Research › Search › Judgment

High Court of Karnataka · body

2026 DAILYLAW 54241 (KAR)

THE SPECIAL LAND ACQUISITION OFFICER UKP v. BORAMMA S/O VEERBHADRAPPA HADAPPA

MFA/201467/2023 · 2026-01-29

R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally

body2026

Judgment text

Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.

- 1 - !"#"$ % &# # &# "#'" %% ())* +) %% ,, $ %% ,,! $ %% $ %% , $ %% $ %% ,, $ %% ! + ) ! " #! $ " % Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !#& "' $ ' " #' ' "! '&$ ( & & #% )* (% " ( " ! $" ! (+ ((#(+ $" &$ $ ,,+ ) ! " #! $ " % " # " "' ' " #' - 3 - ' "! '&$ ( & &#% # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! (+ (#(+ $" &$ $ ,,!+ ) ! " #! $ " % # "' $ ' " #' ' "! '&$ ( & & #% # )* (% " - 4 - ( " ! $" ! (+ (#(+ $" &$ $ + ) ( ! " #! $ " % # % ( " ,& # "' $ ' " #'" ! ' "! '&$ !# "' $ ' " # #'" ! ' "! '&$ & & #% - 5 - # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! ())#(+ $" &$ $ ,+ ) % & "! '&$ ! " #! $ " % ( # "' $ ' " #' & " ' & "! '&$ " # "' $' " #' & " ' & "! '&$ -( & & % - 6 - # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! ) ()#(+ $" &$ $ + ) % & "! '&$ - ! " #! $ " % #& "' $ ' " #' & " ' & "! '&$ & & % # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! +((( - 7 - $" &$ (#(+ $ ,,+ ) ( ! " #! $ " % # "' $' " # "! '&$ -(( & & % # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! (( ((#(+ $" &$ $ - 8 - !+ ) '&$ ( ! " #! $ " % & # "' $ ' " #' ' "! '&$ & & % # )* (% " ( " ! $" ! ( ./ (#(+ $" &$ (#(+$ 0" $"! & ' ' 1 $ $ 2/3 1 $ " $ & - 9 - # '1 $ $% 45(*)##+# 2678.973:;2997/<./<=;7:4667:=/75548=;7>?3<@7/=2/3 2A263 32=73 (+ B25573 ./ 45((#(+ (#(+ 2/3 (#(+ 2/3 45(())# ()# *# # 2/3 (+#* 267 8.973 :;2997/<./< =;7 :4667:=/755 48 =;7 >?3<@7/= 2/3 2A263 32=73 ) +((( (( 2/3 ( B25573 ./ 45())#(+ ()#(+ (#(+ ((#(+ 2/3 (#(+CD=;7 33.=.4/29.5=6.:=2/3755.4/5$?3<7 2/3=;7 2/3 :E?.5.=.4/7;2C.9.=2=.4/2/3757==97@7/= ?=;46.=D &.>2DB?62 ;7/:7846=; 67876673 =4 25 F=;7 678767/:74?6=0% ;7675B4/37/=5;767./;7/:7846=;67876673=4 25 F=;7 :92.@2/=50% A767 =;7 4A/765 48 92/3 C726./< D4(++# @725?6./< ( 2:67 <?/=25 D4(( @725?6./<2:675*<?/=25D4(#@725?6./<( <?/=25 D4(* @725?6./< + <?/=25 D4(#( - 10 - @725?6./< 2:675 ( <?/=25 D4(+)#* @725?6./< <?/=25 D4(( @725?6./< <?/=25 D4(*# @725?6./< 2:675 (* <?/=25 48 /<2975;A26&.992<72<7A23.29?G ;7 2846752.3 92/35 A767 B64B4573 846 2:E?.5.=.4/ 846 =;7 B?6B457 48 ?92A23 .8= 66.<2=.4/ 64>7:= ./ =76@5 48 2 /4=.8.:2=.4/ ?/376 7:=.4/ (((% 48 =;7.<;==42.64@B7/52=.4/2/362/5B267/:D./ 2/3 :E?.5.=.4/ 7;2C.9.=2=.4/ 2/3 757==97@7/= := ( 32=73 ( 2/3 ( ;7 2/3 :E?.5.=.4/ 88.:76 B25573 2/ 2A263 4/ ((+ 37=76@././< =;7 @26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 B64B76=D 2= 2 5?@ 48 5(# B76 2:67 846 36D 92/3 2/3 5(# B76 2:67 846 .66.<2=7392/3;7:92.@2/=52<<6.7H73CD=;7E?2/=?@48 :4@B7/52=.4/37@2/373;.<;76:4@B7/52=.4/A;.:;A767 67876673 =4 =;7 4?6= ?/376 7:=.4/ ((% 48 =;7 2/3 :E?.5.=.4/ :=(+*6723A.=;7:=.4/*(%48=;7.<;= =4 2.6 4@B7/52=.4/ 2/3 62/5B267/:D ./ 2/3 :E?.5.=.4/ 7;2C.9.=2=.4/ 2/3 757==97@7/= := ( 2/3 54?<;= 678767/:7 A;.:; A25 /?@C7673 25 - 11 - 45((#(+ (#(+ (#(+ ())#(+ ()#(+(#(+((#(+2/3(#(+ * ;77H.37/:748=;7:92.@2/=5A76767:4637325 !(./=;7.6675B7:=.H7:25752/3=;7D@26G73I5(=4 ( ./ =;7.6 675B7:=.H7 :92.@5 ;7 C7/78.:.26D @26G73 I5(=4;7678767/:74?6=28=76:4/5.376./<=;7 4629 2/3 34:?@7/=26D 7H.37/:7 B25573 2/ 2A263 32=73 (+ ) +((( (( 2/3 ( 7/;2/:./< =;7 =4=29 :4@B7/52=.4/=425?@48Rs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s.((#B762:67 .G7A.57 =;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76 ;23 37=76@./73 =;7 @26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 92/3 2:E?.673 ./ 4()# ())#2/3()#2=25?@48Rs.((#B76 2:677=;7678467:4/=7/35=;2=./675B7:=48=;792/35./ /<2975;A26 &.992<7 A;.:; A767 2:E?.673 846 =;7 B?6B457 48=;7?92A23 .8=66.<2=.4/64>7:==;792/32:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76 A25 48 =;7 4B./.4/ =;2= 2 ?/.846@ @26G7= H29?7 :4?93C72BB9.737=;7678467:4/=7/35=;2=7H7/25B76 =;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76 299 =;7 92/35 =;2= A767 2:E?.673.//<2975A;26H.992<7A7675.@.9269D5.=?2=72/3 =;7678467 ;7 ;23 37=76@./73 =;7 52@7 @26G7= H29?7 ./ 675B7:= 48 299 =;7 92/35 =;2= A767 2:E?.673 7 =;?5 :4/=7/35 =;2= =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;2H./< 52=.58.73 =;7 :92.@5 - 14 - @237./ 45()#()#2/3())# :2//4=/4A:;2997/<7=;7:4@B7/52=.4/37=76@./73CD=;7 678767/:74?6= ;7 9726/73 33.=.4/29 3H4:2=7 "7/7629 82.69D 5?C@.==73 =;2= ./ 675B7:= 48 45()# ())# 2/3 ()# =;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ .5 296723D B2.3 2/3 =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;25 52=.58.73 =;7 2A263 ;7 ;4A7H76 :4/=7/373 =;2= C78467 2BB9D./< =;7 B6.:7 37=76@./73CD=;7678767/:74?6=./ 45()# ())# 2/3 ()# .= .5 ./:?@C7/= ?B4/ =;.5 4?6= =4 944G ./=4 =;7 E?75=.4/ A;7=;76 299 =;7 92/35 ./H49H73 ./ 45()# ())# 2/3 ()# 267 5.@.9269D 5.=?2=7 25 =;7 92/35 ./ E?75=.4/ ;7 :4/=7/35 =;2= A;7/ =;767 .5 /4 7H.37/:7 =4 =;2= 7887:= =;.5 4?6= :2//4= 2BB9D =;7 52@7 2/3 ?B;493 =;7 2A2635B25573CD=;7678767/:74?6= + !7 ;2H7 :4/5.37673 =;7 5?C@.55.4/5 48 =;7 9726/73 33.=.4/29 3H4:2=7 "7/7629 846 =;7 C7/78.:.26D 2/3=;79726/73:4?/579846=;7675B4/37/=5 - 15 - ( = .5 /4= ./ 3.5B?=7 =;2= 92/35 ./ /<2975;A26 H.992<7 A767 2:E?.673 846 =;7 B?6B457 48 ?92A23 ./46 66.<2=.4/64>7:=;792/35./E?75=.4/A767299/4=.8.73./ =76@5482/4=.8.:2=.4/32=73(2/3( .G7A.57=;792/35./D4((+#((#(2/3(#(48 /<2975A;26 H.992<7 A767 2954 2:E?.673 ./ =76@5 48 =;7 /4=.8.:2=.4/32=73(/675B7:=48299=;792/35./ /<2975;A26 H.992<7 =;7 92/3 2:E?.5.=.4/ 488.:76 ;23 37=76@./73 =;7 @26G7= H29?7 48 =;7 92/3 2:E?.673 2= 2 5?@ 48 Rs.((# B76 2:67 ;7678467 7H7/ ./ =;7 :4/=7@B92=.4/ 48 =;7 C7/78.:.26D 299 =;7 92/35 ./ /<2975;A26H.992<7A7675.@.9269D5.=?2=732/3=;76784672 ?/.846@B6.:7A258.I7325=;7@26G7=H29?7;7678767/:7 4?6= ;23 7/;2/:73 =;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ ./ 45()# ())# 2/3 ()# ./ 675B7:= 48 D45((+#( (#( (#( 48 /<2975;A26&.992<7 ;7 52.32A263.5/4A52=.58.73CD=;7C7/78.:.26D;7678467 =;767 .5 /4 76646 ./ =;7 46376 B25573 CD =;7 678767/:7 4?6= 7/;2/:./< =;7 :4@B7/52=.4/ =4 2 5?@ 48 - 16 - 5(# B76 <?/=2 25 =;7 C7/78.:.26D ;25 296723D 52=.58.73=;72A263./ 45()#())#2/3 ()# (( /=;2=H.7A48=;7@2==76.=:2//4=/4A9.7./ =;7@4?=;48=;7C7/78.:.26D=;2==;7>?3<@7/=2/32A263 B25573CD=;7678767/:74?6=.57I:755.H746A.=;4?=2/D C25.57/:7299=;7572BB7295267 ( /D 2@4?/= ./ 37B45.= .5 4637673 =4 C7 =62/5876673=4=;7678767/:74?6=846/7:75526D463765 -+ (#* # -+ ("#'"* # # .5=4'(94'