Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54209 (KAR)
PRUTHIVIRAJ CHAVAN v. UNION OF INDIA
CRL.P/200035/2026 · 2026-01-28
Rajesh Rai K
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54209 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54209 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! "
#$!! $
%&'%()*&%) +
! " # $
%
%
&'! " # $
%
(%#$ %
#)$ ) & &!'*
% %% #+$ '#+$ #+$ ( &( % # % %
Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
$
%
% )
,
, -
./0123/3/45/06/7289582:
2+3/45 46
' ;<3.2123/3/452:=++90284&64:>:=5346:2>97=:;=/7/5 :/?2 4&!'* :2>/032:28 ;< =:+43/+ 453:47 9:2=9 25>=79:9 8=328 (&'' 64: 3.2 46625+20195/0.=;729582:
2+3/450#+$'#+$#+$=58 (46
+3&(
.2 6=+39=7 ?=3:/@ 46 3.2 +=02 /0 3.=3 45 (&'' = +:28/;72 /564:?=3/45 A=0 :2+2/B28 6:4? = :27/=;72 049:+2 34 3.2
9;5012+34: 46 =:+43/+0 453:47 9:2=9 =5>=74:2 *45=7 5/3 =5>=74:2 3.=3 = 1=:+27 0./1?253A/3.3:=+C/5>4(&' D(&/07=</5>=33.2 466/+246
9;58/=40366/+298;//8=:/03:/+3=58/3 /009012+32834;2+453=/5/5>5=:+43/+8:9>0=58A/3.3.2 :2+2/B2: 5=?2 E:93.B/:=F .=B=5 #=++9028 4&$
- 3 -
:20/8253 46 4902 4D 52=: =59?=5 =58/:
=:C448 =58= 98;/ =0=B=C=7<=5 /8=: /03:/+3 3.=3 3.20=/8:2+2/B2:A4978+4?234+4772+33.20=/81=:+2745 '&'' 0 09+. 3.2 +4?17=/5=53 =745> A/3. 3.2 912:/53258253*/5&.=0+4503/39328=745> A/3. 3.2 32=? :2=+.28 3.2 403 66/+2 =3 (,'' =? 45 '&'' =58 25G9/:28 =;493 3.2 0./1?253 3 /0 /564:?28343.2?;<3.240366/+2466/+/=703.=3:93.B/:=F .=B=5 .=0 ;225 +=77/5> 6:4? ?4;/72 4! !DDD 34 9C=:=?45./0?4;/724(D'D& !&&
++4:8/5>7< 3.2 32=? =745>A/3. 1=5+.=0 ?49532809:B2/77=5+2=33.240366/+2=58A=/328=33.=3 3/?2=;493&, '1?3.2123/3/452:B/0/3283.240366/+2 =58+7=/?283.20./1?253=581403?=5=632:+.2+C/5>3.2 =8.=:+=:8.=58284B2:3.20=/81=:+27 ++4:8/5>7<3.2 32=? +=9>.3 .478 3.2 123/3/452: =58 45 25G9/:< /3 A=0 :2B2=728 3.=3 3.2 1=:+27 +453=/50 3.2 09;03=5+2 46 1=12: ;7430 =58 =704 =0./0. ++4:8/5>7< 3.2 466/+/=70 +4589+328 1=5+.=5=?= /5 3.2 403 66/+2 =58
- 4 -
02/H28 3.2 0=?2 5 A2/>./5> 3.2 0=?2
A2/>.28 &D >:=?0 =58 =0./0. A2/>.28 &(( >:=?0 ++4:8/5>7< =028 45 3.2 % +=02 A=0 :2>/032:28 /5 :/?2 4&!'* =58 :=/8 A=0 +4589+328 ++4:8/5>7<3.2123/3/452:A=0=::20328=58./003=32?253 A=0:2+4:828=58/3A=0:2B2=7283.=33.209;03=5+2A=0 0253 ;< ?:93. 564047 88:200&'
=:=0A=3/ 4902 2.:97=+2!52=:
45=
A223!9/78/5>2A27./ ;<04?203:=5>2:
=32:45G9203/455=/:2463.2123/3/452:/3A=0 69:3.2::2B2=7283.=3452:93./C:=FA=04:82:283.20=/8 +450/>5?253 3:=+C 6:4? 27./ 64: 0277/5> 3.2 0=?2 /5 25>=79:9 =58 =5>=79:9 3.:49>. 452 4.8
46/<=5 46 9339: %4: 3.2 0=/8 3:=+C 3.2 =?4953 A=0 1=/8 ;< 452 :93./C:=F /2 =++9028 4 3.4:9>. ./0 ?4;/72 1.452 .2:2=632: :201458253147/+2 =704 =::20328 3.2 0=/8 :93./C:=F=++90284
.2 123/3/452: /0 /5 +90348< 6:4? '&'' >>:/2B28;<3.20=?23.2123/3/452:=11:4=+.283.2
- 5 -
887/03I
200/450 98>2/8=:
/33/5>=3=0=B=C=7<=5 /5 :7/0+4 ' .2 0=?2 A=0 :2F2+328 B/82 4:82:8=328' &'25+23./0123/3/45 D 2=:872=:528+49502764:3.2123/3/452:=583.2 72=:528
64:3.2:201458253 ! 1=:3 6:4? 9:>/5> 02B2:=7 +453253/450 72=:528 +495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452: 1:/?=:/7< +45325328 3.=3 3.2 +450/>5?253 6:4?
3.2 403 66/+2 A=0 02/H28 45 '&''=3=;493&, '1?=583.2=++9028123/3/452:
A=0 3=C25 34 +90348< 45 3.2 0=?2 8=< =58 =::20328 45 '&&' 3/77 3.25 .2 A=0 C213 /5 /772>=7 +90348< 3 /0 69:3.2: +45325828 3.=3 3.2 0./1?253 A=0 02/H28 =3 3.2 /503=5+2 46 3.2 123/3/452: A./72 :2+2/B/5> 3.2 0=?2 3.2 123/3/452:A=0=;0479327<543=A=:2=;4933.2+453253046 3.21=:+27/23.20=?2+453=/5283.25=:+43/+09;03=5+2 0 09+. 3.2:2 A=0 54 +450+/490 1400200/45 46 3.2 123/3/452:
- 6 -
2 69:3.2: +45325828 3.=3 /5 3.2 03=32?253 46 3.2 123/3/452: 9582:
2+3/45 D! .2 +=32>4:/+=77< 03=328 3.=3 3.2 1=:+27 A=0 0253 6:4? 27./ ;< 04?2 95C54A5 12:045=5864:4;3=/5/5>3.20=/81=:+273.2=?4953A=0 1=/8;<452:93./C:=F/2=++90284 ( %9:3.2: =++9028 4 =704 +=32>4:/+=77< 03=328 /5 ./0 03=32?253 3.=3 3.2 123/3/452: A=0 52/3.2: =A=:2 =;4933.2
4:.=0./0./53.21=:+2754:.2+4509?/5> =5<8:9> 73.49>.3.2=88:20046:93.B/:=F.=B=5A=0 +72=:=58=11:4=+.=;72;<3.274+=71403?=5.2+45B2<28 3.2 =88:200 46 :93.B/:=F .=B=5 .2 02/H28 8:9> A=0 ;44C28 ;< 452 4.8
46/<=5 34 0277 3.2 0=?2 =3 25>=79:9 =58 =5>=79:9 5 09+. +/:+9?03=5+2 3.2 123/3/452: A=0 =;0479327< 95=A=:2 =;493 3.2 1=:+27 =58 A=054A=<+450+/4907<1400200283.28:9>04:/5B47B28/5 3.2=772>2846625+2 &' 4A3.2466/+/=70/53.2:2?=58=117/+=3/45 +72=:7< 03=328 3.=3 69:3.2: /5B203/>=3/45 46 3.2 123/3/452: 8420 543 +=77 64: 5 09+. +/:+9?03=5+2 +90348/=7
- 7 -
/5+=:+2:=3/45 46 3.2 123/3/452: 8420 543 +=77 64: ++4:8/5>7<1:=<034=774A3.2123/3/45 && 72=:528
41140283.2123/3/45 ++4:8/5>34./?3.203=32?253463./0123/3/452:+491728 A/3. =++9028 4 +72=:7< :2B2=728 3.=3 ;43. 46 3.2? ;< C54A/5>7< 4;3=/528 3.2 8:9> 3.:49>. 1403=7 821=:3?253 =58 3./0 123/3/452: A=0 B2:< ?9+. =A=:2 =;493 3.2 +4532530463.21=:+27=58.2:2+2/B283.20=?2 009+. 3.20=?2A=002/H286:4?./0+450+/4901400200/45 & 2 =704 +45325828 3.=3 3.2
02/H28 =3 3.2 /503=5+2463.2123/3/452:A=0/5+4??2:+/=7G9=53/3<.2 1=5+.=5=?= =58 43.2: 03=32?2530 46 3.2 123/3/452: =58 =++90284+72=:7<?=C20493=
+=02=>=/503 3./0 123/3/452: =58 =0 12: 3.2 1:209?13/45 9582:
2+3/45 463.2 +3=33./003=>23.2=++9028123/3/452:+=5543 ;2257=:>2845;=/7 ++4:8/5>7<.21:=<0348/0?/003.2 123/3/45
- 8 -
& .=B2>/B25?<=5@/490+450/82:=3/45;43.45 3.2 09;?/00/450 ?=82 ;< 3.2 72=:528 +495027 64: 3.2 :2012+3/B21=:3/20=5884+9?2530=B=/7=;7245:2+4:8 & 0+4978;2>=3.2:286:4?:2+4:80/3/0543/5 8/01932 3.=3 = 1=:+27 A=0 :2+2/B28 ;< 3./0 123/3/452: 45 '&'' 6:4?
3.2 403 66/+2 .2 0=/8 1=:+27 A=0 =88:20028 /5 3.2 5=?2 46 123/3/452: 4A2B2: =632:
02/H9:2 46 3.2 1=:+27 3.2 466/+/=70 :2+4:828 3.2 03=32?253463./0123/3/452:A.2:2/5.2.=0+72=:7<03=328 3.=33.21=:+27A=00253;<04?203:=5>2:6:4?2A27./ & 9;02G92537< 3.2 03=32?253 :2+4:828 ;< 3./0 123/3/452::2B2=703.25=?246:/3./C:=F=++90284 0 09+.47/+2=::20328./?=58:2+4:828./003=32?253 ;< A=< G9203/455=/:2 45 '&&' A.2:2/5 .2 .=0 03=3283.=3E123/3/452:A=0543=A=:2=;493=5<8:9>054:
.2/0543+4509?/5>=5<8:9>0J 73.49>.3.2=88:20046 123/3/452: A=0 +72=: =58 =11:4=+.=;72 ;< 3.2 74+=7 1403?=5=++90284+45B2<283.2123/3/452:=88:20034 4.8
46/<=5 3 /0 69:3.2: 03=328 3.=3 3.2 02/H28 8:9>0
- 9 -
A=0 ;44C28 ;< 452 4.8
46/<=5 34 0277 3.2 0=?2 /5 25>=79:9=58=5>=79:9 &D 3 3./0 03=>2 3.2 03=32?253 46 +4=++9028 /2 =++90284+=5;2:27/28=012:1:4B/0/45046
+3 =58 .2 .=0 +72=:7< 03=328 3.=3 3.2:2 /0 54 /5B47B2?253 A.=3042B2: 46 3./0 123/3/452: 2@+213 :2+2/B/5> 3.2 1=:+27 =58 3.2 123/3/452: A=0 95=A=:2 46 3.2 +4532530 46 3.2 1=:+27 =3 3.2 3/?2 46 :2+2/B/5> 3.2 0=?2 0 09+. 3.2 +450+/490 1400200/45 46 3.2 123/3/452: /0 543 64:3.+4?/5> 1:/?=:/7<=33./003=>2 &! /5+2 3.2 123/3/452: /0 /5 F98/+/=7 +90348< 6:4? 7=03 ?453.0 =58 3.2 :201458253147/+2 .=B2 =7:2=8< 09;?/33283.2:2?=58=117/+=3/4569:3.2:/532::4>=3/4546 3.2 123/3/452: /0 543 +=7728 64: 5 09+. +/:+9?03=5+2 A/3.4932@1:200/5>=5<41/5/45453.2?2:/30463.2+=02 =58 ?4:24B2: .2 /0 3.2 :20/8253 46 /8=: 3.2 123/3/452: +=5;2257=:>2845:2>97=:;=/7 & .2123/3/45/0
- 10 -
&( .2123/3/452:/08/:2+32834;2257=:>2845;=/7 /5 :/?2 4&!'* :2>/032:28 ;<
25>=79:964:3.246625+20195/0.=;729582:
2+3/450#+$ '#+$ #+$ =58 ( 46
+3 &( 09;F2+3 34 3.2 64774A/5>+458/3/450, =$ 23/3/452:0.=772@2+932=12:045=7;45864:
= 09? 46 0&''''' A/3. 3A4 09:23/20 64: 3.2 7/C209? 34 3.2 0=3/06=+3/45 46 3.2 F9:/08/+3/45=749:3K ;$ .2 123/3/452: 0.=77 =112=: :2>97=:7< 45 =77 3.2 8=320 46 .2=:/5> ;264:2 3.2 :/=7 49:3 957200 3.2 :/=7 49:3 2@2?130 ./0 =112=:=5+264:B=7/8:2=0450K +$ .2123/3/452:0.=775438/:2+37<4:/58/:2+37< 3.:2=325 4: 3=?12: A/3. 3.2 1:402+93/45 A/3520020K 8$ .2 123/3/452: 0.=77 543 /5B47B2 /5 0/?/7=: 46625+20/56939:2K 2$ .2 123/3/452: 0.=77 543 72=B2 3.2 F9:/08/+3/45 46 3.2 :/=7 49:3 A/3.493 12:?/00/45 46 3.2 0=/8 49:3953/7 3.2 +=02 :2>/032:28=>=/503./?/08/014028466K
- 11 -
6$ .2 123/3/452: 0.=77 ?=:C ./0 =33258=5+2 ;264:2 3.2 45 &03
958=< 46 2B2:< ?453.;23A225&'''=?=58'&''1? 3/77 3.2 +=02 :2>/032:28 =>=/503 ./? /0 8/014028466;264:23.2:/=749:3K >$ .2123/3/452:0.=7709::2582:./01=0014:3 /6=5<;264:23.2
200/45049:3
,* %!) ! ,&
,&D 3K:F