- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %&'%()*&' %) + ! " # $%& ! '" # % # !" %# !" Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - ' # $ # ## !" %!" %!" !" !" # # ( ('# $ # #( ' # ' ) ') *' ( ( +,-.+/ 012.3+4 51- 67+ 8+69691.+- 7,3 594+/ , :+:1 3++;9.<4+,=+15679312-661>967/-,>67+8+69691.,<,9.3667+ 8+69691.+-1 ,0023+/1 7+:+:1936,;+.1.-+01-/ .=9+>1567+,?1=+67+8+69691.93 9.-+38+06158+69691.+-1 ,0023+/1 * " $ 793 8+69691. 93 594+/ 2./+- +0691. % 15 ?@ 67+ 8+69691.+- 1 ,0023+/ 1 51- <-,.6 15 ,.69098,61-@ ?,94 9. -9:+ 1 /,6+/ A -+<936+-+/ ?@ +=,/2-<, 1490+ 6,691. 51- 67+ 155+.0+3 - 3 - 82.937,?4+ 2./+- +0691.3 !" %!" %!" ,./ !"- > +0691.!"157,-,69@,@,@, ,.796,!51-371-6 B C" 7+ 5,062,4 :,6-9D 15 67+ 0,3+ 93 67,6 1. A,6,?1268:67+01:84,9.,.6*331.$9.$4,> 1.+ ,07,@@, 8,-;+/ 793 ,261 9. 5-1.6 15 793 3718 9. 67+9- =944,<+33207,0023+/1$,44,@@,36,-6+/61,?23+67+ 01:84,9.,.6*3 31.$9.$4,> 1. 67+ 3,9/ 9332+ 712<7 67+ 3,9/ ,07,@@, -+E2+36+/ 79: 67,6 7+ >124/ 6,;+ 126 793 261 90;37,> 5-1: 67+ 3,9/ 3816 ,0023+/ 1 ,33,246+/ 79: ?@ 519369.<495+67-+,6667,669:+1.+,.2:,.6,88,1490+,694 >71 >,3 8-+3+.6 ,6 67+ 3816 9.6+-=+.+/ >967 67+ E2,--+4 ,./ 3+8,-,6+/ 67+: +3896+ ,0023+/ 1 34,88+/ ,07,@@, 7+-+,56+- 1.+ 1..,@@, ,--9=+/ ,6 67+ 3816 ,./ E2+3691.+/ ,0023+/ 1 9. -+38+06 15 67+ 9.09/+.6 6 67,6 69:+ 67+-+ >+-+ =+-?,4 ,46+-0,691.3 ?+6>++. 67+: ,./ 67+-+?@ 67+ ,0023+/1,33,246+/67+3,9/1..,@@,1.7937+,/>967, 3690; -+,/94@ ,=,94,?4+ ,6 67+ 3816 7+-+,56+- ,0023+/ 1C3 ?-167+-3.,:+4@7,./-,3+;7,-9+,0023+/1-,?72/+=, 9+67938+69691.+-,./,.;1?,,--9=+/,667+38160,--@9.<67+ 042?,./,D+0023+/1,33,246+/1..,@@,1.7937+,/ - 4 - >967 67+ ,D+ ,./ 0,23+/ ?4++/9.< 9.F2-9+3 7+-+,56+- 67+ 82?490 <,67+-+/ 67+-+ 61 8,0959+/ 67+ E2,--+4 2+ 61 67+ ,33,246 1..,@@, ,F;2:,- ,./ ,.2:,@@, 3236,9.+/ ?4++/9.<9.F2-9+3,./,441567+:<16,/:966+/9.67+713896,4,3 9.8,69+.6 ,./ 32?3+E2+.64@ ,.2:,@@, 41/<+/ 67+ 01:84,9.6 ?+51-+67+-+381./+.6G81490+,<,9.3667+8+69691.+-,./167+-3 ,./ 96 >,3 -+<936+-+/ 9. -9:+ 1 51- 67+ ,51-+:+.691.+/ 155+.0+3 2-9.< 67+ 012-3+ 15 9.=+369<,691. 67+ -+381./+.6 $ 1490+ ,--+36+/ ,0023+/ 1 G ,.;,88, 1>+=+-67938+69691.+-93,?301./9.<.67+,88-+7+.391.15 ,--+36 7+ ,88-1,07+/ 67+ //9691.,4 936-906 ,./ +3391. (2/<+ ,9072- ,41.< >967 67+ 167+- ,0023+/ 9. -4'9301&% ?2667+3,:+>,3/93:933+/,<,9.366793 8+69691.+- ?@ , 01::1. 1-/+- /,6+/ %H +.0+ 6793 8+69691. H +,-/ 4+,-.+/ 012.3+4 51- 67+ 8+69691.+- 31 ,431 4+,-.+/9<712-61=+-.:+.64+,/+-51--+381./+.6$ 6,6+ & 8,-65-1:2-<9.<3+=+-,401.6+.691.367+4+,-.+/ 012.3+4 51- 6793 8+69691.+- 7,3 8-9:,-94@ 01.6+.6+/ 67,6 6793 8+69691.+- ?+9.< ,0023+/ 1 67+ ,44+<,691. ,<,9.36 79: 93 - 5 - 67,67+7,/,33,246+/67+9.F2-+/ ,F;2:,-1.67+79./81-691. 15 793 7+,/ 1>+=+- 67+ 9.F2-+/ ,F;2:,- ,./ 67+ 167+- 9.F2-+/ 1..,@@, ?167 >+-+ ,/:966+/ 1. ,./ /9307,-<+/ 1. #2-67+- 67+ 9.F2-9+3 3236,9.+/ ?@ 67+:,-+.16495+67-+,6+.9.<9..,62-+.320709-02:36,.0+ 7+8-,@361,441>67+8+69691. % 4+,-.+/ 51- 67+ -+381./+.6 18813+/67+?,948+69691.,./8-,@361/93:93367+3,:+ A 7,=+<9=+.:@,.D912301.39/+-,691.?1671.67+ 32?:93391. :,/+ ?@ 67+ 4+,-.+/ 012.3+4 51- 67+ -+38+069=+ 8,-69+3,./8+-23+/67+/102:+.63,=,94,?4+1.-+01-/ 30124/?+<,67+-+/5-1:67+-+01-/367+,44+<+/ 9.09/+.6>,30,23+/9.-+38+06158,-;9.<15,.261 90;37,> 15 67+ 01:84,9.,.6C3 31.$9.$4,> 9+ ,07,@@, 9. 5-1.6 15 793 3718 7+ ,44+<,691. ,<,9.36 67+ 8+69691.+- ,0023+/ 1 93 67,6 /2-9.< 67+ 012-3+ 15 E2,--+4 ?+6>++. ,0023+/ 13 ,./9.F2-+/67938+69691.+-,431F19.+/67+:,./32?3+E2+.64@ ,33,246+/ 61 ,F;2:,- 1. 67+ ?,0; 81-691. 15 793 7+,/ . 8+-23,41567+-+01-/367+-+>,3,012.6+-0,3+-+<936+-+/?@ 67+ ,0023+/ 8+-31.3 ,<,9.36 67+ 01:84,9.,.6 9. -9:+ - 6 - 1 ?@67+-+381./+.6$81490+9.-+38+066167+3,:+ 9.09/+.643167+-+01-/3/930413+67,667+9.F2-+//9307,-<+/ 5-1:67+713896,4,./67+9.F2-9+33236,9.+/?@79:,-+.16495+ 67-+,6+.9.< 9. .,62-+ . 3207 09-02:36,.0+3 67+ 02361/9,4 9.6+--1<,691. 15 67+ 8+69691.+- /1+3 .16 0,44 51- . 3207 09-02:36,.0+>967126+D8-+339.<,.@189.91.1.67+:+-96315 67+ 0,3+ 325590+ 61 714/ 67,6 67+ 8+69691.+- ,0023+/ 1 0,. ?++.4,-<+/1.,.69098,61-@?,94 7+ -9:9.,4 +69691. 93 9. -+38+06 15 8+69691.+-1 ,0023+/1,./ 9. -+38+06158+69691.+-1 ,0023+/1 7+-+381./+.6$1490+,-+/9-+06+/61-+4+,3+67+ 8+69691.+- ,0023+/ 1 9. 67+ +=+.6 15 793 ,--+36 9. -9:+ 1 -+<936+-+/ ?@ +=,/2-<, 1490+ 6,691. 51- 67+ 155+.0+3 82.937,?4+ 2./+- +0691.3 !" %!" %!" !" -+,/ >967 +0691. !" 15 32?F+06 61 67+ 51441>9.<01./9691.3) 9 7+ +69691.+- ,0023+/ 1 37,44 ,88+,- ?+51-+67+.=+369<,69.<5590+->9679./,@3 5-1: 67+ /,6+ 15 -+0+986 15 67+ 018@ 15 6793 1-/+-,./37,44+D+026+,8+-31.,4?1./51-, - 7 - 32:15 3 $! 28++3.+,;71.4@" >967 6>1 32-+69+3 51- 67+ 49;+32: 61 67+ 3,6935,0691.1567+9.=+369<,69.<15590+- 99 +69691.+- ,0023+/137,44-+<24,-4@,88+,- ?+51-+ 67+ -9,4 12-6 >967126 5,94 2.4+33 +D+:86+/?@67+-9,412-651-=,49/-+,31.3 999 +69691.+- ,0023+/137,44.166,:8+->967 67+ 8-13+02691. >96.+33 ,./ 7+ 37,44 01$ 18+-,6+ >967 67+ 81490+ 51- 9.=+369<,691. ,./ ,88+,-?+51-+67+:>7+.+=+-0,44+/281. 9= 7+8+69691.+- ,0023+/ 1 37,44 .16 9.=14=+ 9.39:94,-155+.0+39.5262-+I ,* %!) ! ' 9361) 41)H