Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54309 (KAR)
MD.HAJI SAB (HAJI BABA) v. ISMAIL AND ANR
MFA/200700/2018 · 2026-01-20
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54309 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54309 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!"!#
$" %%
&'(
)
! "
#$%$&
'(
#$%$)"
!!(* ! )&)""
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
( ( "+," ( ! (
"+"))"+
( ! ! $
)" (
( ! -
"
" ./0122314/05/637835191/:088.3;<59=3:81:5 1>165 51835 "+"))"+ 210035 /: ! ?$ ?@ )"?:8.3@/43?@8.36/:7/214 3:/?6/A/4<5931:5 ./3@ <5/7/14 19/086183 /516 @?6 0.?68
>.363/: 7?=23:018/?: >10 1>16535 /: @1A?<6?@8.3741/=1:8
(?68.301B3?@7?:A3:/3:738.32168/300.144C3 63@366358?102368.3/661:B/:9C3@?638.36/C<:14 , .3 C6/3@ @1780 ?@ 8.3 7103 163 8.18 ?:
,))D)", 8.3 741/=1:8>1026?7335/:9 10 1 2/44/?:
- 3 -
6/536 ?: 1 =?8?67E743 C316/:9 639/08618/?: ? # ,%
#%D% ?:
/516F<=1:1C15 ?15 <3 8? 610. 1:5:394/93:86/5/:9?@8.301/5=?8?67E743/8510.35 191/:081C<@@14?1:5101630<48?@>./7.8.3741/=1:8 0<081/:3596/3A?<0 /:;<6/30996/3A35CE 8.3/:;<6/30 0<081/:358.3741/=1:8.10@/435!?$?@)" 033B/:97?=23:018/?:
: /00<1:73 ?@ :?8/73 6302?:53:8 ?F :0<61:73 ?=21:E 3:83635 1223161:73 1:5 @/435 /80 >6/883:08183=3:853:E/:98.31A36=3:80=153/:8.3 741/=238/8/?: $ : ?6536 8? 0<C081:8/183 8.3 741/= 8.3 741/=1:8 3G1=/:35./=034@10#"1:53G1=/:35.3?78?610 # 1:5 26?5<735 " 5?7<=3:80 >./7. >363 =16B3510G0#"8?#".36302?:53:805/5:?8 43151:E?614?65?7<=3:816E3A/53:73
- 4 -
& .3 6/C<:14 @61=35 1226?26/183 /00<30 @?6 7?:0/53618/?: 1:5 <2?: 122637/18/?: ?@ 8.3 3A/53:73 ?: 637?65 CE /80 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 51835
"+"))"+ 1>16535 1 8?814 7?=23:018/?: ?@ 0$)D&))
#>/8./:83630818&H2361::<=@6?=8.3 5183?@238/8/?:8/446314/I18/?:?8C3/:9018/0@/35>/8. 8.3 J<1:8<= ?@ 7?=23:018/?: 1>16535 8.3 741/=1:8 .10 263@36635 8.3 26303:8 122314 033B/:9 3:.1:73=3:8 + .1A3 .3165 6/ 1:8.?0. /61516 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 @?6 8.3 1223441:8 1:5 6/ ./A1:1:5 18/4 4316:35 7?<:034 122316/:9 @?6 8.3 6302?:53:8F:0<61:73 ?=21:E 1:5 236<035 8.3 637?650 % .34316:357?<:034@?68.31223441:87?:83:535 8.188.36/C<:14.107?==/88351:366?6/:100300/:9 8.3236=1:3:85/01C/4/8E18")H5302/83#F?78?6
- 5 -
.1A/:9 10030035 8.3 5/01C/4/8E 18 H 8? 8.3 >.?43 C?5E 8 /0 @<68.36 7?:83:535 8.18 8.3 7?=23:018/?: 1>16535<:536A16/?<0?8.36.3150/0/:153J<1831:5 63J</630 3:.1:73=3:8 77?65/:94E 0?<9.8 @?6 /:836@363:73?@8./07?<68 D 367?:8618.34316:357?<:034122316/:9@?68.3 6302?:53:8F:0<61:73 ?=21:E 0?<9.8 8? ;<08/@E 8.3 /=2<9:35 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 210035 CE 8.3 6/C<:14
") : 4/9.8 ?@ 8.3 0<C=/00/?:0 15A1:735 CE 8.3 4316:357?<:034@?68.32168/30/8/0:?8/:5/02<838.18 8.3 177/53:8 ?77<6635 ?: ,))D)", 1:5 8.18 8.3 741/=1:80<081/:3596/3A?<0/:;<6/30103A/53:735CE G0#1:5#&8/0140??:637?658.188.3741/=1:8 >10>?6B/:910110?:2?:7163@<47?:0/53618/?:?@ 8.3@/:5/:90637?6535CE8.36/C<:148./0?<68/0?@
- 6 -
8.3 ?2/:/?: 8.18 /:836@363:73 /0 714435 @?6 /: 8.3 26303:8122314
"" .3 6/C<:14 .10 1>16535 0+$)))
# 8?>1650 21/: 1:5 0<@@36/:9* 0"%,)))
# 8?>1650 =35/714 3G23:030 1:5 0%)))
# 8?>1650 ?00 ?@ 316:/:90 5<6/:941/5<2236/?5>./7.5?:?87144@?6/:836@363:73
" ?>3A36 7?:0/536/:9 8.3 :18<63 ?@ /:;<6/30 1:5 8.3 3A/53:73 ?@ ##7?8?6 8.3 7?=23:018/?: 1>165358?>1650236=1:3:85/01C/4/8E/0?:8.34?>36 0/53 77?65/:94E 8.3 741/=1:8 /0 3:8/8435 8? 7?=23:018/?: ?@ 0,$&))
# 0%)))G"G"%G)H 8?>1650 4?00 ?@ @<8<63 /:7?=3 CE 1224E/:9 8.3 =<48/24/36 ?@ "% /: 836=0 ?@ 8.3 ;<59=3:8 ?@ 8.3 ?:KC43 <263=3?<68/:8.37103?@
632?6835/:
- 7 -
", 1B/:9 /:8? 7?:0/53618/?: 8.3 :18<63 ?@ /:;<6/30 0<081/:35CE8.31223441:8
741/=1:88./0?<68533=0 /8 1226?26/183 8?
1>165 7?=23:018/?: <:536 5/@@363:8 .3150 77?65/:94E 8.3 J<1:8<= ?@ 7?=23:018/?: 63J</6308?C3631003003510@?44?>0 *+,- ./01 1/:1:50<@@36/:9 0+$)))
# ?00 ?@ 316:/:90 5<6/:9 41/5 <2 236/?5@?60/G=?:8.00%)))G& 0%)))
# ?00?@1=3:/8/30 0$))))
# ?00 ?@ @<8<63 ?@ 316:/:90 0%)))G"G"%G)H 0,$&))
# ?>1650 ?:A3E1:73 ?<6/0.=3:8 1:51883:51:87.169300))))
#
317. 0&))))
# /0@/9<63=3:8 0$)))
# 35/7143G23:030 0"%,)))
# ?814 300 7?=23:018/?: 1>16535 CE 8.3 6/C<:14 02+03*,3.4*0-+150 0+%&&))
# 0$)D&))
#
- ##6
- 8 -
" .<0 8.3 741/=1:8 /0 3:8/8435 3:.1:735 7?=23:018/?:?@- ##6>/8./:836308187 4*8 +00/. @6?= 8.3 5183 ?@ 238/8/?: 8/44 6314/I18/?: ?>3A36/:836=0?@8.3?653651835))")8.3 1223441:8/0:?83:8/8435@?6/:836308@?61236/?5?@,) 51E0
"$ 77?65/:94E8.3122314/0
.3 ;<59=3:8 1:5 1>165 210035 CE 8.3 6/C<:14 /0 =?5/@/358?8.33G83:8/:5/718351C?A3
,6 & (
"
/08?" 4?,