- 1 - ! " ## $% & Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ! "#$%&'( & ) *"#$#+' + "#$%' , "#%''' + ,- &! #, ! " +''.&', '% &''. ) ,''''' " - 3 - / 0 123 455647 23 82769 :; <16 =742>4?<3 =14776?@2?@ <16AB9@>6?<4?94C4D994<69+''.&',5433692? E'% E8 &''. E? <16 8276 E8 <16 6?2ED 2F27 B9@6 G 2?94@2 366H2?@ 6?14?=6>6?< E8 >4DH6<F47B6E8<1674?94=IB2D69:;<16D635E?96?<3 8ED31ED<J686D6?=6EBD</! & ED <16 34H6 E8 =E?F6?26?=6 <16 54D<263 2? <12345564731477:6D686DD69<E2?<6D>3E8<162D3<4<B3 4?9D4?H2?@:68ED6<16686D6?=6EBD< + 16 84=<B47>4<D2K E8 <16 =436 4D6 <14< <16 74?93:67E?@2?@<E<16=742>4?<3C6D64=IB2D698ED<16 5BD5E36E8=E?3<DB=<2E?E812>4 4<14 2D4F4D2!28< - 4 - DD2@4<2E? DEA6=< 4< 494?2 2774@6 2?94@2 47BH 2A45BD23<D2=< , 164=IB2D2?@4B<1ED2<;233B6945D672>2?4D; ?E<282=4<2E?B?96D 6=<2E?, !E8<164?9=IB232<2E? =<$(,E?.'&&''+164?9=IB232<2E?882=6D ! 543369 4 6?6D47 C4D9 94<69 &'#&''# 5B:723169 E? ,'.&''# 82K2?@ <16 >4DH6< F47B6 4< 3%''' "56D4=D68ED9D;74?94?93&,''' "56D 4=D68ED2DD2@4<6974?947E?@C2<13<4<B<ED;:6?682<3 # 62?@92334<238269C2<1<162?496IB4=;E8<16 =E>56?34<2E? 4C4D969 :; <16 <16 =742>4?<3 14F6 4? 45572=4<2E? B?96D 6=<2E? $ &! E8 <16 4?9 =IB232<2E?=<:68ED6<16=E>56<6?<686D6?=6EBD< % 16 686D6?=6 EBD< 48<6D =E?3296D2?@ <16 >4<6D247E?D6=ED9:;2<3AB9@>6?<4?94C4D994<69 '6?14?=69<16=E>56?34<2E?438E77EC3 - 5 - • ( ! !)*+,-.,+8ED2DD2@4<6974?94?9 • ( !/!/)*+,-.,+8ED9D;74?9 @@D26F69 :; <16 34>6 <16 =742>4?<3 14F6 5D686DD69 <16 5D636?< 455647 366H2?@ 8BD<16D 6?14?=6>6?<E8=E>56?34<2E? . 14F6 164D9 D2 4D314F4D914? 47254<27 764D?69 =EB?367 8ED <16 4556774?<3- >< D=14?4 2C4D2 764D?69 47E?@ C2<1 D2 163149D2 42314?H4D 764D?69 8ED D635E?96?< E3 + 4?9 ,- D2 14D4?4:434F4 43<45BD 764D?69 =EB?367 45564D2?@ 8ED <16 D635E?96?< E& 4?956DB369<16D6=ED93 $ D2 4D314F4D914? 47254<27 764D?69 =EB?367 8ED <16 4556774?<3 =E?<6?969 <14< <16 686D6?=6EBD<C127682K2?@<16>4DH6<F47B6574=69 D6724?=6 E? <16 AB9@>6?< D6?96D69 2? E'+ E8 &''. 43 ?E<2=69 2? 54D4@D451 &% E8 <16 2>5B@?69 - 6 - AB9@>6?< < C43 3B:>2<<69 <14< <16 4=IB232<2E? 5DE=6692?@3 2? E'+ E8 &''. 56D<42?2?@ <E 4? 64D726D4C4D9543369<16D62?C16D643<164=IB232<2E? 2?<165D636?<=436=B7>2?4<692?54332?@E8<164C4D9 2? <16 ;64D &''# 4?9 <16D68ED6 <16 >4DH6< F47B6 D6IB2D633B2<4:766?14?=6>6?< ( < 23 8BD<16D =E?<6?969 <14< <16 E?/:76 B5D6>6 EBD< 2? ! E3&.$#L&.( E8 &'( 96=2969 E? ',&'&+ D674<2?@ <E <16 34>6 12>4 28< DD2@4<2E? DEA6=< 143 4882D>69 4C4D9 E8 =E>56?34<2E? 4< 3,%&#' " 56D 4=D6 8ED 2DD2@4<69 74?9 6?=6 <16 4556774?<3 4D6 6?<2<769 <E 32>274D 6?14?=6>6?<2?<165D636?<4556476724?=6C43473E 574=69E?<16AB9@>6?<E8<16E?/:76 B5D6>6EBD< 2?<16=436E866D45544?>4?<144D2A4? 9649!:; D3 4?9 E<16D3 F3 <4<6 E8 4D?4<4H4 4?9 4?E<16D D65ED<69 2? $ /% '0 C16D62? 96" - 7 - 63=474<2E?4<<16D4<6E8#M56D4??B>C4349E5<69 8ED 74?93 32<B4<69 2? <16 474:BD4@2 D6@2E? ==ED92?@7;3EB@1<8ED2?<6D86D6?=6E8<123EBD< ' 6D=E?<D4 D2 14D4?4:434F443<45BD 764D?69 =EB?367 45564D2?@ 8ED <16 D635E?96?< E&L :6?682=24D;E8<1674?92?IB63<2E?3B:>2<<69<14<<16 686D6?=6 EBD< 143 9B7; =E?3296D69 477 D676F4?< 84=<ED3 4?9 D2@1<7; 82K69 <16 =E>56?34<2E? < C43 =E?<6?969<14< E'+E8&''.2<3678C4396=2969 :4369 E? 64D726D AB9@>6?<3 D674<2?@ <E <16 34>6 12>428<DD2@4<2E?DEA6=<2?=7B92?@ E,$+E8 &'' 56D<42?2?@ <E 477B?94@2 2774@6 2? 474:BD4@2 23<D2=<4?9<16D68ED62<23=E?<6?969<14<?E8BD<16D 6?14?=6>6?<23=477698ED2?<123455647 ? <16 72@1< E8 <16 D2F47 3B:>2332E?3 <16 5E2?<<14<4D23638ED=E?3296D4<2E?23 - 8 - 16<16D <16 4556774?<3 4D6 6?<2<769 8ED 8BD<16D 6?14?=6>6?< E8 =E>56?34<2E? 4?9 28 3E <E C14< 6K<6?<N & 16D623?E9235B<6D6@4D92?@<164=IB232<2E? E8 <16 74?93 E8 <16 4556774?<3 8ED <16 5BD5E36 E8 12>428<DD2@4<2E?DEA6=<1682K69<16>4DH6< F47B6E82DD2@4<6974?94<3&,''' "56D4=D6C12=1 C43 8BD<16D 6?14?=69 :; <16 686D6?=6 EBD< 4< 3+&+''' " 56D 4=D6 8ED 2DD2@4<69 74?9 4?9 3&##'' " 56D 4=D6 8ED 9D; 74?9 :; D67;2?@ B5E? <16AB9@>6?<2? E'+E8&''. + <23D676F4?<<E?E<6<14<<1674?932?FE7F69 2? E'+ E8 &''. 56D<42?3 <E <16 34>6 5DEA6=< 4?9 4D6 32>274D7; 32<B4<69 BD<16D <16 E?/:76 B5D6>6 EBD< 2? 123-**-4( .-(+ ! E3&.$#L&.(E8&'(96=2969E?',&'&+!143 - 9 - 4882D>69 =E>56?34<2E? 4< 3,%&#' " 56D 4=D6 8ED 2DD2@4<6974?9D674<2?@<E<1634>65DEA6=< , 16E?/:76 B5D6>6EBD<2?#++,-**-4( =43614349E5<69#M56D4??B>4396"63=474<2E?8ED 96<6D>2?2?@<16>4DH6<F47B6E874?932?<123D6@2E? E?3296D2?@ <14< <16 >4DH6< F47B6 E8 3,%&#' " 56D4=D656D<42?3<E<16;64D&''%4?94557;2?@96" 63=474<2E? 4< #M 56D 4??B> 8ED <CE ;64D3 <16 969B=<2E? CEDH3 EB< <E #M 8<6D 4557;2?@ <16 3429 96"63=474<2E? <16 >4DH6< F47B6 54;4:76 <E <16 4556774?<3CEDH3EB<<E ( !0 ! )*+,-.,+8ED2DD2@4<6974?9 # ?F26CE8<164:EF6923=B332E?<16455647 9636DF63<E:6477EC692?54D<==ED92?@7;<16455647 23 16 =742>4?<3 2? E'% E8 &''.4D66?<2<7698ED=E>56?34<2E?E8( !0 ! ) *+, -.,+ 8ED 2DD2@4<69 74?9 47E?@ C2<1 477 3<4<B<ED; - 10 - :6?682<3 4?9 =E3<3 43 45572=4:76 B?96D <16 4?9 =IB232<2E?=< % 16 2>5B@?69 AB9@>6?< 4?9 4C4D9 E8 <16 686D6?=6EBD<3<4?93>E928269<E<164:EF66K<6?< 5) $% 23< E 7 E&+