Research › Search › Judgment
High Court of Karnataka · body
2026 DAILYLAW 50774 (KAR)
SRI M KONDAL RAO v. KARNATAKA INDUSTRIAL AREAS DEVELOPMENT BOARD
WP/28745/2023 · 2026-01-29
E S Indiresh
body2026
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 50774 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
[ 2026 DAILYLAW 50774 (KAR) · dailylaw.ai ]
Judgment text
Extracted from the PDF above. The PDF is authoritative.
- 1 -
! " #$#%
&'$!! ! (' )
! " # # $% # $
# $ # %
""# $
# $
$#
&$
' % #(
%
$
%
""#
"
Digitally signed by LUCYGRACE Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA
- 2 -
)
*%
##
$
#
! $ $ $# #
$ $ $
$
)"
&$
'$%# % #" +
#
" % #" !(
) $
" #
!! !! " #
" $
) # $
!!!$ $
$ #
$ $ # ! , "
$
"
%
$ $#
#
$
" $
) ) $ ) #
#
" -
#
"
## # "#
$ #
" $
)
. - 3 -
# . /
*#
0123 24 13567635181 19 :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 24 $% #518321750@512 :012803;96870:1<<01248=>92207<98308? 9183 A? 00?1
6?521 :012803 08492 #96870: 1<<01248= 98 B051:> 9> 24 131275 9?5124 :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92207<98308? 9! ! 50 20:0C18? >1;?7 >92 13D634;1?498 9> ?50 E24? <0?4?498120?51??50207<98308? 95171::9??03 18 0F?08? 9> 1;207 9> :183 48 <:9? 9 48 933181@6834 8367?241: 201 7? <5170 17 <02 ?50 <977077498 ;02?4>4;1?0 31?03 '880F620( ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9! 50201>?02 207<98308? 9 5130F0;6?03181=200A08?31?03 '880F620 (E4?5?50207<98308? 9!48207<0;?9>?5076BD0;?:183 98 :0170;6A71:0 B1747 ? 47 >92?5;9A48= >29A ?50 E24? <0?4?498 ?51? ?50 207<98308? 9! >14:03 ?9 ;9A<:G E4?5
- 4 -
?50?02A7183;9834?49879>?50:0170;6A71:01=200A08? 1831776;5?50207<98308? 9BG:0??0231?03 !! '880F620#( 48?4A1?03 ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9!?920?628?50686?4:4H03:183?9180F?08?9>!7I A?27 183 17 76;5 ?99@ <977077498 9> ?50 :183 ?9 18 0F?08?9>!7IA?2750201>?02?50207<98308? 9! 513 >4:03 764? 48 9! B0>920 ?50 #4?G #4C4: 183 0774987 *63=0 08=1:626 1=1487? ?50 207<98308? 9 183 ?50 7143 764? ;1A0 ?9 B0 347A47703 98 ! ! 50201>?02 ?50 207<98308? 9! >4:03 "
9!E54;5;1A0?9B0347A47703BG?547#962? ? 47 >62?502 7?1?03 48 ?50 E24? <0?4?498 ?51? 36248= ?50 <08308;G 9> ?50 1>920A08?49803 <29;00348=7 ?50 207<98308? 9! 133207703 20<20708?1?498 31?03 ! !! ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 207?920 ?50 :183 ?9 18 0F?08? 9> ! 7I A?27 183 517 >4:03 18 1>>431C4?9>68302?1@48=?51?50751::<1G?50A12@0?C1:60 9> ?50 :183 17 <02 880F6207 183 207<0;?4C0:G $627618? ?9 ?50 71A0 ?50 207<98308? 9 BG
- 5 -
:0??02 31?03 !!! '880F620"( 3420;?03 ?50 207<98308? 9!?9<1G176A9>7E4?548 31G7 9> ?50 20;04<? 9> ?50 48?4A1?498 1? 880F620" 6248= ?507143 48?0220=86A<02493?50 207<98308? 9! 513 08?0203 48?9 1 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= 31?03 ! !!'880F620(E4?59807%#987?26;?498 >92 D948? 30C0:9<A08? 9> ?50 :183 48 I607?498 >92 ?50 <62<9709>A9B4:4H48=?50>6837?471:797?1?03?51??50 207<98308? 9!513>4:03)$ 9!!1=1487??50 207<98308? 9 B0>920 ?547 #962?
6248= ?50 <08308;G 9> ?50 E24? <0?4?498 ?50 207<98308? 9! 513 08?0203 48?9 1 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= 31?03 !'880F620(E4?5?50<0?4?498027<29<9703?9 51C0 1 D948? 30C0:9<A08? 1=200A08? 48 207<0;? 9> ?50 76BD0;? :183 ? 47 1:79 7?1?03 ?51? ?50 <0?4?498027 <143 7?9?50207<98308? 9!1789820>6831B:0 30<974? 183 >92 ?50 7143 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= ?50 20<20708?1?4C0 9> ?50 7 % #987?26;?498 517 74=803?500A921836A9>83027?18348=A13048>1C962
- 6 -
9> ?50 <0?4?498027 17 1 ;98708?48= E4?8077 ?9 50:< ?50 207<98308? 9! ?9 1;I6420 ?50 :183 48 I607?498 183 ?9 30C0:9<?5071A0481779;41?498E4?5?50<0?4?498027
8 ?50 A018E54:0 17 7?1?03 1B9C0 )$ 9!!!>4:03BG?50207<98308? 9!;1A0?9 B0347<97039>98 !'880F620*(E502048?547 #962? =218?03 >962 E00@7 ?4A0 ?9 30<974? ?50 1A968? 9> 7 E4?5 48?0207? 1? ?50 21?0 9> J <02 1886A >29A !!! ?4:: ?50 31?0 9> 30<974? ? 47 7?1?03 48 ?50 E24? <0?4?498 ?51? ?50 207<98308? 9! 517 >14:03?9 12218=0>6837 >92 30<974? B0>920?50 207<98308? 9 17 <02 ?50 3420;?498 477603 BG ?50 #962? 48 )$ 9!!!1831776;5?50<0?4?49802 9<143 176A9>7!?9?50207<98308? 9K17?9 ;9A<:0?0 ?50 >92A1:4?407 9> 20=47?21?498 9> 71:0 3003 E4?5 ?50207<98308? 9L50?2187>029>>6837>29A ?50 <0?4?498027 ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9K 47 <2936;03 1? 880F620 702407 ? 47 >62?502 7?1?03 ?51? ?50 207<98308? 9! 517 <29A4703 ?50 <0?4?498027 17 ?9 <12? KK;9220;?03C430;51AB029230231?03!!! - 7 -
E4?5?50751209>?50:18348I607?4981>?02?50;98;:67498 9>?50>92A1:4?40717?90F0;6?4989>?5071:03003BG?50 207<98308? 9 E4?5 ?50 207<98308? 9! 9E0C02?50207<98308? 9!;16703:0=1:89?4;031?03 ! '880F620 ( ?9 ?50 <0?4?498027 7?1?48= ?51? ?50 1=200A08? 68302 ?50 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= 08?0203 E4?5 ?50 <0?4?498027 ;1889? B0 08>92;03 183 1;;92348=:G ;18;0::03 ?50 71A0 684:1?021::G AA0341?0:G ?50 <0?4?498027 BG 20<:G 31?03 !! '880F620$( 308403?50;:14AA130BG?50207<98308? 9!48?50:0=1: 89?4;01?880F620$183796=5?>9220;987?4?6?4989>?50 <12?802754<30038?54720=123?50<0?4?49802751C0>4:03
9!!!1=1487??50207<98308? 9!B0>920?50 ;9A<0?08?#4C4:#962?1?08=1:626
8?50A018E54:0?50207<98308? 9!517>4:03 )$ 9! B0>920?547#962?700@48=3420;?498?9 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 0F0;6?0 1 20=47?0203 71:0 300318348?507143E24?<0?4?498?50<0?4?49802751C0>4:03
9!! ?9 4A<:013 48 ?50 E24? <0?4?498 547 #962? - 8 -
C430 92302 31?03 !! '880F620,( 3420;?03 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 ?1@0 30;47498 48 ?50 A1??02 1>?020F1A4848=?50=240C18;09>?50<0?4?498027502048183 ?50207<98308? 9! "00:48=1==240C03BG?5071A0?50207<98308? 9! 502048 517 >4:03 )24? <<01: 9 !! 183?547 #962?C4309230231?03!!!!'880F620(3420;?03 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 ;9874302 ?50 ;170 9> ?50 207<98308? 9!
4830<08308?:G BG <17748= 1 <01@48= 2302 8 ?02A7 9> ?50 3420;?498 477603 BG ?547 #962? 48 )24?<<01:
9 !!?50207<98308? 9L 517<17703?509230231?03!!'880F620(183 1776;520D0;?03?50;:14A A130BG?50207<98308? 9! >920F0;6?4989>?5020=47?020371:03003
? 47 >62?502 <:01303 48 ?50 E24? <0?4?498 ?51? 36248= ?50 7143 48?0220=86A <02493 ?50 <0?4?498027 51C0 133207703120<20708?1?49831?03!!!'880F620 ( ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9 20I607?48= ?50 7143 16?5924?G89??90F0;6?0?5020=47?020371:0300348>1C962
- 9 -
9> ?50 207<98308? 9! 183 ?9 1::9? ?50 <:9? 48 >1C962 9> ?50 <0?4?498027 17 ?50 <0?4?498027 51C0 <143 7! ?9E1237 ;98743021?498 48 207<0;? 9> ?50 76BD0;? :183 183 A130 30C0:9<A08? 48 ?50 :183 48 I607?498 08;0 ?50 <0?4?498027 51C0 <20>02203 ?547 E24? <0?4?498 748;0 ?50 207<98308? 9 517 89? ;987430203?5020<20708?1?498<2936;031?880F620
24 135676318 19 :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 ;98?08303 ?51? ?596=5 ?50 207<98308? 9! 517 B008 1::9??03 E4?5 ?50 :183 48 I607?498 36248= 17 <02 <977077498 ;02?4>4;1?0 59E0C02 >92 1 <02493 9> A920 ?518 G0127 89 20=47?0203 71:0 3003 517 B008 0F0;6?03 BG 207<98308? 9 48 >1C962 9> 207<98308? 9! 98 ?50 =29683 ?51? 207<98308? 9! 517 89? ;9A<:403 E4?5 ?50 ?02A7 183 ;9834?49879>?501=200A08?1?880F620?47>62?502 12=603 BG ?50 :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 ?51? 207<98308? 9 L 513 ?1@08 <977077498 9> ?50 ! 7I A?7 9> 686?4:4H03 :183 E1G
- 10 -
B1;@48!!4?70:>183?5020>92017?50207<98308? 9! ?596=5>4:03181>>431C4?'880F620(51789??1@087?0<7 >92 =0??48= ?50 20=47?0203 71:0 3003 >29A ?50 207<98308? 9 183 ?51? 1<12? ?547 #962? 517 =218?03 ?4A0 >92 ;9A<:418;0 17 ?9 30<974? 48 )$ 9!! 183 ?50714392302517B0083479B0G03BG?50207<98308? 9! 183 >62?502 17 ?50 207<98308? 9! 343 89? 51C0 ?50 20I6474?0>6837?9;9A<:0?0?500F0;6?4989>?5020=47?0203 71:0 3003 E4?5 ?50 207<98308? 9 183 48 ?547 20=123 ?50 207<98308? 9! 517 08?0203 48?9 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= E4?5 ?50 <0?4?498027 183 ?50 08?420 71:0 ;98743021?498 9> 7! 17 0C4308? >29A 880F620 <143 BG ?50 <0?4?498027 183 ?5020>920 796=5? >92 3420;?498 ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 ;9874302 ?50 20<20708?1?498 A130 BG ?50 <0?4?498027?90F0;6?0?5020=47?020371:0300348>1C9629> ?50 <0?4?498027 748;0 ?50 207<98308? 9 L 517 20D0;?03?50;:14AA130BG207<98308? 9K!17 KK;9220;?03C430;51AB029230231?03!!! - 11 -
<02 92302 31?03 !! 183 1;;92348=:G 796=5? >92 48?02>0208;09>?547#962? 24 $%#518321750@512 :012803 ;96870: 20<20708?48= ?50 207<98308?
9 L 76BA4??03?51??5020<20708?1?498A130BG?50<0?4?498027 E4::B0;987430203481;;92318;0E4?5:1E A? 00?1
6?521 :012803 08492 #96870:
1<<01248= 98 B051:> 24 131275 9?5124 :012803 ;96870:
>92207<98308? 9! 76BA4??03 ?51? ?50 E24?<0?4?498 517 ?9 B0 20:0=1?03 ?9 ?50 $248;4<1: 08;5 08=1:626 >92 501248= B0>920 ?50 1<<29<241?0 2917?02 08;5 183 1:79 76BA4??03 98 A024?7 ?51? ?50 E24? <0?4?498 47 89? A148?1481B:048C40E9>?5092302<17703BG?547#962?48 ) 9 !! 183 1;;92348=:G 796=5? >92 347A4771: 9>?50E24?<0?4?498?471:7976BA4??03?51??547#962?B0 3420;? ?50 0=47?2G ?9 <97? ?547 E24? <0?4?498 B0>920 ?50 1<<29<241?008;51?08=1:626>92;98743021?498
- 12 -
1C48= ?1@08 89?0 9> ?50 76BA477498 A130 BG ?50 :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <12?407 4? 47 ?9 B0 89?03 ?51? ?50 <20708? E24? <0?4?498 E17 ;9880;?03 E4?5 )$ 9 !!! 98 !! 183 ?50201>?02 :47?03 B0>920?547#962?9870C021:31?07)$ 9 !!E17 >4:03 BG 207<98308? 9! 48 ?50 <20708? E24? <0?4?498 ;51::08=48= ?50 92302 9> 20D0;?498 9> 0F0;6?498 9> 20=47?020371:03003BG?50207<98308? 9E54;5 ;1A0?9B0347A4770317E4?5321E81??50487?18;09>?50 <0?4?498027 ?502048 '207<98308? 9! 48 ?50 <20708? E24? <0?4?498( ! 547 #962? 50123 ?50 :012803 08492 #96870: 24$1D=9<1:98B051:>9>24135676351819183 24$%#518321750@12:012803;96870:71<<01248=>92?50 207<98308? 9 98 ?50 012:402 9;;17498 1:98= E4?5 ?50 A024?7 9> ?50 ;170 48 )$ 9 !!! ? 47 1:79 ?9 B0 89?03 ?51? :012803 ;96870: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 48 )$ 9 !!! ?99@ 13D9628A08?7 307<4?0 ?50 71A0 E17 9<<9703 BG ?50 :012803 08492
- 13 -
#96870: 24 $1D=9<1: 1<<01248= >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 48 )$ 9! !!98?50012:4029;;174989E0C02?547 #962?=218?03?4A0?9?50207<98308? 9!502048?9A1@0 76BA4774987 183 0F?08303 >142 9<<92?684?G ?9 ?50 207<98308? 9! 5020>920 ?547 #962? 47 9> ?50 9<48498 ?51? 17 ?50 A1??02 E17 50123 48<12? 183 17 ?50 ;9880;?03 E24? <0?4?498 ;1A0 ?9 B0 E4?5321E8 BG ?50 <0?4?498027 ?502048 48 )$ 9 !!! 183 1? ?50 ;98708? 9> :012803 ;96870: >92 ?50 <0?4?498027 183 207<98308? 9L?99@6<?50A1??02>92501248= 5020>920 ?50 ;98?08?498 214703 BG 207<98308? 9! 17 7?1?031B9C0;1889?B01;;0<?03 879>1217?50A024?79>?50;17047;98;02803 4?4789?48347<6?0?51??50:18348I607?498E171::9??0348 >1C962 9> 207<98308? 9! 17 <02 <977077498 ;02?4>4;1?0 31?03 '880F620( ? 47 1:79 >92?5;9A48= ?51? ?50 207<98308? 9 L BG :0??02 31?03 !! '880F620#( 2076A03 ?50 686?4:4H03 :183 ?9 180F?08?9>!7IA?717?50207<98308? 9!34389? - 14 -
;9A<:GE4?5?50?02A7183;9834?49877?4<6:1?0348:0170 ;6A71:01=200A08?<2936;031?880F620#$02671:9> ?50E24?<0?4?498E96:34834;1?0?51??50207<98308? 9! 517 >4:03 18 1>>431C4?
?9 ?50 207<98308? 9 ?9 ;9A<:G E4?5 ?50 ?02A7 183 ;9834?4987 9> ?50 :0170 1=200A08? 59E0C02 89 0>>92?7 517 B008 A130 BG ?50 207<98308? 9!?9=0??5020=47?020371:03003BG<1G48= ?5020I6474?071:0;98743021?498;:14A03BG?50207<98308? 9 L ? 47 ?9 B0 89?03 ?51? BG :0??02 31?03 !!! '880F620"( ?50 207<98308? 9 3420;?03 ?50 207<98308? 9! ?9 <1G ?50 1A968? 9> 7 >92 207?921?498 9> ?50 1::9?A08? 48 207<0;? 9> B1:18;0 ! 7I A?7 9> :183 ? 47 >92?5;9A48= >29A 880F620 ?51? 207<98308? 9! 517 08?0203 48?9 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= 31?03 ! !!'880F620(?9A9B4:4H0?50>6837E4?5?5423 <12?G 183 ?50201>?02 08?0203 48?9 0A921836A 9> 83027?18348= 31?03 ! '880F620( E4?5 ?50
- 15 -
<0?4?498027 17 ?9 A9B4:4H0 ?50 >6837 ?9 <1G ?50 71:0 ;98743021?498?9?50207<98308? 9 ?471:79?9B089?03?51??547#962?C43092302 ! 48 )$ 9!! C430 880F620* 1? <121=21<5 9 50:317>9::9E7. ! "#""$$ % &' ' $
( ##" ) $ * % $ &'
$+ ' ' (&$ '$$ $ , -$&'. - 16 -
8 ?50 A018 E54:0 <627618? ?9 ?50 D948? 1=200A08?B0?E008?50<0?4?498027E4?5207<98308? 9! ?50<0?4?49802751C0?2187>02203176A9>7! 48>1C962207<98308? 9K>92=0??48=?5020=47?020371:0 3003 >29A 207<98308? 9 L 183 1:79 30C0:9<03 ?50 :183 48 ?02A7 9> ?50 D948? 30C0:9<A08? 1=200A08? 50 <1GA08? 9> 7! ?2187>02203 BG ?50 <0?4?498027 48 >1C962 207<98308? 9K 47 20>:0;?03 48 880F620702407?471:79?9B089?03?51?207<98308? 9! >4:03 764? 48 9! 1=1487? 207<98308? 9LE54;5;1A0?9B0347A4770398! ! 183 ?50 71A0 E17 ;98>42A03 BG ?547 #962? 48 "
9!183?5020>9204?E96:3A1@074?;:012?51? 207<98308? 9! 517 89? ?1@08 18G 7?0<7 >92 1 <02493 9> >4C030;1307>29A?5031?09>1::9?A08? ?471:79>92?5;9A48=?51??50207<98308? 9! 517 ;18;0::03 ?50 D948? 30C0:9<A08? 1=200A08? E4?5 ?50 <0?4?498027 17 <02 :0=1: 89?4;0 31?03 ! '880F620 ( 183 4? 47 0C4308? >29A <121=21<5 9 9> KK;9220;?03C430;51AB029230231?03!!! - 17 -
?50:0=1:89?4;017?9?2187>029>76A9>7! B048=<143BG?50<0?4?498027?9207<98308? 9K?9E1237 207?921?4989>:183>29A?50207<98308? 9L? 47 >62?502 ?9 B0 89?03 ?51? 207<98308? 9! 517 >4:03 )$ 9! 183 ?547 #962? BG 92302 31?03 !!'880F620,(3420;?03?50207<98308? 9L ?9;9874302?50=240C18;09>?50<0?4?498027502048 183 207<98308? 9! 17 ?9 0F0;6?498 9> ?50 71:0 3003 50 1>9207143 92302 <17703 BG ?50 :012803 48=:0 *63=0 E17 ;51::08=0348 ) 9 !! 183 ?547 #962? C430 9230231?03!!!!'880F620(1?<121=21<5 97 ?950:317>9::9E7.
/ % 0 $$ $$ ( $ 1 $$ $ 2 3/ &' ' % $ + ( ' $ *" $$ K;9220;?03C430;51AB029230231?03!!! - 18 -
4 5 #" &6 *$ *" $$& $&' ' '& 1 $ &$ 1 ', 8?50B1;@329<9>?5070>1;?7<627618??9?50 92302 <17703 BG ?50 4C47498 08;5 9> ?547 #962? ?50 207<98308? 9 517 20D0;?03 ?50 ;:14A A130 BG ?50 207<98308? 9!17<02?509230231?03!!!183 ?50 71A0 E17 I607?49803 48 )$ 9 !!! BG ?50 207<98308? 9! E54;5 ;1A0 ?9 B0 347A47703 1? ?50 487?18;0 9> ?50 <0?4?498027 ?502048 51C48= E4?5320E ?50 71A0 8 ?51? C40E 9> ?50 A1??02 ?1@48= 48?9 ;98743021?498 ?51? ?50 <0?4?498027 51C0 <143 7! ?9207<98308? 9K?9;9A<:GE4?5?50 ?02A7 183 ;9834?4987 9> ?50 :0170;6A71:0 1=200A08? <2936;03 1? 880F620 183 >62?502 <1GA08? 9> 71:0 ;98743021?4984720>:0;?0317<02880F6207183702407 183 1:79 4? 47 89? 48 347<6?0 ?51? >92 1 <02493 9> >4C0 K;9220;?03C430;51AB029230231?03!!! - 19 -
30;1307 207<98308? 9! 517 89? A130 18G 0>>92?7 ?9 70;620?5020=47?020371:03003183?50201>?0271A0E17 20D0;?03BG9230231?03!!!BG207<98308? 9L 1A9>?50C40E?51??502047894A<034A08?>92 ?50207<98308? 9LB048=18487?26A08?1:4?G9> ?50?1?0683022?4;:0!9>?50#987?4?6?4989>8341?9 ?1@030;4749848?50A1??02?91::9??50:18348I607?49848 >1C9629>?50<0?4?49802717?5071431::9?A08?517?9B0 A130 48 >1C962 9>207<98308? 9! 517 B00820D0;?03 BG 92302 31?03 !!! BG ?50 207<98308? 9 183 17 76;5 207<98308? 9 47 3420;?03 ?9 ?1@0 30;47498 17 ?9 ?50 20<20708?1?498 31?03 !!! '880F620( 48 1;;92318;0E4?5:1E1??50012:407?E4?5481896?02:4A4?9> ?E9 A98?57 >29A ?50 31?0 9> 20;04<? 9> ;02?4>403 ;9<G 9> ?547923028?50:4=5?9>?509B702C1?4987A1301B9C0 ;;92348=:G)24?$0?4?49847347<97039> !*+ (! !) $ C52? 47? 9.:
9. #.$