Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Punjab and Haryana · body
2026 DAILYLAW 5258 (PNJ)
LT COL ASHOK BEMBEY v. PUNJAB STATE ELECTRICITY REGULATORY COMMISSION AND ANOTHER
CWP/16174/2017 · 2026-02-02
Harpreet Singh Brar
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 5258 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 5258 (PNJ) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
! "#! $%"&
'()'* !!! ' + +",'- .$! /,01)
2 1 '
#'3 -+3+ *
'4/#1 "-*
"((+$$+",
1,5
1," %'- !!! '$6",5', $ '$'-7'5
",8
! ! -","/,3'5
",8 ! ! 6#"15'5
",8 ! ! 8 9
! 2
2
!"# $$$$$$$ 2
:
! #%%&'%%( ) * + , %-.%-&/0 %&1+ 2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
+" + 2# +345 ; % 6 ,
7 +#2 8 " * 2 ) 9:.(; %;..( ! ,
* < 82# < ) .'%%%---/0 1
"# 70 ) ! != "# +> + +2 !2 ! /
? 1 + ) %4-%%--%/0 %1>
" 2 -@-;%--% ++ -;-;%-@ > -;-;%-@/0 @1 + #20 #0 %;-..%/0 A1#2
"#+ "#)8< **> 2+2 # VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
<
2++"#2 %-.%-&/0 %&1?+
2 ; > + # 70 + 2#2 ) -@-;%--% -;-;%-@ %2 + ) * "#< 70 <.4%#2
"# -%-%.4%/0 1 70 #28 + 2 B CD 2 2 #2<(. "#)8</ B)8<C1+<((
2 #B2 2 2CD<;% )8< + 2 -2 , + + ) -@-;%--% -;-;%-@> # 2 )8 < + %;-..%/0< '.1#2
"# %2#2 <+ "#2) VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
!" #2? C#8) "
# #$%%% @ > # 2 ;-%--4#2 # + A42? +
) -;-;%-@ 2 # 2 #2 &;2E+ # %@%%-%A? "#872 < 2) / 8) 7 21 < %-%-A%-%/0 %(1 +#2+ 2 2+ -A2 &;2# + 2<&&) 2 2+ # 2+ %2 2D #+ ..2# --%%-&/0 (1>%-2 +F#2 2+2 # ;--2 ;-%--4 *2%-; 0 * ;42/%(-%%-; -A-@%-;1<4;; VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
= )8<=+ ) %2 #2 2# 2 4-2
A #
"# 8 72 < 2 ) + 2# 2 8 ( 72< 2 ) .44++##272%--; 6 # ) + #2 "# ? + %A-%--#2D !
+ %A-%--#2D ! ) %;-.%--% 4@ 2 .; +*# ' + ) ># 2 # 2 > + "#870 )
2#2 2 #2 %4-%%--%/0 %1 +2 2+ + # 2*+ #2 > VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
2 +0 2 -@-;%--( , & D # -@-;%-% (-%%-% 0 #2 + 2 )= ;;@4 %-% %;-%%-% ) + + + # 02 -@-;%-% 2 ) 0 2 -A-;%-%/0< '%18#,2 (-%%-%+" .-@%-%/0< ';1? + + + %;-%%-% #2) ++ # -4-A%-% ( >&-A%-%/0< '@1 + 0 -%2 # #2 2 (-A%-%/0< 'A1
2 + 0 + 2 -@-;%-@62 ++)= ;;@4 %-% #2 %4-A%-%/0< '&1-;-;%-@ /0< '(1 ) !2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
! / 81 # + -A-;%-@ 0 <4----'
2+ +! +#2# 2+ # +> # + $&"'(()*+
! " #$%%%%&'
( (
(
)
* (+ ( ,
-&./0
(
( ( ( 1 4 D %@%%-A 8 < + +++
) 2+ # < &/1 # 2 # #2 &A2 8 2&A 2 # %@%%-A . D2 +0 # #2+#2*2 +#2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
> %;-..% #+2
%--% %--? +0 2 + 20 >8#%--2+ #0 2 ) /#1 %;-..%> + G/#1 %;-..%# +2 + ) 2 # 2'0 > ,
"# 2 #2 + ## 2+ /0 < '- 21 - 8 + + + 2 ) /H71"#H6> )+ + 2 # ) -@-%-& /0< '%1? +++,2 +-22# C 2 -& 2 +2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
? ;-%--4+ A4 2 * --%%-& /0< ';1 # 2 + %@%-( /0 < '@1 !
+
"# %;-..% # <
) "# %%%-(/0< 'A1 2 2 2 ++ + .-%-4/0< '&1
I # ;-.A- 2
"#A42+ ;-%--%> 2# 2-&2-4 %&2 ;-%--4#
) 2 < + + ##2J #2 )= ;4( %-&# ) ++ A-(%-&/0 %A1+ ) #2 2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
+"#2 %-.%-&/0 %&1 + ) <%@/1 )8<2+ 2 #2 2 + D< ;% )8 < , 2 # # + 2 2+ # 28 +
-2 # A42 2 2# 2.2
22 % ? +# 70 + ) 9 * 2 %;..( 8#,2 2 + !2 ! /
? 1 ) %4-%%--%/0 %1> 2 ++-;-;%-@ ++ # #2 0 @ > 2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
#2 # 2+ ) ; * 2 # # #2 2 # ' *+ # 2 #) 2 2 #
:G ? C#8) ,"
- . # /0
1
( -%23%%4$%$% + 23 4 5
/
6 7
, #
* (#
* *#5(
#
## 6(
&
.1
*" 55(
*(( &"
*
. (
"5 5"7
(#
* 8
. 0 . 1
. "#
5
*
5(6
&"**
(
&
5(
*1
*) / ( 5
/7
1 /1 @ 9 + + #2 # 2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
#2* + 2 ,2 2 ## 2 2 # 2 # #2 2 2 /1# /#1##,2F/1, # )2 #2 2 # # + , F # + 2 0 #
2 > * 2+ 2+ ) 2 2# I 2 ) + # #2 2 # " #2+ :G ? C#8) 9")&
",
*
(",
*'*
90
1
('55(- 2 $%$% %&-(%-%@ + : ++ 89) / : (
5(5
**(
#"(&)
5#
(" (1(* #:
VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
<
4.
(
(
1 A > + + %4-%%--%/0 %1+ + 2# -2> # + . ;#
*
+ +
<
' 5= #; 2%%23%%3
+ +
<
5 >
'
' ?#/
((& 5
" & (
55
#
5(& #5&"&1
**#
"&
# (
+. +
<
5= : )
55* 0 #1 & D #2 )8< ? +)8<+ #2 ) 2 + # ) )= ;4( %-&+ A-(%-&/0 %A1+ 2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
#2 )8< 2 ) # > + 0
((> + +
<
5>
(
. ? # /
? # /
*2@@$5 8%223%%$. #
) /
. #
8)1
*( )
;(*
*
&.(&0##
"5" 0
1
( 1
*(&5*
*" :
( ( *!'3A
( )
>(
(
1 /1 ( > "#872 < 2) / 8) 7 21 < %-%/0 %(1# + 2 G2 2 2 ) 62 "# "#872 < 2) / 8) 7 21 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
= < %-A %@%%-A/0< '41++ # # #2 )/1 ) @ + 2 /1
) 2 2# 2 # # 2 # # +
) 2)& 2 &A2 + + ? + ##2, 2 # 4 > #2 , ##2 %;-..%/0< '.1+ # #2 + 2# 2
)
"#* %@%-( /0< '@1 + ## %;-..%/0< '.1> %@%-( /0< '@1 # + :
- + 4
B3$C@2'4::&$A2 VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
38%22@@3. *>D
1 . #2 ) 2 +2 # /0< ';1
#2 "# : )8< # ); <&&) 2 # 2 2
<(.
2 0 2+2 + + 0 2 #
2
C # #"#+2 +2 # ++ 2+ 2I2<;% + #2 + D 2 < ;% # + 823)
- ,
(
;E 4
E)
- VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
.E: #5(&# #
1 " 5# )
E) - ) ! (
E),
( ,
(
(
(F , ',
(
1 %- /0 %1 #2+ 2 2D <;%+ 2+ +,2 + ##2#+ # # 2 2# #2 # 2 ) % 82 +++ + 2 2+ #2 >0 + 0 # 2#2 2#2 2 2#+ # VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh
> > + 2 # -2 2 %% *+ # 2
) 2
%; > /1 2
@
2
A -%-%%-%&
= ' J' = # J' VISHNU 2026.02.02 17:41 I attest to the accuracy and integrity of this document Punjab and Haryana High Court, Chandigarh