Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54280 (KAR)
SHRI SHAIK SHAMSE NAVEED v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA
WP/200487/2026 · 2026-02-04
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54280 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54280 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
!!"
#$% %
#$% !%&! ' (
! ! "
" ! #
$ ! %
! &
& &
&
'((( ! ! && & &
'
Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
'((( ! )! &&
& &
( ! #
$ %
& '
* &
&
&
& + (,!( !('
!((((' ')(
& -
+
&
&
!(((('
&
! &
. ! ! . ! ! - 3 -
$ . ! ! %
/0 1023234506 /78 9/7::05;0< 75 46<06 <720< (,!( !(' 17880< => 765727?7 2720 <@353826723A0 63=B57:
7:1B6;3 CD46 8/462 EFG
35 11:3972345
4!(((('! ! /0 1023234506 H78 6359317: 72 354632> 4676I3 0873 083<05237: 9/44: 72 75<423 3::7;0! 5 ! !( H/05 /0 H78 45 4DD3937: <B2> 63 0A75783<<737/
35<3 079/06
H78 1:790< 359/76;0 4D 2/014824D6359317:!22/7223@07@0<37106845A38320< 2/06083<05237:9/44:
H/39/H78B5<062/0945264:4D2/0 102323450675<60946<0<7A3<047=4B22/0H7>35H/39/2/0 /4820: H78 @73527350< 75< 9369B:720< 45 7 84937: ;64B1! 023234506 45 94@35; 24 ?54H 4D 2/0 A3<04 9:31
388B0< 7 8/4H 97B80 542390 <720< (! !( 24 2/0 76<05 75< 63 0A75783<<737/
24 H/4@ /0 /75<0< 4A06 9/76;0 4D 2/058232B2345 75< 97::0< D46 2/0360J1:75723458! 0 7:84 =64B;/22/03593<052242/05423904D608145<052 4!)75<
- 4 -
8B=@3220< 7 <0273:0< 601462 45 (! !(! 08145<052
4!2/05388B0<78/4H97B80542390<720< ! !(24 2/0 1023234506 24 8/4H 97B80 H/> 792345 8/4B:< 542 =0 27?057;73582/3@!/010232345069:73@82/72/0601:30<24 2/0 8/4H 97B80 542390! 4H0A06
608145<052 4!) D46H76<0<760146224608145<052 4!H32/4B2/07635;2/0 1023234506! /0 1023234506 2/0607D206 94::0920< 7:: 2/0 60:0A752@720637:75<8B=@3220<794@160/0583A0601:>45 *! !( 24 2/0 8/4H 97B80 542390 <720< ! !(! 4502/0:0882/0608145<052 4!)7<<60880<7:02206<720< ! !(242/0608145<052 4!75<=780<452/0873< :02206
2/0 608145<052 4! 17880< 75 46<06 <720< (! !(1:7935;2/01023234506B5<068B81058345!/0 1023234506 9/7::05;0< 2/0 87@0 =0D460 2/0 ! 5 75 35206:49B246>711:3972345/084B;/2D46352063@60:30D24827> 2/0 46<06 4D 8B81058345! /0 63=B57: 7D206 94583<0635;
2/0 @720637:
60I0920< 2/0 60KB082 D46 352063@ 60:30D A3<0 46<06<720<(,!( !('!/01023234506382/060D460=0D460 2/384B629/7::05;35;2/0873<46<06! - 5 -
)! /0:07650<94B580:D462/010232345068B=@3220< 2/722/01023234506/7<=0050897:7235;/38;630A759082/72 2/060H78548BDD393052/75<824@73527352/0/4820:!0 2/060D460 8B=@328 2/72 2/0 1023234506 7:450 38 542 24 =0 =:7@0<75<32382/0608145<0528H/47607:8460814583=:0 D462/0873<827204D7DD7368352/0/4820:!08B=@3282/72 2/0 63=B57: H32/4B2 94583<0635; 2/0 <49B@0528 1:790< =0D460 32 /7< 9B68463:> 60I0920< 2/0 60KB082 D46 352063@ 167>06! 0 2/060D460 167>8 2/72 2/0 3@1B;50< 46<06 =0 802 783<0 75< 75 352063@ 46<06 =0 ;67520< 827>35; 2/0 46<064D8B81058345! ! /0 :07650< <<323457: 4A065@052 <A49720 452/042/06/75<8B=@3220<2/722/0/7<0J069380< <3896023457D206;435;35242/0@720637:1:790<=0D4603275< 2/060D4602/384B629755420J069380IB638<392345B5:08875 0664671176052452/0D7904D60946<38143520<4B2=>2/0 :07650< 94B580: D46 2/0 1023234506! 0 8B=@328 2/72 7 106B87:4D2/06014623280:D<0@4582672082/0H7>35H/39/ 2/0/4820:H78?01275<2/01023234506=035;2/06359317:
- 6 -
4D 2/0 9/44: 38 =4B5< 24 ?001 2/0 /4820: 35 7 ;44< 945<32345
=B2D73:0<24<48475<2/060D4602/0:07822/72 2/0 608145<0528 94B:< <4 H78 24 1:790 /3@ B5<06 8B81058345!
/060D460
/0 8B=@328 2/72 2/0 3@1B;50< 46<0638IB8275<16410675<5435206D06059038H7667520<! ! 0 /7A0 94583<060< 8B=@388345 @7<0 => :07650< 94B580: D46 2/0 1023234506 75< 2/0 :07650< <<323457:4A065@052<A49720D462/0608145<0528! '! 106B87: 4D 2/0 46<06 4D 8B81058345 4D 2/0 10232345068/4H82/722/060H06080A067:7::0;723458H/39/ 8/4H2/722/0/4820:H78@73527350<357A06>B5/>;30539 @75506! /0 1023234506 =035; 2/0 6359317: 4D 2/0 58232B2345 975542 =0 4=:3A34B8 4D 2/0 945<32345 4D 2/0 /4820:! /060D460
2/0 7D206 ;435; 3524 2/0 <49B@05281:790<=0D4603263;/2:>97@0242/09459:B8345 2/722/046<064D8B810583454D2/01023234506500<542=0 827>0<! 3590 2/38 0J069380 4D <389602345 38 =780< 45 @720637: 1:790< =0D460 2/0
H0 <4 542 94583<06 32
- 7 -
50908876>2435206D060H32/2/046<0617880<!4H0A06
32 384105D462/010232345062460KB0822/02494583<06 75< <381480 4D 2/0 @735 711:3972345 78 0J10<3234B8:> 78 14883=:0! *! 5 2/72 A30H 4D 2/0 @72206
2/38 10232345 38 <381480<4DB1/4:<35;2/046<0617880<=>2/0!2 2/0 87@0 23@0 :3=062> 38 60806A0< 24 2/0 1023234506 24 60KB082 2/0 24 94583<06 75< <381480 4D 2/0 711:3972345H32/35754B206:3@324D)@452/8D64@24<7>! *+ '%( %
*+ '!%&!( %
382 4! : 4!'