- 1 - !"#"$ %# && '() && '() !" # $%$ & # $&$ # $'$ Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # $ $ ' # $% # ! '(% ! ! ! ! '" )" ! ! (#&% &* ! ! ! & && # *+ # , ' $ & # , * $ # , $ # , $ ' # , '* $ - 3 - # ! ! ! ! !" !" )" ! &* ! ! ! !(#&% ! $ $ - # ./0123.4./05.167859.4:7023.;/02<.9 - 4 - & 3.9./;;./49/0./0<9<5=7827:23.81=>.52/51 /?/01 1/2.1 &* ;/99.1 <5 ! 7(#&% 75 23. :<4. 7: 23. 0<56<;/4 .5<70 <@<4 81=. /51 /51 7270 66<1.52 4/<>9 0<A85/4 7! !<B/C/;80/ :70 93702 D23. 0<A85/4E"/?/01<5=67>;.59/2<752723.64/<>/529 2<923.6/9.7:23.64/<>/52923/2 75(*&' 23.389A/517:23.64/<>/527/93<>?/9;076..1<5=<5/ >72706C64. /9 / ;<44<75 0<1.0 :07> 3<9 @<44/=. 27 74/;80 /51 ?3.5 3. 0./63.1 5./0 <51/=< <4 <44 75 C1.0/A/174/;80 07/1 / A89 A./0<5= 0.=<920/2<75 7#55.F80.G*%% 1/93.1 27 23. >72706C64. <5 ?3<63 23. 9/<1 /93<> ?/9 20/@.44<5=/51/9/0.98427:23.9/>.3.1<.1<523.07/120/::<6 /66<1.52 .56. 23. 64/<>/529 3/@. ;0.:.00.1 ! 7(#&% :2.0 9.0@<6. 7: 572<6. 23. 0.9;751.52 .52.0.1 /;;./0/56. /51 :<4.1 1.2/<4.1 ?0<22.5 92/2.>.52 1.5C<5= 23. /@.0>.529 >/1. <5 23. ;.2<2<75 5 701.0 27 .92/A4<93 23.<0 6/9. 23.64/<>/5293/@..F/><5.12?7?<25.99.9/9/51 & /51 =72>/0H.1 * 1768>.529 /9 F 27 F* 7 70/4/511768>.52/0C.@<1.56.?/9/1186.1AC23.0.9;751.52 - 5 - 9<1.3.20<A85/4 /:2.06759<1.0<5=23.>/2.0</4750.6701AC <29 81=>.52 /51 /?/01 1/2.1 &* /?/01.1 67>;.59/2<757:9& && #?<23<52.0.92/223.0/2.7:*+ ;.0/558>:07>23.1/2.7:;.2<2<752<4423.1/2.7:0./4<I/2<75 ..4<5=/==0<.@.1AC23.<5/1.J8/2.67>;.59/2<75/?/01.1AC 23. 20<A85/4 23. 64/<>/529 3/@. ;0.:.00.1 7&(*#&* 9..H<5= .53/56.>.52 7: 67>;.59/2<75 5 23. 723.0 3/51 23. 74/;80 /3/5/=/0 /4<H/ 0/59;702 3/9 ;0.:.00.1 7&%*#&& 63/44.5=<5= 23. 4</A<4<2C /9 27 23. B80<91<62<75 7: 23. @.3<64. <5 J8.92<75 /51 /66701<5=4C 978=32:709.22<5=/9<1.23.81=>.52/51/?/01;/99.1AC23. 20<A85/4 ' 0</5B/C793< 4./05.167859.4:7023.74/;80 /3/5/=/0 /4<H/ 0/59;702 <5 7&%*#&& /0=8.1 23/2 23. /44.=.1 /66<1.52 766800.1 5./0 <51/=< <4 <44 75 C1.0/A/174/;80 07/1 /51 23. 0.9;751.5267>;/5C <9 9<28/2.1 /2 74/;80 /51 23.0.:70. 23. 64/<> ;.2<2<75 78=32 27 3/@.A..5:<4.1A.:70.23.B80<91<62<75/420<A85/4/5123.0.:70. 978=32:70<52.0:.0.56.7:23<97802 2<9/497/0=8.1AC0< /5B/C 793< 4./05.1 67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. /;;.44/52 23/2 23. /?/01 7: 67>;.59/2<75 <9 75 23. 3<=3.0 9<1. /51 - 6 - :8023.023./44.=.1/66<1.52766800.1<523.><114.7:23.07/1 /5123.0.:70. 23.20<A85/478=32273/@.9/114.167520<A8270C 5.=4<=.56. 75 23. ;/02 7: 23. 0<1.0 7: 23. >72706C64. /51 23.0.:70. 978=32:70<52.0:.0.56.7:23<97802 % .067520/ >20.>/!/H0/5< 4./05.167859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. 64/<>/529 978=32 27 B892<:C 23. <>;8=5.1 81=>.52/51/?/01>/1.AC23.0<A85/4/92723.4</A<4<2C<9 6756.05.1 37?.@.0 <2 <9 98A><22.1 23/2 23. /?/01 7: 67>;.59/2<750.J8<0.927A..53/56.1<523<9/;;./4 ) 523.4<=327:23.98A><99<75>/1.AC23.4./05.1 67859.4:7023.;/02<.9 <2<9572<51<9;82./92723.766800.56. 7: 23. /66<1.52 75 (*&' <5 ?3<63 23. 1.6./9.1 /93<> ?/9 ;076..1<5= <5 / >72706C64. 5 0.9;.62 7: 23. /0=8>.52 /1@/56.1 AC 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 :70 23. /;;.44/52 /9 27 B80<91<62<75 7: 23. 0<A85/4 <9 6756.05.1 75 6/0.:84 6759<1.0/2<757:.62<75%%&"7:23.7270!.3<64.962 *(( :7093702D23.62E" >/H.9<264./023/2 23.64/<>;.2<2<75A. :<4.1A.:70.23.B80<91<62<75/420<A85/4<5?379.B80<91<62<7523. 1.6./9.1#64/<>/529 0.9<1.9 5 23/2 @<.? 7: 23. >/22.0 9<56. 23.4/5=8/=..>;47C.1<523./:70.>.52<75.1;07@<9<75<964./0 - 7 - /5185/>A<=8789 /51/923.6/89.2<24.7:23.64/<>/529937? ?<23<523.B80<91<62<757:23.0<A85/4 />7:23.@<.?23/2 23. 9/<1 6752.52<75 0/<9.1 AC 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 :70 23. 74/;80 /3/5/=/0/4<H/0/59;7026/5572A./66.;2.1 ( 597:/0 /9 23. /0=8>.52 /1@/56.1 /9 27 23. 67520<A8270C5.=4<=.56.<96756.05.1 851<9;82/A4C579H.263<9 ;07186.1 A.:70. 23. 0<A85/4 3/2 /;/02 2/H<5= <527 6759<1.0/2<7523./?/017:67>;.59/2<75 23./66<1.52<97:23. C./0 &' /51 /9 ;.0 23. =8<1.4<5.9 7: 23. /05/2/H/ .=/4 .0@<6.982370<2C 23.>75234C<567>.7:23.1.6./9.13/927 A.2/H.5/29% #;.0>7523/:2.0/;;4C<5=23.>842<4<.07: D%E/9;.023.81=>.527:23.75EA4.8;0.>.7802<523. 6/9.7: 0.;702.1<5 8023.0 +7:23.:8280. ;079;.629 3/9 27 A. /11.1 /9 ;.0 23. 81=>.52 7: 75EA4. 8;0.>. 7802 <5 23. 6/9. 7: ! " # 0.;702.1<5$ % .56. 23. 4799 7: 1.;.51.56C ?7841 A. /9 851.0$ 9% #K+L9( # - 8 - 9( #M&M%L9% & (# * 3.64/<>/527<923.?<:./5164/<>/5279& 27/0.23.63<410.5/5164/<>/527'<923.>723.07:23. 1.6./9.1 .56. 23. 64/<>/529 /0. .52<24.1 :70 6759702<8> 7: 9 # ./63 <. 9& # 3. 0<A85/4 3/9 /?/01.1 9' # 27?/019 20/59;702/2<75 /51 :85.0/4 .F;.59.9 ?3<63 <9 572 /42.0.1 .56. 23. 64/<>/529 /0. .52<24.1:7023.272/467>;.59/2<75/9851.0$ * +,-./01+2.,342 0523 7997:1.;.51.56C 9% & (# & 7997:6759702<8> 9& # 0/59;702/2<75 /51 :85.0/4 .F;.59.9 9' # 72/4 9( &) (# 597:/0 /9 23. /?/01 7: <52.0.92 <9 6756.05.1 :<51 :706. <5 23. 98A><99<75 >/1. AC 23. 4./05.1 67859.4 /;;./0<5= :70 23. 74/;80 /3/5/=/0 /4<H/ 0/59;702 <5 ?3<63 23. 0<A85/4 78=32 27 3/@. /?/01.1 23. ;0.@/<4<5= /5H<52.0.92/2%+;.0/558> 66701<5=4C ;/9923.:7447?<5=$ - 9 - <" 723/;;./49/0./447?.1<5;/02N <<" 3. 64/<>/529 /0. .52<24.1 :70 272/4 67>;.59/2<75 7: 9( &) (# /475= ?<23 <52.0.92/223.0/2.7:%+;.0/558>:07>23.1/2. 7: ;.2<2<75 2<44 23. 1/2. 7: 0./4<I/2<75 /9 /=/<592 9& && #/9/?/01.1AC23.0<A85/4N <<<" 3. />7852 <5 1.;79<2 <: /5C A. 20/59><22.12723.0<A85/4 :7023?<23 - ' ) # ! <927$47$' $