- 1 - !!" #$% % &$ ' ! " ! # ! ! !$! % !& ' ! " !!$# Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! $ ( )$$ $ ! # $$! ! ! " )# ! "!# # * ! " )#$ $$! )"#"+#$ !$! &$ ! " $ ! ! # " ,# ! ! ! $ $ !! ! "!# " ,%# ! $ - - . % % /01 23404056 01 70839 :693; ;40<831 ( =69 ) 57 4/3 561404:4056 57 690= 45 >:=1/ 4/3 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 4/3 234040563; =<<:13906285;;5 =;0106?5:457;0@3 5 ;3?0143;39+A5B=A:B4=!580<3=8=+:;=?075;4/3 57736<3 2:601/=+83 :693; 13<4056 )"#"+# 57 !;3C364056 57 5;;:24056 <4 & " @369@364 # "75;1/5;4 D4/3 ! <4E# 236906? 56 4/3 7083 57 !;8 014;0<4 =69 3110561 5:;4 =8=+:;=?0 - 3 - /3 =+;09?39 7=<41 57 4/3 <=13 =;3 4/3 <5@28=06=64 ;312569364 5 01 4/3 3<;34=;A 57 5/=6 =F= 9:<=4056=8 61404:4056 /3 1=09 61404:4056 01 ;:6606? :693; 5<034A 75; :;=8 =69 ;+=6 3C3852@364 <4056 =8=+:;=?0 /06?1145594/:1065;93;45?;=644/31402369454/314:93641 57 7;5@ 4/3 5<0=8 387=;3 32=;4@364 4/3 234040563; =<<:13933;31/ =90?3; :139 45 C3;07A =69 28=<3 4/3 ;3<5;91 +375;3 4/3 /0?/3; =:4/5;04031 75; 901+:;13@364 57 1402369454/3 =6B=<<5:641574/314:93641 <<5;906?8A4/3 140236975;4/3A3=;&G=11=6<405639=44/=440@34/3 234040563; 93@=6939 1 0883?=8 ?;=4070<=4056 7;5@ 4G5 14:9364175;901+:;13@364574/30;1402369 ' 6 =4 =+5:4 - 2@ ;312569364 5 C010439 4/3 5770<3 57 4/3 234040563; +A 1G04</06? 56 4/3 C50<3;3<5;93; 06 /01 @5+083 2/563 =69 @34 4/3234040563; 4 4/=440@34/3234040563;93@=69391 7;5@;312569364 55G3C3;/3G04/=6=11:;=6<3572=A@364574/31=@3 8374 4/3 5770<3 =69 859?39 4/3 <5@28=064 +375;3 ;312569364 5!580<3 =856? G04/ 4/3 C50<3 ;3<5;93; 56 /3 1=@3 G=1 ;3?0143;39 06 ;0@3 5 =?=0614 4/3 - 4 - 234040563; 75; 4/3 57736<3 2:601/=+83 :693; 3<4056 )"#"+# 57 ! <4 /3;3=743; 56 ;312569364 5!580<3 <569:<439 364;:14@364 2=6</=6=@= =69 4/3;3=743; <569:<439 4/3 4;=2 2;5<33906?1 56 4/3 1=@3 9=A 1:<<3117:88A =69 ;3<5C3;39 4=06439 @563A 57 1 =4 4/3 0614=6<3 57 234040563;=69<=:?/4/589/0@!:;1:=648A5B=A:B4=5770<0=81 G=1/39 4/3 /=691 57 =<<:139 G/0</ 4:;639 0645 206B <585; G/0</ 36C01=?39 4/=4=<<:139 /=9 =<<32439 4/3+;0+3 =@5:64 =1 23; /01 93@=69 /3;3=743; ;312569364 5!580<3 9;=G6 2=6</=6=@= =69 =;;31439 4/3 234040563; =69 2;59:<39 /0@ +375;3 4/3 83=;639 23<0=8 %:9?3 =69 4/3;3+A 1364 /0@ 45 F:90<0=8 <:1459A 743; <5@283406? 06C3140?=4056 ;312569364 5!580<3 8=09 </=;?3 1/334 =?=0614 /0@ 75; 4/3 =75;3@3640563957736<3 ??;03C39+A4/31=@34/3234040563; 01+375;34/015:;445>:=1/4/32;5<33906?1=?=0614/0@ 3=;983=;639<5:613875;4/3234040563;=6983=;639 23<0=8<5:613875;;3125693645 2=;4 7;5@ :;?06? 13C3;=8 <5643640561 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 234040563; <56436939 4/=4 56 23;:1=8 57 4/3 </=;?31/334@=43;0=816557736<3/=1+336@=935:4=?=0614 - 5 - 4/3 234040563; :693; 3<4056 )"=# 57 4/3 ! <4 106<3 4/3 2;513<:4056 7=0839 45 28=<3 @=43;0=81 45 2;5C3 4/3 06?;3903641574/357736<303"=#93@=69"+#=<<324=6<3=69 "<#G5;B364;:14@3645;G5;B236906? <<5;906?45/0@=465 25064 57 40@3 4/3 234040563; /=1 93@=6939 4/3 0883?=8 ?;=4070<=4056 =69 4/3 <56C3;1=4056 =883?398A ;3<5;939 +A ;312569364595654901<85131:</<56C3;1=4056=114=43906 4/3 4;=2 @=/=H=; +A 4/3 6C3140?=4056 770<3; =69 4/3 2=6</ G04631131 ( 3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/=4 4/3 4=06439 @563A G=1 =883?398A;3<5C3;397;5@4/34=+83574/3234040563;/5:?/4/3 /=691 57 234040563; G3;3 G=1/39 G04/ 590:@ +0<=;+56=43 158:40564/31=@39096544:;60645206B<585;$:;4/3;4/3;3 G=1 65 G5;B 57 ;312569364 5 364;:1439 45 4/3 234040563; 9:;06?4;=2=694/3;3<5;91G3;3130H397;5@=90773;3645770<3 6 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3 4/3 2;513<:4056 :443;8A 7=0839 45 28=<3 @=43;0=81 45 2;5C3 4/3 93@=69 =<<324=6<3 =69 G5;B236936<A+A4/3234040563; ) 3 7:;4/3; <56436939 4/=4 06 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 4/3 36>:0;A ;325;4 1:+@04439 +A 4/3 - 6 - 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 3I563;=439 4/3 234040563; 7;5@ 4/3 </=;?3183C3839=?=0614/0@ 61:</ <0;<:@14=6<3+A;38A06? 56 4/3 F:9?@364 57 4/3 56J+83 23I 5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57 ;325;439 06 !"!" #$% &'& /3 1:+@041 4/=4 4/3 14=69=;9 57 2;557 06 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?101@:<//0?/3;4/=6932=;4@364=82;5<33906?1=69 4/3932=;4@364=82;5<33906?10413873I563;=439<56406:=405657 <;0@06=82;5<33906?1=?=06144/3234040563;01654/06?+:4=+:13 572;5<311575:;4 <<5;906?8A/32;=A145=885G4/323404056 83=;639 23<0=8 <5:6138 75; ;312569364 55B=A:B4=<564369394/=40401134483925104056578=G+A 4/015:;4=694/356J+83 23I5:;406<=436=57F:9?@3641 4/=4 3I563;=4056 57 93806>:364 5C3;6@364 3@285A33 06 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 <=6654 +A 041387 7:;601/ = ?;5:69 45 >:=1/ 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 3C36 07 +54/ 4/3 2;5<33906?1=;375:6939564/31=@3134577=<41 <<5;906?45 /0@064/30614=64<=13=884/3G04631131/=C31:225;439064/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 =69 06 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3 =1/389+A4/356J+83 23I5:;4064/3<=1357( ) - 7 - * + () , #%-#%...&"/...&.0!"!1" 06 = <=13 G/3;3 4/3 G04631131 4:;639 /514083 +375;3 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 4/5:?/ 4/3 =<<:139 01 3I563;=439 4/3 <;0@06=8 </=;?31 <=6654 +3 >:=1/39 /3 3I563;=4056 06 4/3 32=;4@364=86>:0;A2;5<33906?19531654 7:;601/= ?;5:69 75; 9;52206? <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 @5;3 2=;40<:8=;8A 06 4;=2<=1315G3C3;064/30614=64<=13=884/3G04631131/=C3 1:225;439 06 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A2;5<33906?1 =694/3;3 01 3C3;A 25110+0804A 57 4/3@ 1:225;406? 06 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 6 1:</ <0;<:@14=6<3 /3 2;=A1 45 901@011 4/3 23404056 & /=C3?0C36@A=6I05:1<561093;=4056+54/564/3 1:+@0110561 @=93 +A 4/3 83=;639 <5:6138 75; 4/3 ;3123<40C3 2=;4031=694/395<:@3641@=93=C=08=+83+375;34/015:;4 6 23;:1=8 57 4/3 <5@28=064 =69 </=;?3 1/334 @=43;0=810401654069012:434/=44/3234040563;3I563;=43906 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 9312043 =88 4/3 G04631131 /=C3 1:225;439 4 01 =815 654 06 9012:43 4/3 - 8 - G04631131064/332=;4@364=86>:0;A2;5<33906?1=;3=8154/3 G04631131064/3<;0@06=82;5<33906?1 4 01 1344839 25104056 57 8=G +A 4/3 56J+83 23I 5:;4064/3<=13572 3* ) 4 ;325;43906!"..#'%56.4/=44/3 =9F:90<=4056 2;5<33906?1 =69 4/3 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1 =;3 06932369364066=4:;3453=</54/3;=694/3706906?=?=06144/3 23;1567=<06?2;513<:4056064/3=9F:90<=40562;5<33906?101654 +06906? 56 4/3 2;5<33906?1 75; <;0@06=8 2;513<:4056 6 4/3 0614=64 <=13 106<3 =88 4/3 G04631131 /=C3 1:225;439 06 4/3 32=;4@364=8 6>:0;A 2;5<33906?1 >:=1/06? 57 <;0@06=8 2;5<33906?19531654=;0134/5:?/4/3234040563;3I563;=43906 4/332=;4@364=82;5<33906?1 /3 56J+83 23I 5:;4 06 4/3 <=13 57 7 ( , #%-.""860!"!' .!88&0!"!' /389 4/=4 06 = <=13 ;3?0143;39 :693; 4/3 123<0=814=4:4303! <4>:=1/06?574/357736<31:693;4/3 1=09=<4G5:89/=C3=?;=C3=691:+14=640=80@2=<4654F:1456 4/32=;403106C58C39+:4=815564/315<034A=48=;?3 - 9 - ' $:;4/3;4/356.+83 23I5:;406<=1357 9 ) *3 ;325;439 06 #!""5% .' 51" /389 06 2=;=?;=2/ 51 =69 & =1 75885G1- 6 ! " # $ " #! % $ &' !# &' # $ &' % " $ $ $ !# % ( ! # ! # $ # # ! $ !) # ! * # $ # ! ! % +, , # , + & !# ! !# ' - ! - 10 - #" % ! $ ! % $ " $ $ % $ % * # % $ % # $ " $ $ % # % " $ % , ! . $ ,! ! # % - $ , - ! $ , $ / ! # ! 00 * $# $ ! # # , ! $ $ $ ! ! $ ! ! !#! ) - 11 - # $ $ ## ! ! $ # 1 $ ! ! % ,! ! ! & 2 3 4 # 50667 89: ;!$ &4' # < *"; &06=' 0' " $ ! ! $$ # $ $ # ! $ , " $ $ $ - ! ! $ " ! # ! # ! ! , $ # $ $ ,! ! & 2 4/ # ; >506697== < # *"; &066=' 896 ; 4 <%% # > ! ? 5066:7 = 06 > #1> *"; &0666' 09 @ # 1 - 12 - 5066=7 A A9: ; >#B ><5066A7 86A # > # &?# ( 4 *"; &066=' 68 ;% <%% # ( 4 5066678:6' 0 " $ # ! ! $ ! / $ - ! % $ # ! ! $ $ ! ! ! C # $ # , # # ! " 4& '#3D1 50667880A $ # $ , $ # $ $ $ $ $ # $ ! # +& ' - 13 - $ $# E$ / $ $ ! ! $ $ # F 64/30614=64<=13=1901<:11391:2;=4/32;0@=;A 06?;3903641574/357736<32:601/=+83:693;3<4056)"#"+#57 ! <401@=935:4+A4/32;513<:4056=694/31=@3/=145+3 43143906=934=08394;0=8/015:;4<=6654<569:<4=@0604;0=8 =44/0114=?345/5894/=4G/34/3;4/3=<<:1=4056@=93=?=0614 4/3234040563;G0882;5C35;6546=63640;323;:1=857</=;?3 1/334@=43;0=81=@574/3C03G4/=4<56406:=405657<;0@06=8 2;5<33906?1=?=06144/3234040563;G088654=@5:6445=+:1357 2;5<311575:;4 <<5;906?8A2;5<339452=114/375885G06?- /3;04!3404056013 *+ &% ' % 0145-85-