Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54298 (KAR)
M/S SWASTIK CONSULTANCY SERVICES v. M/S MENMENTOR FACILITIES PRIVATE LIMITED
WA/200041/2026 · 2026-02-05
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54298 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54298 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$%%
#$% %&
""
'$(
! "
# $
"
%
&
"
"
""
&'( '
" &
)*
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
+,-./0,-123445+46+4678398+ $%*))' (
'
:
&(
:
&(
(
:
&(
""
"
:
&(
$
%
# $
"&$%;
"'(%
- 3 -
" (
"
&*)&
' <'''
'&'')
"
" / /
=
=
%$ $/
=
%
2-1 -673, 8>37 ,??4,. >6@43 497-86 ( 8A 724
,36,7,B, -C2 8>37 97 &*)& -1 A-.4@ 92,..46C-6C 724 98334976411 8A ,6 -6743-+ 83@43 @,74@ '&'') ?,114@ DE 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 -6 3-7 47-7-86 8' <''' ' $-% 3-4A.E 17,74@ 724 A,971 8A 724 9,14 72,7 ,34 34.4F,67A83724?>3?8148A9861-@43-6C72-1G3-7,??4,.,34 72,7 341?86@467
8' 2,@ -6F-74@ D-@1 A83 1>??.E 8A +,6?8G4324,??4..,67,6@341?86@467
8&G434,A4G 8A724D-@@43124D-@1>D+-774@DE341?86@467
8&G,1 ?>3?8374@.E3404974@G2-92G,192,..46C4@DE341?86@467
- 4 -
8& D4A834 724 ,??4..,74 ,>7283-7E >6@43 497-86 &) 8A 724 ,36,7,B, 3,61?,3469E -6 >D.-9 389>34+4671 97 &***24,??4..,74,>7283-7E3404974@724,??4,.A-.4@DE 341?86@467
8& G2-92 G,1 7246 92,..46C4@ D4A834 72-1 8>37-63-747-7-86
8' <''' $--% 24,??4..,672434-6G,1,33,E4@,1341?86@467 8( -6 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86 ,6@ -7 467434@ ,??4,3,694 86 &&''' ,6@ 86 & &'') 7-+4 G,1 C-F46 A83 724 ,??4..,67 78 34F437 G-72 724 17,74+467 8A 8D0497-861 24 G3-7?47-7-86G,172434,A743.-174@86'&''),6@,C,-6 ,@08>364@86'&&'')24,??4..,672434-6,??,3467.E @-@ 687 A-.4 -71 17,74+467 8A 8D0497-861 ,6@ 9867-6>4@ 78 ?>12 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86 2434A834 G246 724 +,7743 G,1 .-174@ 86 '&'') 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 ?,114@ ,6 83@43G2-9234,@1,1A8..8G1/
!"#$
%& ! '(%
" )
)
(
- 5 -
% )
! %&
)
*
(
'
) %
+
"
) & $
(
%
( ( %
+&
" (
%
"
" )
%
""
&
,
"
-
4-6C,CC3-4F4@DE7241,-@83@43724,??4..,67 -1D4A83472-18>37 ( 4,364@98>614.
A83 724,??4..,67 1>D+-7172,7 724 ,??4..,67 G,1 C3,674@ 724 746@43 ,6@ , G83B 83@43 G,1 -11>4@ 86 ' &'''( ,6@ 7246 ,6 ,C344+467 9867,-6-6C743+1784H49>7472498673,97G,1467434@-678 86 &&'' 4 986746@1 72,7 724 ,??4..,67 2,1 D446 ?38F-@-6C +,6?8G43 143F-941 A38+ 7246 ,6@ 72,7 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 98>.@ 687 2,F4 >?147 724 143F-941 ?38F-@4@ DE C3,67-6C ,6 -6743-+ 83@43 4 ,.18 986746@1 72,7 724 -+?>C64@ 83@43 -6 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86 -1 E47 78 D4 74174@,6@-6724+4,6G2-.4724.4,364@-6C.4>@C42,1
- 6 -
,..8G4@ 724 341?86@467
8& 78 ?38F-@4 724 143F-941 4 986746@1 72,7 72-1 G8>.@ F-37>,..E C3,67 724 D464A-7 78 341?86@467
8&4F46D4A834724.4,364@-6C.4>@C42,1 9861-@434@7249,1486+43-714,.18986746@172,7724 98673,97 743+ -1 7G8 E4,31 ,6@ 72,7 724 ,??4..,67 2,1 ,.34,@E 98+?.474@ 864 E4,3 ,6@ 72,7 724 83@43 8A 724 .4,364@-6C.4>@C42,198+4,1,D.8G78724,??4..,67 ,6@ 724 98614I>4694 G8>.@ D4 72,7 724 +,6?8G43 @4?>74@ DE 724 ,??4..,67 G8>.@ D4 G-72@3,G6 DE 341?86@467 8' 4 72434A834 986746@1 72,7 724 -+?>C64@83@43?,114@DE724.4,364@-6C.4>@C4D4147 ,76,>C27,6@724?,37-41D4@-34974@78,??4,3D4A834724 .4,364@-6C.4>@C4A83,6,@0>@-9,7-8686+43-71
43 98673, 724 .4,364@ 98>614. A83 341?86@467 8&1>D+-7172,7724D-@1>D+-774@DE724,??4..,67-714.A G,1 @4A497-F4 ,6@ 98>.@ 687 2,F4 D446 ,994?74@ 4 986746@172,7724.4,364@-6C.4>@C42,1F43-A-4@72414 A,971 ,6@ 2,1 98+4 78 724 9869.>1-86 72,7 J (
)
- 7 -
! %K 4 72434A834 986746@1 72,7 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 ?,114@ ,6 83@43 @46E-6C 724 D464A-78A724746@43C-F4678724,??4..,67472434A834 1>D+-7172,772434-16843383-672483@43?,114@DE724 .4,364@-6C.4>@C44A>37243986746@172,7728>C2724 ,??4..,67 G,1 687-A-4@ 8A 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86 -7 G,1 687 4,36417-6@4A46@-6C724G3-7?47-7-86DEA-.-6C,17,74+467 8A 8D0497-861 6 724 98673,3E 724 ,??4..,67 B4?7 86 ?>12-6C7249,14,6@72434DE@34GD464A-7A38+724@4.,E 4 72434A834 986746@1 72,7 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 2,@ 68 87243 8?7-86 72,6 78 17,E 724 83@43 ?,114@ DE 341?86@467
8'@-1+-11-6C724,??4,.A-.4@DE341?86@467 8& ,6@ ,.18 4673>17 724 98673,97 G83B 78 341?86@467 8& ,1 , 178? C,? ,33,6C4+467 4 72434A834 986746@1 72,772434-16872-6C-..4C,.,D8>772483@43?,114@DE724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 ,6@ 72434A834 24 ?3,E1 72,7 724 ,??4,.D4@-1+-114@
- 8 -
) 4 2,F4 9861-@434@ 724 1>D+-11-861 +,@4 DE 724 .4,364@ 98>614. A83 724 ,??4..,67 ,1 G4.. ,1 724 .4,364@98>614.A83341?86@467
8& < ?43>1,.8A724-+?>C64@83@43128G172,7724 .4,364@-6C.4>@C4D,14@86,?3-+,A,9-48?-6-8624.@ 72,7 724 ,??4..,67 12,.. 687 D4 ?43+-774@ 78 4608E 724 D464A-78A724746@43C-F46DE341?86@467
8'2434-624 ,??4..,67G,1,.34,@EC-F46,G83B83@43A8..8G4@DE724 4H49>7-86 8A ,6 ,C344+467 ,6@ -7 2,1 D446 ?38F-@-6C 143F-94178341?86@467
8'1-694&&''41?86@467 8& G2814 746@43 G,1 ?>3?8374@.E 3404974@ 92,..46C4@ 724 1,+4 D4A834 724 ,??4..,74 ,>7283-7E G28 ,.18 @-1+-114@ 724 ,??4,.
,6@ 724 1,+4 -1 92,..46C4@ D4A834 724.4,364@-6C.4>@C42434A8344F46D4A83472483@43 340497-6C 724 D-@ 1>D+-774@ DE 341?86@467
8& G,1 9861-@434@ 86 +43-71 724 746@43 98>.@ 687 2,F4 D446 C-F4678341?86@467
8&4F46,1,6,@289,33,6C4+467 2-1 G8>.@ F-37>,..E ,+8>67 78 ?340>@C-6C 724 -11>4 ,6@ C3,67-6C , D464A-7 78 341?86@467
8& G2-92 87243G-14
- 9 -
+>172,F4D446C3,674@86.E,A743724@-1?81,.8A724G3-7 ?47-7-86
6 72,7 F-4G 8A 724 +,7743 G4 9861-@43 -7 ,??38?3-,74 78 147 ,1-@4 724 83@43 ?,114@ DE 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 ,6@ 78 34I>417 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 78 @-1?8148A724G3-7?47-7-86,14,3.E,1?811-D.4 * 9983@-6C.E72-1G3-7,??4,.-1,6@724 -6743-+ 83@43 ?,114@ DE 724 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 @,74@ '&'') -1 147 ,1-@4 24 .4,364@ -6C.4 >@C4 -1 34I>4174@ 78 4H?4@-74 724 9861-@43,7-86 8A 724 G3-7 ?47-7-861-69472498673,97743+-186.EA83,?43-8@8A7G8 E4,3198++469-6CA38+&&'' 683@43784H?4@-74 724 @-1?81,. 8A 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86 724 ,??4..,67 2434-6 -1 @-34974@78,??4,3D4A834724.4,364@-6C.4>@C4,6@A-.4 , 17,74+467 8A 8D0497-861 -A ,6E 24 ,??4..,67 -1 ,.18 @-34974@68778144B,6E>6649411,3E,@08>36+46714-1 @-34974@ 78 988?43,74 -6 724 4,3.E @-1?81,. 8A 724 G3-7 ?47-7-86G-728>7144B-6CA83,@08>3+4671
- 10 -
& ..9867467-861,34B4?78?46 && 3- +3412
80, .4,364@ 98>614. -1 ?43+-774@78A-.4+4+88A,??4,3,694G-72-6,?43-8@8A& @,E1A38+78@,E
)* '%( %
)* ' %& ( %
-17
8/&. 8/&(