- 1 - ! " " #$%&#'()$& #( * ! " # $ % # & ' Digitally signed by SHIVALEELA DATTATRAYA UDAGI Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - # # ( # '"%! ) * # # + # # '"%! ### '"%"" ) # * # + # !% *+ !% * #+ # ## # # $ # " # %&*+ &*+ &*+ "*+ %*+ & $! " "*+ & *+ # ## # * #+ # # # # ## #, , - - 3 - ./0 123/3/45 /0 6/728 9582: 2;3/45 !% 46 <=3.2123/3/452:0>;;9028 40 34 64: ?:>5346 >53/;/1>34:=<>/7 /5 :/@2 4" 8>328 " :2?/032:28 <= 98?>7 47/;2 3>3/45 >/;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450 %&*+ &*+ &*+"*+%*+&$!""*+:A2;3/45 &46.>:>3/=>=>=>>5./3>*64:0.4:3B+ .2 6>;39>7 @>3:/C 46 3.2 ;>02 /0 3.>3 1:/4: 34 3A4@453.06:4@8>3246748?/5?3.2;4@17>/533.2:2A>0 > D9>::27 <23A225 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 >58 >;;9028 4' >@20.64:3:/E/>7/00920.2:264:2>;;902846/728> ;4@17>/53 >?>/503 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 >58 ./0 6>@/7= @2@<2:0A./;.A>0:2?/032:28/5:/@24!"0 09;. 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 A>0 549:/0./5? /77'A/77 >?>/503 >;;90284 25;245&">3><493"1@ A.25 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 >58 ./0 A/62 >@>7><>/ A2:2 52>: 3.2/: .4902 >77 3.2 >;;9028 .>E2 64:@28 >5 957>A697 >002@<7= <= .478/5? 82>87= A2>1450 >58 3.2= ><9028 - 4 - 3.2@ >58 3.:2>32528 3.2@ /5/3/>77= >58 3.2:2>632: 3.2= >00>973283.2;4@17>/5>53'>77>11>>58./0A/62A/3.3.2 ;79< #92 34 A./;. <43. 46 3.2@ 0903>/528 /5F9:/20 >58 3.2:2>632: >8@/3328 34 3.2 401/3>7 >58 7>32: 748?28 3.2 ;4@17>/53 45 " 5 3.2 03:25?3. 46 ;4@17>/53 ;>@2 34<2 :2?/032:28 /5 :/@2 4" >?>/503 3.2123/3/452:0E2:0/5;23.28>3246:2?/03:>3/4546 3.2:201458253'147/;2>:2@>G/5?.2;3/;>332@1334>::203 3.2123/3/452:0 0 09;. 45 >11:2.250/45 46 3.2/: >::203 3.2=>11:4>;.28'887#/03H200/45098?2>/;.9: /33/5? >3 /58.>59: /5 :7/0;4""!%" .2 0>@2 A>0:2F2;32845" 25;23./0123/3/45 2>:8 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 >58 72>:528 /?. 49:3 4E2:5@253 72>82: 64: :201458253' 3>32 ! 1>:3 6:4@ 9:?/5? 02E2:>7 ;453253/450 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 123/3/452:0 1:/@>:/7= ;45325328 3.>3 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 .>0 748?28 3.2 ;4@17>/53 >?>/503 3.2 - 5 - 123/3/452:0 >0 > ;49532: <7>03 34 3.2 2>:7/2: ;4@17>/53 748?28 <= >;;9028 4 A./;. A>0 :2?/032:28 /5 :/@2 4!" 9:3.2: 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53 >58 ./0 A/62 0903>/5280/@172/5F9:/20A./;.>:25437/623.:2>325/5?/5 5>39:2 >58 3.2= A2:2 8/0;.>:?28 6:4@ 3.2 401/3>7 ;;4:8/5?7=.21:>=034>774A3.2123/3/45 " 72>:528 /?. 49:3 4E2:5@253 72>82:41140283.2<>/7123/3/45>581:>=0348/0@/003.2 0>@2 .>E2?/E25@=>5C/490;450/82:>3/45<43.45 3.2 09<@/00/450 @>82 <= 3.2 72>:528 ;495027 64: 3.2 :2012;3/E21>:3/20>5884;9@2530>E>/7><7245:2;4:8 $ 0;4978<2?>3.2:286:4@:2;4:80/3/0543/5 8/01932 3.>3 >;;9028 4 .>0 748?28 3.2 ;4@17>/53 >?>/503 3.2 ;4@17>/5>53'>77>11> <264:2 3./0 /5;/8253 A./;.A>0:2?/032:28/5:/@24!".2:2>632:/3 /03.2;>023.>3892343.>3E25?2>5;2>;;9028>00>97328 3.2;4@17>/5>53.49?./3/0>772?283.>3>773.2>;;9028 - 6 - A2:2>00>973283.2;4@17>/5>53>58./0A/62A/3.3.2:480 3.2@28/;>7;2:3/6/;>32821/;303.>3<43.463.2@0903>/528 0/@172/5F9:/20>583.2=.>8>7:2>8=8/0;.>:?286:4@3.2 401/3>7 25;2/3/0;72>:;>023.>33.2/5F9:/200903>/528 <=3.2@>:25437/623.:2>325/5?/55>39:2/5;23.2:2>:2 ;>02>58;49532:;>020748?28>?>/5033.2123/3/452:0>58 ;4@17>/5>53A/3.4932C1:200/5?>5=41/5/4545@2:/3046 3.2;>020966/;234.4783.>33.2;90348/>7/532::4?>3/4546 3.202123/3/452:084543;>7764:>58123/3/452:0>:2253/3728 64:>53/;/1>34:=<>/7 % .2:/@/5>723/3/45/0 & .2:201458253'47/;2>:28/:2;32834:272>02 3.2123/3/452:0>;;9028403445<>/7/53.22E25346 3.2/: >::203 /5 :/@2 4" :2?/032:28 <= 98?>7 47/;2 3>3/45 >/;.9: 64: 3.2 46625;20 195/0.><72 9582: 2;3/450%&*+&*+&*+"*+%*+&$! " "*+ :A 2;3/45 & 46 09<F2;3 34 3.2 64774A/5?;458/3/450, - 7 - */+ .2 123/3/452:0 0.>77 >112>: <264:2 3.2 5E203/?>3/5? 66/;2: A/3./5 " 8>=0 6:4@ 3.2 8>32 46 :2;2/13 46 3.2 ;41= 46 3./0 4:82: >58 0.>77 2C2;932 > 12:045>7 <458 64: > 09@ 46 0' *91220 52 >G. 457=+ 2>;. A/3. 3A4 09:23/20 64: 3.2 7/G209@ 34 3.2 0>3/06>;3/45463.25E203/?>3/5?466/;2:I *//+ .2123/3/452:00.>77:2?97>:7=>112>:<264:23.2 :/>749:3A/3.4936>/79572002C2@1328<=3.2 :/>749:364:E>7/8:2>0450I *///+ .2 123/3/452:0 0.>77 543 3>@12: A/3. 3.2 1:402;93/45 A/35200 >58 3.2= 0.>77 ;4'412:>32 A/3. 3.2 147/;2 64: /5E203/?>3/45 >58 >112>: <264:23.2@A.252E2:;>77289145I */E+ .2 123/3/452:0 0.>77 543 /5E47E2 /5 0/@/7>: 46625;20/56939:2 +) #( # , , ,