Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 54097 (KAR)
DEWAMMA v. BIRAPPA AND ANR
MFA/200036/2019 · 2026-01-22
R Nataraj, Tyagaraja N Inavally
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54097 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 54097 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #
# $
""
%$& '(
""
)%$&
'
(
! "
#
$%&%
'
(((")&)
Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
""*"+
(%&")" ! '
' '
"+"'
'
'"%&&"))(
",
' -
")+)"& -
+)"%
' ) (
""*"+
"
- 3 -
$%&%)
#"
$%&%)
' ((")&)
'
". ' '
"+" '
-
")+)"& -
+)"%
' -
/- -
/-
-
$
/-
-
' 0)))*)"1234' 0)1)"&256 78964 :; <=6 >928?23< 234 <=6 83@A565 56@B6><8C69;
>=29963D83D <=6 EA23<A? 07 >0?B63@2<803 234 982:898<; <0 B2; <=6 >0?B63@2<803 2F25464 :; <=6 63805 8C89 -A4D6
- 4 -
234 448<80329 2< =2=2BA5705 @=05< G58:A329H 83
0+)"%
>928?B6<8<803F2@78964:;<=6>928?23<:67056 <=658:A329A34656><803"**07<=60<056=8>96@>< @66I83D >0?B63@2<803 07 @)))))( 705 <=6 83JA586@ @A@<28364:;=658325024<52778>2>>8463<03"))#)"% F=63 @=6 F2@ <52C6983D 83 2 82DD80 B6 2A<0 :62583D 56D8@<52<803 0((")&)
=6 @2?6 F2@ >03<6@<64 :; <=6 83@A565 F=0 463864<=62>>8463<2348<@982:898<;<0B2;>0?B63@2<803 2@6403<=62:0C6<=658:A329=694<=6B50>66483D@234 56>05464<=66C8463>607>928?23<2@ "2346C8463>607 <=6 0><05 2@ 234 ?25I64 40>A?63<@ 2@ K@ " <0
"*=60F36507<=607763483DC6=8>96F2@6K2?83642@
" 234 40>A?63<@ 2< K@" <0 % F656 ?25I64 03 :6=29707<=656@B03463<@
# =6 58:A329 >03@846583D <=6 0529 234 40>A?63<25; 6C8463>6 =694 <=2< <=6 2>>8463< F2@ 4A6 <0
- 5 -
<=6 52@= 234 36D98D63< 458C83D :; <=6 458C65 07 <=6 2A<0 234 2F25464 >0?B63@2<803 2@ A3465 234 4856><64 <=6 83@A565<0B2;<=6@2?6
9 0 624@ ?0A3<
" 2832342D03; @))))(
0@@077A<A56625383D >2B2>8<; @&&&))(
'00423430A58@=?63< @"))))( # 523@B05<2<803>0@< @"))))( % 0@@072?638<86@ @"))))( * 648>296KB63@6@ @"%)*+( + <<63423<>=25D6@ @")))(
*+,
-!!).'
% 683D 2DD586C64 :; <=6 EA23<A? 07 >0?B63@2<803 2F25464 <=6 >928?23< =2@ 78964 23 2BB629 F=896 <=6 83@A565 =2@ 78964 23 2BB629 >=29963D83D <=6 EA23<A? 234 <=6 982:898<; 8?B0@64 03 8< <0 B2; <=6 >0?B63@2<803
* =6 72>< <=2< <=6 >928?23< @A776564 83JA586@ 83 <=62>>8463<2@>03<63464:;=6583<=6>928?B6<8<803234
- 6 -
<=640>A?63<@B504A>64:;=6556D25483D<562<?63<<2I63 :;=6583<=6=0@B8<29@<234A348@BA<64
+ @B65<=625DA?63<07<=69625364>0A3@69705 <=6>928?23<23429@02@B65<=66C8463>60356>054<=6 >928?23<@A776564752><A5607967<@=27<76?A5234752><A56 07 967< <8:82 90F65 "54 F8<= 752><A56 07 6?:098@?
234@=6A3465F63<@A5D65;F8<=328983D70576?A5234 <8:82234@=6F2@<562<642@83B2<863<705"42;@:6<F663
"))#)"%234))#)"%83<=6=0@B8<29705<=683JA586@ @A@<28364 83 <=6 2>>8463< 63>6 23 2?0A3< 07 @#))))(8@2F25464<0F254@GB2832342D03;H
& =6 >928?23< 6K2?8364 2 0><05 2@ 234 ?25I648@2:898<;65<878>2<62@B65K ")F=8>=@=0F64 <=2<<=6>928?23<@A776564B65?2363<48@2:898<;07),<0 <=6F=096:04;=6568@306C8463>6<0B50C6<=683>0?6 07<=6>928?23< 63>630<8032983>0?607@&)))(B65 ?03<= 8@ <2I63 <0 46<65?836 <=6 >0?B63@2<803 B2;2:96 03@846583D <=6 2D6 07 <=6 >928?23< <=6 ?A9<8B9865
- 7 -
2BB98>2:96<0<=6>2@603=2348@G"&H83C86F0746>8@80383 H@ >2@6 =6567056 <=6 >0?B63@2<803 B2;2:96 <0 <=6 >928?23< A3465 <=6 =624 G90@@ 07 7A<A56 625383D>2B2>8<;H>0?6@<0 ),07@&)))(K"K"&L@%"&#))(
1 'A5<=65<=6>928?23<8@63<8<964<0<=62?0A3< 07 @#)))( A3465 <=6 =624 G90@@ 07 83>0?6 4A583D <562<?63< B65804H 03@846583D <=6 % B56@>58B<803@ 1# ?648>29 :899@ 234 % 56>68B<@ B504A>64 :; <=6 >928?23< 2< K@ " <0
"% <=6 58:A329 =2@ D523<64 <=6 >0?B63@2<803 07 @"%)*+( A3465 <=6 =624 G?648>29 6KB63@6@HF=8>=406@30<56EA856?04878>2<803
") 03@846583D<=66C8463>60356>054<=6568@30 562@03 <0 83<657656 F8<= <=6 2?0A3<@ 07 >0?B63@2<803 D523<64 :; <=6 58:A329 A3465 0<=65 =624@ 63>6 <=6 >928?23<8@63<8<964<0<=6<0<29>0?B63@2<803F=8>=8@2@ 70990F@
- 8 -
,
/+0- 123*
" 2832342D03; @#))))(
0@@077A<A56625383D>2B2>8<; @%"&#))(
'00423430A58@=?63< @"))))( # 523@B05<2<803>0@< @"))))( % 0@@072?638<86@ @"))))( * 648>296KB63@6@ @"%)*+( + <<63423<>=25D6@ @")))( & 0@@0783>0?64A583D<=6 B6580407<562<?63< @#)))(
*+,
-.!)4!5.'
"" < 8@ 24?8<<64 72>< <=2< <=6 2BB69923< 83 '
0)1)"& 8@ <=6 83@A565 07 <=6 07763483D C6=8>96 234 3@A523>6 098>; F2@ C2984 2@ 03 <=6 42<6 07 <=6 2>>8463< 0F6C65 8< 8@ >928?64 <=2< <=6 B098>; >0C6564 039;B2@@63D65@:A<<=656F656"%B2@@63D65@<52C6983D 83 <=6 07763483D C6=8>96 2< <=6 <8?6 07 2>>8463< 234 <=6567056<=656F2@C8092<80307>0348<803@07<=6B098>;07 83@A523>6 234 =63>6 8< 8@ 30< 982:96 <0 B2; 23; >0?B63@2<803
" 0F6C658<8@F699@6<<964B583>8B960792F<=2<87 <=6 >928?23<@ 256 <=854 B25<86@ <0 <=6 83@A523>6 B098>;
- 9 -
6C63 87 <=656 8@ C8092<803 07 23; >0348<803@ 07 B098>; <=6 83@A565 8@ 982:96 <0 B2; >0?B63@2<803 F8<= 98:65<; <0 56>0C65 <=6 @2?6 750? <=6 83@A5640F365 07 <=6 C6=8>96 =6567056<=683@A565=2@728964<0?2I60A<23;D50A34 <0 @6< 2@846 <=6 8?BAD364 JA4D?63< 234 2F254 07 <=6 58:A329838<@63<856<;2@@0AD=<70583<=6852BB629
" 3<=656@A9<F625607<=6>03@846564C86F<=2< <=62BB629@78964:;<=6>928?23<@23483@A56546@65C6<0 :62990F6483B25<234<=6567056F6B50>664<0B2@@<=6 70990F83D
8 0<=<=62BB629@256 88 =68?BAD364JA4D?63<2342F25442<64
")+)"& B2@@64 :; <=6 63805 8C89 -A4D6234448<803292<=2=2BA583
0+)"%8@?0487864
- 10 -
888 =6 >0?B63@2<803 2F25464 :; <=6 58:A329 8@ 63=23>64 750? @*""&*+( <02@A?07-.!)4!5.' 8C =663=23>64>0?B63@2<8038@B2;2:96:; <=683@A5652903DF8<=83<656@<2<<=652<6 07 *,B65 233A? 750? <=642<607>928? B6<8<803<899<=642<60746B0@8< C =6 83@A565 8@ 4856><64 <0 46B0@8< <=6 63=23>64 >0?B63@2<803 :67056 <=6 58:A329 F8<=83 2 B65804 07 ) 42;@ 750?
<=6 42<6 07 56>68B< 07 >0B; 07 <=8@ JA4D?63< 728983D F=8>= <=6 83@A565 @=299 B2;83<656@<2<<=652<6071,B65233A? 234 56>0C65 <=6 6K>6@@ 83<656@< 750? <=6 B65@03 56@B03@8:96 705 <=6 4692; 83 46B0@8<83D<=62?0A3< C8 =6 83@A565 8@ 63<8<964 <0 56>0C65 <=6 >0?B63@2<803 2?0A3< 750? <=6
- 11 -
83@A5640F365 07<=6 C6=8>96 83 <=6 @2?6 B50>66483D@ C88 =656@=29930054652@<0>0@<@ C888 32F254@=299:6452F32>>05483D9;
0' % &
0' % $&
8@< 0"9 0"