- 1 - !" "## $% &$'#()&*+$( , !" # $ % &'' &'' '(! # $ % & ") $% & & )!(! & !(! &$ % $ % !( * & & Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - & + + ,' )-" -./011203./4.526724080.9/77-2:;48<297=>6=9?.67.=9 40724 )!(! 094 =5425 => /2972962 40724 !(! 10//24 .9 126.03 0/2 $ % = ! @A 7-2 3205924 44.7.=903 2//.=9/ ;482 * & $ % 07 .:0A01;50 $-252.90>725 52>25524 7= 0/ B3205924 126.03 ;482C% D-252@A 7-2 3205924 126.03 ;482 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425 267.=9/ " 094 ")) => 094 /29729624-.<7=;94258=5.8=5=;/.<15./=9<297>=5125.=4=> 7D= A205/ 094 7= 10A 0 >.92 => /(!!!! .9 42>0;37 7= ;94258=/.<132.<15./=9<297>=50125.=4=>=92<=97->=57-2 =>>2962 1;9./-0@32 ;9425 267.=9 " => &;57-25 -2 ./ /29729624 7= ;94258= 5.8=5=;/ .<15./=9<297 >=5 0 125.=4 => 7D=A205/ 094 7= 10A 0 >.92 => /(!!!! .9 42>0;37 7= ;94258=/.<132.<15./=9<297>=50125.=4=>=92<=97->=57-2 =>>29621;9./-0@32;9425267.=9"))=>7./03/=4.526724 7-07@=7-7-2/2972962/.963;4.989=910A<297=>>.92/-0335;9 6=96;552973A - 3 - -20@5.4824>067/=>7-215=/26;7.=960/20527-07 )?.67.< 094 7-2 011233097066;/24 @23=98/ 7= 98040825. .33082-2011233097D2977==07=2E2=;7-./3.?23.-==4094 -2 ;/24 7=?./.7 -./ ?.33082 =660/.=9033A ;5.98 /;6- 7.<2 -2 D0/D23306F;0.9724D.7-?.67.<)094-22G152//24-./3=?2 7= -25 094 03/= .97294/ 7= <055A -25 66=54.983A =9 !"!H!(070@=;7!(+"!1<7-20112330977==E7-2?.67.< )>5=<7-230D>;36;/7=4A=>-25105297//(094>5=< 98040825.?.330827=2D094.9205;92094/70A247=827-25 >=50125.=4=>"40A/97-2<209D-.32=9! !H!(7-2 >07-25=>?.67.<(3=482406=<130.97@2>=527-252/1=94297 =3.62 0@=;7 <.//.98 => -./ 40;8-725 /126.>.6033A 080.9/7 066;/24 =/( 7= 03328.987-07 066;/24 =( -0/ E.4901124 -./ 40;8-725 07 7-2 .9/70962 => 066;/24 =/ 7= 0/ 125 G( " 9 7-2 /752987- => G( 7-2 52/1=94297=3.62 528./725247-260/2.95.<2=(H !(080.9/77-2011233097 094=7-25/>=57-2=>>2962/1;9./-0@32;9425267.=9/" "094 (!H5 D267.=9()H=>0/125G));@/2F;2973A) ?.67.< 094 066;/24 D252 750624 =9 !H!( 07 I05. 520 9205 .51=57 =04 07 =0 -2520>725 7-2 52/1=94297=3.62 - 4 - 526=5424 7-2 /7072<297 => 7-2 ?.67.< 094 .<13.60724 066;/24 =( 094 =7-25/ .9 7-2 0332824 65.<2 >725 6=94;67.98 .9?2/7.807.=9 7-2 52/1=94297=3.62 30.4 6-0582 /-227 080.9/7 7-2 066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425 267.=9/ " " " 094 (!H 5 D 267.=9 ()H => 094 267.=9 $3% 5 D 267.=9/ 094(=> 67 ) = 15=?2 7-2 6-0582/ 32?2324 080.9/7 7-2 066;/24 7-215=/26;7.=9.97=7032G0<.924!D.792//2/0//(7=! 094 <05E24 ) 4=6;<297/ 0/ G/( 7= ) -2 066;/24 92.7-25 2G0<.924 09A D.792// =9 -./ @2-03> 9=5 <05E24 09A 4=6;<297/ >725 0 p. 2 <297 => =503 094 4=6;<29705A 2?.42962 7-2 3205924 126.03 ;482 6=9?.6724 7-2 066;/24 =(011233097>=57-2=>>2962/1;9./-0@32;9425267.=9/" 094 ")) => 094 /29729624 -.< 0/ /70724 /;150 -2 /0.4 :;48<297./6-03329824.97-./011203 205432059246=;9/23>=57-20112330970943205924 .8-=;57=?259<297320425>=552/1=942977072 - 5 - 1057 >5=< ;58.98 /2?2503 6=97297.=9/ 3205924 6=;9/23>=57-201123309715.<05.3A6=97297247-077-2:;48<297 ;9425 7-./ 011203 /;>>25/ >5=< 125?25/.7A 094 .332803.7A /.962 7-23205924126.03;482-0/>0.3247=011526.0727-22?.42962 .9 0 5.8-7 125/1267.?2 2 6=9729724 7-07 9=92 => 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 D.792//2/ /;11=5724 7-2 60/2 => 15=/26;7.=9 .963;4.98 7-2 ?.67.< D-= D0/ 2G0<.924 0/ ) 9 /;6- 6.56;</70962/7-23205924126.03;4826=9?.67247-2066;/24 @0/24=9/;5<./2/0946=9:267;52/203/=6=97294247-077-2 ?.67.</126.>.6033A429.24-25/7072<297/;9425( (094( )=> 5 2?257-232// 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 03/= >0.324 7= 15=?2 7-2 082=>7-2?.67.<7-07/-2D0/<.9=5077-27.<2=>.96.42979 /;6- 6.56;</70962 7-2 :;48<297 => 7-2 5.03 =;57 ./ 9=7 /;/70.90@32@=7-;942530D094=9>067/66=54.983A-2150A/ 7=033=D7-2011203 3205924.8-=;57=?259<297320425 6=9729424 7-07 7-2 320924 2//.=9/ ;482 0>725 <27.6;3=;/3A 2G0<.9.987-22?.42962=9526=546=9?.67247-2066;/24.90 D233 520/=90@32 :;48<297 D-.6- 4=2/ 9=7 6033 >=5 09A .9725>252962 2 6=9729424 7-07 .9 7-2 ( ) /7072<297 => 7-2 ?.67.< /-2 60728=5.6033A /70724 7-07 /-2 -04 3=?2 0>>0.5 D.7- - 6 - 066;/24=(094E9=D.98>;33A7-07/-2D0/<.9=5077-27.<2 =>.96.4297066;/24=(70E29-257=2D094.9205;92094 >5=<7-2527==0094-04/2G;03.97256=;5/2=9-259/;6- 6.56;</70962/7-23205924126.03;482-0/5.8-73A6=9?.6724 066;/24 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425 267.=9/ " 094 ")) => -=;8- ?.67.< 094 =7-25 D.792//2/ -0?2 9=7 /;11=5724 7-2 60/2 => 15=/26;7.=9 7-2 =;57 609 6=9?.67 7-2 066;/24 /.962 7-2 ?.67.< D0/ <.9=5 07 7-2 7.<2 => .96.4297 66=54.983A-2150A/7=4./<.//7-2011203 H 0?.98-20547-232059246=;9/23>=57-252/1267.?2 1057.2/094=9125;/03=> 7-2.<1;8924:;48<297/=03/=7-2 <0725.030?0.30@32=9526=547-2/=321=.977-07D=;3405./2>=5 <A6=9/.42507.=9./+ J-27-25 7-2 :;48<297 ;9425 7-./ 011203 /;>>25/ >5=< 125?25/.7A =5 .332803.7A 094 7-2 /0<2 52F;.52/09A.9725>252962@A7-./=;57KL (! 9 6052>;3 125;/03 => 7-2 2?.42962 094 7-2 4=6;<297/ 130624@2>=52 7-./ =;57 .7 ./ 9=7 4./1;72 7-07 7-2 ?.67.< 094 066;/24 =( @23=98/ 7= 7-2 /0<2 ?.33082 / 125 7-2 6=<130.97 0?25<297/ 07 G( .7 ./ /70724 @A (7-2 - 7 - >07-25=>?.67.<7-07066;/24=(03=98D.7-=7-25/E.4901124 -./ 40;8-725 =D2?25 4;5.98 7-2 6=;5/2 => 2?.42962 ( 7=7033A8.?2908=@A27=7-26=<130.970?25<297/094429.24 7-2/0<2-=;8-(D0/65=//2G0<.9240732987-@A7-2 15=/26;7.=99=7-.98D=57-D-.32-0/@22923.6.724>5=<-.<7= 523A-./6=<130.9707G( (( 2?257-232// 7-=;8- 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 2G0<.924 ?.67.<) D-252.9 /-2 -0/ 03/= /126.>.6033A 429.24 7-2 .96.4297094/707247-0792.7-25/-2066=<109.24066;/24=( 0/ /70724 .9 7-2 6=<130.97 9=5 7-2 066;/24 >=5624 -25 7= 066=<109A-.<7=2D094.9205;92=5=0=97-28;./2=> <055A.98-25-203/=/707247-07077-27.<2=>.96.4297/-2 -04@2297=-25;9632,/-=;/2094/70A247-252>=57-2520/=9 7-07 -25 105297/ D252 >=56.@3A.9/./7.98-25 7= 827 <055A -2 ?.67.< -0/ 03/= /126.>.6033A 429.24 7-2 /0<2 .9 -25 ( ) /7072<29744.7.=9033A7-2<=7-25=>?.67.<03/=7;5924 -=/7.32 7=7-2 60/2 => 15=/26;7.=9 9 /;6- 6.56;</70962/ 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 -0/ >0.324 7= 15=?2 7-2 6-0582/ 32?2324 080.9/7 066;/24>=57-2=>>2962/1;9./-0@32;9425267.=9/" =5")) =>-2520529=/;6-2?.429620?0.30@32=9526=542G6217 7-2 2?.42962 => 9?2/7.807.98 >>.625 094 7-2 =7-25 =>>.6.03 - 8 - D.792//2/ = 4=;@7 7-2 15=/26;7.=9 -0/ 130624 7-2 @.57- 6257.>.6072=>?.67.<0/125G")D-.6-421.67/7-077-2?.67.< D0/ 0824 0@=?2 ( A205/ =D2?25 D-29 7-2 ?25A .96.4297 .7/23> ./ 429.24 @A 7-2 ?.67.< 6=<130.9097 094 7-2 <=7-25 => ?.67.<<;6-652429626099=7@207706-247=7-208215==>=> ?.67.<D-297-22?.42962306E/7=6=99267066;/24=(.97-2 0332824.96.4297 65.<2 ( 7 ./ /277324 1=/.7.=9 => 30D 7-07 7-2 2?.42962 => =>>.6.03D.792//2/6099=7@24./605424=93A>=57-2520/=97-07 7-2A 052 7-2 =>>.6.03 D.792//2/ @;7 .9 7-2 /0<2 7.<2 7-2 =9C@3212G=;57.9 521=5724 .9 -2347-077-272/7.<=9A=>7-2=>>.6.03D.792//6099=7@2 4./605424 /=323A =9 7-2 @0/./ 7-07 7-2A 052 7-2 =>>.6.03 @;7 .9 7-2 /0<2 7.<2 D.7-=;7 7-252 @2.98 09A 6=55=@=507.=9 7-2 2?.42962=>7-2=>>.6.03D.792//6099=7@206724;1=9-2=;57 -0/ 7= 3==E .97= 6=55=@=507.?2 1.262 => 2?.42962 => =>>.6.03 D.792///.9627-252./01=//.@.3.7A=>>03/2.<13.607.=9 (" &;57-257=15=?27-26-058232?2324;9425267.=9 " =>7-2.98524.297/=>7-2=>>2962-0/7=@215=?24.2 - 9 - 066;/24 <;/7 E.4901 7-2 ?.67.< >5=< 7-2 30D>;3 8;054.09 080.9/7 -25 D.33 @A 6=<1233.98 -25 7= <055A 9 7-2 .9/7097 60/27-2?.67.<-25/23>-0//707247-077-2066;/24079=1=.97 => 7.<2 -04 >=5624 -25 7= 066=<109A -.< =5 .9/./724 -25 7= <055A -.< 9 /;6- 6.56;</70962/ 7-2 .98524.297/ => 267.=9 " =>4=2/9=70775067/.97-./60/2 () -2 =9C@32 12G =;57 .9 7-2 60/2 => ! "#521=5724.9$$%%&& -0/ <042 09 =@/25?07.=9 .9 52/1267 => <=503 6=9?.67.=9 7-07 D09425.98=9/75=98/;/1.6.=9./9=709=17.=97=426.42060/2 @A7-22//.=9/=;57094-234.910508501-=0/;9425+ & ! " # - 10 - $ % & % & ' ( 97-2.9/709760/203@2.77-252.//-=57=>2?.42962 7=15=?27-26-0582/32?2324080.9/7066;/24=(7-23205924 126.03 ;482 6=9?.6724 066;/24 =( 011233097 @0/24 =9 /;5<./2 094 6=9:267;52 9 <A 6=9/.42524 ?.2D 7-2 /0.4 6=9?.67.=9 =5425 6099=7 @2 /;/70.924 094 .9725>252962 ./ 52F;.524.97-2.<1;8924:;48<297=>6=9?.67.=9094=5425=> /2972962 66=54.983A 09/D25 1=.97 50./24 0@=?2 .9 7-2 0>>.5<07.?209415=62247=10//7-2>=33=D.98+ $.% -25.<.90311203./'' ( / $..% -2 :;48<297 => 6=9?.67.=9 40724 )!(! 094=5425=>/297296240724!(!10//24 .9 126.03 0/2 $ % = !( @A 7-2 3205924 44.7.=903 2//.=9/ ;482 * & $ %07.:0A01;50./-252@A/270/.42 - 11 - $...% =9/2F;2973A 7-2 011233097066;/24 =( ./ 06F;.7724 >=5 7-2 =>>2962/ 1;9./-0@32 ;9425 267.=9/" 094"))=> $.?% 0.3@=94=>7-2066;/240947-07=>-.//;527.2/ /-033/7094609623324 $?% -2 >.92 0<=;97 .> 09A 421=/.724 @A 066;/24 =( ./ =542524 7= @2 52>;9424 7= -.< =9 4;2 .4297.>.607.=90>725011203125.=4./=?25 28./75A 7= 4.526724 7= /294 @06E 7-2 03=98 D.7- 6257.>.24 6=1A => 7-./ :;48<297 7= 7-2 6=9625924 =;57 >=57-D.7- .) $( ./7=+(3=+( +