- 1 - ! "#"$ %&#!# '!( ! !" ## $ %## & '' Digitally signed by SACHIN Location: HIGH COURT OF KARNATAKA - 2 - $ ' & ( ) * ( - 3 - &* $ ' && ! # $+ #+ #&" ' # $$( $$ # # ' # , $*$$ )$$-$( ## %- ' # ' . - 4 - . / 01 2134345617 089 :08;;16<1= 8 6534:1 >18746< 5 ?8@26 5.)$$-$( =831= $*$$ 499?1= >A 719256=163 5 301 86:08A830 1B1;52@163 CC4:17 46C57@46< 301 2134345617 8>5?3 8 7195;?3456 28991= >A 719256=163556&)$$86==471:31=04@35904C3 57 71@5B1 301 24<93A C84;46< D04:0 82275274831 8:3456 D5?;=>146434831= $!4" 01 2134345617 :56316=9 3083 01 49 301 5D617 86= 46 2599199456 5C 8 2752173A >18746< 1-E08308 5 )))) 943?831= 46 598>?=86?7? 4;;8<1 898>8 5>;4 86=A88;?E@189?746<<?63891:;84@930830149 8 @4:75 C87@17 86= 089 1938>;4901= 8 24<93A 56 301 :56B1731=;86=1822758:01=719256=1635C57<7863 5C;4:16:1D04:0D898::57=46<;A<78631=56)$* 1 :56316=9 3083 01 089 >116 7?6646< 8 24<93A 46 8 9:41634C4: @86617 08B46< 71<87= 35 301 C8:3 3083 301 24<9 - 5 - 86=24<;1398719?9:1234>;135B478;86=>8:31748;46C1:34569 18;95:56316=930833012752173A46F?19345649943?831= 5?394=1 301 78@83868 D04:0 49 1B4=163 C75@ 301 16=5791@163 >18746< 5 ?8@26 5 ($$-$( =831=)$$499?1=>A719256=1635 !44" 1C?73017:56316=93083719256=1635>A8 6534:1=831=$$46C57@1=3012134345617355>3846 8;4:16:1>1C571:56346?46<3018:34B43A5C718746<24<901 2134345617712;41=35301984=6534:156$$<4B46< 30128734:?;8795C3018:34B43419?6=1738E164630124<93A !444" 1 :56316=9 3083 301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 46921:31=30124<93A86=8C317:5;;1:346<46C57@83456C75@ 301 7194=1639 46 301 B4:4643A 8==71991= 8 ;13317 =831= ))$$ 35 301 49374:3 18;30 86= #8@4;A '1;C871 CC4:17 86=A8 938346< 3083 301 7194=1639 D171 5C 301 52464563083301213434561708=@84638461=2752170A<4161 46 301 24<93A 86= 3083 65 C5?; 9@1;; D89 1@868346< 30171C75@ - 6 - !4B" 4E1D491 8 5:357 83 301 74@87A 18;30 16317 1;1>?=86?7? 8C317 46921:346< 301 24<93A 5C 301 213434561708=8==71991=8;13317=831=)$$35301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 938346< 3083 301 24<93A 49 5217831= 0A<4164:8;;A !B" 01 041C 13174687A CC4:17 86=A8 8;95 46921:31= 301 24<93A 5C 301 2134345617 86= C5?6= 3083 01 08=@84638461=0A<41614630124<93A17125731=30838 >571D1;; D89 943?831= 83 8 =49386:1 5C C113 C75@ 301 24<93A 86= 30171 D89 25994>4;43A 5C 301 >571D1;; >146< 25;;?31= 86= 30171C571 01 08= 8=B491= 301 2134345617 35 38E1 61:19987A 93129 35 =492591 5CC 301 >45-D8931 <1617831=4630124<93A !B4" 1 :56316=9 3083 301 12?3A 471:357 5C 301 13174687A 12873@163 86=A8 D4305?3 46921:346< 301 24<93A8==71991=8;1331735301041CG1:?34B1CC4:175C 3018;?E86:08A83938346<3017146308330124<93A5C301 2134345617 49 ;5:831= 8=H8:163 35 8 758= 86= 3083 301 - 7 - 2134345617 08= 653 822;41= C57 7161D8; 5C 301 ;4:16:1 86= 3083 01 08= 653 5>38461= 8 65-5>H1:3456 :1734C4:831 C75@ 3015;;?345656375; 587=3D89C?73017@1634561=3083 8 >571D1;; 49 943?831= 83 8 =49386:1 5C C113 C75@ 301 9D461 C87@ 86= 3083 30171 D89 8 25994>4;43A 5C :5638@4683456 5C 301 D8317 46 301 >571D1;; 89 301 >45- D8931 <1617831= 46 301 24<93A D89 653 9:41634C4:8;;A =492591= 5CC D04:0 D89 08I87=5?9 35 301 <16178; 2?>;4: 86= 30171C571 71:5@@16=1= 9?438>;1 8:3456 8<84693 301 2134345617 !B44"01718C317 301 041C G1:?34B1 CC4:17 5C 301 8;?E86:08A83046317@95C8;13317=831=*)$$ =471:31= 719256=163 5 35 38E1 8:3456 8<84693 301 2134345617 >A 143017 1B4:346< 301 2134345617 57 :;5946< 301 24<93A 86= 712573 :5@2;486:1 5691F?163;A 719256=163 5 28991= 8 7195;?3456 =831= &)$$ C5;;5D46< D04:0301499?1=3014@2?<61=6534:1012134345617 4930171C571>1C57130495?73:08;;16<46<301984=6534:1 - 8 - &!4" 01;18761=:5?691;C5730121343456179?>@4331= 3083 7?6646< 8 24<93A 49 8 217@4331= 8:34B43A ?6=17 301 876838E8 86= 1C57@9 :3 C57 D04:0 65 217@499456 57 ;4:16:1 49 71F?471= 1 C?73017 9?>@439 3083 301 24<93A 49 1938>;4901= 46 274B831 ;86= >1;56<46< 35 301 2134345617 D04:0 49 943?831= 5?394=1 301 78@83868 ;4@439 86= 30171C57130121343456174916343;1=357?630124<93A46049 ;86= !44" 1 :56316=9 3083 301 712573 9?>@4331= >A 301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 35 301 49374:3 18;30 86= #8@4;A '1;C871 CC4:17 89 D1;; 89 301 ;13317 =831= )$$ 8==71991=>A 301 5:357 8330174@87A 18;30 1631735 3018;?E18;30CC4:17 86= 301 ;133178==71991=>A 301 041C13174687ACC4:1786=A88718;;91;C-:56378=4:357A !444" 1 :56316=9 3083 D04;1 301 712573 5C 301 041C 13174687A CC4:17 C8B5?79 301 2134345617 301 12?3A 471:357 5C 13174687A 12873@163 D4305?3 B494346< 301 C87@>891=5630152464565C301041C13174687ACC4:17/9 - 9 - 712573 :56:;?=1= 3083 301 7?6646< 301 24<93A @8A 8CC1:3 301 018;30 5C 301 <16178; 2?>;4: 1 9?>@439 3083 30191 7125739=565308B186A>894986=871C87-C13:01= !4B" 1 C?73017 :56316=9 3083 301 2134345617 49 718746<87871>711=5C24<9D04:008B135>178491=468 0A<4164:16B4756@16386=308330171491B17A25994>4;43A5C 301 24<9 86= 24<;139 9?::?@>46< 35 B478; 86= >8:31748; 46C1:34569 0171C571 01 :56316=9 3083 301 2134345617 49 >5?6=35@8463846:;186;46199>530D4304686=5?394=1301 24<93A0?901:56316=930833014@2?<61=6534:108965 >8949 !B" 1 C?73017 :56316=9 3083 4C 301 7?6646< 5C 301 24<93A >A 301 2134345617 :8?919 86A 6?4986:1 3016 301 275:1=?71 :5631@2;831= ?6=17 1:3456 $ 5C 301 087834A8 8<874E ?78E908 860438 ! " 905?;= >1 :5@2;41= D430 1 30171C571 9?>@439 3083 >1C571 719256=163 5 38E19 86A 8:3456 43 49 46:?@>163 ?256 301 719256=1639 35 5>3846 8 C8:3?8; 712573 71<87=46< 301 - 10 - 98C1<?87=9 38E16 >A 301 2134345617 D04;1 7?6646< 301 24<93A D013017 301 24<93A 49 >146< @84638461= 0A<4164:8;;A 86= 8;95 D013017 43 49 8CC1:346< 301 <16178; 2?>;4: 46 86A @86617 D083951B17 1 30?9 :56316=9 3083 301 4@2?<61= 6534:1 089 >116 499?1= D4305?3 :56=?:346< 86A9?:01G17:49186=49>891=568@171899?@234563083 301 7?6646< 5C 301 24<93A >A 301 2134345617 49 ;4E1;A 35 :8?91018;3008I87=86=6?4986:1353017194=1639 !B4" 69?225735C30191:5631634569;18761=:5?691; 71;41= ?256 301 H?=<@163 5C 5-57=46831 16:0 5C 3049 5?73 46 74@468; 1343456 5$)$* 1 089 8;95 71;41= ?256 301 H?=<@163 5C 5-57=46831 16:0 5C 3049 5?7346'74313434565&))$(D017185-57=46831 16:0 D89 :5694=1746< 301 F?193456 D013017 8 ;4:1691 49 71F?471=357?6825?;37AC87@ !B44"1 089 8;95 71C1771= 35 301 H?=<@163 5C 301 4B49456 16:0 5C 3049 5?73 46 '743 1343456 5($) D04:0 D89 71;8346< 35 301 =49:087<1 5C - 11 - D893186=3018;;1<1=6?4986:1:8?91=>A8646=?937A1 :56316=9 3083 301 4B49456 16:0 5C 3049 5?73 5>917B1= 3083D0168646=?937A491938>;4901=468646=?93748;8718 87194=163469?:046=?93748;8718:86653:5@2;8463083301 46=?937A49:8?946<25;;?3456130171C5719?>@4331=3083 30121343456170891938>;4901=824<93A46049;86=86=301 7194=1639 5C 301 B4;;8<1 :86653 :5@2;846 89 7?6646< 5C 8 24<<17A >A 301 2134345617 49 86 8<74:?;3?78; 8:34B43A 217@4331= ?6=17 301 275B494569 5C 301 876838E8 86= 1C57@9 :3 1 8;95 71C1771= 35 8 4B49456 16:0 H?=<@163 5C 3049 5?73 46 '743 1343456 5$)$* D04:0 D89 8 2?>;4: 46317193 ;434<83456 C4;1= >A 8 95:413A 71271916346< 8 28734:?;87 :5@@?643A D04:0 D89 274@874;A 46B5;B1= 46 718746< 24<9 1 :56316=9 3083 301 4B49456 16:08C3176534:46<301B8745?9:5631634569?7<1=83301 87469?225735C30147:;84@3083718746<24<9@8A:8?91 2?>;4: 6?4986:1 =471:31= 301 8?305743419 5C 301 3831 35 187@87E 2?>;4: 2;8:19 D0171 2179569 >1;56<46< 35 301 :5@@?643A :5?;= 7187 24<9 86= 8;95 35 =12?31 9?:0 - 12 - 2179569 35 301 :56:1761= ?64B17943419 35 ;1876 8>5?3 0A<4161 46 301 1938>;490@163 5C 9?:0 24<<17419 1 30171C571:56316=930833015?73908B1>1168;4B135301 275>;1@9 C8:1= >A 2152;1 718746< 24<9 89 D1;; 89 301 5D61795C9?:024<<174191:56316=9308395;56<89301 2134345617 49 7?6646< 049 24<93A D4305?3 :8?946< 86A 6?4986:1 57 087@ 35 301 7194=1639 5C 301 B4;;8<1 719256=1635:8665346B5E186A25D1735:8;;?256301 213434561735:;591=5D630124<<17A !4" 01 D743 21343456 49 522591= >A 719256=163 59 35 & D05 089 C4;1= 8 93831@163 5C 5>H1:34569 :56316=46< 3083 301 2134345617 49 52178346< 8 24<93AD43046301;4@4395C719256=163546B45;834565C 3019383?357A71F?471@1639 3 49 :;84@1=3083 305?<0 301 213434561708=187;4175>38461=8<16178;;4:169130198@1 08= 1G2471= 46 301 A187 $$$ 86= 65 93129 D171 38E16 301718C31735<13437161D1=>?33012134345617:56346?1935 521783130124<93A - 13 - !44" 349:56316=1=3083?6=17301275B4945695C301 876838E8 86:08A83 8H :3 8 B8;4= 86= 9?>949346< ;4:16:149@86=8357AC57378=199?:08924<<17AD04:0089 25316348;43A 35 <1617831 6?4986:1 C5?; 5=5?7 86= 749E 5C :5638@4683456 5C D8317 95?7:19 3 49 C?73017 :56316=1= 3083 301 2134345617 49 7?6646< 301 24<93A 46 8 04<0;A ?60A<4164:?69:41634C4:86=4771925694>;1@8661786=3083 43 49 <16178346< C5?; 5=5?7 86= 49 =49:087<46< ?6371831= D8931 83378:346< 4691:39 86= C;419 30171>A :8?946< 6?4986:186=018;3008I87=353017194=16395C301B4;;8<1 349:;84@1=30833017194=16395C3016187>AB4;;8<108B1 >116 9?CC1746< :56346?5?9 6?4986:1 25;;?3456 @59F?435 @168:1 86= =493?7>86:1 C57 30147 218:1C?; 86= =4<64C41= ;4B46< !444" 3 49 93831= 3083 91B178; 7194=1639 08B1 ;5=<1= 6?@175?9 :5@2;84639 D430 719256=163 5 86= B8745?9 8?305743419 5C 301 3831 46:;?=46< 301 ?@86 4<039 5@@499456 891= 56 301 :5@2;84639 95 ;5=<1= 301 5;;?3456 56375; 587= B4=1 ;13317 =831= $$$ - 14 - 46C57@1= 719256=163 5 35 89:173846 D013017 301 2134345617 08= 5>38461= 301 @86=8357A 5->H1:3456 1734C4:831C75@301 587=953083822752748318:3456:5?;= >146434831=01 587=8;9571:57=1=30833014<<17AD89 :8?946<6?4986:186=25946<8018;3008I87= !4B" 3 49 :;84@1= 3083 301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 86=A8 8C317 46921:346< 301 ?643 5C 301 2134345617 9?>@4331=8712573=831=))$$3530149374:318;30 CC4:17 938346< 3083 301 24<<17A 49 @84638461= 46 86 ?60A<4164:@8661786=49:8?946<?635;=6?4986:135301 B4;;8<179 3 D89 8;95 7125731= 3083 89 217 2?>;4: 018;30 657@9824<<17A@?93>1;5:831=83;189330711E4;5@13179 8D8AC75@87194=16348;08>4383456D0171893012134345617/9 ?64349943?831=>871;A838=49386:15C$@13179C75@301 B4;;8<1 !B" 349:56316=1=30832?79?86335301:5@2;84639 ;5=<1= >A 301 719256=1639 301 041C 13174687A CC4:17 ! =@46493783456" 46921:31= 301 24<<17A 86= 9?>@4331= 8 - 15 - 712573 =831= ()$$ 35 301 12?3A 471:357 ! =@46493783456" 12873@163 5C 64@8; 86= ?9>86=7A 86=A8 :56C47@46< 3083 301 2134345617 08= 653 5>38461= 5>H1:34561734C4:831C75@301876838E838315;;?3456 56375; 587= 86= 089 653 5>38461= 8 ;4:16:1 >?3 49 935746< >45-D8931 46 614<0>5?746< ;86= D04:0 49 ;5:831= :;591 35 8 >571D1;; 3 49 :;84@1= 3083 =192431 7121831= D87646<9 301 2134345617 C84;1= 35 38E1 86A 71@1=48; @189?719 !B4" 6301:563787AD016301B4;;8<179822758:01= 301213434561771F?19346<04@3593523016?4986:186=35 8=523 0A<4164: @189?719 301 2134345617 8998?;31= 301 B4;;8<179 86= 307183161= 301@ D430 =471 :5691F?16:19 :5@2;846346308371<87=D89;5=<1=D43030186=A8?78; 5;4:156)$$ !B44"3 49 :56316=1= 3083 301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 8<846 46921:31= 301 24<93A 86= 9?>@4331= 8 712573 =831= (*$$ 921:4C4:8;;A 938346< 3083 301 24<<17A @?93 >1 - 16 - 83 ;1893 30711 E4;5@13179 8D8A C75@ 7194=16348; 87189 D01718930124<<17A7?6>A301213434561749943?831=838 =49386:15C$@131798D8AC75@30178@830868;4@439 3D89C?730177125731=30833012134345617=4=6532599199 8B8;4=;4:169186=308301D89:5;;1:346<301;1C35B17C55= C75@:05?;3741986=0531;986=935746<46C5?7755@9?6=17 ?60A<4164::56=43456986=3083>571D1;;9D171943?831=83 8 =49386:1 5C ( C113 86= -$ C113 8D8A C75@ 301 24<<17A D04:0 D171 83 749E 5C >146< 25;;?31= 3 49 :56316=1=30833012?>;4:C8:1<7183=4CC4:?;3A468::19946< 30131@2;1=?135301C4;3086=5=5?71@868346<C75@301 24<<17A3D898;957125731=308330171D89891745?9749E 5C:5638<45?9=4918919?6;1994@@1=48318:3456D8938E16 19256=163 5 30171C571 9?>@439 3083 3049 :56:;?94B1;A 1938>;4901=308330121343456174952178346<30124<93A4686 4;;1<8;?60A<4164:=86<175?9@8661786=:8?946<?635;= 6?4986:1353017194=16395C301B4;;8<1 !B444"3 49 8;95 :;84@1= 3083 89 217 124=1@45;5<4:8; =838 2?>;4901= >A 301 834568; 1:357 5761 491891 - 17 - 56375;75<78@@1464937A5C18;3086=#8@4;A'1;C871 5B176@163 5C 6=48 D04:0 49 :5775>57831= >A 93?=419 :56=?:31=>A 86=3016=4865?6:4;5C1=4:8; 19187:0 !" 876838E8 8 94<64C4:863 46:4=16:1 5C 8286191 16:1208;4349 :8919 18:0 A187 49 7125731= D430 =49374:394695?30176876838E846:;?=46<A957186=A8 04B8@5<<8 86= 9?775?6=46< 71<4569 C8;;46< D43046 301 6534C41=16=1@4:I5619 !4G" 3 49 C?73017 93831= 3083 30191 93?=419 @163456 308324<9871301274@87A8@2;4CA46<059395C3018286191 16:1208;4349 B47?9 86= 3083 D016 @59F?43519 >431 86 46C1:31= 24< 301A 8:F?471 04<0 B478; ;58=9 86= 9?>91F?163;A37869@43301B47?9350?@8693075?<0>4319 !G" 3 49 :56316=1= 3083 301 24<93A 1938>;4901= >A 301 2134345617 49 653 8 9@8;;-9:8;1 ?643 >?3 8 ;87<1 1938>;490@163 D0171 8>5?3 ( 35 24<9 871 71871= ?:0 8 ;87<1:56:163783456 5C24<9 46 8=1691;A4608>431= 7194=16348; 8718 25919 8 04<0 124=1@45;5<4:8; 749E - 18 - 0171C5714349:;84@1=3083434961:19987AC57719256=163 53571<?;8313018:34B434195C3012134345617349 8;95 :56316=1= 3083 301 @86617 46 D04:0 301 2134345617 49 52178346<30124<93A495CC16=46<301C?6=8@1638;74<0395C 301B4;;8<17916907461=?6=17 734:;1$5C301569343?3456 5C 6=48 3 49 :;84@1= 3083 ?6=17 30191 :5@21;;46< :47:?@9386:19 719256=163 5 D89 C57:1= 35 499?1 301 4@2?<61=6534:1=831=$*$$86=430898:31=D43046 439 25D179 ?6=17 1:34569 $&$ $&& $&* 86= $$ 5C 301 876838E886:08A8308H :3**& 01;18761=:5?691;C57719256=1635935& 714317831=3018C571984=:5631634569 ( 01 ;18761= :5?691; C57 719256=163 5 089 8;95 522591= 301 D743 21343456 >A C4;46< 86 1;8>57831 93831@163 5C5>H1:34569 D01714643 49:56316=1= 3083 301 2134345617 497?6646< 30124<93A4686 ?60A<4164: @86617 34993831=30833018;?E18;30CC4:1786=A846921:31= 30124<93A86=@87E1=8;13317=831=))$$71257346< - 19 - 301 @86617 46 D04:0 301 2134345617 D89 52178346< 301 24<93A 4E1D491 43 49 :;84@1= 3083 301 5:357 5C 301 74@87A 18;30 16317 08= 8;95 8==71991= 8 ;13317 =831= )$$8C317:5694=1746<301<741B86:195C301<16178; 2?>;4:4@4;87;A301041C13174687ACC4:1786=A88C317 46921:346< 30124<93A5C 3012134345617 8==71991=8 ;13317 =831=()$$ C?73017;13317=831=*)$$D89 8==71991= >A 301 12?3A 471:357 5C 301 13174687A 12873@163 35 301 041C G1:?34B1 CC4:17 938346< 3083 30171 49 8 25994>4;43A 5C :5638@4683456 5C D8317 46 8 >571 D1;; 943?831= 83 8 =49386:1 5C 8>5?3 C113 C75@ 301 C87@ 3 49 C?73017 93831= 3083 301 G1:?34B1 CC4:17 08= 8==71991= 8 ;13317 35 719256=163 5 35 38E1 93129 143017 C57 904C346< 301 24<93A C75@ 301 1G49346< 9431 57 35 :;59?715C301C87@3D89463083:5631G33083719256=163 5 8==71991= 301 6534:1 D04:0 49 4@2?<61= 46 3049 21343456 3 49 :56316=1= 3083 301 8;?E 18;30 CC4:17 86=A8 08= 8==71991= 8 ;13317 =831= (*$$ 35 - 20 - 719256=1635938346<3083824<<17A905?;=>1;5:831= 83 ;1893 30711 E4;5@13179 8D8A C75@ 8 7194=16348; 8718 D01718930124<93A1938>;4901=>A301213434561749>871;A $ @13179 C75@ 301 7194=16348; 8718 0171C571 43 49 :56316=1=30833016534:1499?1=>A719256=16354946 57=1786=49@18633527531:386=271B16330192718=46<5C 86A=49189186=35169?7130833017194=16395C301B4;;8<1 ;4B1468018;30A83@5920171 ) 01 ;18761= :5?691; C57 719256=163 5 714317831=3018>5B1:5631634569 * 6 822;4:83456 49 C4;1= >A 301 7194=1639 5C 301 B4;;8<1911E46<217@49945635:5@15671:57=86=:563193 301D7432134345634930147:891308330124<93A1938>;4901= >A301213434561749:8?946<6?4986:135301@86=3083301 2134345617 D4305?3 5>384646< 86A ;4:1691 C75@ 301 86:08A83 49 52178346< 301 ?643 46 86 4;;1<8; 86= ?60A<4164:@8661730171>A1G25946<3017194=163935301 749E5C46C1:345601A30171C571=1947135:5@15671:57= - 21 - 86= 719493 301 D743 21343456 01 ;18761= :5?691; C57 301 2752591= 719256=1639 8;95 714317831= 301 8>5B1 :5631634569 86= 278A1= 3083 946:1 301 822;4:8639 871 8CC1:31= >A 301 521783456 5C 301 24<93A 301A 905?;= >1 0187=46301@83317>1C57186A57=174928991= '1 08B1 :5694=171= 301 9?>@4994569 5C 301 ;18761= :5?691; C57 301 2134345617 89 D1;; 89 301 ;18761= :5?691;C57301719256=1639 ?746< 301 :5?791 5C 3049 D743 21343456 3049 5?73=19471=355>38468C4793086=46C57@834568>5?3301 24<93A 7?6 >A 301 2134345617 86= 30171C571 D1 71F?1931= 86 =B5:8314657=17=831=$$35B494330124<93A 1938>;4901= >A 301 2134345617 86= 9?>@43 8 712573 01 5?73 5@@49945617 B49431= 301 ?643 5C 301 2134345617 56 $$86=9?>@4331=8712573D04:0718=989C5;;5D9. ! " # $ - 22 - % & '() " & ' & & ! & *) ! ! ' +! ! ! ! ! ! ! , & - &.% & / 0 & 1(. " 22322% % & 4 4 & & & 4!% &&& & % ! % & - 23 - 0 1(* " 22322 % " 443/45% & % 6 ! && & 3% ! 7 & - % & & & . & 6%( & && & && 5 0&% & - .& 6 4 & & & & & & ' &&& . ! 2 0 % %&! 0. - 24 - & !8 &% 3% ! ! 9 !% #& ! $ ! & & & & % & % &! % & ! ! % 4 ! * ) % 8& % - 25 - !&. 0 & +% & ! & . % + 6% 6 44 &1:4"7 & 2(4 ! 8 !& ! ( ; 4 0 % & 1 ! 4 % ! 4/ 5 .% & ! & ! &% ! 9 #$ - 26 - 4 0 & &% #1:$%& &&&& 4/ 0&% & % ! 4 ! &% ! && 4 0 % 0 & & % / & . " ( 1 8 ! & 47 0 (& .% ! (% & %&. 45 0:%! &% %0 . ! . &&< &( - 27 - !%& & % ! % & + 6% 6 = $ C31771:1423 5C 301 5@@49945617/9712573 301 2134345617 :56316=1= 3083 01 08= 2?3 ?2 8==434568; 46C78937?:3?71358771933016?4986:1>A1938>;49046<8>45- D89312;863D04:049:5B171=568;;94=19349:56316=1= 30833049C8:4;43AD5?;=38E1:8715C3018227101694565C301 <16178; 2?>;4: 86= :56316=9 3083 301 99493863 5@@499456175C3018;?E@8A>1=471:31=35:56=?:386 46921:3456 5C 301 ?643 35 89:173846 D013017 301 2719163 521783456 5C 301 24<93A 49 :8?946< 86A 6?4986:1 35 301 2?>;4: & 01:5631634565C301213434561730837?6646<8 24<<17A46868<74:?;3?78;;86=498217@4331=8:34B43A8943 - 28 - C8;;9D43046301=1C46434565CJ8<74:?;3?71K?6=171:3456$!4" 5C 301 876838E8 86= 1C57@9 :3 8221879 275>8>;1 83 301 C4793 >;?90 89 8 217?98; 5C 1:3456 $ @8E19 43 8>?6=863;A:;1873083301D57=J8<74:?;3?71K46:;?=19 % 301 >711=46< 5C ;4B1935:E 5D1B17 8 =11217 ?6=179386=46< 5C 8<74:?;3?71 905D9 3083 43 46:;?=19 86:4;;87A 8:34B43419 3083 :5@2;1@163 8<74:?;3?71 9?:0 89 8F?8:?;3?71=847AC87@46<25?;37AC87@46<57>711=46<5C ;4B1935:E 0171C571 95 ;56< 89 301 274@87A 8:34B43A 49 C87@46< 86A2573456 5C 9?:0 C87@ ;86=?91= C57 86:4;;87A 8:34B43419D5?;=>1:56937?1=89>146<?91=C578<74:?;3?71 5D1B17 D016 301 ;86= 46 439 1634713A 49 ?91= C57 301 2?72591 5C>711=46< ;4B1935:E 56 8 :5@@17:48; >8949 301 5D617 5C 9?:0 ;86= :86653 :;84@ 301 >161C43 5C 301 =1C4643456?6=171:3456$5C301876838E8 86=1C57@9 :3 *( 049 49 95 946:1 301 ;86= 46 F?193456 49 65D 8991991= 35 38G >A 301 86:08A83 @18646< 30171>A 3083 301;86=;419D43046301;4@4395C30186:08A83 - 29 - 01 2134345617 089 653 =492?31= 301 C8:3 3083 301718713071175D95C:5@2873@16394630124<<17A01 C4793 75D :5@274919 5C $ 9@8;; 755@9 301 91:56= :5@274919 5C 9@8;; 755@9 46 301 C7563 86= 9@8;; 755@983301718786=3013047=:5@2749195C$75D9D430 *& <19383456 :8<19 01 2134345617 089 653 =492?31= 301 C8:330838;87<16?@>175C9D46187171871=4630124<93A 546<>A301=19:74234565C30146C78937?:3?717125731=>A 301 5?73 5@@49945617 43 <4B19 86 4@27199456 3083 301 213434561749718746<8;87<16?@>175C24<94630124<93A 98@833175CC8:3301213434561704@91;C089:;84@1=3083 301718718>5?3&24<9D017189301;18761=:5?691;C57 719256=163 5 35 & :;84@9 3083 30171 871 @571 3086 (24<9 13083 8943 @8A 43 49 65346 =492?313083301 C11=?91=C573019124<949;87<1;AC55=D8931<1617831=46 0531;986=530171938>;490@1639D04:0493786925731=C75@ 301?7>86871893530124<93A?:0D893108935>193571= 46 8 0A<4164: @86617 86= 301 D8931 <1617831= C75@301 - 30 - 24<93A 089 35 >1 =492591= 5C 46 86 1F?8;;A 0A<4164: @86617 3 :86653 >1 ;13 4635 301 91D8<1 57 8;;5D1= 35 217:5;8314635301954;893049@8A:5638@46831301D8317 95?7:19 89 7125731= >A 301 B8745?9 8?305743419 5C 301 3831 ( 34971;1B8633565313083301275B4945695C301 876838E8 86:08A83 8H :3 **& !0171468C317 71C1771= 35 89 L301 8:3 **&M" :5631@2;831 :173846 C?6:34569 86= =?341935>1217C57@1=>A30186:08A831:3456)5C301 :3 **& @86=8319 3083 43 49 301 =?3A 5C 1B17A 78@8 86:08A83 35 @113 301 611=9 5C 301 2152;1 5C 301 86:08A83 8718 86= 43 908;; 08B1 25D179 35 8=@4649317 @83317916?@17831=46:01=?;186=8;95891;8>57831= 46 30171925694>4;43A @82 46 71921:3 5C 78@8 86:08A83 86= 35 2712871 86= 4@2;1@163 9:01@19 C57 95:48; 1:565@4: 86= :?;3?78; =1B1;52@163 C57 301 718;4I83456 5C 95:48;H?934:1C578;;958935169?718616B4756@1633083 49 98C1 86= :56<1648; C57 8;; :434I169 35 1G17:491 30147 74<039:01=?;15C301 :3**&:57719256=9351:3456 - 31 - )5C301 :3**&637A!&":56C17930125D1756301 86:08A83 35 38E1 271B1634B1 @189?719 35 :56375; 124=1@4:986=:5638<45?9=4918919D04;1637A$:56C179 ?256 301 86:08A83 30125D17 35169?71 =1B1;52@1635C 018;30 86= 9864383456 25;4:A 86= 439 4@2;1@16383456 46:;?=46< :5;;1:3456 91<71<83456 86= 378692573 5C 95;4= D893135@?;34-B4;;8<195;4=D8931@868<1@1632;863986= 4@2;1@16383456 5C 9864383456 86= D8931 @868<1@163 275<78@@19 83 301 78@8 86:08A83 ;1B1; 637A $) 71:5<64I1930174<035C30186:08A83352;864@2;1@163 27531:386=271917B17?78;16B4756@16386=1:5;5<A 1:3456 ) @86=8319 301 286:08A83 35 38E1 9312935@84638460A<416146301286:08A83871886=C57 30832?7259143908;;46921:386=71<?;8313018:34B434195C 46=4B4=?8;9 57 1938>;490@1639 3083 871 16<8<1= 46 301 :831746<5CC55=D831786=53017:569?@8>;19D43046301 286:08A83871886=35275B4=18:;18616B4756@163C711 C75@5216=1C1:8345686=<87>8<11:3456)#5C301 :3 **& 8;95 16=5D9 ?256 301 86:08A83 B8745?9 - 32 - 71925694>4;43419 35 169?71 3083 0A<4161 86= 98C1 16B4756@163 871 @84638461= D43046 301 B4;;8<1 286:08A83 8718 ) 0171C571 43 :86653 >1 :56316=1= 3083 86 8:34B43A9?:089824<93AD04:0089@5713086&57( 24<9 :86 >1 371831= 89 86 8<74:?;3?78; 8:34B43A D04:0 49 1G1@23C75@;4:16946<>A30186:08A836304971<87=43 49275C438>;13571C1735301?=<@1635C30156M>;1 21G 5?73 46 301 :891 5C !" D0171 301 56/>;1 21G 5?73 D04;1 :5694=1746< 8 :891 5C 71;5:83456 5C @4;E =847419 D04:0 D89 :718346< 6?4986:1 35 301:434I1695C5=02?7499?1=C87-718:046<=471:3456986= 01;=89C5;;5D9. J > % < ?% & & @ - 33 - 4 : &3 & &).A B% & & & ! ! 4( (58 . &3 & . ? ! ? (/(5 B,)A ? +! ' &3 !%!8 ) A ? ! % %% %%% ? ! (/(58 - 34 - / -! ! -! 4( (58 ) A ! % 8 7 -! A ! . &3 ! ( (58 5 0 & A A.%& A 5((5 * 01 4<0 5?73 5C 8=789 46 # #$% & '!! ( ) - 35 - *+ D04;1 :5694=1746< 8 :891 5C 8 24<<17A1938>;4901= 46 8 274B831 ;86= D04:0 D89 :8?946< 6?4986:1 35 301 <16178;2?>;4:01;=89C5;;5D9. C9 D %; & < & & ; ! 0 % ! AA2 )%) 0 %2 '- > " 45/B +! + 2 4997% 0 % E 1! > 0 % & % A> % 1! > &% % - 36 - % /% /% /7 /5 " + ) D% 49 & . & / . % - > " 45/B +! + 2 4997 ' % %0 % 0 % &A& % : = $ 4E1D4913014<05?735C?6H8>86=87A868 46 * ! *, F > !!, ( &-.,,"D04:08;9571;831=357?6646<5C 824<<17A468274B831;86=01;=89C5;;5D9. C G0%&( &&'+ >% !+) - 37 - '+ >% & % ( D% % +) '+ > E &! ('+ > -! +)! . ( 0 & . & ( 0!&% ! 4 A A 7 E !!< !& % % ! +) = - 38 - $ 5-57=46831 16:0 5C 3049 5?73 46 '5$$*$$D04;1:5694=1746<301:8915C824<93A 1938>;4901=4687194=16348;;5:8;43A01;=89C5;;5D9. C/ ! H- D!& % 0 & = $$ 01834568;711674>?68;468:8917125731= 46 / $ # - ( !* ( 01$ 2 46 71921:3 5C 8 :891C75@301938315C876838E871;8346<351938>;490@163 5C824<93A468274B831;86=01;=89C5;;5D9. C42 H % ! &;A13A>: DD%! . - % & ! % - 39 - +A % )!%*. A'! A A' ! A A' - A A1 A> % = $& 01 8C571984= H?=<@163908B1 34@1 86= 8<846 714317831= 3083 1938>;490@163 5C 8 24<93A =519 :8?91 6?4986:1 >A 301 C5?; 9@1;; D04:0 :86 8CC1:3 301 <16178; 2?>;4: 7194=46< 6187>A 6 301 4693863 :891 301 24<93A 1938>;4901=>A301213434561749943?831=$@131798D8A C75@30161871937194=16348;8718 $ 19256=163 5 D04:0 49 >5?6= 46 ;8D 35 169?71 3083 301 7194=1639 ;4B1 46 8 0A<4164: 83@5920171 86= 16B4756@163 =4= 653 >;46=;A 499?1 301 4@2?<61= 6534:1353012134345617>?330198@1D89>891=56B8745?9 71257399?>@4331=>A3018?305743419:56:1761=0171C571 - 40 - 301 2134345617 :86653 C46= C8?;3 D430 301 6534:1 499?1= >A 719256=163586=6546317C1716:149D8778631=D430301 984=6534:1 $ ::57=46<;A301D7432134345649 $( 6 B41D 5C 301=492598; 5C 3049D743 21343456 8;; 216=46<822;4:8345699386==492591=5C !)* '#( # 4935.*;5.

SUNIL B R v. PANCHAYATH DEVELOPMENT OFFICER

Judgment text