- 1 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 !"# $ !" # $ % % & $ ' ' ' % Digitally signed by RAKESH S HARIHAR Location: High Court of Karnataka, Dharwad Bench - 2 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 ( '' # $ (% ' % '"") % %% & ( $& % "" ''" % * ( ) & ( + $& ( "" ''" % * % '"$'& $& ) $& ( ( ' ( - 3 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 * % ( * ,, ( - - , ./ 0/121234/5 6578971/8 24 :3;;/5:/ <53; 7467=35/ 42>/5?21@ 748 03??/??/? 74 8/65// <53;754717A7 171/7B42>/5?21@./0/121234/5 2? 7=?3 ?9::/??<9= 24 1./ == 4827 75 C7;2471234 D91 ./ 2? 3D?159:1/8 D@ 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41E? 2;0964/8 358/5 871/8 "" FG 24 :3;;/4:246.2?053</??2347=H3954/@7?7478>3:71/ ./<25?15/?0348/41.7?24<35;/81./0/121234/51.71 .2? 700=2:71234 <35 /453==;/41 2? 5/H/:1/8 <35 :34157>/412343<1./;7487135@053>2?234?3<1./75 394:2=3<48279=/?F G - 4 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of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o. 28563 of 2025 24=7B.7?431D//4:7==/824J9/?123421B39=8431 D/30/4131./<25?15/?0348/41135/<9?//453==;/41 ./=/754/8:394?/=7569/?1.711./<25?15/?0348/41 ?.39=8 .7>/ /453==/8 1./ 0/121234/5 7? 74 78>3:71/ 748 1./4 17A/4 7:1234 948/5 /:1234 3< 1./ 8>3:71/? :1 '" ' F<35 ?.351 # $ %G 7<1/5 89/ 4312:/13.2; I 52 3B521./=/754/8:394?/=<351./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 ?9D;21? 1.71 1./ /512<2:71/ 2??9/8 D@ 1./ 0/121234/5,? /;0=3@/5 8/;34?1571/? 1.71 ./ B7?24?/5>2:/B./4./B7?095?9246.2?6578971234 24 =7B 748 1./5/<35/ 1./ 0/121234/5 :74431 ?9?1724 1.2? 0/121234 24 >2/B 3< 1./ 0/C 3951E? 8/:2?234? B.2:. 75/ 5/</55/8 13 24 1./ 2;0964/8 358/5 (./4 J9/52/8 34 1./ 7:1234 17A/413 <248 391 B./1./51./ 0/121234/5 .7? 248//8 711/48/8 :=7??/? 748 <35 :74:/==71234 3< 1./ 8/:5// 7::358/8 13 .2; 34 1./ 653948 1.71 ./ .7? 431 711/48/8 1./ ;242;9; - 6 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 49;D/53<:=7??/?1./=/754/8:394?/=?9D;21?1.71 437:1234.7?D//417A/4?3<75 ./ J9/?1234 05/?/41/8 <35 :34?28/571234 241./52>7=?9D;2??234?2?- & ' ( ') $ ) ( $ $ ( $ "*+, $ ' -) ' ) ' . ' ) /$ ''' $ ./ 2>2?234 /4:. 3< 1.2? 3951 B.2=/ :34?28/5246 B./1./5 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 :39=8 .7>/ 5/H/:1/8 1./ 5/J9/?1 <35 /453==;/41 D/:79?/ 1./ 700=2:741:39=8431.7>/7:.2/>/8!K3<711/4874:/ 7? 5/J925/8 948/5 1./ /67= 89:71234 9=/? - 7 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 F<35?.351# 0"!!"%G7?./B7?24/;0=3@;/41 B21.1./4:3;/7C/0751;/41.7?3D?/5>/81.9?- 1& /- ) & $ ( ) $ $ /- ) $ $)2 3( -0 4$ $ / ' '- ' $4$ $ $ /- 3( - 5 ' /4$ ) $ / 0 $ 6/4$ / /- $$ 7' ) $ ' /- ) ' /- 3( -0 $ $ 8 $ ) ' ' $/ ( ' ' )/ - $ 9 - '$ $ $ 8 ( - $ $ $ 1 - 8 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 ./ 2>2?234 /4:.E? >2/B 2? D7?/8 34 1./ 9== /4:.E? 8/:2?234 3< 1./ 26. 3951 3< 982:7195/ 71 7857? 24 ! ./ :/512<2:71/ 2??9/8 D@ 1./ 0/121234/5,? /;0=3@/5 5/78? 1.71 ./ B7? B35A246 B21. 1./ 356742L71234 <35 /=/>/4 @/75? 748 ./ .7? D//4 0/5;211/8 13 :341249/ .26./5 ?1982/? 053>28246 7== 7??2?174:/ 5/=71/8 13 1./ ?1982/? ?3 1.71 ./ :39=8 :3;0=/1/ ?9:. .26./5 ?1982/? ./ 0/121234/5 .7? D//4 7B758/8 7 =7B 8/65// D@ 1./ 754717A7 171/ 7B 42>/5?21@ D7?/8 34 1./ 11/4874:/ /512<2:71/ <9542?./8D@1./7B3==/6/24B.2:.1./0/121234/5 .7?095?9/8.2?1.5//@/75:395?/ ./5/ 2? 43 ;71/527= 13 2482:71/ 1.71 1./ 11/4874:/ /512<2:71/ 2??9/8 D@ 1./ 4?12191234 2? 89D239?351.711./0/121234/5.7?D//40/5;211/813 ' 424/78 - 9 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 :3;0=/1/ .2? :395?/ 748 17A/ 90 /C7;2471234? 8/?021/?9:.89D239?:/512<2:71/<1./5/2?4324J925@ 241.2?5/67587482<1./0/121234/5,??0/:2<2::7?/2? 1.71B21..2?/;0=3@/5E?/4:39576/;/41748?900351 ./.7?711/48/8=7??/?7?5/J925/8948/51./9=/? 1.2? 3951 3024/? 1.71 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 :39=8431.7>/5/<9?/8/453==;/41 " ./4/C17?0/:13<1./J9/?12342?B./1./5 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 2? 05/>/41/8 <53; 24J925246 <951./52<21.7?5/7?34?13D/=2/>/1.711./0/121234/5,? :/512<2:71/? 75/ 248//8 89D239? 748 1.71 ./ 2? 0/5;211/8 13 17A/ 90 1./ =7B /C7;2471234 D7?/8 34 ?9:.:/512<2:71/?./ /:1234 3<1./:15/78?7? 948/5- 1 :+, $ (- $ ' ($ ' $'' 0/4$ (/$ +",+;, -$ '-/)( )/- $ / 0$ $'' - 10 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 $ $/ ' 7( $ '-0 0 $' / 0 - ) ' ($ /- ' $ /- $0 '( ' $ ' ($ )() ' -/) < +", & ' $'' $ - $ $ 0 $ $(-$ $ /$$'/- ' ) $ +;, ' $'' $ - $ $/$ +", $' - $ +=, & ' $'' $ - $ ' ($ 0 $ 0 '- /0 ' $ / $ ) '0 - 11 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 8$ $ ) 1 ' ./ 053>2?3 13 /:1234 $'& 3< 1./ :1 5/78? 1.71 2< 1./ 75 394:2= 3< 48276 171/ 75 394:2= 2? ?712?<2/8 1.71 7 0/5?34 .7? 631 .2? 47;/ /41/5/8 34 1./ 53==? 3< 78>3:71/? D@ ;2?5/05/?/41712347?1374/??/4127=<7:1357<5798 21;7@5/;3>/1./47;/3<?9:.0/5?34<53;1./53==? 3< 78>3:71/? D91 7<1/5 62>246 .2; 74 3003519421@ 3< D/246./758.2?/4?95/?1.712<9034?:59124@3<1./ 83:9;/41? <9542?./8 71 1./ 12;/ 3< 700=2:71234 1./ 75394:2=3<4827 7 171/75394:2=2??712?<2/8 21 :39=8 />/4 7<1/5 0/5;211246 /453==;/41 7:1 <35 5/;3>7= ? 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 ?12== .7? ?9:. 5/:395?/ 13 /4?95/ 1.71 2< 248//8 1./ 0/121234/5 .7? 431711/48/8:=7??/?D/:79?/./B7?24/;0=3@;/41 1.2? 3951 2? 3< 1./ >2/B 1.71 1./ J9/?1234 <57;/8 ;9?1 D/ 74?B/5/8 24 <7>395 3< 1./ 0/121234/5 241/5</5246B21.1./<25?15/?0348/41E?358/5D91B21. - 12 - HC-KAR NC: 2026:KHC:6453 WP No. 28563 of 2025 =2D/51@131./<25?15/?0348/41137:1948/51./053>2?3 13 /:1234 $'&3<1./:1 ./ 0/121234 2? 7==3B/8 J97?.246 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41E? 2;0964/8 358/5 871/8 ""FG825/:12461./<25?1 5/?0348/41B21.1./0/121234/5<9542?.246 7:/512<2/8:30@3<1.2?58/513/453==1./ 0/121234/5 34 1./ 3==? 3< 1./ 8>3:71/? D91 5/?/5>246 =2D/51@ 13 1./ <25?1 5/?0348/41 13 7:1 948/5 1./ 053>2?3 13 /:1234 $'&3<1./:1 8 !# :1-?5