- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %& %'()& %( * ! !!" ! # $ ! % & " ! ! !! & '( # ! $ ! % Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - &! )( & $ !% )( & $*% & & " ! & && ( $% $% * $% & &+!" & ! ! !*!!, , - ++ ./0123/3/45/06/7289582:2;3/45)(46 <= 3.2123/3/452: 4034>;;902840>5864:?:>5346 >53/;/1>34:= <>/7 /5 :/@2 4 8>328 ( :2?/032:28 <= 3.2 ./5;.47/ 47/;2 3>3/45 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><729582:2;3/450($%$%>58 $%46 .>:>3/=>=>=>>5./3>$64:0.4:3A B% .26>;39>7@>3:/C463.2;>02/03.>3=2>:01:/4: 343.2/5;/82533.2@>::/>?246;4@17>/5>53-02782:045/0.>5 D>012:64:@28D/3.452>7/3.> 93463.2D2874;E3.2=.>F2 <2?43325 3.:22 ;./78:25 >32: 3.2:2 D>0 > @/09582:03>58/5? <23D225.2:045>58.2:8>9?.32:'/5'7>D/5;22/?.3=2>:0 .2: 8>9?.32:'/5'7>D /0 :20/8/5? >3 .2: 1>:253>7 .4902 .2 - 3 - 1>:2530 46 .2: 8>9?.32:'/5'7>D .>F2 3>E25 .2: 34 9@<>/ 64: 3.2/: 7/F27/.448 <493 @453.0 1:/4: 34 3.2 /5;/8253 .2: 8>9?.32:'/5'7>D 6277 84D5 6:4@ > 52D7= ;4503:9;328 <9/78/5? D./72 0.2 D>0 84/5? > ;447/2 D4:E !92 34 3.2 0>@2 0.2 09;;9@<28 .2 ;4@17>/5>53B0 045G/0.>5 >632: 3>E/5? 72?>7 03210 ?43 0' >0 ;4@1250>3/45 >58 /5 3.>3 ;4@1250>3/45 >@4953 > 09@ 46 0' D>0 ?/F25 34 .2: 8>9?.32:'/5'7>DB0 1>:2530 >58 :2@>/5/5? >@4953 46 0'D>0>?:22834<2E213/53.25>@246;./78:2546 82;2>028 5 ) >3 ><493 ) 1@ D.25 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53B0045D25352>:/5>19: 9003>583482140/33.2 ;4@1250>3/45>@4953/53.25>@246;./78:253.2123/3/452:0 >745?D/3.43.2:>;;902812:0450;>@23.2:2>581/;E2891> H9>::27D/3../@>58><9028./@/5>6/73.=7>5?9>?2<=64/03/5? 7/623.:2>334./@!92343.20>/8>;3463.2>;;902812:0450 ;4@17>/5>53B0045;4@@/332809/;/82<=;4509@/5?1203/;/82/5 ./0 7>58 <2>:/5? =4) 45 3.2 0>@2 8>= >3 ><493 I 1@ 25;2 3.2 ;4@17>/53 .>0 <225 748?28 >?>/503 3.2 123/3/452:0>5843.2:0 53.203:25?3.46;4@17>/533.2:201458253G 47/;2 :2?/032:28 > ;>02 >?>/503 3.2 123/3/452:0 >58 43.2:0 64: 3.2 - 4 - >64:2@253/4528 46625;20 /5 :/@2 4 F2: 0/5;2 6:4@ :2?/03:>3/45 46 & 3.2 :201458253' 47/;2 >:2 @>E/5? .2;3/; >332@13 34 >::203 3.2 123/3/452:0 25;2 45 3.2 >11:2.250/45 46 3.2 >::203 3.2 123/3/452:0 >745? D/3. 3D4 43.2:0>11:4>;.2888/3/45>7!/03:/;3>58200/450+98?2>3 >7><9:>?/0/33/5?>33.228>@64:?:>534653/;/1>34:= >/7/5 :7/0;4( .2 0>@2 D>0 1>:37= >774D28 <= 3.2 72>:528 200/450 +98?2 F/82 4:82: 8>328 >58 ?:>5328 >53/;/1>34:= <>/7 /5 :2012;3 46 >;;9028 40 >58 ) .4D2F2: :2J2;328 3.2 <>/7 123/3/45 >?>/503 >;;9028 40 >58/2123/3/452:0/53./0123/3/4525;23./0123/3/45 ) 2>:8 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 >58 72>:528 /?. 49:3 4F2:5@253 72>82: 64: 3.2 :201458253' 3>32 1>:36:4@9:?/5?02F2:>7;453253/4503.272>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 .>0 ;45325828 3.>3 >3 54 14/53 46 3/@2 3.202 123/3/452:0 /503/?>328 3.2 82;2>028 34 ;4@@/3 09/;/82<=82@>58/5?3.2;4@1250>3/45>@4953D./;..2?43 64:3.282>3.46./0D/622>704;453253283.>334>33:>;33.2 46625;2 9582: 2;3/45 ( 46 3.2:2 @903 <2 - 5 - /503/?>3/45 6:4@ 3.2 >;;9028 34 8:/F2 3.2 82;2>028 34 ;4@@/3 09/;/820445<264:23.282>3.53.2/503>53;>023.2:2>:254 09;.>772?>3/45064:3.;4@/5?;;4:8/5?7=.21:>=034>774D3.2 123/3/45 72>:528/?.49:34F2:5@253 72>82: 4114028343.2<>/7123/3/45>581:>=0348/0@/003.20>@2 I .>F2?/F25@=>5C/490;450/82:>3/45<43.453.2 09<@/00/45 @>82 <= 3.2 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/F2 1>:3/20>5812:90283.284;9@2530>F>/7><7245:2;4:8 ( 0 ;4978 <2 ?>3.2:28 6:4@ 3.2 :2;4:80 3.2 123/3/452:0 >58 3.2 F/;3/@ >:2 :27>3/F20 .2 >772?28 /5;/8253 D>0 ;4@@/3328 /5 :2012;3 46 8/03:/<93/45 46 ;4@1250>3/45 >@4953 4<3>/528 <= 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53B0 045 64: 3.2 >;;/8253>7 82>3.46./0D/62.2>772?>3/450>?>/503>;;902840>58) /5 3.2 ;4@17>/53 >704 03>580 0/@/7>: 3.>3 46 3.202 123/3/452:0 >583.20>/8>;;9028>:2>7:2>8=?:>5328D/3.>53/;/1>34:=<>/7 <= 3.2 200/450 49:3 5 09;. ;/:;9@03>5;20 >@ 46 3.2 ;450/82:2841/5/453.>33.202123/3/452:0>:2>70403>580>3> 0/@/7>:6443/5?>583.2=;>5543<2825/283.2>53/;/1>34:=<>/7 - 6 - ;;4:8/5?7=D/3.4932C1:200/5?>5=41/5/45453.2 @2:/30 46 3.2 ;>02 0966/;2 34 .478 3.>3 3.202 123/3/452:0>;;9028 40 >58 ;>5 <2 257>:?28 45 >53/;/1>34:=<>/7 .2:/@/5>7 23/3/45/0 .2 :201458253' 47/;2 >:2 8/:2;328 34 :272>02 3.2 123/3/452:0>;;902840>58/53.22F253463.2/:>::203 /5 :/@2 4 :2?/032:28 <= 3.2 ./5;.47/ 47/;2 3>3/45 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450 ( $%$%>58$%46 09<J2;334 3.264774D/5?;458/3/450, /% .2 123/3/452:0 0.>77 >112>: <264:2 3.2 5F203/?>3/5? 66/;2: D/3./5 8>=0 6:4@ 3.28>3246:2;2/13463.2;41=463./04:82: >58 0.>77 2C2;932 > 12:045>7 <458 64: > 09@ 46 0' $91220 52 >E. 457=%2>;.D/3.45209:23=64:3.27/E209@ 34 3.2 0>3/06>;3/45 46 3.2 /5F203/?>3/5? 466/;2: - 7 - //% 23/3/452:0 0.>77 :2?97>:7= >112>: <264:2 3.2 :/>7 49:3 D/3.493 6>/7 957200 2C2@1328 <= 3.2 :/>7 49:364:F>7/8:2>0450 ///% 23/3/452:0 0.>77 543 3>@12: D/3. 3.2 1:402;93/45 D/35200>583.2=0.>77;4'412:>32D/3.3.2147/;264: /5F203/?>3/45 >58 >112>: <264:2 3.2@ D.252F2: ;>77289145 /F% .2123/3/452:00.>77543/5F47F2/50/@/7>:46625;20 /56939:2K +) %!( ! /034,74,)