- 1 - !!" #$% ! & ' ! "#$#% & '(( ) "# * "# + Digitally signed by VARSHA N RASALKAR Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - "# & ' ,*- ( +) . ** ** . ""** /" ) . $ +** # . 0 ( 123451236147896:15;83<=1>1<?<?8613 * 123614 44?<?8625 8@136A16< 4@872<1 ?: 4?317<14 <8 <2B1 68<?71 ;83 31:>86416< 8: 264 * 3?94=?3:?6C=?D2>935123614 1>9<E85?7?<83161325 8;64?2?:4?317<14<8<2B168<?71;8331:>86416<8+ + 1<?<?8613 F2: ::87?2<1 ?317<83 8; 264 17834: 264 2;<13 2<<2?6?6C :9>1326692<?86 =1 ;?514 - 3 - >16:?86>2>13:G1;831<=131:>86416<29<=83?<?1::11B?6C <8 4?:G93:1 =?: >16:?86 2:14 86 F=?7= <=1 31:>86416< 29<=83?<?1:C326<14<=1>16:?86264:1<<=1>16:?86;83<=1 2A896< 8; :" 78AA9<14 >16:?86 F2: :1< 2< :#"264<=178AA9<142A896<8;:#"?:<8 G141497<149><8+**+:<23<?6C;38A* % 1<?<?8613 A241 2 31>31:16<2<?86 42<14 ** G1;831 <=1 31:>86416< 29<=83?<?1: :11B?6C 31497<?86 8; <=1 41497<?86 >13?84 ;83 <=1 78AA9<2<?86 2A896< ;38A # E123: <8 E123: 264 $ A86<=: 8F1@13 <=1 :2A1 F2: 68< 786:?41314 1671 <=1 >1<?<?8613?:>13;83714<82>>3827=<=?:893< # 1236147896:15;83<=1>1<?<?8613786<164:<=2< <=18"834?62<1167=8;<=?:893<2< =23F24167=?6 .8#*%%**#264<=13?67?>25167=16C25939 ?6 .8*+%%$**% =2@1 786:?41314 :?A?523 >32E13 8; 8<=13 1A>58E11: 264 :<2E14 <=1 41497<?86 ;38A <=1 >16:?86<?:25:8:9GA?<<14GE<=151236147896:15;83<=1 - 4 - >1<?<?8613 <=2< <=1 8"834?62<1 167= 8; <=?: 893< ?6 .8$+**# 2< =23F24 167= 264 .8***% 2< <=1 3?67?>25 167= 26C25939 >2::14 26 83413 4?317<?6C <=1 31:>86416< 29<=83?<?1: <8 786:?413 <=1 31>31:16<2<?86 8; <=1 >1<?<?8613: <=131?6 =131;831<=1>1<?<?8613:11B::?A?52383413?6=?:;2@893 2: =1 ?: :?A?5235E >52714 2: <=2< 8; <=8:1 >1<?<?8613: 6 @?1F 8; 686"786:?4132<?86 8; <=1 31>31:16<2<?86 :8 A241 GE <=1 >1<?<?8613 42<14 ** 2< 661H931" =1 ?: G1;831<=?:893< 2@?6C =1234 <=1 5123614 7896:15 ;83 <=1 >1<?<?8613 264 <=1 5123614 44?<?8625 8@136A16< 4@872<1 2>>123?6C ;83 31:>86416<"<2<1 264 86 >139:25 8; <=1 83413: 315?14 9>86 GE <=1 >1<?<?8613 F=?7= 231 2661H14<8<=1>1<?<?86<=?:893<411A:?<2>>38>3?2<1<8 2558F<=1 >1<?<?86 F?<= 24?317<?86<8 786:?413>1<?<?8613I: 31>31:16<2<?8642<14** "?6<=1A26613B68F6<8 52F264?62778342671<8<=1:?A?52383413:>2::14GE<=?: 893<86<=11235?138772:?86 - 5 - 77834?6C5E>2::<=1;8558F?6C ? =1>1<?<?86?:2558F14 ?? =1 F3?< 8; A2642A9: ?: ?::914 4?317<?6C 31:>86416< 8* <8 786:?413 <=1 31>31:16<2<?86 8; <=1 >1<?<?8613 42<14 ** 2< 661H931" 264 >2:: :9?<2G51 83413: F?<=?6 2 >13?84 8; 1?C=< F11B: ;38A <=1 42<1 8; 3171?>< 8; 78>E 8; <=?:83413 ??? < ?: 25:8 611451:: <8 A16<?86 <=2< 68 3178@13E>387114?6C::=255G1?6?<?2<1496<?5 786:?4132<?86 8; <=1 31>31:16<2<?86 8; <=1 >1<?<?86131<?<?8613?:2<5?G13<E<8>384971 26E 244?<?8625 A2<13?25 ?6 :9>>83< 8; =?: 72:1G1;831<=178671361429<=83?<?1: () & !' % ++