- 1 - !"#"$ %&#" '() !" # $ "" % " & & !" # " % Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' " ( ) * ( ( " % " ( " ( *& " &&&* + ( (" ( " " ( ,-- & )-- & " ( " ' ." " /0123/014/256748/3961:;/</:=:=64/1 /014/2 22=:=6403 6>/14?/4: 2>650:/ =8 2=1/5:/2:6:0@/46:=5/961:;/1/8<642/4:8 ;=8</:=:=64=89=3/2AB:;/</:=:=64/188//@=4C0 2=1/5:=64 :6 :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 :6 5648=2/1 :;/ 530=? 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 =4 :/1?8 69 D72C?/4: 042 2/51// 20:/2 - 3 - *& =4 6&&&* E;=5; =8 573?=40:/2 =4 :;/ ( 6)& & 5644/5:/2 E=:; ( 6&&&*& : =8 :;/ 508/ 69 3/014/2 56748/3 961 :;/ </:=:=64/18 :;0: A08/2 64 :;/ 87=: 9=3/2 AB :;=12 <01:B 40?/3B //1/8; 6 05;0440 =4 6&&&* </:=:=64/18 E/1/ 210CC/2 =4:6 :;/ 5=>=3 3=:=C0:=64 69 :;/ <16</1:BA/01=4CB6 ,--?/0871=4C &C74:08042 B6)-- ?/0871=4C & 051/8 C74:08 A6:; 01/ 8=:70:/2 0: 01633= =330C/ 04>= 037@ 0=5;71 =8:1=5: ;/80=287=:50?/:6A/2=8?=88/2042:;/5674:/1530=? ?02/AB:;/</:=:=64/1850?/:6A/2/51//2 CC1=/>/2AB :;/ 80?/ :;/ <30=4:=99 :;/1/=4 <1/9/11/2 ( 6)& & 5644/5:/2 E=:; ( 6&&&*& ;/ 80=2 0<</038 0386 50?/ :6 A/ 2=8?=88/2 ;/1/AB :;/ D72C?/4:0422/51//=4 6&&&*0::0=4/29=403=:B E=:;67:971:;/15;033/4C/ <64 2=8?=8803 69 :;/ 87=: </:=:=64/18 ?02/ 0 1/<1/8/4:0:=64:61/8<642/4:6E;6=4:714961E012/2 - 4 - :;/3/::/1:61/8<642/4:6 :6/99/5::;/?7:0:=64/4:1B =4 :;/ 40?/8 69 </:=:=64/18 6E/>/1 :;/ 80?/ E08 46: 264/ 042 :;/1/09:/1 :;67C; :;/ 5;033/4C/ E08 ?02/ 0C0=48::;/D72C?/4:0422/51//:;/80?/E08038646: 8755/88973 042 :;/ 0<</038 <1/9/11/2 AB :;/ 80=2 <30=4:=99 50?/:6A/2=8?=88/2 ) ;/C1=/>045/69:;/</:=:=64/18=8:;0:645/04 0<<3=50:=641/<1/8/4:0:=64 =8 ?02/ AB :;/ </:=:=64/18 A1=4C=4C :6 :;/ 46:=5/ 69 :;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 1/C012=4C :;/ D72C?/4: 042 2/51// <088/2 AB :;/ =>=3 671:E;/1/:;/</:=:=64/18;0>/8755//2/2=:=8:;/27:B 042 6A3=C0:=64 508: 7<64 :;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 40?/3B :;/ 0;08=3201 :6 /4:/1 :;/=1 40?/8 =4 :;/ 1/>/47/1/56128A08/264:;/80=2D72C?/4:0422/51// E;=5; ;08 46: A//4 264/ 2/8<=:/ 0 1/<1/8/4:0:=64 A/=4C ?02/ AB :;/ </:=:=64/18 CC1=/>/2 AB E;=5; :;/ </:=:=64/1801/A/961/:;=8671: * /014/2 22=:=6403 6>/14?/4: 2>650:/ 1/<1/8/4:=4C :;/ :0:/ 564:/428 :;0: <718704: :6 :;/ - 5 - 61=C=403 87=: 1/C7301 9=18: 0<</038 530=?/2 :6 ;0>/ A//4 9=3/2 042 :;/ 56<B 69 :;/ 80?/ =8 46: 9714=8;/2 042 46 87A8/F7/4: 1/<1/8/4:0:=64 =8 ?02/ ;/1/961/ ;/ 564:/428 :;0: :;/1/ 4//2 46: A/ 04B =4:/19/1/45/ 61 =4273C/45/AB:;=8671: ;0>/;/0123/014/256748/3961:;/</:=:=64/1 042 3/014/2 22=:=6403 6>/14?/4: 2>650:/ 961 :;/ 1/8<642/4::0:/ , <<01/4:3B=:=88//4:;0::;/</:=:=64/18;/1/=4 ;0>/ 8755//2/2 =4 :;/ 61=C=403 87=: =48:=:7:/2 0C0=48: :;/ </:=:=64/18AB //1/8;042:;/5674:/1530=?9=3/2AB:;/ 2/9/4204:8:;/1/=4=/</:=:=64/1650?/:6A/0336E/2 AB 2/5301=4C :;/ </:=:=64/18 042 :;/=1 90:;/1 08 0A8637:/ 6E4/1869:;/<16</1:=/8"718704::6E;=5;040<<3=50:=64 E08 ?02/ :6 :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 :6 ?7:0:/ :;/=1 40?/8 =4 :;/=1 1/>/47/ 1/56128 E;=5; E08 961E012/2 :6 :;/ 0;08=3201AB:;//<7:B6??=88=64/1042:;/80?/;08 46:A//405:/27<64:=8038646EA167C;::6:;/46:=5/ 69:;=8671::;0:<718704::6D72C?/4:0422/51//=4:;/ - 6 - 61=C=403 87=: :;/ 0CC1=/>/2 <01:B =/ :;/ <30=4:=99 <1/9/11/2 04 0<</03 =4 ( 6)& & E ( 6&&&*& ;/ 80=2 0<</03 0386 50?/ :6 A/ 2=8?=88/2>=2/D72C?/4:20:/2&& & ;/<16>=8=64869/5:=6469:;/$0140:0@0 042 />/47/ 5: 53/013B 2/03 E=:; ;6E :;/ ?7:0:=64 /4:1=/801/:6A/?02/AB:;/0;08=3201 45/:;/1/=80 D72C?/4: 042 2/51// E;=5; =8 <088/2 AB :;/ =>=3 671: 042:;/80?/=856??74=50:/2:6:;/07:;61=:=/840?/3B :;//<7:B6??=88=64/1042:;/80?/961E012/2:6:;/ 0;08=3201 ;/ =8 27:B A6742 :6 /4:/1 :;/ 40?/8 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 E;6 ;0>/ 8755//2/2 =4:;/ 61=C=403 87=: 09:/1 46:=9B=4C :;/ 5645/14/2 </18648 E;68/ 40?/8 01/ /G=8:=4C=4:;/1/>/47/1/56128=904B 4 :;/ <1/8/4: 508/ 46 05:=64 =8 :0@/4 AB :;/ 1/8<642/4:8 2/8<=:/ 04 0<<3=50:=64 A/=4C ?02/ AB :;/ </:=:=64/18 A/=4C 8755/88973 =4 :;/ 61=C=403 87=: E;/1/=4 56<B69:;/D72C?/4:=8/45368/2AB:;/?:=8:;/27:B 042 6A3=C0:=64 69 :;/ 1/8<642/4: 07:;61=:=/8 :6 /99/5: - 7 - ?7:0:=64 =4 :;/ 40?/8 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 E;6 ;0>/ 8755//2/2 =4 :;/ 61=C=403 87=: 7<64 0 56<B 69 :;/ D72C?/4: 042 2/51// A/=4C <305/2 A/961/ :;/? AB 46:=9B=4C04B</18648E;68/40?/801/96742=4:;/ 4 :;/ 0A8/45/ 69 04B 1=>03 530=? 61 04B 0<</03 ;0>=4C A//4 <1/9/11/2 042 0 8:0B ;0>=4C A//4 C104:/2 AB 0 56?</:/4:671::;/1/8<642/4:07:;61=:=/801/A6742:6 8:1=5:3B 56?<3B 042 C=>/ /99/5: :6 :;/ 612/18 69 :;/ 5=>=3 671: AB /4:/1=4C :;/ 40?/8 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 =4 :;/ 1/>/47/1/56128;/90=371/69:;/1/8<642/4:8:62686=8 01A=:101B=33/C0304274878:0=40A3/=430E 4 :;/ <1/8/4: 508/ :;/ 5;033/4C/ :6 :;/ D72C?/4:0422/51//<088/2=4:;/61=C=40387=:=45372=4C :;/ 0336E=4C 69 :;/ 5674:/1530=? ;08 A//4 2=8?=88/2 =4 :;//C7301(=18: <</0381/9/11/2:6;/1/=40A6>/ ;/1/961/ 46:;=4C 1/?0=48 961 :;/ 07:;61=:=/8 /G5/<: :6 5;04C/ :;/ ?7:0:=64 /4:1=/8 =4 :;/ 1/>/47/ 1/56128 =4 90>671 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 08 </1 :;/ D72C?/4: 0422/51//<088/2AB:;/1=03671:042:;=8671: - 8 - 55612=4C3B<165//2:6<088:;/96336E=4C #0% ;/'1=:"/:=:=64=8 #A% E1=: 69 ?0420?78 =8 =887/2 2=1/5:=4C 1/8<642/4: 6 :6 5;04C/ :;/ ?7:0:=64 /4:1=/8 =4 :;/ 40?/8 69 :;/ </:=:=64/18 08 </1 :;/ D72C?/4: 042 2/51// 20:/2 *& <088/2 =4 6&&&* AB :;/ "1=45=<03 /4=61 =>=3 72C/ 0: 0=5;71 042 099=1?/2 =4 ( 68)& & 042 &&&*& >=2/ D72C?/4: 042 2/51// 20:/2 && AB :;/ 64HA3/ =>=8=64 /45;69:;=8671:E=:;=40467:/13=?=:69 9671E//@8916?:;/20:/691/5/=<:6956<B 69:;/612/1 *( '") # " =8:636&