- 1 - !" "## $ !"#$ % & & !"#'" & !"#$ ' # !"#$ % & ( & ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & #)' & & * &' !$)'$'# '$' ' & && #'# $ $" & #+, & '$ & & - - . " /0+1223140+5043617108+99/31:;<09914=<67>38921++36 0823:0141+3 ? '$'61936!$)'$'#@A9/3 66090?8140+9B0:91863++0?8+C23:014<6730=1A12<B1 ,/3B3@A 9/3 431B836 23:014 <673 1:;<09936 9/3 1::<+36 5?B 9/3?5538:32<80+/1@43<863B3:90?8#'# $ $"?5 186 3:90?8 #+, ?5 C B3D3890?8 ?5 9B?:09A >386>389:9'$ ' /3 51:9<14 >19B0E ?5 9/3 2B?+3:<90?8 :1+3 0+ 9/19 ?8$ $!'$'191@?<9$$2>085B?89?5 /1@1?5 :?>24108189+09<1936190F?91?,89/31::<+360893890?8144A 08+<49369/3:?>24108189@A1@<+087/3B085049/A4187<173186 14+?>3890?8087/3B:1+931869B0369??<9B173/3B>?63+9A+ - 3 - +<:/ +/3 4?6736 9/3 :?>241089 ?8 '"$!'$' @35?B3 9/3 B3+2?863892?40:31+23BE 89/3+9B3879/?5E & :1>39?@3B370+93B3608B0>3?'G '$'61936'"$!'$' 1+ 23B E/0@09 ! 17108+9 9/3 1::<+36 5?B 9/3 15?B3+106 ?5538:3+ <@+3;<3894A 9/3 ++0+9189 ?>>0++0?83B ?5 ?40:308D3+90719369/3:1+31864106:/1B73+/33917108+99/3 1::<+3603B3+2?863895?B9/315?B3>3890?836?5538:3+ # 593B91F087:?780H18:3?59/3?5538:39/331B836 23:014<6735B1>369/3:/1B73+17108+99/31::<+365?B9/3 ?5538:3 2<80+/1@43 <863B 3:90?8+ #' # $ $" ?5 186 3:90?8 #+, ?5 C B3D3890?8 ?5 9B?:09A >386>389 :9 '$ ? 2B?D3 9/3 :/1B73+ 43D34436 17108+9 9/31::<+369/32B?+3:<90?8089?9143E1>0836",0983++3+1+ +9? "1867?9>1BF36!6?:<>389+1+E+ 9? ! 186 0638905036 ?83 >193B014 ?@=3:9 1+ 8 1++3++>389 ?5 9/3 ?B14 186 6?:<>3891BA 3D0638:3 9/3 9B014 ?<B9 1:;<09936 9/3 1::<+36 5?B 9/3 :/1B73+ 43D34436 17108+9 /0> /3 +106 =<67>3890+:/14438736089/0+122314@A :?>24108189 31B6 9/3 431B836 :?<8+34 5?B 9/3 :?>24108189 122344189 186 431B836 07/ ?<B9 ?D3B8>389 - 4 - 43163B5?BB3+2?8638991931869/3431B836:?<8+3412231B087 5?B1::<+36 B3+2?86389?' 21B9 5B?> <B7087 +3D3B14 :?893890?8+ 431B836 :?<8+345?B9/3122344189 :?>241081892B0>1B04A:?89386369/19 9/3 =<67>389 <863B 9/0+ 122314 +<553B+ 5B?> 23BD3B+09A 186 044371409A +08:3 9/3 3++0?8+ <673 /1+ 510436 9? :?8+063B 9/3 3D0638:3 ?8 B3:?B6 08 1 B07/9 23B+23:90D3 3 14+? :?8938636 9/199/3B014<673/1+5104369?:?8+063B9/33D0638:3?59/3 08=<B36:?>24108189 18614+?9/33D0638:3?5 ',/?0+ 8?83?9/3B9/189/3+?8?5 3B<+14?59/30B3D0638:39/3 :/1B7317108+99/31::<+360+2B?D36@3A?86B31+?81@436?<@9 ++<://32B1A+9?144?,9/3122314@A:?8D0:90879/31::<+36 5?B9/3:/1B73+43D3443617108+9/0> " 3B :?89B1 431B836 :?<8+34 5?B 9/3 1::<+36 B3+2?86389 ?' +<@>09+ 9/19 9/3 431B836 3++0?8+ <673 1593B >390:<4?<+4A 3E1>08087 9/3 3D0638:3 1D1041@43 ?8 B3:?B6 21++36 1 ,344 B31+?836 =<67>389 ,/0:/ 6?3+ 8?9 :144 5?B18A0893B53B38:3199/3/186+?59/0+?<B9/3:?8938636 9/199/33D0638:3?5 7?3+;<093:?89B1BA9?9/3:?>241089 1D3B>389+1869/3B31B34?9?560+:B3218:A089/33D0638:3?5 - 5 - 186 ' 186 14+? 9/3 8D3+90719087 550:3B /3 :?>24108189 @A >0+<+087 9/3 2B?D0+0?8 <863B 3:90?8 23:014 :9 4?6736 +3D3B14 ?9/3B :?>241089+ 17108+9 +3D3B14 23B+?8+/32B3+389:?>2410890+14+??83?5+<:/:?>241089 /3+3 1+23:9+ ?5 9/3 >1993B ,3B3 63149 08 639104 @A 9/3 B014 ?<B9 186 1:;<09936 9/3 1::<+36 5?B 9/3 :/1B73+ 43D34436 17108+9/0>::?B60874A+/32B1A+9?60+>0++9/3122314 ) 31B83607/?<B9?D3B8>389 43163B12231B087 5?B 9/3 B3+2?86389 ?9193 +<22?B9+ 9/3 0>2<7836 =<67>389 ! /1D370D38>A18E0?<+:?8+063B190?8@?9/?8 9/3+<@>0++0?8>163@A9/3431B836:?<8+345?BB3+23:90D3 21B903+ 186 23B<+36 9/3 0>2<7836 =<67>389 +? 14+? 9/3 >193B0141D1041@43?8B3:?B6 G 8 :1B35<4 23B<+14 ?5 9/3 B3:?B6+ 09 :?<46 @3 719/3B36 9/19 1::?B6087 9? 9/3 :?>24108189 9/3 1443736 08:06389 ,1+ ?::<BB36 ?8 $ $!'$' 19 1@?<9 $$ 2> ?,3D3B9/3:?>241089,1+4?6736?8'"$!'$'/3B30+18 08?B6081936341A084?670879/3:?>2410891869/3:?>24108189 - 6 - /1+8?93E24108361@?<99/3B31+?85?B+<:/08?B6081936341A08 4?67087 9/3 :?>241089 4@309 ?8 23B<+14 ?5 9/3 :?>24108189 3D0638:3,/38+/3,1+08/3B6/1@19/31::<+361@<+36/3B @A>3890?8087/3B:1+9318614+?>163181993>299??<9B173 /3B >?63+9A @A 1++1<49087 /3B ::?B6087 9? /3B 6<3 9? 9/3 1++1<49+/3+<+910836@433608708=<B03+?8/3B/316?,3D3B +/3/1691F389B319>3895?B9/3+1>3?8$"$!'$'191@?<9 $1>@<99/3B30+8?+<:/6391045?B9/:?>087089/3B32?B9 E ",?<86 :3B9050:193 35?B3 9/3 ?:9?B 9/3 :?>24108189 /1+ 8?9 60+:4?+369/3 81>3 ?5 9/3 1::<+36 + 23B E " +/3 /1+7?9+,344087?89/3B07/9+063?5/3B51:3186B3683++089/3 :/3+9 186 8? 3E93B814 08=<BA ?,3D3B 08 9/3 3D0638:3 /1++919369/19+/3+<+910836@433608708=<B03+?8/3B5?B3/316 186 /3B :4?9/3+ ,3B3 14+? @4??6 +910836 &<B9/3B 1+ B07/94A :?8938936 @A 9/3 431B836 :?<8+34 5?B 9/3 B3+2?86389 ?' 9/3B3 1B3 +3B0?<+ 60+:B3218:03+ 08 9/3 3D0638:3 ?5 186 ' ,/? 0+ 8?83 ?9/3B 9/18 9/3 +?8 ?5 /3 ?9/3B 3A3,0983++9?9/308:06389 +'186#/1D39<B836/?+9043 9?9/32B?+3:<90?8:1+366090?8144A9/3+2?9218:/181>1/1+ 14+?8?92B?D36+08:39/3218:/,0983++3+/1D39<B836/?+9043 /0+1223140+17108+99/3=<67>389?51:;<09914186090++399436 - 7 - 2?+090?8 ?5 41, 9/19 08 :1+3 ?5 1:;<09914 05 9/3 9B014 ?<B9 /1+ 91F38 1 241<+0@43 D03, 9/3 22344193 ?<B9 ><+9 @3 +4?, 08 0893B53B087 ,09/ 9/3 1:;<09914 =<67>389 8 :1B35<4 +:B<908A 3890B3 3D0638:3 1D1041@43 ?8 B3:?B6 1> ?5 9/3 :?8+063B36 D03, 9/19 9/3 431B836 B014 ?<B9 /1+ 91F38 1 241<+0@43 D03, 186 21++36 9/3 0>2<7836 =<67>389 ,/0:/ 6?3+ 8?9 :144 5?B 0893B53B38:3@A9/0+?<B9 ::?B60874A 9/3 122314 41:F+ >3B09+ 186 9/3 +1>3 0+ %& ' ( 0+9?-4?-G