- 1 - !"!# $%"! &'( ! " # $ %%&!'!() %%&!'!() %% &!'!() ( &!'!() " # $ Digitally signed by RENUKA Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - % * % % % %% % +,% &)!&))! !&)!&))! -& &&)! -& % , ))))! % . /01234/5/016/27896:/5;8134/</3=3=86/1: /016/2 22=3=8605 8>/16?/63 2>8703/ =: 2=1/73/23830@/683=7/;8134/1/:<862/63: 4=:</3=3=86=:;=5/2AB34/</3=3=86/1:://@=6C0 D1=3 8; ?0620?9: 2=1/73=6C 1/:<862/63 8: 38 38 /;;/73?9303=86=634/60?/8;34/</3=3=86/1:8634/A0:=: 8; %81?& =::9/2 AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// 203/2 - 3 - )!))! 062 !)!))! :8 05:8 38 786:=2/1 34/ 1/<1/:/6303=86 203/2 )! 0586C D=34 <10B/1 38 78?<5B 34/ 812/1 <0::/2 AB 34=: 8913 =6 8))))! ( 3=:34/70:/8;34/</3=3=86/1:340334/B01/34/ 0A:8593/8D6/1:8;5062A/01=6C91>/B 8'(?/0:91=6C )( 071/: ' C9630: =6 40?:4060C01 =550C/ 059@ 062 =:31=73 =201 40>=6C A//6 =::9/2 %81?& 062 0C9>05= 74=3 =6 34/ 60?/ 8; </3=3=86/1: 203/2 )!))! 062 !)!))! AB 1/78C6=E=6C 34/=1 96093481=:/2 7953=>03=86 =61/:</738;34/8>/16?/635062 ! 3 =: 7863/63/2 AB 34/ 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ </3=3=86/1:34035062=691>/B 8'(81=C=6055B?/0:91/2 071/:062)C9630:062=3D0:81=C=6055B0F010?<8@ 8>/16?/63 062G 4/ </3=3=86/1: D/1/ 96093481=:/2 7953=>0381: 062 ?02/ 06 0<<5=703=86 38 34/ 7867/16/2 093481=3B ;81 C1063 8; 5062 4/ :0=2 0<<5=703=86 D0: 786:=2/1/2 AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// 062 9<86 7862973=6C :91>/B 062 =2/63=;B=6C 34/ <813=868; 34/ 5062 - 4 - =6 91>/B 8'( 962/1 34/ 7953=>03=86 8; </3=3=86/1: 0 <0674060?0D0:210D69<06234/5062D0:=2/63=;=/2=6 ;0>891 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1: 38 06 /H3/63 8; )( 071/: ' C9630:D=34</3=3=86/1 8:0621/:</73=>/5B 91:9063 38 7/13=;=703/ 8; 1/C=:3103=86 </3=3=86/1:?02/060<<5=703=863834/040:=5201://@=6C 38=6781<8103/34/=160?/:=634/1/78128;1=C43:86D4=74 34/ 1/<813 D0: 7055/2 AB 1/:<862/63 8 38 =2/63=;B 34/ 5062 =6 7953=>03=86 /:<862/63 8 1/>/69/ 093481=3B :9A?=33/202/30=5/21/<813203/2')I)ID=34078<B 8; <0674060?0 7/13=;B=6C 34/ ;073 1/C012=6C <8::/::=86 062 7953=>03=86 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1: 8>/1 34/ 5062 062 1/78??/62=6C;81/;;/73=6C1/>/69//631=/:=634/60?/8; 34/</3=3=86/1:4=:A/=6C34/:303/8;0;;0=1:1/:<862/63 8=634/1/<8134021/;/11/2/631=/:=67859?6 88; 34//78128;=C43:1/;/11=6C3834//631=/:=634/60?/8; %81/:3/<013?/634/1/;81/1/:<862/63 8040:=5201 4/52 3403 0;3/1 =::9=6C683=7/38 1/:<862/63 8!<0::/2 06 12/186)))(1/J/73=6C34/0<<5=703=86;=5/2AB - 5 - 34/ </3=3=86/1: ;81 /;;/73=6C ?9303=86 /631=/: =6 34/ 1/>/69/1/7812: * 4/ </3=3=86/1: 0CC1=/>/2 AB 34/ 812/1 <0::/2 AB1/:<862/63 80<<18074/21/:<862/63 8093481=3B AB <1/;/11=6C 06 0<</05 =6>8@=6C /73=86 (I 8; 34/ 016030@0 062 />/69/ 73 I( #;81 :4813 +34/ 73,$ 6 34/ ?/06D4=5/ 34/ 1/:<862/63&303/ 7863/:3/2 34/ ?033/1AB7863/62=6C340334/5062A/586C/23834/%81/:3 /<013?/630623403=3=:0683=;=/25062962/1/73=86I 8; 34/ B2/10A02 %81/:3 73 062 34/1/;81/ =::9067/ 8; %81?& AB 34/ 7867/16/2 093481=3B =6 ;0>81 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1:=:D=34893J91=:2=73=8606234/1/;81/:89C43;81 1/J/73=86 8; 34/ 0<</05 4/ 062 1063 8??=33// <187//2/2 38 <0:: 06 812/1 7067/55=6C 34/ C1063 ?02/ =6 ;0>891 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1: AB 0 78??86 812/1 203/2 )!)( ' CC1=/>/2 AB 34/ 812/1 <0::/2 AB 1/:<862/63 8 34/ </3=3=86/1: <1/;/11/2 0 1/>=:=86 A/;81/ 1/:<862/63 8 093481=3B 962/1 /73=86 #$ 8; 34/ - 6 - 73 6 786:=2/103=86 8; 34/ :0=2 1/>=:=86 062 86 786:=2/103=868;34/:0=2<187//2=6C:1/:<862/63 8C83 =::9/2%81?&4=:A/=6C34/:303/8;0;;0=1:1/:<862/63 8093481=3BD=348930<<1/7=03=6C34/7863/63=86:8;34/ </3=3=86/1: 1/C012=6C 96093481=:/2 7953=>03=86 =6 34/ 8>/16?/63 010?<8@ 062 1/J/73/2 34/ 1/>=:=86 <1/;/11/2 AB 34/ </3=3=86/1: CC1=/>/2 AB 34/ :0=2 1/J/73=86 812/1 </3=3=86/1: <1/;/11/2 D1=3 </3=3=86 A/;81/ 34=: 8913 =6 8))))! ://@=6C 38 /;;/73 ?9303=86 /631=/: =6 34/=1 60?/: A0:/2 86 %81?& =::9/2 AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// 4=: 8913 077/<3/2 34/ 70:/ 8; 34/ </3=3=86/1: 062 K90:4/2 34/ 812/1 203/2 )I)! I 3 =: 34/ 7863/63=86 8; 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/ </3=3=86/1: 3403 <91:9063 38 K90:4=6C 8; 34/ 812/1 D4=74 D0:=?<9C6/2AB34/</3=3=86/1:=634/<1/>=89:</3=3=86 34/B 0<<18074/2 1/:<862/63 8: 38 ://@=6C 38 /63/1 34/=160?/:=634/1/>/69/1/7812:8634/A0:=:8;%81?& =::9/2 8D/>/1 1/:<862/63 8: 38 7863/62/2 3403 - 7 - 34/1/ D0: 68 :</7=;=7 2=1/73=86 38 /63/1 34/ 60?/: 062 1/;9:/238=6781<8103/34/60?/8;34/</3=3=86/1: ) 4/ ;9134/1 7863/63=86 8; 5/016/2 7896:/5 ;81 34/</3=3=86/1:=:34031/:<862/63:01/31B=6C38/>02/34/ =?<5/?/6303=868;34/812/1:8;34=:8913D=342/5=A/103/ ?050;=2/=63/63=86=67592=6C34//631B8;%81?&=::9/2AB 34/06210638??=33//=634/1/>/69/1/7812:/67/ </3=3=86/1: 5/;3 D=34 68 834/1 053/1603=>/ 062 /;;=707=89: 1/?/2B 01/ A/;81/ 34=: 8913 =6 34=: </3=3=86 4/ 1/<1/:/6303=868;34/</3=3=86/1:40:683A//6786:=2/1/2 AB34/1/:<862/63: /016/2 22=3=8605 8>/16?/63 2>8703/ 0<</01=6C;8134/1/:<862/63:7863/62:340334/1/=::8?/ ;50D06234/B01/=634/>/1C/8;74055/6C=6C34/812/18; 34=:8913A/;81/34/=>=:=86/674/67/4/7863/62: 3403965/::34/1/=:06B89378?/=634/74055/6C/D4=74=: :89C43 38 A/ ?02/ AB 34/ 303/ 34/1/ 706683 A/ 0 2=1/73=86=::9/23834/1/:<862/63&303/38=?<5/?/6334/ 812/18;34/06210638??=33//;81=::9067/8;%81?& - 8 - 06234/1/>/69//631=/:38A/1/7812/2=634/60?/8;34/ </3=3=86/1: 4/ 7863/63=86 8; 5/016/2 22=3=8605 8>/16?/63 2>8703/ 706683 A/ 077/<3/2 ;81 34/ 1/0:86 340368289A334/8>/16?/6340:34/5=A/13B3874055/6C/ 06B 812/1 3403 =:<0::/2 AB 34=: 8913 =6 34/ 0<<18<1=03/ ;819? 93 =3 706683 A/ 7863/63/2 3403 3=55 :974 812/1 =: <0::/2 34/B D8952 683 =?<5/?/63 34/ 812/1 <0::/2 AB 34=: 8913 81 34/ =::9067/ 8; %81?& AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// ;81 /;;/73=6C ?9303=86 81 7406C/ 34/ 1/>/69/ 1/7812:4/1/=:0?06203/<18>=2/2962/1/73=86I8; 34/73D4/1/34/<1/:71=A/28;;=7/1=:8A5=C03/238/63/1=6 34/1/C=:3/18;?9303=86:/>/1B1/<813?02/384=?962/1 :9A&:/73=86 #$ 8; /73=86 ' 8; 34/ 73 81 1/7/=>/2 AB 4=? 962/1 :9A&:/73=86 #$ 81 :9A&:/73=86 #($ 8; :0=2 :/73=86/73=86I#*$8;34/7305:87863/?<503/:3403 3106:;/1 8; /631=/: ;18? 34/ 1/C=:3/1 8; ?9303=86: 38 34/ 1/78128;1=C43:4055A//;;/73/2=634/<1/:71=A/2?066/1 <18>=2/2 3403 06 /631B =6 34/ 1/C=:3/1 8; ?9303=86: :4055 - 9 - 683 A/ 3106:;/11/2 38 34/ 1/7812 8; 1=C43 963=5 :974 /631B 40: A//6 295B 7/13=;=/2 4/1/;81/ D4/6 34/1/ =: 0 ?06203/ 75/015B <1/:71=A/2 962/1 34/ :30393/ =3 =: 06 8A5=C03=86062683068<3=86;8134/1/:<862/63093481=3=/: 38 =67592/ =6781<8103/ 81 7406C/ /631=/: A0:/2 86 34/:/ 7/13=;=703/:8134/;81?:=::9/2AB34/:3039381B093481=3=/: =67592=6C ;81?: =::9/2 AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// 62/1 34/ 7=179?:3067/: 34=: </3=3=86 D8952 40>/ 38 A/ 0558D/2 77812=6C5B<0::34/;8558D=6C = 4/D1=3</3=3=86=: == D1=38;?0620?9:=:=::9/206202=1/73=86=: C=>/6 38 1/:<862/63 8 38 /;;/73 ?9303=86 /631=/:=634/60?/8;34/</3=3=86/1:A0:/286 %81?& =::9/2 AB 34/ 062 1063 8??=33// 203/2 )!))! 062 !)!))! D4=74 :4055 A/78?<5=/2D=34=60</1=828;/=C43D//@:;18? - 10 - 34/ 203/ 8; 1/7/=<3 8; 0 78<B 8; 34=: 812/1 8D/>/1 34/ :0?/ D8952 A/ :9AJ/73 38 06B 7406C/81?82=;=703=868174055/6C/811/>/1:05 =; 06B 8A30=6/2 AB 06B <013B =67592=6C 34/ 303/ )' &!( " =:3 85 8(