- 1 - ! "#$$ # % %&'( %' ) !"#$ % & & !"#$ '! ( ! ) * +! ! ! !! ** "#"$ % ! !! # !,"#$ ' ! ( !*- *%) Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - !* #%*!() "%#*( &)! ! ! $%$%" * ** ! ()(.) ()(/) (%)(01) * (!) "(%) #() "(%)"%& (")*%$%* %$%" * + ! ! ! * * ! ! * ! * & 2 2 3 45/ 6785859: 5/ ;5<7=>:=7. 7?859: "%# 9; 41.185@1 1A1.5B >.1B/41 1:4581 %$% 89 C>1/4 6.9?77=5:A/ 1A15:/8 847 6785859:7./1??>/7= 9/% 1:= 5: 67?51< 1/79$%$%"1.5/5:A9>89;.5D79%$%" .7A5/87.7= E@ 9<A>DE1F !9<5?7 5G1@16>. ;9. 847 9;;7:?7/ 6>:5/41E<7 >:=7. 7?859:/ "(%) #() "(%)1:="%.H7?859:(")9;%$%1:=>:=7. 7?859:/()(.)()(/)1:=(%)(01)9;(!)?8 67:=5:A9:847;5<79;==<5/8.5?81:=7//59:/ >=A7 5G1@16>.1 - 3 - % 71.:7=?9>:/7<;9.8476785859:7./1:=<71.:7= ?9>:/7<;9..7/69:=7:89%G95:8<@/>ED58841884761.857/ 41071D5?1E<@ /788<7= 847=5/6>87E78H77: 847D 1:=847 ?9D6<15:1:8.7/69:=7:8 9% 1A.77= 89 H584=.1H 847 ?9D6<15:8<9=A7=E@45D1A15:/88476785859:7./ 9H707. 847 9;;7:?7/ ?41.A7= 1A15:/8 847 6785859:7./ 1.7 :98 ?9D69>:=1E<7 5: :18>.7 5:?7 847 61.857/ /788<7= 847 =5/6>87H45?45/8981<<@6.501875::18>.7847 9:3E<767I 9>.8 5: 847 ?1/79; .769.87=5: 47<=5: 61.191/>:=7.2 J 9:/5=7.5:A 847 <1H 9: 847 695:8 1:= 847 9847. =7?5/59:/9;845/9>.89:847695:8.7;7..7=8947.75:1E907585/ 9E/7.07=1:=47<=1/>:=7.2 5)841884769H7.?9:;7..7=>:=7.7?859:#% 9; 847 9=7 89 C>1/4 847 ?.5D5:1< 6.9?77=5:A/ ;9. 847 :9:?9D69>:=1E<7 9;;7:?7/ >:=7. 7?859: %$ 9;8479=7?1:E77I7.?5/7=4105:A907.H47<D5:A<@ 1:= 6.7=9D5:1:8<@ 847 ?505< ?41.1?87. 61.85?><1.<@ 849/7 1.5/5:A 9>8 9; ?9DD7.?51< 8.1:/1?859:/ 9. 1.5/5:A 9>8 9; D18.5D9:51< .7<1859:/456 9. ;1D5<@ =5/6>87/ 1:= H47: 847 61.857/ 4107 .7/9<07= 847 7:85.7=5/6>871D9:A/8847D/7<07/- 55)/>?469H7.5/ :9889 E77I7.?5/7= 5: 849/7 6.9/7?>859:/ H45?4 5:09<07= 475:9>/ 1:= /7.59>/ 9;;7:?7/ 9; D7:81< =76.1058@ 9. 9;;7:?7/ <5B7 - 4 - D>.=7. .167 =1?958@ 78? >?4 9;;7:?7/ 1.7 :98 6.50187 5: :18>.7 1:= 4107 1 /7.59>/ 5D61?8 9: /9?578@- 555)/5D5<1.<@/>?469H7.5/:9889E77I7.?5/7= ;9. 847 9;;7:?7/ >:=7. 847 /67?51< /818>87/ <5B7 !.707:859: 9; 9..>6859: ?8 9. 847 9;;7:?7/ ?9DD5887=E@6>E<5?/7.01:8/H45<7H9.B5:A5:8418 ?161?58@1.7:9889E7C>1/47=D7.7<@9:847E1/5/ 9;?9D6.9D5/7E78H77:84705?85D1:=8479;;7:=7.- 50) 9;;7:?7/ >:=7. 7?859: $K ! 1:= 847 .D/?878?H9><= ;1<< 5: 847?187A9.@9; 475:9>/ 1:=/7.59>/9;;7:?7/1:=847.7;9.71.789E78.7187= 1/ ?.5D7 1A15:/8 847 /9?578@ 1:= :98 1A15:/8 847 5:=505=>1< 1<9:7 1:= 847.7;9.7 847 ?.5D5:1< 6.9?77=5:A/ ;9. 847 9;;7:?7 >:=7. 7?859: $K ! 1:=9. 847 .D/ ?8 78? H45?4 4107 1 /7.59>/ 5D61?89:847/9?578@?1::98E7C>1/47=5:7I7.?5/7 9; 69H7./ >:=7. 7?859: #% 9; 847 9=7 9: 847 A.9>:= 8418 847 61.857/ 4107 .7/9<07= 8475. 7:85.7 =5/6>87 1D9:A/8 847D/7<07/ 9H707. 847 5A4 9>.8 H9><= :98 .7/8 58/ =7?5/59: D7.7<@ E7?1>/7 847.75/1D7:859:9;7?859:$K!5:847*9. 847?41.A7 5/;.1D7=>:=7.845/6.905/59:8H9><= E7967:89847 5A49>.8897I1D5:71/89H47847. 5:?9.69.1859: 9; 7?859: $K ! 5/ 847.7 ;9. 847 /1B79;589.8476.9/7?>859:41/?9<<7?87=/>;;5?57:8 705=7:?7H45?45;6.907=H9><=<71=89;.1D5:A847 ?41.A7 >:=7. 7?859: $K ! *9. 845/ 6>.69/7 58 H9><=E7967:89847 5A49>.889A9E@847:18>.7 9; 5:G>.@ />/815:7= H47847. />?4 5:G>.@ 5/ 5:;<5?87= 9: 847 0581<=7<7A187 61.8/ 9; 847 E9=@ :18>.7 9; H7169:/>/7=78? 9H707./>?41:7I7.?5/7E@847 5A4 9>.8 H9><= E7 67.D5//5E<7 9:<@ 1;87. 847 705=7:?7 5/ ?9<<7?87= 1;87. 5:07/85A1859: 1:= 847 ?41.A7/47785/;5<7=?41.A75/;.1D7=1:=9.=>.5:A 8478.51<>?47I7.?5/75/:9867.D5//5E<7H47:847 D1887.5//85<<>:=7.5:07/85A1859: 47.7;9.7 847 ><85D187 ?9:?<>/59: 5: 61.1A.164/ % 1:= %K 9; 847 =7?5/59: 9; 845/ 9>.8 5: 847 ?1/7 9; 1.5:=7. 5:A4 (/>6.1) /49><= - 5 - E7.71=41.D9:59>/<@1:=89E7.71=1/1H49<71:= 5:847?5.?>D/81:?7//8187=47.75:1E907- 0) H45<7 7I7.?5/5:A 847 69H7. >:=7. 7?859: #%9;8479=789C>1/4847?.5D5:1<6.9?77=5:A/5: .7/67?8 9; :9:?9D69>:=1E<7 9;;7:?7/ H45?4 1.7 6.501875::18>.71:==9 :9841071/7.59>/ 5D61.8 9: /9?578@ 9: 847 A.9>:= 8418 847.7 5/ 1 /788<7D7:8?9D6.9D5/7E78H77:84705?85D1:=847 9;;7:=7.847 5A49>.85/.7C>5.7=89?9:/5=7.847 1:87?7=7:8/ 9; 847 1??>/7=- 847 ?9:=>?8 9; 847 1??>/7= :1D7<@ H47847. 847 1??>/7= H1/ 1E/?9:=5:A1:=H4@47H1/1E/?9:=5:A49H4741= D1:1A7= H584 847 ?9D6<15:1:8 89 7:87. 5:89 1 ?9D6.9D5/778?L 7:?7 166<@5:A 847 ;5:=5:A/ 9; 847 9:ME<7 67I 9>.8 5: 847 1E907 G>=AD7:8 89 847 ;1?8/ 1:= ?5.?>D/81:?7/ 9; 845/ ?1/7 58 5/ ?<71. 8418 845/ 9>.8 ?1: 7I7.?5/784769H7.>:=7.7?859:"%#9;89C>1/4 847?.5D5:1<6.9?77=5:A/5:.7/67?89;8479;;7:?7/1<<7A7= 1.7 :9:?9D69>:=1E<7 5: :18>.7 H47: 847 /1D7 1.7 6.501875::18>.71:==9:98?9:/858>871:@/7.59>/5D61?8 9: 847 /9?578@ 47.7;9.7 ?9:/5=7.5:A 847 :18>.7 1:= ?5.?>D/81:?7/ 9; 847 ?1/7 1:= 1</9 8418 :9H 847 61.857/ 4107 >:7C>509?1<<@ /8187/ 8418 847@ 4107 /788<7= 8475. =5/6>87?9:85:>1859:9;8476.9?77=5:A/H9><=1D9>:889 - 6 - 1E>/79;6.9?7//9;9>.8??9.=5:A<@6.9?77=8961// 847;9<<9H5:A- 5 476785859:5/!!"# 55 47 6.9?77=5:A/ 1A15:/8 847 6785859:7./1??>/7= 9/% 1:= 5: 67?51< 1/79$%$%"1.5/5:A9>89;.5D7 9%$%".7A5/87.7=E@9<A>DE1F!9<5?7 5G1@16>. ;9. 847 9;;7:?7/ 6>:5/41E<7 >:=7. 7?859:/"(%)#()"(%)1:="%.H 7?859:(")9;%$%1:=>:=7.7?859:/ ()(.)()(/)1:=(%)(01)9;(!) ?867:=5:A9:847;5<79;==<5/8.5?81:= 7//59:/ >=A7 5G1@16>.1 5/ 47.7E@ C>1/47= *( %$' $ 5/892<92 2