- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %&%'()& %( * !"#"$$% & ' !! !"#"$$% ' !"#"() & ' *' # ' + " ")) $)$, !! ((" $)$" ' ' ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - '' (#*()($#* ,($ " ' $)$ ' ' + - ./0123/3/45/06/7289582:2;3/45#46 $)$ <= 3.2 123/3/452: >;;9028 4" 64: ?:>53 46 <>/7 /5 :/@2 4((" $)$" 8>328 )$()$)$" :2?/032:28 <= 3.2 >55> A.277/ 47/;2 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450 (#*()($#*,($:2>8B/3.2;3/45"46 .>:>3/=> =>=> >5./3> $)$ C64: <:2D/3= E3.2 $)$FG B./;. /0 1:202537= 1258/5? 45 3.2 6/72 46 88/3/45>7 /03:/;3 >58 200/450 49:3 /8>: 0/33/5? >3 >0>D>A>7=>5/54")) $)$, $ .26>;39>7@>3:/H463.2;>02/03.>382;2>028 >5>1>3/ /5 3./0 ;>02 /0 3.2 =495?2: <:43.2: 46 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53!>:93/.282;2>028B>02@174=28>3123:47 <95A/5>55>A.277/D/77>?25)(()$)$".28/8543 ;4@234./0.49023/77@/85/?.3009;../0B/62>15> - 3 - ;>7728 ./@ 3.:49?. 1.452 >58 25I9/:28 >3 3.>3 3/@2 .2 :217/283.>3452>;./5>58 .>8:9 .>8:20.>;;9028 40( >58 $ .>8 I9>::2728 B/3. ./@ /5 3.2 123:47 <95A >58.2/01:4;228/5?34B>:80.>A3/.><>>745?B/3.452 >:>0>11>>58 ><964:8/552:>58>632:.>D/5?8/552:.2 B/77;4@2343.2.49024B2D2:.28/8543:239:5343.2 .4902 45 3.>3 8>= 5 3.2 52H3 8>= @4:5/5? /2 45 )$()$)$" 452 >@20. ;>7728 3.2 <:43.2: 46 82;2>028 >58/564:@283.>33.282>8<48=46./0<:43.2:B>07=/5? 45 3.2 :4>8 52>: /J>= 2;.>5/; ?>:>?2 0 09;. B/62 >5843.2:6>@/7=@2@<2:0463.282;2>028:90.28343.2 0143 >58 /8253/6/28 3.2 82>8 <48= 46 3.2 82;2>028 .2 82;2>028 .>8 0903>/528 /5J9:/20 45 ./0 12:045 0 09;. 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 748?28 3.2 ;4@17>/53 <264:2 3.2 :201458253 K 47/;2 B./;. B>0 :2?/032:28 /5 :/@2 4((" $)$" 8>328 )$()$)$" 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450 ()( :2>8 B/3. 2;3/45" 46 $)$>?>/503>;;902840(>58$9<02I92537= 3.2 :201458253 K 47/;2 >::20328 >;;9028 40( 34 45 - 4 - )$()$)$" >58 )()$)$" :2012;3/D27= <>028 45 3.2/: D47953>:= 03>32@253 3.2 123/3/452: >;;9028 4" B>0 >::20328 45)*()$)$" >58 /@17/;>328 ./@ /5 3.2 ;:/@2 .2:2>632: 3.2 :201458253 K 147/;2 ;4@172328 3.2 /5D203/?>3/45 >58 7>/8 ;.>:?2 0.223 >?>/503 6/D2 >;;9028 12:0450>::>/?5/5?3./0123/3/452:>0>;;90284"64:3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450 (#* ()( $# * ,($ :2>8 B/3. 2;3/45 " 46 $)$ 25;2 3.2123/3/452: >11:4>;.28 64:?:>53 46:2?97>: <>/7 <264:2 3.2 88/3/45>7 /03:/;3 >58 200/45 98?2 /8>: 0/33/5? >3 >0>D>A>7=>5/5:7/0;4"))$ $)$,.20>@2B>0 :2J2;328 D/82 4:82: 8>328 ()($)$, 25;2 3./0 123/3/45 2>:8 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: >58 72>:528/?.49:34D2:5@25372>82:64:3.2:201458253 !3>32 1>:3 6:4@ 9:?/5? 02D2:>7 ;453253/450 3.2 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: ;45325828 3.>3 3./0 - 5 - 123/3/452:B>0/@17/;>328/53.2>772?2846625;20<>02845 3.2 D47953>:= 03>32@253 46 >;;9028 40( 34 8@/33287=/53.2;4@17>/533.25>@2463./0123/3/452:/0 543 64:3.;4@/5? ;;4:8/5? 34 ./@ 3.2 ;.>:?2 0.223 >772?>3/450>704821/;33.>3>33.23/@246>772?28/5;/8253 3./0 123/3/452: 52/3.2: >00>97328 54: B>0 1:20253 >3 3.2 0;252464;;9::25;2.2>772?>3/450>?>/5033./0123/3/452: /0 3.>3 .2 >745? B/3. >;;9028 4 /503/?>328 >;;9028 40(3434;4@@/33.2@9:82:463.282;2>028509;. ;/:;9@03>5;2 69:3.2: ;90348/>7 /5;>:;2:>3/45 46 3.2 123/3/452:/0543;>772864:;;4:8/5?7=.21:>=034>774B 3.2123/3/45 " 72>:528 /?. 49:3 4D2:5@253 72>82: 4114028 3.2 <>/7 123/3/45 45 3.2 ?:4958 3.>3 ;.>:?20.223>D2:@2530821/;3> ;>02>?>/503 3.2 123/3/452: 3.>3 .2 >745? B/3. >;;9028 4 09117/28 3.2 B2>145 34 >;;9028 40( 34 >58 >704 @>82 ;4501/:>;= B/3. 43.2: >;;9028 34 84 >B>= 3.2 7/62 46 82;2>02825;2.21:>=0348/0@/003.2123/3/45 - 6 - , .>D2?/D25@=>5H/490;450/82:>3/45<43.45 3.2 09<@/00/45 @>82 <= 3.2 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/D2 1>:3/20 >58 12:90283.2 @>32:/>70>D>/7><72 45 :2;4:8 % 0 ;4978 <2 ?>3.2:28 6:4@ 3.2 :2;4:80 3.2 ;4@17>/53 748?28 <= 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 3.>3 45 )(()$)$" 3.282;2>028/564:@28./0B/623.>3>;;902840(>58$ I9>::2728 B/3. ./@ /5 3.2 123:47 <95A .2:2>632: .2 8/8 543:239:5.4@253.252H38>=@4:5/5?3.282>8<48= 46 3.2 82;2>028 B>0 64958 <= +!$, >58 3.2 0>@2 B>0 /564:@28343.2;4@17>/5>53/23.2<:43.2:4682;2>028 ;;4:8/5?7= ' ;>@2 34 <2 :2?/032:28 >?>/503 >;;9028 40( >58 $ 9<02I92537= >;;9028 40 ( 34 B2:2 >::20328 >58 <>028 45 3.2/: D47953>:= 03>32@253 3./0 123/3/452: B>0 /@17/;>328 /5 3.2 ;:/@2 .>:?2 0.223 >D2:@25308/0;74023.>3>;;9028409117/28B2>14534 >;;902840(3464:3.2;4@@/00/45463.2;:/@2.2 >772?>3/45>?>/5033./0123/3/452: /03.>3.2 ;4501/:28 >58 /503/?>328 >;;9028 40( 34 34 ;4@@/3 3.2 @9:82: 46 - 7 - 82;2>028 <= >;;4@1>5=/5? >;;9028 4 H;213 3.202 >772?>3/450 3.2:2 >:2 54 43.2: >772?>3/450 64:3.;4@/5? >?>/503 3./0 123/3/452: /5 3.2 ;.>:?2 0.223 64: 3.2 .4@/;/8>782>3.463.282;2>028509;.;/:;9@03>5;20 54B3.>33.2/5D203/?>3/45.>0<225;4@172328>58;.>:?2 0.223 .>0 <225 7>/8 <= 3.2 47/;2 >0 09;. 3.2 ;90348/>7 /5;>:;2:>3/45 46 3./0 123/3/452: /0 543 ;>7728 64: 25;2 B/3.4932H1:200/5?>5=41/5/45453.2@2:/30463.2;>02 0966/;2 34 .478 3.>3 3.2 123/3/452: >;;9028 4" 8202:D20 34<2257>:?2845<>/7 # ;;4:8/5?7=3.2123/3/45/0 * .2 123/3/452: >;;9028 4" /0 8/:2;328 34 <2 257>:?2845<>/7/54")) $)$,>:/0/5?49346:/@2 4((" $)$" :2?/032:28 <= >55> A.277/ 47/;2 3>3/45 64:3.246625;20195/0.><729582:2;3/450(#*()( $# * ,($ :2>8 B/3. 2;3/45 " 46 $)$ 1258/5? 45 3.2 6/72 46 88/3/45>7 /03:/;3 >58 200/450 - 8 - 49:3 /8>: 0/33/5? >3 >0>D>A>7=>5 09<J2;3 34 3.2 64774B/5?;458/3/450 >23/3/452:0.>772H2;932>12:045>7<45864: >09@46 0())))) !B/3.3B409:23/2064: 3.2 7/A209@ 34 3.2 0>3/06>;3/45 46 3.2 J9:/08/;3/45>749:3L <.2123/3/452:0.>77>112>::2?97>:7=45>77 3.2 8>320 46 .2>:/5? <264:2 3.2 :/>7 49:3 9572003.2:/>749:32H2@130./0>112>:>5;2 64:D>7/8:2>0450L ; .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 543 8/:2;37= 4: /58/:2;37= 3.:2>325 4: 3>@12: B/3. 3.2 1:402;93/45B/3520020L 8 .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 543 /5D47D2 /5 0/@/7>: 46625;20/56939:2L 2 .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 543 72>D2 3.2 J9:/08/;3/45 46 3.2 :/>7 49:3 B/3.493 12:@/00/45 46 3.2 0>/8 49:3 953/7 3.2 ;>02 :2?/032:28>?>/503./@/08/014028466 6 .2 123/3/452: 0.>77 @>:A ./0 >33258>5;2 <264:2 3.2 3>3/45 4902 66/;2: >55> A.277/ 47/;2 3>3/45 45 6/:03 958>= 46 - 9 - 2D2:=@453.<23B225()))>@>58)()) 1@ 3/77 3.2 ;>02 :2?/032:28 >?>/503 ./@ /0 8/014028466<264:23.2:/>749:3 +) %!( ! + /034(74,