/61E93524511?305G393EE33459 5? 4./ E86E6?54;? 61 4./ 13D59F 320 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852< F6!% ! 5? E86E/84F 61 4./ 13D59F 61 305G393EE3 ./ E86E/84F 7/3852< ;8:/F 6!!! G3? >;945:34/0 7F 305G393EE3 3? 4/2324 320 314/8 .5? 0/34. 52 4./ F/38 !*+( 4./ 0/1/20324 G3? >;945:3452< 4./ 9320 3? 4/2324 ./ 6>>;E32>F 85<.4 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F G3? >621/88/0 62 4./ 0/1/20324 320 .5? C;2568 ;2>9/ 3./73<6;03 7F 4./ 320 857;239 ;00/75.39 320 D;434562G3?/11/>4/03>>68052<9F./8/5?37?69;4/9F26 05?E;4/ 8/<38052< 4./ 13>4 4.34 4./ E86E/84F 685<52399F 7/962</046 305G393EE3 4 5? 39?6 264 05?E;4/0 7F4./ - 10 - 0/1/20324 4.34 4./ E86E/84F 7/3852< F6!!! G3? <8324/0 52 13:6;8 61 4./ 0/1/20324 320 .5? C;2568 ;2>9/ 3./7<6;03 7F 4./ 320 857;239 320 4.34 /3895/8 305G393EE3 G3? 4/2324 52 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 E86E/84F ./ 629F >624/24562 61 4./ 0/1/20324 5? 4.34 4./ E93524511 6! 5? 264 4./ G51/ 61 305G393EE3 320 ./2>/ 4./ E93524511? 38/ 264 /24549/0 46 ?.38/ 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/84F 6G/:/84./13>44.344./E935245116"G3?134./8/07F 305G393EE34.86;<.E935245116!5?2645205?E;4/ !" ./ E93524511 6! G3? /J3D52/0 3? ! ;4 ?;7?/I;/249F ./8 /:50/2>/ G3? 05?>380/0 ./ E93524511 6"G3?/J3D52/03?"320?./8/54/834/04./13>4?3? ?434/0 52 4./ E93524 ./ E93524511 6" D38H/0 " J483>4?%J483>4?!J483>40/34.>/84515>34/61 305G393EE30/34.>/84515>34/6132<3DD34./D64./8 61 0/1/20324 ?>.669 >/84515>34/ 61 4./ E93524511 6" 3JD5735 0/34. >/84515>34/ 61 305G393EE3 3>H26G9/0</D/24 8/<38052< .66D5 EE95>34562 38305 320>6EF612645>/52)68D"!8/<38052<>.32</61$.343 - 11 - 3? E/8 J?! 46 !% ./8/ G3? 37?69;4/9F 26 >6248305>4562 /J483>4/0 7F 4./ 0/1/20324 52 4./ >86??& /J3D523456261"46D3H/./8/:50/2>/2647/95/:379/ !, 68/6:/83??;7D544/07F4./9/382/0>6;2?/9 168 4./ E93524511? 54 5? :/8F E/8452/24 46 264/ 4.34 4./ 0/1/20324 G.6 G3? /J3D52/0 3? ! 52 .5? >86??& /J3D5234562.300/E6?/04.34.5?134./8305G393EE305/0 524./F/38!*+(320.5?D64./805/0524./F/38!*'%4 5? 48;/ 4.34 52 4./ >.5/1&/J3D5234562 61 ! ./ .30 0/25/0 4.34 314/8 4./ 0/34. 61 32<3DD3 305G393EE3 >62483>4/03?/>620D38853</G54.4./E935245116!/ 39?6 0/25/0 4.34 4./ E93524511 6! G3? 4./ G51/ 61 305G393EE3;43?E6524/06;47F4./9/382/0>6;2?/9 1684./E93524511?4./06>;D/2434J!(G6;90?.6G4.34 4./ E93524511 6" G3? 7682 62 !'!(!*' 314/8 4./ 0/34. 61 32<3DD3 4./ 158?4 G51/ 61 305G393EE3 320 376;4 " F/38? E8568 46 4./ 0/34. 61 305G393EE3 62 !'(!*+(3?E/84./0/34.>/84515>34/34J45?264 343994./>3?/610/1/203244.344./E935245116!.3032F - 12 - 8/934562?.5E G54. 305G393EE3 /3895/8 46 4./ 0/34. 61 32<3DD34./158?4G51/61305G393EE3 !% ? ?;7D544/0 7F 4./ 9/382/0 >6;2?/9 168 4./ E93524511? 4./ /:50/2>/ 61 0/1/20324 3? ! G6;90?.6G 4.34./.3030D544/04./>3?/61E93524511?./8/9/:324 E684562524.//:50/2>/52>86??&/J3D523456261!8/30? 4.;? “ !"# $% &'() % *'+,-." $%&'&/0") $% !1/2/ 3"4 56 7 '+ -#)7 8-# *'+, $% &'&/0") !/# $% ! 9 : ;'+ < ' = <>: ?@2 /<'A = % 16/) % 1/! 9<>:<'A = 3"4 @2 / / 6!BC/ / !#)DE4@F& 4!GH!"6/ 1 I!J K$L'$L / 6!BC/ /!#)M - 13 - NO ! 9 <>: % 3"4 !# / !# O ! 9 <>: 3"4 $% &'&6) !1/2 / ! /PB 60/0#/ I# % '/' "C 3"4 ! '& &Q/0" )3"4 !'&&Q/ 3"4 -#) 3"4 8 -# 7 ! '& &Q/0" ) /R % B'+6S'## "T 7U 'VL 3"4 ! '& &Q/ ) O $% 1Q B'+6S'# '$L/0" /!#)O O '$L/0" )!DE( WO O B'+6S'# 7U 'VL 3"4 ! '& &Q/0" / &) X / ?/ 3"4 !'&&Q/0" )M ! );84./8 54 5? E/8452/24 46 264/ 4.34 4./ 0/1/20324 3? ! 52 .5? >86??&/J3D5234562 .30 >9/389F 0/E6?/0 4.34 .5? ;2>9/ 3./73<6;03 <64 $.343 61 F6!!! >.32</0 46 4./ 23D/ 61 ! 320 52 4./ 23D/?614./E93524511?3203./73<6;03./06>;D/24 34 J, 5? 4./ ;434562 J483>4 61 F6!!! 320 52 - 14 - 8/?E/>4 61 4./ ?350 06>;D/24 4./ 0/1/20324 E9/30/0 5<26832>/ 6G/:/8 ./ 30D544/0 4.34 52 4./ 52 8/?E/>461;8:/F6!%4./8/5?D/24562614./23D/? 61 E93524511? 320 23D/ 61 .5? ;2>9/ 3./73<6;03 3962< G54. .5? 23D/ / .3? 1;84./8 0/E6?/0 4.34 ./ 050 264 43H/32F?4/E?46</44./23D/614./E93524511?8/D6:/0 186D4./ !' 68/6:/8!0/E6?/04.344./E935245116! ;?/046:5?54.5?.6;?/3204./E935245116!;?/046?43F 52.5?.6;?/168376;4%4603F?;44./0/1/203243? !.3??434/04.34./050264/2I;58/4./E935245116! 3?46G./4./8?./.30D3885/0.5?134./8305G393EE368 264/2>/4.//:50/2>/1684.>6D52<186D4./0/1/20324 >6;E9/0 G54. 4./ 06>;D/24? E860;>/0 7F 4./ E93524511? G6;90?.6G4.344./?;54E86E/845/?38/4./E86E/845/?61 305G393EE33204./E93524511?6!320"7/52<G51/320 03;<.4/83204./8/168/4./F38//24549/046?.38/524./ ?;54 E86E/845/? 3962< G54. 4./ 0/1/20324 ./8/168/ 4./ 85396;84.3?264>6DD544/032F/8868520/>8//52<4./ - 15 - ?;54 159/0 7F 4./ E93524511? ;20/8 5DE;<2/0 C;0<D/24 320 0/>8// !+ >38/1;9>62?50/834562614./8/3?6252<614./ 8539 6;84 G6;90 ?.6G 4.34 54 .3? >62?50/8/0 6839 320 06>;D/2438F /:50/2>/ 62 8/>680 52 E86E/8 E/8?E/>45:/ 32085<.49F0/>8//04./?;54614./E93524511?<832452<?.38/ 46 4./D 52 4./ ?;54 E86E/845/? /2>/ 4./ E6524 168 >62?50/834562183D/07F;?5?32?G/8/03>>68052<9F ! 14./8/5?32F5??;/8/<38052<4./I;324;D61 ?.38/ 4./ E93524511? 38/ 34 957/84F 46 E;4 1684. 4./58 >624/24562 1680/4/8D523456261 ?.38/?/:/234 4./?43</ 61)5239/>8//86>//052<?24./8/?;94G/38/614./ >62?50/8/0:5/G4.344./0/1/20324.3?1359/046D3H/6;4 32F<86;2046524/81/8/G54.4./5DE;<2/0C;0<D/24320 0/>8//614./85396;843204./8/168/4./3EE/395?95379/ 467/05?D5??/0 !* >>68052<9FG/E86>//046E3??4./16996G52< - 16 - 5 .5? 3EE/39 159/0 7F 4./ 3EE/99324 0/1/203245?05?D5??/0 55 62?/I;/249F 4./ C;0<D/24 320 0/>8// 034/0 ("(,"("( 61 4./ 9/382/0/25685:59;0</320) ;00/75.39526+ "(!"?4320? >62158D/0 555 24./>58>;D?432>/?764.4./E3845/? ?.3997/384./586G2>6?4? ./ 8539 6;84 />680? ?.399 7/ 8/4;82/0 1684.G54. 3962<G54.>6EF614.5?C;0<D/24 () %& () %$& 5?46!96+