Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54251 (KAR)

NAGAPPA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA

CRL.A/200007/2026 · 2026-01-31

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - ! " #$ #$ % $"" & &'"()*&( + ! " #$ % & ! & ! ' ! Digitally signed by SUMITRA SHERIGAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ( ) ! ' ! ! " #& % & & !*! $ & ! !*! $ $ & & *(+!*! & ! & && *(+!*! & & $ $&& & $ ) , $$ , $$ - 3 - % $ # , $$ % -./0- 1-23 455647 23 5.3168 9.: 48;2332.< 1.84= >21-1-6?.<36<1.9@.1-1-654:12631-634;62314A6</5 9.:92<478235.347 ! -6 4556774<18694?1. ?.;5742<4<1 @62<0 400:26B68 @= 1-6 C/80;6<1 84168 ! !*! .9 1-6 764:<6888212.<47231:2?14<86332.<3$/80642?-/: 32112<0 41 2<8-4<..: 2< 57 .*(+!*! 4?D/2112<0 1-6 4??/368 . 9.: 1-6 .996<?63 5/<23-4@76 /<86: 6?12.< + (+ :648 >21- 6?12.< .9 4<8 6?12.<3 4<8 + .9 ?1 4<8 4?D/2112<0 4??/368 .!1..91-6.996<?635/<23-4@76/<86:6?12.< +!*+:648>21-6?12.<.94<86?12.< ( .9?1-43927681-65:636<1455647 &4?13 1-41 ?4< @6041-6:68 9:.;1-6C/80;6<1 .91-6:247./:14:61-4145:.36?/12.<>4374/<?-68@= 1-6 ?.;5742<4<1 @= 2<9.:;2<0 1-6 5.72?6 .< *!*! - 4 - 1-41-2384/0-16:>43A28<45568@=1-64??/368. 4<8 1-6 .1-6: 4??/368 4@61168 1-6 .996<?6 -6 5.72?6 :602316:68 4 ?436 9.: 1-6 .996<?63 5/<23-4@76 /<86: 6?12.< +* *E!*+:648>21-6?12.< .9 -6 4??/368 . 4<8 1-6 02:7 >6:6 1:4?68 9:.; 43A2916:2<16::.0412.<1-602:7823?7.3681-413-6>43 A28<45568 @= 4??/368 . 4<8 4??/368 .! 1. 2<31204168 -2; -6 473. 823?7.368 1-41 3-6 >43 14A6< 1. 6<047/:/ 4<8 1-41 .< **E!*! 4<8 1>. 1-:66 12;63 1-6:64916: 4??/368 . -48 9.:?2@76 36F/47 2<16:?./:36 -6B2?12;02:7>439./<81.@64;2<.:-6<B63120412<0 992?6: 4916: 8:4>2<0 :676B4<1 4-4G4:3 4<8 3/@C6?12<0 1-64??/368. 4<81-602:71.;682?476F4;2<412.<4<8 36?/:2<0 477 ;682?47 6B286<?6 7428 4 ?-4:06 3-661 9.: 1-6 .996<?63 5/<23-4@76 /<86: 6?12.<3 + *+ (+ :648 >21- 6?12.< .9 4<8 6?12.<3 4<8 + .9 ?1!* !4042<314??/368. 4<8/<86:6?12.< + *+ (+ :648 >21- 6?12.< .9 4<8 6?12.<3 4<8 + .9 ?1 !* ! 4042<31 4??/368 - 5 - .!4<84??/368.4<8/<86:6?12.<3! * *+ *E :648 >21- 6?12.< .9 4<8 6?12.< ( .9 ?1!* !4042<314??/368.-6?.5263.91-6 ?-4:063-661>6:69/:<23-681.1-64??/368-64??/368 5764868<.10/271=4<8?742;681.@61:268<3/55.:1.9 1-6 ?436 .9 5:.36?/12.< 1-6 02:7 >43 6F4;2<68 43 ) 4-4G6:>21<633631-6?.;5742<4<143)1-6;.1-6: .91-602:743)+1-6.?1.:3>-.6F4;2<681-64??/368 . 4<8B2?12;43)(4<8)4<81-6 648 4316:.9 1-6 ?-..7 43 )E 4<8 .1-6: >21<63363 4<8 ;4:A68 F 1. * . ;416:247 .@C6?13 >6:6 ;4:A68 -6 4??/368 2< 1-62: 31416;6<1 /<86: 6?12.< 86<268 1-6 6B286<?6 .9 1-6 5:.36?/12.< >21<63363 4368 .< 1-6 6B286<?6 488/?68 1-6 :247 ./:1 -678 1-41 1-6 5:.36?/12.< 942768 1. 5:.B6 1-6 ?-4:063 4<8 4?D/21168 477 1-64??/36862<0400:26B68@=1-63428$/80;6<11-6 ?.;5742<4<1-43927681-23455647 64:81-6764:<68?./<3679.:1-64556774<11-6 941-6:.9B2?12;4<8764:<688879.:1-6:635.<86<1 - 6 - . ?.;5742<4<1 1416 6:/368 1-6 :676B4<1 ;416:2473 9/:<23-68@=1-6764:<68?./<3679.:1-64556774<1 -6 .<7= D/6312.< 1-41 4:2363 9.: ./: ?.<3286:412.<23>-61-6:1-62;5/0<68C/80;6<1>4::4<13 2<16:96:6<?6411-62<314<?6.91-68694?1.?.;5742<4<1 + < 1-6 2;5/0<68 C/80;6<1 6B6< 1-./0- 1-6 :247 ./:1 -43 ?.;6 1. 1-6 ?.<?7/32.< 1-41 1-6 B2?12; 23 @67.> 1-6 406 .9 =64:3 43 .< 1-6 8416 .9 4776068 .996<?6 21 -43 -678 1-41 1-6 5:.36?/12.< -43 942768 1. 5:.B61-6.996<?634776068431-6B2?12;1/:<68-.312761. 1-6 ?436 .9 5:.36?/12.< -6 .1-6: ;416:247 >21<63363 -4B6 473. <.1 3/55.:168 1-6 ?436 .9 5:.36?/12.< -6 6B286<?6 .9 ;416:247 >21<63363 :604:82<0 A28<45 4<8 36F/47 4334/71 23 @4368 .< 1-6 2<9.:;412.< 3428 1. -4B6 @66<02B6<@=1-6B2?12;-6;682?476B286<?6.<:6?.:8 2< 1-6 9.:; .9 .:47 6B286<?6 .9 ) 4<8 1-6 :65.:1 41 F >./783-.>1-41411-612;6.96F4;2<412.<.91-6 B2?12;-6:-=;6<>432<14?14<8 1-6:6>6:6<.320<3.9 - 7 - 9.:?69/736F/474334/71&/:1-6:.<1-6@4323.9&:65.:1 41 F ) -43 .52<68 1-41 1-6:6 >43 <. 6B286<?6 3/006312B6 .9 36F/47 4334/71 .< 1-6 B2?12; 6<?6 1-23 ./:1 23 .9 1-6 ?.<3286:68 B26> 1-41 .< 1-6 ;416:2473 .< :6?.:8 1-6:6 23 <. 5:2;4 94?26 ?436 1. 3-.> 1-41 1-6 :635.<86<13 . 1. -4B6 ?.;;21168 1-6 .996<?63 ?-4:068 ( &/:1-6: 21 23 9.:1-?.;2<0 2< 1-6 2;5/0<68 C/80;6<1 1-41 2< 1-6 31416;6<1 .9 1-6 4??/368 . :6?.:868@=1-6:247./:1/<86:6?12.< .9:21 23 ;6<12.<68 1-41 4??/368 . ;4::268 1-6 B2?12; 4<8 1-62:;4::2406-43@66<:602316:68356:1-6?6:1292?416 .9 :60231:412.< .9 ;4::2406 1-6 8416 .9 ;4::2406 .9 1-6 4??/368. 4<8B2?12;23 *!*!>-2?->./783-.> 1-418/:2<01-656<86<?=.91-6?436@69.:61-6:247./:1 1-6:635.<86<1.!4??/368. ;4::2681-6B2?12; .:6.B6: 21 23 56:12<6<1 1. <.16 1-41 1-6 :635.<86<1 . ?.;5742<4<1 1416 -43 <.1 ?-.36< 1. - 8 - ?-4776<06 1-6 2;5/0<68 C/80;6<1 .9 4?D/21147 6<?6 1-6:6 23 4@3.7/167= <. ;416:247 1. 2<16:96:6 >21- 1-6 2;5/0<68 C/80;6<1 .9 1-6 :247 ./:1 >-6:62< 1-6 :635.<86<13 .! 1. 4:6 4?D/21168 .9 1-6 .996<?63 ?-4:0684042<311-6;2<1-6?436 E <1-6:63/711-2345564723-6:6@= * .<36D/6<17= 1-6 2;5/0<68 C/80;6<1 84168 ! !*!.91-6764:<6888212.<47231:2?1H6332.<3 $/80642?-/:32112<0412<8-4<..:4<856?247$/8069.: 1:247.9?436/<86:?12<57436.*(+!*! 3-477314<8?.<92:;68 ,) & ( ,) & %( 231. 7.