- 1 - ! " #$!! $ %& %'()& %( * ! " # ! $ % & ' ! ' ! " ( ! $ Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % ' ) " & '" ' % &* " ' %& ' "!" ' '' %"&! %&' "!" %&%+&%,&"%&' % ' & ( ( ' ' ' - - . /0,123030450,607289582+2:3045* "46 "!";< 3/2 123030452+,=::9,28 4, =58 " 64+ >+=53 46 =530:01=34+< ;=0705+0?2 4 "!"8=328"!"!"+2>0,32+28;<3/2 274>0 470:2 3=3045 =7=;9+=>0 64+ 3/2 46625:2, 1950,/=;72 9582+ 2:3045, %"& ! +@ 2:3045 %& 46 /=+=30<= <=<==5/03=%64+,/4+3A B&"!"=582:3045,%&%+&%,& =58 "%C& 46 % +2C253045 46 3+4:0302,& :3 ( ( %64+ ,/4+3A% & :3B& " /2 6=:39=7 ?=3+0D 46 3/2 :=,2 0, 3/=3 +2,1458253 4"B, ,45 452 =53/4,/ %54@ 82:2=,28 05 3/0, :=,2& >43 - 3 - ?=++028123030452+ 4=::9,28 493463/2@2874:E3/2< /=C2 3@4 :/078+25 ::9,28 4" F =77=11= +2,082, =3 3/2 /49,2 =8G=:253 34 3/2 /49,2 46 =53/4,/ 3/2+2;< =::9,28 4" 82C274128 0770:03 0530?=:< @03/ =::9,28 4 /2 ,=?2 :=?2 34 3/2 E54@728>2 46 3/2 82:2=,28=53/4,/ , ,9:/ +2,1458253 4" 82:2=,28 =58 43/2+ +27=30C2, =8C0,28 123030452+,=::9,28 4, =58 " 543 34 05897>2 05 ,9:/ =:3, 4@2C2+ 123030452+, 3/+2=32528 +2,1458253 4" =58 3/2 82:2=,28 64+ 4;G2:305> 3/20+ 2D3+= ?=+03=7 +27=3045,/01 3 0, 69+3/2+ ,3=328 3/=3 =::9,28 4123030452+ 4 02 @062 46 3/282:2=,28H9=++2728@03/3/282:2=,28=32+,/2/2+,276 =58=::9,28 4",3=+32834+2,082,21=+=327<=3=7=;9+=>005 =+25328/49,2=583/2+2=632+3/2<;43/@25334=/=+=,/3+= , ,9:/ 3/2 82:2=,28 @253 34 821+2,,045 ,05:2 /0, @062 02 =::9,28 4@253=745>@03/=::9,28 4"'9+3/2+=::9,28 4 0, 3/2 4@52+ 46 ;+0:E E075 =;9,28 3/2 82:2=,28 ;< ?25304505> /0, :=,32 64+ 543 8405> /0, @4+E =632+ 3=E05> =8C=5:2 34 84 3/2 ,=?2 25:2 3/2 82:2=,28 :4??03328 ,90:08245("!"=3=;493!!!=?;</=5>05>05/0, /49,225:23/2:4?17=053/=,;225748>28;<3/26=3/2+46 - 4 - 3/2 82:2=,28 02 +2,1458253 4" ;264+2 +2,1458253 4 470:2 5 3/2 ,3+25>3/ 46 ,=08 :4?17=053 3/2 +2,1458253 4 470:2 +2>0,32+28 = ' 05 :+0?2 4 "!" 64+ 3/2 =64+2?25304528 46625:2, =>=05,3 3/2 123030452+, =58 =543/2+ C2+,05:26+4?3/28=3246+2>0,3+=304546'3/2+2,1458253 4 470:2=+2?=E05>/2:30:=332?1334=++2,33/2123030452+, 5=11+2/25,045463/20+=++2,33/2123030452+,=11+4=:/28 8803045=7 0,3+0:3 =58 2,,045, 98>2 =3 =7=;9+=>0 05 +70,: 4 I"!"64+>+=5346=530:01=34+<;=074@2C2+ 3/2,=?2@=,80,?0,,28C0824+82+8=328"""!"25:2 3/0,12303045 * 2=+8 72=+528 :495,27 64+ 3/2 123030452+, =58 72=+528 0>/ 49+3 4C2+5?253 72=82+ 64+ +2,1458253 4 3=32 /49>/ 5430:2 0, ,2+C28 34 +2,1458253 4" /2 +2?=0528=;,253 1=+3 6+4? 9+>05> ,2C2+=7 :453253045, 72=+528 :495,27 64+ 3/2 123030452+, /=, :45325828 3/=3 3/2 82:2=,28 :4??03328,90:08245("!"@/2+2=,3/2123030452+,@2+2 052D3+=?=+03=7=66=0+64+,2C2+=7<2=+,@/0:/@=,E54@5343/2 - 5 - 82:2=,28'05=77<3/2<;43/@25334=/=+=,/3+==58,3=+328 34 +2,082 3/2+2 5 ,9:/ :0+:9?,3=5:2, 3/2+2 =+2 54 ,9:/ 05,30>=3045 34 3/2 82:2=,28 34 :4??03 ,90:082 ;< 3/2 123030452+, ::4+805>7</21+=<,34=774@3/212303045 I 72=+5280>/49+34C2+5?253 72=82+ 4114,28343/2;=0712303045=581+=<,3480,?0,,3/2,=?2 # , :4978 ;2 >=3/2+28 6+4? +2:4+8, 3/2 :4?17=053 =C2+?253, 80,:74,2 3/=3 =632+ 3/2 ?=++0=>2 46 =::9,28 4 =58 82:2=,28 3/2< ;2>43325 3@4 :/078+25 =32+ 3/2 =::9,28 4"02123030452+ 4"82C274128=52D3+=?=+03=7=66=0+@03/ =::9,28 402123030452+ 4=58,/272633/2:4?1=5<46 82:2=,28 =58 ,3=+328 34 +2,082 =745> @03/ =::9,28 4" =3 =/=+=,/3+= /2 ,=08 6=:3 @=, @277 @03/05 3/2 E54@728>2 46 82:2=,28 /2 +2:4+8, 69+3/2+ 80,:74,2 3/=3 3/2+2 @=, = 1=5:/=<=3@=,=7,4:45C2528343/=32662:3/4@2C2+=::9,28 4 :45305928 3/2 +27=3045,/01 @03/ =::9,28 4" 5 ,9:/ :0+:9?,3=5:2, 3/2+2@=,54,9:/05,30>=3045;<3/2 123030452+,348+0C23/282:2=,2834:4??03,90:08225:23/2 :9,3480=7 0532++4>=3045 46 3/2 123030452+,=::9,28 4, =58 " 842, 543 :=77 64+ 05 3/0, :=,2 25:2 @03/493 2D1+2,,05> =5< - 6 - 4105045 45 3/2 ?2+03, 46 3/2 :=,2 ,9660:2 34 /478 3/=3 3/2 123030452+,=::9,28 4, =58 " =+2 25303728 64+ =530:01=34+< ;=07 /2+0?05=7 23030450, ( /2+2,1458253 4 470:2=+280+2:32834+272=,2 3/2123030452+,=::9,28 4,=58"053/22C253463/20+=++2,3 05+0?2 4 "!"+2>0,32+28;<3/2 274>0 470:23=3045 =7=;9+=>064+3/246625:2,1950,/=;729582+2:3045,%"& ! +@2:3045%&46 "!"=582:3045,%&%+&%,&=58 "%C&46% & :3,9;G2:3343/264774@05>:45803045,- 0& /2 123030452+, ,/=77 =112=+ ;264+2 3/2 5C2,30>=305>660:2+@03/058=<,6+4?3/2 8=32 46+2:2013 46 3/2 :41< 46 3/0, 4+82+ =58 ,/=77 2D2:932 = 12+,45=7 ;458 64+ = ,9? 46 ,!!!!! %9122, 52 =E/ 457<& 2=:/ @03/ 3@4 ,9+2302, 64+ 3/2 70E2,9? 34 3/2 ,=30,6=:3045463/205C2,30>=305>4660:2+ 00& 23030452+, ,/=77 +2>97=+7< =112=+ ;264+2 3/2 +0=7 49+3 @03/493 6=07 9572,, 2D2?1328 ;< 3/2+0=749+364+C=708+2=,45, 000& 23030452+, ,/=77 543 3=?12+ @03/ 3/2 1+4,2:93045 @0352,,2, =58 3/2< ,/=77 :4 - 7 - 412+=32 @03/ 3/2 1470:2 64+ 05C2,30>=3045 =58 =112=+;264+23/2?@/252C2+:=77289145 0C& /2 123030452+, ,/=77 543 05C47C2 05 ,0?07=+ 46625:2,056939+2) +) %!( ! 0,3 4-7 4-